Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Om Prakash Gupta v. Union Of India (Uoi) And Anr.

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 13, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arose from suit proceedings before the Delhi High Court in which the Union of India, though served on 11 October 1996 and appearing from the first hearing date (9 January 1997), repeatedly failed to file a written statement despite multiple extensions. The High Court nevertheless passed an order dated 12 January 1999 granting further time for filing the written statement. In the present appellate proceedings, this Court had granted the Union of India (as a last chance) two weeks to file a counter affidavit, having earlier indicated that the matter would be finally disposed of on 25 February 2000; no counter affidavit or explanatory application was filed despite these opportunities, and the Court proceeded to decide the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts, the High Court was justified in granting the Union of India further time to file its written statement despite prolonged and repeated defaults.
  2. Whether the appellant's application under Order 8, Rule 10 of the C.P.C. should be allowed, enabling the suit to proceed in accordance with law in the absence of a written statement.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted persistent non-compliance by the Union of India: despite being served in October 1996 and afforded repeated extensions from January 1997 onwards, no written statement had been filed even after more than two years, including after the High Court's impugned order granting additional time. The Court characterized this as callousness and found that, on these facts, any further indulgence by the High Court would be unjustified. Although the High Court order was described as ordinarily "innocuous" and one the Court would not normally interfere with, the prolonged default and continued inaction made interference appropriate in the interest of justice. The Court also recorded that counsel for the Union of India stated that the real contesting party was the National Capital Territory of Delhi, which had been served but also had not filed a counter; this reinforced the Court's decision to proceed and dispose of the matter.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED: The appeal was allowed with costs, the High Court's order dated 12 January 1999 was set aside, and the appellant's application under Order 8, Rule 10 of the C.P.C. filed before the High Court was allowed.

Implications: The suit was directed to proceed, and the court was permitted to dispose of it in accordance with law in light of the failure to file the written statement. The opinion does not indicate any broader implications or that any new precedent was set.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

1. Leave granted.

2. By the order dated 2511 February, 2000 learned Counsel for the Union of India was granted, as a last chance, two weeks' time for filing counter. Neither any counter affidavit has been filed nor any application made explaining any reason for not filing the same. This Court by Order dated 13.12.1999 made it clear that this matter will be finally disposed of on 25th February, 2000. No counter affidavit is filed on this date as aforesaid in spite of last opportunity granted. In spite of indulgence, even today neither any counter is filed nor any application is filed disclosing any reason for not filing the same. So we proceed to dispose of this appeal finally today.

3. Heard learned Counsel for the parties.

4. In fact, grievance of the Appellant is, Respondents because of their inaction are delaying the legitimate relief to which Appellant is entitled. In the suit proceedings, before the Delhi High Court, the same Respondent has yet not filed any written statement in spite of repeated time being granted. We express with restraint that there is total callousness on the part of the Union of India. Learned Counsel for the Union of India states that the real party contesting this matter is the National Capital Territory of Delhi which has also been served but yet no counter has been filed on its behalf. In view of this, we are left with on option but to proceed to dispose of this appeal.

5. We feel on the facts of this case, the High Court granting indulgence to the Union of India further time for filing written statement would not be justified. Normally, we would not have interfered with this innocuous order but on facts of this case, we feel it appropriate, in the interest of justice to interfere with it. In this suit Union of India was served on 11th October, 1996 and first date of hearing was 9th January 1997, no written statement was filed then. Since thereafter repeated time was granted by the Court, for the same yet it was not filed. When the impugned order was passed granting further time, more than two years expired yet no written statement was filed. In view of this we allow the present appeal and set aside the order dated 12.1.1999 passed by the High Court. We also allow the application filed by the Appellant before the High Court under Order 8, Rule 10 of the C.P.C. Now, the court may proceed and dispose of the suit in accordance with law.

6. The appeal is, accordingly, allowed with costs.