- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of A.P v. G. Ramakishan And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petitioners, postgraduate students of Andhra Pradesh Agricultural University, challenged Government Order G.O. Ms. No. 742 dated 3-12-1990, which enhanced their stipends but made the increase operative only from 3-12-1990. They sought parity with postgraduate medical students, whose stipends were raised earlier by G.O. Ms. No. 655 dated 26-12-1989 with effect from 1-10-1989. A Single Judge of the Andhra Pradesh High Court allowed the writ petition on 28-4-1992, directing payment of the enhanced stipends from 1-10-1989. The State appealed, but the Division Bench dismissed the appeal on 7-7-1993 as time-barred (delay of 365 days). The State of Andhra Pradesh then brought the present appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the State Government’s fixation of different effective dates for enhanced stipends of agricultural and medical postgraduate students violates Article 14 of the Constitution (equality before the law).
- Whether the High Court was correct in refusing to condone a 365-day delay in filing the State’s appeal.
Arguments of the Parties
Writ Petitioners (Postgraduate Agricultural Students)
- The State had historically treated agricultural and medical postgraduate students alike in stipend matters; any deviation is arbitrary.
- No rational basis exists to grant the medical students the benefit from 1-10-1989 while postponing the same benefit for agricultural students to 3-12-1990.
- The differential treatment infringes Article 14.
State of Andhra Pradesh
- Parity in stipend amounts does not imply parity in all respects; the nature of study, research, and duties differs between agricultural and medical postgraduate students.
- The Government independently evaluated representations from both groups and was entitled to prescribe different effective dates.
- In the condonation petition, administrative processes were cited as reasons for the filing delay (held insufficient by the High Court).
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the pleadings and judgments below and agreed with the Single Judge that:
- The State maintained parity in stipend rates but deviated only with respect to the effective date, without offering any reasonable basis or intelligible differentia.
- Differences in course content or practical duties were irrelevant to the narrow issue of the date from which enhanced stipends should apply.
- Because the Government failed to articulate a justification, the departure constituted arbitrary and discriminatory action prohibited by Article 14.
Regarding limitation, the Supreme Court saw no error in the Division Bench’s refusal to condone a 365-day delay, noting the absence of “sufficient cause.”
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
The dismissal upholds the Single Judge’s direction that agricultural postgraduate students receive the enhanced stipend from 1-10-1989, thereby restoring parity with medical postgraduate students. The ruling affirms the necessity for the State to provide a rational basis when differentiating between similarly situated groups but does not establish new precedent beyond reinforcing Article 14 principles.
D.P Mohapatra, J.— The respondents herein, who were postgraduate students of Andhra Pradesh Agricultural University, filed a writ petition (Writ Petition No. 16050 of 1991) against the State of Andhra Pradesh, represented by the Secretary, Food and Agriculture Department (Agrl. III), and Andhra Pradesh Agricultural University, represented by the Registrar, challenging the Government Order i.e GOMs No. 742 dated 3-12-1990, in which the date from which they are entitled to stipend at the enhanced rate was specified and sought a direction to the respondents to pay the enhanced rate of stipend to them from 1-10-1989 as in the case of postgraduate students of medical colleges in the State. It is the case of the writ petitioners that prior to the issue of the aforementioned Government Order, postgraduate students of the Agricultural University were receiving stipend at the rates of Rs 1000 per month during the first year, Rs 1100 per month during the second year and Rs 1200 per month in the third year, same as in the case of the postgraduate students of medical colleges. By the Government Order, GOMs No. 655, Health, Medical and Family Welfare (E-II) Department dated 26-12-1989, considering the representation made by the Andhra Pradesh Junior Doctors' Association, the rates of stipend were enhanced to Rs 1500 per month for the first-year students, Rs 1900 per month for the second-year students and Rs 2000 per month for the third-year students with a direction that the order of enhancement was to take effect from 1-10-1989. A similar enhancement of the rate of stipend was made by GOMs No. 742, Food and Agriculture (Agrl. III) Department, for the postgraduate students of the Agricultural University but the order was given effect from 3-12-1990. The case of the writ petitioners was that the State Government had always treated the postgraduate students of the Agricultural University on a par with the postgraduate students of medical colleges in the matter of stipend and there was no rational basis to make a difference regarding the effective date from which the enhanced rates of stipend will be paid to the postgraduate students of the Agricultural University on this occasion.
2. The respondents in the writ petition denying the claim of the writ petitioners, contended inter alia that it is not correct to assume that the State Government was all along treating the postgraduate students of the Agricultural University on a par with the postgraduate students of medical colleges simply because the rates of stipend paid to the two groups of postgraduate students happened to be the same. According to the respondents, there was no comparison between the writ petitioners and the postgraduate students of medical colleges since the nature of studies, research work and practical duty done by them are not similar. It was further contended on behalf of the respondents in the writ petition that the writ petitioners represented their case to the State Government for enhancement of the rate of stipend and the State Government, after due consideration of the case of the petitioners and the postgraduate students of medical colleges, passed the order enhancing the rate of stipend with effect from different dates.
3. A Single Judge of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, vide judgment dated 28-4-1992, allowed the writ petition granting the relief sought. The learned Judge observed:
“It is very vaguely stated in the counter that nothing prevents the petitioners to make a representation to the Government. That is not a valid answer. No intelligible differentia has been pointed out by the 1st respondent to discriminate the petitioners from that of the medical postgraduates. As such, the action of the 1st respondent in depriving the petitioners of the increased stipend amounts on par with the medical postgraduates with effect from 1-10-1989 results in invidious discrimination infracting fundamental right of equality before law and equal protection of laws enshrined under Article 14 of the Indian Constitution.”
4. Being aggrieved by the judgment, the Government of Andhra Pradesh filed an appeal (WASR No. 29437 of 1993) challenging the same. A Division Bench of the High Court, by the judgment dated 7-7-1993 dismissed the appeal on the ground of being grossly barred by time. The Division Bench of the High Court, on a perusal of the condonation of delay petition (WAMP No. 815 of 1993) filed by the appellant, held:
“The facts referred to above clearly establish that no sufficient cause is made out for condoning the inordinate delay of 365 days in filing the appeal. Therefore, the petition is dismissed.”
The said order is under challenge in this appeal filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh.
5. The respondents have not appeared despite service of notice on them.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the appellant. We have also perused the judgment of the learned Single Judge, the judgment passed by the Division Bench and the other relevant records included in the paper-book.
7. It is our considered view that on the pleadings of the parties, the learned Single Judge rightly came to the conclusion that the State Government failed to show that there was any reasonable basis or intelligible differentia for giving effect to the enhanced rates of stipend for the postgraduate students of the Agricultural University from a date different from the effective date of the postgraduate students of the medical colleges, particularly when it was the specific case of the writ petitioners that the State Government had all along maintained parity in the matter of stipend paid to the postgraduate students of both the institutions. On this occasion also, regarding the rates of stipend payable to postgraduate students in the two institutions (sic parity) was maintained. However, a differentiation was made insofar as the date with effect from which the benefit of the enhanced rates will be available; while in case of postgraduate students of medical colleges, the benefit was extended with effect from an anterior date, in the case of postgraduate students of the Agricultural University, the benefit was extended from a date subsequent thereto. This departure from the parity in the matter between the two groups of postgraduate students, which had admittedly been maintained all along, was assailed as arbitrary and discriminatory. When the action of the Government was challenged on the ground of arbitrariness and discrimination it was for the Government to plead justification for fixing the two different dates in the matter. It neither stated in the pleadings any reasonable or rational basis for giving effect to the enhanced rate of stipend with effect from different dates nor did it place any material before the Court in that regard. For this purpose it is of no relevance that courses of studies of the postgraduate students in the two institutions and the nature of practical duty done by them are different, for the reason that the matter under challenge related to the date with effect from which the enhanced stipend is to be paid to postgraduate students of the Agricultural University.
8. In such circumstances the learned Single Judge cannot be faulted for having taken the view that the action of the State Government in the matter was not supported by any rational basis or intelligible differentia. The Division Bench, in the facts and circumstances of the case, rightly dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant herein.
9. In the result, the appeal being devoid of merit, is dismissed. No costs.
Alert