- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Factory Manager, Cimmco Wagon Factory v. Virendra Kumar Sharma And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The State Government of Rajasthan, by notification dated 1-2-1984 under Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, referred for adjudication the question whether the termination of Shri Virendra Kumar by the Manager, CIMMCO Limited, Bharatpur was proper and, if not, what relief he was entitled to. Before the Labour Court the workman asserted that, after completing an apprenticeship (10-9-1979 – 21-9-1980), he worked continuously in various capacities until April 1983 and therefore had attained the status of a permanent workman. CIMMCO countered that he was only an apprentice on two discrete spells and that no contract of employment ever came into existence.
The Labour Court found that (i) the respondent was appointed only as an apprentice under Exhibits M-1 and M-2, (ii) he received merely a stipend of Rs 250 per month, (iii) no appointment letter or salary record existed and (iv) the presumption under Section 103 of the Factories Act, 1948 stood rebutted. Accordingly, it held that he was not a “workman” and denied relief.
Challenging the award, the respondent filed SB Civil Writ Petition No. 1384 of 1987. The Single Judge affirmed the Labour Court and dismissed the petition on 6-3-1997. On appeal, the Division Bench (DB Civil Appeal No. 523 of 1997) set aside the Single Judge’s order, quashed the award, declared the respondent a workman, ordered reinstatement and 25% back wages (order dated 3-12-1997). CIMMCO brought Civil Appeal No. 4501 of 1998 to the Supreme Court. The respondent, dissatisfied with the partial back-wage award, filed Civil Appeal No. 5408 of 1998.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent, having undergone apprenticeship, acquired the status of a “workman” under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 entitling him to relief against termination.
- Whether the statutory presumption under Section 103 of the Factories Act, 1948 could be invoked to establish an employment relationship in industrial-dispute proceedings.
- Whether the Division Bench of the High Court was justified in overturning concurrent factual findings of the Labour Court and the Single Judge.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments (CIMMCO Ltd.)
- The respondent was engaged only as an apprentice on two short spells, expressly under terms that imposed no obligation to offer permanent employment.
- He received merely a stipend; no appointment order or salary payment existed, negating a master-servant relationship.
- Letters relied on by the respondent were mere recommendations by an officer lacking appointing authority.
- The Division Bench erroneously invoked Section 103 of the Factories Act; that provision is inapplicable and, in any event, the presumption stood rebutted.
Respondent’s Arguments (Virendra Kumar)
- Letters dated 22-1-1983 and 7-5-1983 from Deputy Manager S. G. Goyal to the Vice-President showed that the respondent was in regular employment.
- On that basis, the Division Bench correctly treated him as a workman and granted reinstatement with back wages.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court undertook a factual re-appraisal and endorsed the Labour Court’s findings:
- Status of the respondent: Exhibits M-1 and M-2 evidenced an apprenticeship arrangement with a clear stipulation (Clause 5) that the company bore no obligation to employ him thereafter. No salary, GPF or ESI deductions, or appointment letter existed.
- Letters W-7 and W-8: These were merely recommendatory. The author, Deputy Manager Goyal, lacked authority to make appointments; hence the letters could not create a contract of employment.
- Presumption under Section 103, Factories Act: The Court clarified that (a) the presumption is rebuttable, and (b) it operates only “for the purposes of” the Factories Act, which concerns health, safety and penal provisions. It is not meant to determine workman status under the Industrial Disputes Act. In any event, factual evidence rebutted the presumption.
- Review of High Court interference: With no perversity or legal infirmity in the Labour Court’s award, and with the Single Judge concurring, the Division Bench lacked sustainable grounds to disturb concurrent factual findings. Its conclusion of “unfair labour practice” was likewise unsupported.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Civil Appeal No. 4501 of 1998 is allowed; the Division Bench’s order dated 3-12-1997 is set aside and the Labour Court’s award is restored. Consequently, Civil Appeal No. 5408 of 1998 (seeking full back wages) is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Implications: The respondent is not entitled to reinstatement or back wages; he remains unrecognised as a workman. The decision reaffirms that the Section 103 Factories Act presumption is confined to proceedings under that Act and cannot, without more, establish employment status in industrial-dispute adjudication. The judgment turns on evidentiary evaluation rather than establishing new legal precedent.
Shivaraj V. Patil, J.— Civil Appeal No. 4501 of 1998 is directed against the order dated 3-12-1997 made by the High Court of Rajasthan in DB Civil Appeal No. 523 of 1997. Briefly stated, the facts, which are necessary and relevant for the disposal of this appeal, are the following:
At the instance of the respondent, the State Government referred the dispute under Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 vide Notification No. SPI(i)(884)LC/83 dated 1-2-1984 to decide
“whether the termination of service of labourer Shri Virendra Kumar by the Manager, CIMMCO Limited, Bharatpur, was proper and legal? If not, what relief the labourer was entitled to?”
2. The contesting respondent claimed that he was appointed as an apprentice by the appellant from 10-9-1979 to 21-9-1980. After the expiry of the said period, he was on regular service between 22-9-1980 to 21-12-1980. As there was lockout in the factory from 7-10-1980 to 8-2-1981, he was asked by the appellant not to come for work. After the lockout was over, the respondent worked as General Clerk in the assembly shop of the appellant from 9-2-1981 to 30-6-1982. Thereafter he worked in the vacancy of Shri K.G Venkatesan till April 1983. He was given Rs 250 per month from 22-9-1980 to 30-6-1982 and when he demanded salary for the period between 1-7-1982 to April 1983 he was told that his case had been recommended for approval of the higher officers. He was told by the appellant orally not to come for work from 16-6-1983 on the ground that his services were already terminated. It was his further case that he had continuously worked from 9-2-1981 to 15-4-1983. Hence he was entitled to become a permanent worker.
3. The appellant resisted the claim of the respondent by filing a written statement. It was admitted that the respondent had been appointed as an apprentice between 10-9-1979 and 22-9-1980 at the request of his father who was already serving in the appellant factory. It was pointed out that between the periods 11-8-1981 to 10-12-1981 and 11-12-1981 to 30-6-1982 the respondent had been an apprentice as per Exts. M-1 and M-2 respectively. It was stated that neither was the respondent employed by any competent authority in the establishment of the appellant nor had he been paid the salary. It is clear from Condition 5 in Exts. M-1 and M-2 that the appellant was not obliged to give a job to the respondent after the completion of apprenticeship. The Labour Court after considering the rival contentions, in the light of the evidence brought on record, held that the respondent was not a workman. It was also held that the presumption that could be raised under Section 103 of the Factories Act, 1948 (for short “the Act”) stood rebutted as no appointment letter was given to the respondent; he was neither paid any salary or wages and that the relationship of master and servant did not exist between the appellant and the respondent. In view of the conclusions arrived at, the Labour Court passed the award holding that the respondent was not entitled to any relief from the appellant.
4. The respondent challenged the validity and correctness of the said award in the High Court of Rajasthan in SB Civil Writ Petition No. 1384 of 1987. The learned Single Judge did not find any good ground to disturb the award passed by the Labour Court, exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed on 6-3-1997. The respondent took up the matter in appeal in DB Civil Appeal No. 523 of 1997. The Division Bench of the High Court by the impugned order dated 3-12-1997 allowed the appeal, set aside the order of the learned Single Judge and allowed the writ petition quashing the award of the Labour Court. Hence this appeal is brought before us by the appellant.
5. The learned counsel for the appellant urged that the Division Bench of the High Court failed to see that the respondent was only an apprentice for a short period in two spells; that too with a clear understanding that the appellant was not bound or obliged to give him a job in the establishment; he was only taken as an apprentice at the request and persuasion of his father to train him, who was already an employee in the appellant factory; he was only paid a stipend of Rs 250 per month; neither was there any appointment order issued nor was any salary paid to the respondent by the appellant; the documents placed on record clearly show that he was only an apprentice and the letters relied on by him given by the officer, who was not the appointing authority, contained only recommendations. The learned counsel added that the presumption raised by the Division Bench under Section 103 of the Act was clearly erroneous and the said provision has no application to the case of the respondent.
6. On the other hand, the learned Senior Counsel for the respondent argued in support and justification of the impugned order. He laid stress on the two letters dated 22-1-1983 and 7-5-1983 written by one Shri S.G Goyal, Deputy Manager to the Vice-President of the appellant factory and argued that the respondent was regularly employed by the appellant. Under the circumstances, according to the learned Senior Counsel, the learned Single Judge (sic Division Bench) of the High Court was right in quashing the award passed by the Labour Court and granting relief.
7. The facts that are not in dispute are that the respondent was taken as an apprentice for the given period in Exts. M-1 and M-2 referred to in the award. He was paid a monthly stipend of Rs 250 during the apprenticeship period. Annexures M-1 and M-2 contained a clause that after the expiry of the training period, the appellant Company shall not be under obligation to give employment to the respondent. The respondent had signed Exts. M-1 and M-2 after carefully going through the terms and conditions contained in them. There was no appointment letter issued to the respondent and no material was placed before the Labour Court to show that any salary was paid to the respondent at any time apart from the stipend of Rs 250 per month.
8. The Labour Court in the award, on analysis and appreciation of the evidence brought before it, refused to grant any relief to the respondent. It is stated in the award that the respondent worked between 22-9-1979 and 21-8-1980 and from 11-8-1981 to 30-6-1982 as only an apprentice as per Exts. M-1 and M-2. Shri Goyal, the Deputy Manager, had admitted that the respondent worked as a coordinator with the appellant which is clear from Exts. W-7 and W-8. These two letters revealed that he had recommended for the appointment of the respondent. The Labour Court had also noticed that the respondent had neither been employed by a competent authority nor was he paid salary. It was also noticed that the respondent was neither under any compulsory obligation to undergo training nor could he be compelled to do so. Maybe, the respondent did not give up training and continued working as a coordinator in anticipation of being provided employment as his father was also an employee in the factory. There was no evidence on record to indicate that either GPF or ESI were deducted from the salary of the respondent as he was not being paid any salary. Having regard to the evidence placed on record, the Labour Court held that the respondent was not a workman. As regards the presumption to be drawn under Section 103 of the Act, the Labour Court observed that such a presumption was put to an end by the facts of the case as the respondent was not given any appointment letter; he was neither paid any salary or wages and that the master and servant relationship did not exist between the parties. As per clause 5 of Exts. M-1 and M-2, the appellant was not bound to give employment to the respondent. It may be added here that the letter Ext. W-6 (Annexure R-1/8 produced in this appeal) written by the respondent himself shows that his services came to an end on 30-6-1982. If that be the case, his claim that he continued in the service as a regular employee till April 1983 is not acceptable.
9. The learned Single Judge looking to the award passed by the Labour Court has observed that the respondent was continued as an apprentice for a period of two years in the appellant Company and beyond that his services were not extended by the appellant. The learned Single Judge did not find any illegality, impropriety or perversity in the award. The learned Single Judge also proceeded to say that not a single document was placed on record from which it could be established that the respondent was a regular employee. In this view, the learned Single Judge declined to exercise jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and dismissed the writ petition.
10. The Division Bench of the High Court in the impugned order referred to Exts. W-7 and W-8 to hold that the respondent was a workman. From a plain reading of these letters, it is clear that they are only recommendatory. It is also brought on record, as observed by the Labour Court that Shri Goyal was not the competent authority to give any appointment. The Division Bench in the impugned order has stated thus:
“Though it is true that no appointment letter has been issued to the writ petitioner, nor was any payment made to the writ petitioner, but still it is the established fact that he was asked to work in the factory by the authorities.”
11. Assuming that the respondent was asked to work in the factory in anticipation of securing employment, that too by an officer who was not competent to give appointment, that did not make the respondent a workman or a regular employee of the appellant Company. We have no hesitation to say that the Division Bench was not right in raising presumption under Section 103 of the Act in order to say that the respondent was a workman in relation to an industrial dispute for the purposes of any proceedings under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Section 103 of the Factories Act, 1948 reads as under:
“103. Presumption as to employment.—If a person is found in a factory at any time, except during intervals for meals or rest, when work is going on or the machinery is in motion, he shall until the contrary is proved, be deemed for the purposes of this Act and the rules made thereunder to have been at that time employed in the factory.”
(emphasis supplied)
12. The presumption available under this section in the first place is rebuttable and secondly, it is available only for the purpose of the said Act. It is also not the case of the respondent that this presumption is made available in relation to an adjudication of a dispute referred to under Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Section 103 of the Act is included in Chapter X under the heading “Penalties and Procedure”, which chapter deals with general penalty for offences, liability of owner of premises in certain circumstances, enhanced penalty after previous conviction, etc. The Act provides for the health, safety, welfare and other aspects of workers in the factories. It was enacted to consolidate and amend the law regulating labour in factories. The presumption under Section 103 of the Act as already noticed above is to be raised for the purpose of the said Act. Even otherwise on the material placed on record when it was factually established that the respondent was not a workman, raising a presumption under Section 103 of the Act in his favour was not correct. At any rate there were no good reasons sustainable in law to upset the finding of fact recorded by the Labour Court based on the evidence placed on record after proper appreciation of the same and more so when the award of the Labour Court was affirmed by the learned Single Judge. Having regard to the facts, circumstances of the case and in the light of the evidence placed on record, it is not possible to accept that there was any unfair labour practice as observed in the impugned order. Thus in view of what is stated above, we find it difficult to sustain the impugned order. Hence the appeal is allowed. The impugned order is set aside and the award of the Labour Court is restored.
13. The Division Bench of the High Court while directing reinstatement of the respondent in service had ordered payment of 25% of the back wages. The respondent aggrieved by denial of the full back wages, has filed Civil Appeal No. 5408 of 1998. In the light of the conclusions arrived at by us in Civil Appeal No. 4501 of 1998, this appeal is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
Alert