Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M. Sreenivasulu Reddy v. State Of T.N .

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 18, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The accused in these Special Leave Applications (SLPs) face allegations under Sections 420 and 409 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) read with Section 120-B. They sought anticipatory bail from the High Court, which granted relief subject to substantial monetary conditions: payment of Rs 20 crores by 15-2-2000, Rs 15 crores by 31-3-2000, and another Rs 15 crores by 30-4-2000, along with further conditions detailed in paragraph 18 of the High Court’s order of 30-3-2000.

By 17-4-2000 the petitioners had paid Rs 35 crores. On that date the Supreme Court stayed the High Court’s order, leaving a balance of Rs 15 crores unpaid. The petitioners then filed the present SLPs challenging the severity of the remaining monetary and other conditions. Applications for impleadment were allowed at the outset of the Supreme Court proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Supreme Court, exercising jurisdiction under Article 136, should interfere with the monetary and other conditions imposed by the High Court while granting anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC.
  2. What standards govern the imposition of conditions—particularly large monetary deposits—when a court grants anticipatory bail for offences under Sections 409 and 420 IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

State of Tamil Nadu (represented by the Solicitor-General, Mr Salve)

  • Given the serious nature of the accusations, anticipatory bail ought not to have been granted at all.
  • As bail was nevertheless granted, the Supreme Court should not disturb the High Court’s stringent terms and conditions.

Accused (represented by Mr Nariman)

  • While Section 438 CrPC permits the court to impose conditions, such conditions must be reasonable, judicious, and non-arbitrary.
  • The High Court’s requirement of massive monetary deposits is excessive and unrelated to the legitimate objectives of anticipatory bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reiterated that the purpose of conditions under Section 438 CrPC is to ensure the accused does not abscond or hamper investigation. Relevant factors include past conduct and domestic assets. The Court emphasised:

  • Conditions must be an exercise of judicial discretion aimed at preventing interference with the investigation, not at recovering alleged defalcated amounts.
  • Monetary recovery is not the object of bail in offences under Sections 409 and 420 IPC.

Applying these principles, the Court found the High Court’s requirement to deposit money acceptable only because the accused had voluntarily undertaken to pay. It declined to modify that part but required payment of the remaining Rs 15 crores within four weeks. Condition (b) of paragraph 18, however, was found unduly onerous; the Court substituted it with permission to furnish a corporate guarantee of equivalent value, subject to the Magistrate’s satisfaction regarding solvency. All other conditions remained intact, and the Court directed expeditious completion of the criminal proceedings.

Holding and Implications

The Special Leave Applications were disposed of with partial modification of the High Court’s bail conditions.

Immediate effects:

  • The petitioners must pay the outstanding Rs 15 crores within four weeks.
  • Condition (b) is replaced by a requirement to furnish a corporate guarantee of equivalent amount within eight weeks, subject to the Magistrate’s scrutiny.
  • All other High Court conditions remain operative; the prosecution is to expedite the trial.

The decision refines, but does not substantially extend, principles governing the reasonableness of bail conditions under Section 438 CrPC; no new precedent of broader application was explicitly set.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Applications for impleadment are allowed.

2. These special leave applications have been filed by the accused against whom offence under Sections 420 and 409 IPC read with Section 120-B IPC has been alleged.

3. The accused moved for grant of anticipatory bail and the High Court from time to time has exercised discretion in granting anticipatory bail subject to certain terms and conditions thereon.

4. By order dated 31-1-2000, after taking into consideration all relevant facts as well as the undertaking of the accused, the High Court granted anticipatory bail in favour of the petitioner subject to his depositing Rs 20 crores on or before 15-2-2000, Rs 15 crores on or before 31-3-2000 and another Rs 15 crores to be paid on or before 30-4-2000 apart from other conditions. This order of 31-1-2000 stood modified by the order of 30-3-2000 for payment of the aforesaid Rs 15 crores by modifying the dates and putting several other conditions as enumerated in para 18 of the said order.

5. The accused thereafter approached this Court and this Court had stayed operation of the aforesaid order on 17-4-2000, by which date a sum of Rs 35 crores out of Rs 50 crores had already been paid and it is on account of the said order passed by this Court, a further sum of Rs 15 crores as was required by the High Court, remained unpaid. Mr Salve, the learned Solicitor-General appearing for the State of Tamil Nadu vehemently contended that bearing in mind the nature of accusation, in fact, no anticipatory bail should have been granted, but the same having been granted the terms and conditions imposed should not be interfered with by this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. Mr Nariman, on the other hand, contended that when the Court exercises jurisdiction under Section 438 CrPC though is entitled to put conditions, but such conditions must be reasonable and judicious and the conditions should not be arbitrary.

6. Having considered the rival submissions and the provisions of Section 438 CrPC, we are of the considered opinion that the court while exercising jurisdiction under Section 438 CrPC must bear in mind and be satisfied that the accused will not abscond or otherwise misuse liberty and this can be ascertained from several factors like conduct of the accused in the past, his assets in the country and so on. But, while granting such anticipatory bail, though the court may impose such conditions as it thinks fit, but the object of putting conditions should be to avoid the possibility of the person hampering investigation. The discretion of the court while putting conditions should be an exercise of judicial discretion. In an offence under Sections 409 and 420 IPC, the court is certainly not going to recover the alleged amount as a condition to granting of bail. This being the position, since the High Court had directed the payment of the aforesaid money on the basis of the undertaking given by the accused, we would not modify that part of the order and, therefore, the accused would be required to pay the balance sum of Rs 15 crores within a period of four weeks from today. So far as condition (b) imposed in para 18 of the order is concerned, having considered the facts and circumstances of the case in hand and the object for which an accused is granted bail and the impossibility and/or severity of satisfying the said condition, we would alter the said condition (b) by directing that it would be open for the accused to furnish corporate guarantee to the extent mentioned in para 18(b) of the aforesaid order to the satisfaction of the Magistrate concerned with whom the case is now pending. The Magistrate should be fully satisfied about the solvency of the corporate guarantee. All other conditions mentioned in para 18 of the aforesaid order would remain operative and the prosecution should take expeditious steps for completing the criminal proceedings. The corporate guarantee as aforesaid should be furnished within eight weeks from today.

7. The special leave applications stand disposed of accordingly.