Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Canbank Financial Services Ltd. v. Custodian And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 6, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal concerns a dispute over whether Respondent 2, Ashwin Mehta, received Rs 2.90 crores as sale consideration for 10 lakh shares of Reliance Petrochemicals Ltd. allegedly belonging to the appellant, Canbank Financial Services Ltd. The Special Court had earlier dealt with the matter, but no detailed factual record was established because Ashwin Mehta’s relevant documents were under seizure by the Income-Tax Department and the CBI, and he had not been examined on oath. The present order is issued in the course of that appeal to elicit fuller facts before deciding the substantive issues.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, at the instance of the appellant, Ashwin Mehta received Rs 2.90 crores as sale proceeds of the appellant’s Reliance Petrochemicals shares.
  2. If the amount was received, when it was received and how the funds were deployed.
  3. Whether Ashwin Mehta can claim a set-off on the ground that substantial sums are allegedly owed by the appellant to M/s Harshad S. Mehta.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Canbank Financial Services Ltd.)

  • Does not dispute the balances in Ashwin Mehta’s various accounts as recorded by the Special Court, yet contends that further facts about the receipt and utilisation of Rs 2.90 crores must be ascertained.
  • Sought an affidavit from Ashwin Mehta detailing how the purported sale proceeds were utilised.

Respondent 2 (Ashwin Mehta)

  • Filed an affidavit stating that Canbank Financial Services Ltd. owes substantial sums to M/s Harshad S. Mehta, and therefore he is not liable to pay Rs 2.90 crores to the appellant.
  • Could not confirm the exact date of receipt of the alleged sale proceeds because relevant records were seized by investigative agencies.
  • Affidavit was based solely on recollection and not on documentary evidence.

Harshad S. Mehta (Broking Firm)

  • No separate arguments recorded, but the order notes Ashwin Mehta’s claim that more than Rs 2.90 crores is due to the broking firm from the appellant.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court found that reliable factual data are essential before it can address the substantive legal questions. Observing that Ashwin Mehta’s earlier affidavit lacked documentary support and that neither he nor Harshad S. Mehta had been examined, the court concluded that:

  • A complete factual record regarding the alleged sale of 10 lakh Reliance Petrochemicals shares and the handling of Rs 2.90 crores is indispensable.
  • Both Ashwin Mehta and Harshad S. Mehta must be given an opportunity to access documents presently seized by investigative agencies so that they can depose accurately.
  • Cross-examination by the Custodian and the appellant is necessary to test the veracity of their statements.

On that basis, the court issued detailed procedural directions aimed at creating a full evidentiary foundation, rather than deciding the dispute on the present, inadequate record.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The court directed Ashwin Mehta and Harshad S. Mehta to file comprehensive affidavits, allowed inspection of relevant seized documents, ordered their cross-examination before the Special Court, and set a schedule for completion of these steps, listing the matter for directions on 24-07-2001.

Implications: The order does not resolve the merits of the financial dispute. Its immediate effect is to compel disclosure and evidence-gathering so the Special Court, and ultimately the appellate court, can make an informed determination. No new legal precedent is established; the decision is procedural and case-specific.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. In this appeal, one of the points which arises for consideration is whether, at the instance of the appellant, Respondent 2, namely, Ashwin Mehta had received Rs 2.90 crores as the sale consideration of the appellant's shares of Reliance Petrochemicals Ltd. Further question is as to when, if at all, the said amount of Rs 2.90 crores was received and how it was deployed.

2. In the affidavit which has been filed by Ashwin Mehta before the Special Court, in para 4, it has been stated that M/s Canbank Financial Services Ltd. owes substantial sums of money to M/s Harshad S. Mehta (a broking firm of Shri Harshad Mehta). In this affidavit, it is further stated that the detailed particulars of the transactions were not immediately available to Ashwin Mehta on account of the fact that his records and the records of Mr Harshad Mehta were under seizure by the Income Tax Authorities and CBI. In this affidavit, he further states that he could not confirm the date on which the payment of the sale proceeds of shares of Reliance Petrochemicals Ltd. was received. He again reiterates that he is not liable to pay the sum of Rs 2.90 crores to the appellant, inasmuch as large amounts of money were receivable from the appellant by M/s Harshad S. Mehta which had not been repaid.

3. While Mr Harish N. Salve, the learned Solicitor General appearing for the appellant Canbank Financial Services Ltd. does not dispute the balances in the various accounts of Ashwin Mehta as on the date he was notified under the Special Courts Act and as set out in the impugned judgment, but in order to decide the legal issues it is essential to find out more facts with regard to receipt or non-receipt of Rs 2.90 crores and about amounts stated to be due to Mr Harshad Mehta from Canbank Financial Services Ltd. against which Ashwin Mehta claims a set-off.

4. In the application which was filed before the Special Court by the appellant herein, one of the prayers was that Ashwin Mehta be ordered and directed to disclose on affidavit how he had utilised the sum of Rs 2.90 crores which was payable to the appellant. It appears that neither was any affidavit called for nor Ashwin Mehta appeared in the witness box. There was, however, one affidavit filed by him but which was not based on any document and the affidavit was merely on the basis of his recollection.

5. In our opinion, in order to decide the points in issue, it is essential that facts are ascertained in relation to the sale proceeds and the alleged claim of set-off.

6. We hereby direct Ashwin Mehta to file an affidavit before the Special Court disclosing all facts relating to the sale, if any, of 10 lakh shares of Reliance Petrochemicals Ltd. alleged to have been effected for Rs 2.90 crores. He shall also disclose the following facts:

(a) the dates on which and the parties to whom the said 10 lakh shares were allegedly sold;
(b) the manner in and the date on which the price of the said shares was realised;
(c) the manner in which he dealt with the proceeds stated to have been realised from the sale of those shares;
(d) the account particulars (insofar as it is relevant) of the bank in which the proceeds, if any, of the sale of the said shares were deposited; and
(e) in case any payment had been received by way of settlement or adjustment of any other transaction, then the full particulars of the parties with whom those transactions were held and the particulars of those transactions.

7. In order to enable Ashwin Mehta to file such an affidavit, he is given liberty to file before the Special Court at Mumbai within 10 days from the communication of this order a list of such documents or records belonging to him which he wishes to inspect which may have been taken in custody by CBI and/or the Income Tax Authorities. On such an application being filed, the Special Court will issue necessary directions permitting the inspection of such documents as the court may deem fit, within such a time-frame that the inspection is completed so as to enable Ashwin Mehta to file the affidavit within eight weeks from today. After the affidavit is filed, the Custodian and/or the appellant will be at liberty to cross-examine Ashwin Mehta and on request being made by them, Ashwin Mehta shall present himself before the court for cross-examination. The cross-examination should be completed within 10 weeks of the filing of the affidavit. During that period, or before that, the Custodian and the appellant will be at liberty to inspect such records of Ashwin Mehta which may be with CBI or the Income Tax Office and as the court may direct.

8. Inasmuch as in the affidavit of Ashwin Mehta it has been categorically stated that more than Rs 2.90 crores was due from Canbank Financial Services Ltd. to M/s Harshad S. Mehta, we hereby direct Harshad Mehta to file an affidavit in this behalf within eight weeks from today and if he so desires he may similarly within 10 days from the communication of this order apply to the Special Court for permission to inspect his records which may be in the custody of CBI and the Income Tax Authorities and, thereafter, the same procedure would be followed with regard to Harshad Mehta as has been directed with regard to the examination of Ashwin Mehta.

9. After the examination of Ashwin Mehta and Harshad Mehta is completed, the Special Court will forward the testimony of the said persons along with the affidavits filed by them within four weeks thereafter.

10. Either party will be at liberty to take xerox copies of the documents which are relied upon or filed in court.

11. If either Ashwin Mehta or Harshad Mehta does not appear before the Special Court, the court will take appropriate action to secure their presence.

12. Copies of this order be served by the parties on Ashwin Mehta and Harshad Mehta immediately by dasti.

13. List this case for directions on 24-7-2001.