- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
J. Lingaiah And Others v. G. Hanumanthappa And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The matter arises out of a suit instituted in 1980. In the ensuing proceedings, the High Court, by the impugned judgment, remanded the case to the trial court for a fresh decision on the stated ground that no issue had been framed regarding the exact identification of the suit property. In the present appeal, the Supreme Court heard counsel for the appellants and counsel for Respondents 1 to 3 (contesting respondents). Respondents 4 and 5 did not appear despite service/deemed service, and Respondents 6 and 9 were reported dead and treated as pro forma; their names were struck off as no application had been filed to bring their legal representatives on record. The remaining respondents were pro forma respondents.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court was justified in remanding the suit to the trial court on the ground that no issue had been framed regarding identification of the suit property.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The High Court had remanded the matter on the premise that no issue had been framed concerning the exact identification of the property. The Supreme Court examined the record (paper-book) and found that the trial court had, in fact, framed an issue directly on identification of the suit schedule property, namely whether it comprised Survey No. 26.2.B or Survey No. 4 of Vyalikaval village. The Supreme Court also noted that another issue had been framed regarding whether Defendant 2 and others proved that the entire schedule property was acquired for formation of Vyalikaval Extension by CITB.
The Supreme Court observed that the High Court had not taken note of the fact that these issues were not only framed but were also adjudicated by the trial court on the evidence, with findings recorded. The Supreme Court further noted that, although paragraph 3 of the impugned judgment appeared to suggest that the respondents had prayed for such a remand, a reading of the paragraph did not clearly support that impression, and the appellants' counsel stated that no such prayer had been made before the High Court. On these grounds, the remand was found unjustified.
Holding and Implications
ALLOWED: The appeal was allowed and the High Court's impugned remand order was set aside.
Regular First Appeal No. 172 of 1992 was restored to the file of the High Court with a request to decide it afresh on merits in accordance with law after hearing the parties. The Supreme Court expressly gave no opinion on the merits of the underlying controversy. No costs were awarded. The decision’s direct effect was to reverse the remand and require a merits determination by the High Court; no broader precedential implications were articulated in the opinion.
Order
1. Leave granted.
2. We have heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned counsel appearing for Respondents 1 to 3 who are the contesting respondents finally in this appeal.
3. Respondent 5 who is a contesting respondent, though served, has not thought it fit to appear and contest the present proceedings. Respondent 4 who is deemed to be served has not thought it fit to appear and contest the proceedings though 30 days are over since the issuance of notice to him. Respondents 6 and 9 who are reported dead are merely pro forma respondents. Their names shall stand struck off from the record as no application for bringing their legal representatives on record is filed so far by the appellants. Rest of the respondents are pro forma respondents.
4. In a suit of the year 1980, the High Court by its impugned judgment has remanded the proceedings for fresh decision of the trial court. The reasoning adopted by the High Court for passing the remand order is that no issue was framed about the exact identification of the property. When we turn to p. 40 of the paper-book we find that the trial court has already framed one issue to that effect. Issue 1 reads as under:
“1. Whether the suit schedule property comprises in Survey No. 26.2.B or in Survey No. 4 of Vyalikaval village?”
5. Not only that, Issue 3 was framed to the following effect:
“3. Whether Defendant 2 and others prove that the entire schedule property was acquired for formation of Vyalikaval Extension by CITB?”
6. Unfortunately, the High Court has not noted that such issues were not only framed but on evidence the trial court arrived at findings thereon. When we turn to para 3 of the impugned judgment, we find as if the respondents had prayed for such a remand order before the High Court, though on a reading of the whole paragraph, it does not appear to be so. Learned counsel for the appellants — the respondents before the High Court submitted that such a prayer was never made before the High Court. For all these reasons, therefore, the appeal is allowed. The impugned order of the High Court is set aside. Regular First Appeal No. 172 of 1992 is restored to the file of the High Court with a request to redecide the same on merits in accordance with law after hearing the parties. We express no opinion on the merits of the controversy between the parties. No costs.
Alert