- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Labishwar Manjhi v. Pran Manjhi And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute concerns property left by the deceased Lakhiram, a member of the Santhal Scheduled Tribe. His widow (Appellant 1) had gifted the property to Appellants 2 and 3. The father of Respondents 2 and 3 (and husband of Respondent 1) sued, asserting that, under Santhal custom—which excludes females from succession—he and other male agnates were the rightful heirs and that the widow’s gift was void.
The trial court found the parties had become “sufficiently Hinduised,” applied Hindu law, held the widow to be the heir, and upheld the gift deed. The first appellate court initially reversed this decision, but on second appeal the High Court remanded the matter to determine the degree of “Hinduisation.” After remand, the first appellate court reaffirmed that Hindu law governed and again upheld the widow’s title and gift.
The respondents then filed a second appeal. On 27-1-1986 the High Court allowed that appeal, reasoning that, although the parties were Hinduised, Section 2(2) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 excluded Scheduled Tribes; hence pre-1955 Hindu law applied, giving the widow only a limited estate that would revert to the male agnates. The present appeal challenges that High Court ruling.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether members of the Santhal Scheduled Tribe who have become “sufficiently Hinduised” remain excluded from the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 by virtue of Section 2(2).
- If the Act applies, whether the widow acquired absolute ownership under Section 14, thereby validating her gift to Appellants 2 and 3.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Both lower courts, on remand, found the parties “Hinduised”; therefore they should be governed by the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 like any other Hindus.
- Consequently, under Section 14 the widow became absolute owner and her gift is valid.
Respondents' Arguments
- Section 2(2) expressly excludes members of Scheduled Tribes from the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
- Even if the parties have adopted certain Hindu practices, they remain Santhals, and their customary law of succession continues to apply.
- Relied on Satish Chandra Brahama v. Bagram Brahma (1967) 15 Bihar LJ 323 to contend that change of religion alone does not remove tribal status for succession purposes.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Satish Chandra Brahama v. Bagram Brahma (1967) 15 Bihar LJ 323 | Scheduled Tribe members remain outside the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 notwithstanding conversion, unless broader evidence shows complete abandonment of tribal customs. | Relied on by respondents; the Court distinguished it, holding that in the present case ample evidence proved abandonment of tribal customs, so Section 2(2) did not exclude the parties. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court focused on whether Section 2(2) of the Hindu Succession Act continued to bar application of the Act. It reviewed the specific findings made by the first appellate court after remand:
- Family members bore predominantly Hindu names.
- Witnesses admitted performing Hindu rites such as pind-daan and ten-day shradh ceremonies.
- Married women used vermilion, and widows observed Hindu widowhood practices.
From this evidence, the Court concluded that the parties had abandoned Santhal customary practices and had fully adopted Hindu traditions. Accordingly:
- Section 2(2) did not apply, because the exclusion is meant for members who continue to follow tribal customs; once those customs are renounced, the Act governs.
- Under Section 14 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the widow became the absolute owner of her deceased husband’s property.
- Her subsequent gift deed in favour of Appellants 2 and 3 was therefore valid.
- The High Court erred in applying pre-1955 Hindu law and in negating the effect of Section 14.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED; the High Court’s order dated 27-1-1986 is set aside.
Direct Consequences: The widow’s absolute title under Section 14 is affirmed and the gift to Appellants 2 and 3 stands. Respondents’ suit is dismissed and there is no order as to costs.
Broader Implications: The decision underscores that Section 2(2) of the Hindu Succession Act may not exclude Scheduled Tribe members who have demonstrably abandoned tribal customs and fully adopted Hindu practices, though no new formal precedent was expressly laid down.
Order
1. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. The present appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 27-1-1986, passed by the High Court whereby the second appeal of the respondent was allowed while the concurrent findings of the two courts below were set aside.
3. The short facts are that the father of Respondents 2 and 3 and husband of Respondent 1 filed a suit against the appellant for declaration that they being agnates of the deceased husband, inherited the property according to the custom of the Santhal Tribe where females are excluded from the right of succession. He further challenged the gift made by the widow of the deceased Lakhiram, namely, by Appellant 1 to Appellants 2 and 3. The trial court dismissed the suit by holding that parties have become sufficiently Hinduised and as such the Hindu law of succession would apply and thus the widow will inherit the property of the deceased, consequently the gift made by her to Appellants 2 and 3 is also valid. The appeal filed by the plaintiff-respondent was allowed. In second appeal the High Court remanded the case back to the first appellate court for recording the finding whether the parties were sufficiently Hinduised after setting aside the first appellate court's judgment.
4. After remand the first appellate court held that parties were sufficiently Hinduised and the Hindu law of succession would be applicable and confirmed the judgment of the trial court.
5. The respondent filed second appeal before the High Court challenging the said finding contending that the courts below had committed error in recording the finding that the Hindu Succession Act will apply. However, the High Court allowed the appeal of the respondent by holding that Hindu law as it stood prior to enactment of the Hindu Succession Act, 1955 would apply, hence Appellant 1 inherited the property during her lifetime and on her death it would devolve to the agnates of her husband viz. contesting Respondent 1. Challenging the said finding, the submission on behalf of the appellant is that the High Court committed error in concluding that the parties would be governed by the law as prevailed prior to coming into force of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. The submission is, once finding is recorded by the first appellate court and confirmed by the High Court that the parties are Hinduised then they would be governed by the law as is applicable to any Hindu and if that be so the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 would be applicable to the parties. Challenging this submission learned counsel for the respondent submits that the parties being tribals by virtue of sub-section (2) of Section 2, the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 would not be applicable. It excludes the members of any Schedule Tribes from application of the said Act to them. Based on this, submission is, even if the parties have Hinduised, the parties being of the Santhal Tribe they are following their customary law of Santhal, hence the Hindu Succession Act would not be applied. Reliance was placed on the decision of the Patna High Court, reported in Satish Chandra Brahama v. Bagram Brahma (1967) 15 Bihar LJ 323. This decision dealt with the case of Scheduled Tribes, namely, Uraon. The Court held that the Uraon Tribe is a Scheduled Tribe within the meaning of clause (25) of Article 366 of the Constitution of India and by virtue of sub-section (2) of Section 2 of the Hindu Succession Act the provision of that Act will not apply to this tribe, consequently Section 14 would also not apply. The said decision further records, the Uraon can change their religion but by changing of the religion alone they do not cease to be Uraon for other purposes. The Court has to base its findings on various other factors such as religious functions, marriages, disposal of the dead bodies by cremation or by burying the dead body etc. which have to be tested before such changing.
6. The question which arises in the present case is, whether the parties who admittedly belong to the Santhal Tribe are still continuing with their customary tradition or have they after being Hinduised changed their customs to that which is followed by the Hindus. It is in this context when the matter came first before the High Court, the High Court remanded the case for decision in this regard. After remand the first appellate court recorded the finding that most of the names of the families of the parties are Hindu names. Even PW 1 admits in the cross-examination that they perform the pindas at the time of death of any body. Females do not use vermilion on the forehead after the death of their husbands, widows do not wear ornaments. Even PW 2 admits that they perform shradh ceremonies for 10 days after the death and after marriage females used vermilion on their foreheads. The finding of the words is that they are following the customs of the Hindus and not the Santhal customs. In view of such a clear finding it is not possible to hold that sub-section (2) of Section 2 of the Hindu Succession Act excludes the present parties from the application of the said Act. Sub-section (2) only excludes members of any Scheduled Tribe admittedly as per finding recorded in the present case though the parties originally belong to the Santhal Scheduled Tribes they are Hinduised and they are following the Hindu traditions. Hence we have no hesitation to hold that sub-section (2) will not apply to exclude the parties from application of the Hindu Succession Act. The High Court fell into error in recording a finding to the contrary. In view of this, the widow of Lakhiram would become the absolute owner by virtue of Section 14 of the said Act, consequently the gift given by her to Appellants 2 and 3 was a valid gift, hence the suit of Respondent 1 for setting aside the gift deed and inheritance stands dismissed.
7. The appeal is allowed. The order dated 27-1-1986 passed by the High Court is set aside. No order as to costs.
Alert