- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
T.N Civil Supplies Corpn. Workers' Union v. T.N Civil Supplies Corpn. Ltd. And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant is a workers’ union representing employees engaged in various Direct Purchase Centres operated by the first respondent in Thanjavur, Tiruvarur and Nagapattinam. After the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishment (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (“the 1981 Act”) came into force on 1-1-1982, employees who had completed more than 480 days of service sought confirmation as permanent workers. The first respondent refused, prompting W.P. No. 5459 of 1983 seeking a mandamus to implement the 1981 Act.
On 10-10-1991 the High Court held that the 1981 Act applied to the first respondent and directed the employees to approach the Inspector of Labour to ascertain their eligibility. In two reports dated 25-3-1995 and 31-5-1995, the Inspector concluded that the establishment was not seasonal, the work was not intermittent, and the employees met the statutory criteria for permanency. The first respondent challenged these reports by separate writ petitions, which remain pending.
During the pendency of those proceedings many workers were terminated. The union’s writ petition for a blanket injunction against such terminations was dismissed by a Single Judge on 10-4-1997; an appeal followed. Numerous individual workers also filed writ petitions for permanency. On 14-10-1997 a Division Bench disposed of the union’s appeal together with the individual writ petitions, holding that the union must await the result of the first respondent’s pending writ petitions and that terminated workers must pursue individual remedies.
The present appeal challenges the Division Bench’s judgment of 14-10-1997.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Supreme Court should interfere with the Division Bench’s refusal to grant collective relief and its direction that individual employees pursue separate remedies pending the first respondent’s writ petitions.
- Whether findings made by the Division Bench on the seasonal character of the establishment and the intermittent nature of the work should be set aside or disregarded in the still-pending writ petitions filed by the first respondent.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant Union’s Arguments
- The Division Bench, despite stating that the union must await the outcome of the first respondent’s writ petitions, proceeded to record findings that the establishment is of a seasonal character and that the work is intermittent. These findings could prejudice the union’s defence in the pending writ petitions.
- The Supreme Court should therefore either (a) set aside those findings, or (b) clarify that the High Court should decide the pending writ petitions uninfluenced by the impugned findings.
Respondent’s Arguments
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court found no infirmity in the Division Bench’s reasoning that:
- The issues raised by the union in its appeal overlap with those already pending in the first respondent’s writ petitions challenging the Inspector of Labour’s reports, and the union must await their outcome.
- Because the workers’ services had been terminated, their appropriate remedy is to challenge the termination orders individually rather than seek a blanket injunction.
On the appellant’s request to expunge or neutralise the Division Bench’s findings regarding the seasonal character of the establishment and the intermittent nature of the work, the Court held:
- The findings were entered in the context of individual workers’ writ petitions, whose petitioners have not appealed and have thus accepted those findings.
- The union cannot seek to set aside findings in matters where the concerned employees themselves are not in appeal.
- Even assuming the 1981 Act applies fully and the establishment is not seasonal or intermittent, the primary dispute now concerns the validity of the terminations, which must be pursued through appropriate proceedings.
Accordingly, the Court declined to revisit the High Court’s factual findings or grant the clarifications sought.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed and stands disposed of; no order as to costs.
Immediate Effect: The Division Bench’s judgment dated 14-10-1997 remains undisturbed. The union must await the result of the first respondent’s pending writ petitions, and individual workers must challenge their terminations through appropriate legal channels.
Broader Implications: The decision sets no new precedent; it affirms the appellate deference to factual findings in matters where the affected parties have not themselves appealed.
S.N Variava, J.— This appeal is against a judgment dated 14-10-1997. By this judgment a large number of writ petitions and certain writ appeals were disposed of.
2. Briefly stated the facts are as follows:
The appellant is a union, which represents the workers working in the various Direct Purchase Centres of the 1st respondent at Thanjavur, Tiruvarur and Nagapattinam.
3. The Government of Tamil Nadu brought into force the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishment (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 with effect from 1-1-1982. The said Act will hereinafter be referred to as the said Act.
4. After the enactment of the said Act, the workmen who had been employed in the Direct Purchase Centres of the 1st respondent and had rendered more than 480 days of service claimed that they should be confirmed. The 1st respondent refused to confirm them. The appellant then filed Writ Petition No. 5459 of 1983 for a mandamus that the provisions of the said Act should be implemented and employees of Direct Purchase Centres who had rendered more than 480 days of service, should be confirmed (sic conferred) the status of a permanent employee. In this writ petition the only point which was argued was whether the 1st respondent Corporation was governed by the provisions of the said Act. The 1st respondent claimed that the said Act applied only to establishments to which the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act, 1947 applied. The 1st respondent claimed that, by virtue of Section 4(1)(c) of the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act, the provisions of that Act were not applicable and hence the said Act was also not applicable to them. The High Court negatived this contention and held that the said Act would apply to the 1st respondent. The High Court, by its order dated 10-10-1991, directed the employees to approach the Inspector of Labour for determination of the question whether they satisfied the conditions and were entitled to be declared as permanent workers. In this judgment the question whether the various Direct Purchase Centres were seasonal in nature and/or whether the work performed in those Centres was intermittent was not decided or dealt with even though raised in the affidavits.
5. Pursuant to this judgment the Inspector of Labour held an enquiry. By two reports, dated 25-3-1995 and 31-5-1995, it was held that the establishment was not of a seasonal character and the work performed by the workmen concerned was not intermittent. It was also held that the workmen fulfilled the criteria laid down under the Act and were therefore entitled to be made permanent. Against these reports the 1st respondent has filed writ petitions which have been admitted and are pending.
6. In the meantime the 1st respondent terminated the services of a number of workmen. The Union, therefore, filed a writ petition claiming a blanket injunction that the workers should not be relieved from their work. The writ petition filed by the Union was dismissed by a Single Judge on 10-4-1997 by holding that the Union was not entitled to have a blanket injunction of the nature sought. It was held that the employees whose services were terminated would take such action as is available to them in accordance with law. Against the dismissal of the writ petition the petitioners filed an appeal. In the meantime a number of workmen had filed writ petitions claiming permanency. By the impugned judgment dated 14-10-1997 the appeal of the Union came to be disposed of along with the numerous writ petitions filed by the workmen.
7. The Division Bench held that the questions raised by the appellants herein in that appeal were the same which were pending in the writ petition filed by the 1st respondent against the orders made by the Inspector of Labour. The Division Bench held that the Union had to await the final outcome of those writ petitions. The Division Bench also agreed with the conclusion of the Single Judge that since the services of the employees had been terminated, it was for the employees to seek their remedies in a manner known to law. We find no infirmity with the reasoning of the Division Bench and see no reason to interfere.
8. Mr Sharma submitted that even though the Division Bench has held that the questions raised in the appeal of the Union were the same as those pending in the writ petitions filed by the 1st respondent, yet the Division Bench has gone on to give a finding that the establishment is of a seasonal character and the work is not (sic) intermittent. Mr Sharma submitted that these findings would now come in the way of the Union while defending the writ petition filed by the 1st respondent. He submitted that this Court should either set aside these findings or clarify that those writ petitions would be decided without taking those findings into account.
9. We are unable to accept these submissions. Those findings were given because the individual employees, who had filed various other writ petitions, raised these contentions before the Division Bench. As those contentions were raised the Division Bench has answered these contentions. None of the workmen, in whose matters those findings are given, have come up in appeal to this Court. They have accepted those findings. It is, therefore, not open for the Union to claim that those findings should be set aside.
10. In any event, as stated above, the services of the workmen have been terminated. Therefore, even if the said Act squarely applied and the establishment of the 1st respondent was not of a seasonal character and the work was not intermittent, the remedy would now be to file the appropriate proceedings against the order of termination. In this view of the matter no purpose would be served by dealing with the correctness of the finding given by the Division Bench.
11. We, therefore, see no reason to interfere. The appeal stands disposed of accordingly. There will, however, be no order as to costs.
Alert