- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sarabjit Singh v. Ex-Major B.D Gupta And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Mr. Sarabjit Singh, was promoted to the post of Chief Engineer by a Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) that met on 16-4-1999. Ex-Major B.D. Gupta, a Superintending Engineer seniority-ranked sixth, filed CWP No. 13240 of 1999 before the Punjab & Haryana High Court claiming that the DPC had applied outdated State guidelines and therefore failed to consider him for promotion. On 7-6-2000 the High Court accepted his contention, quashed the promotions of Mr. Singh and two others, and directed a fresh DPC applying Central Government guidelines adopted by the State on 1-10-1999. Mr. Singh appealed to the Supreme Court; pending the appeal he was reverted to Superintending Engineer, and the Supreme Court stayed the fresh DPC.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court erred in applying the Punjab Government circular dated 1-10-1999, which adopted Central Government DPC guidelines, to a DPC that had met earlier on 16-4-1999.
- In the absence of applicability of the 1-10-1999 circular, which State guideline governed the 16-4-1999 DPC—the 17-6-1960 guideline cited by the writ-petitioner or the 28-6-1961 guideline cited by the appellant?
- If the 28-6-1961 guideline applied, was the DPC’s decision liable to be set aside for omitting the writ-petitioner’s candidature?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments (Mr. Sarabjit Singh)
- The 1-10-1999 circular could not govern a DPC held on 16-4-1999; therefore the High Court’s reliance on it was misplaced.
- The operative guideline on 16-4-1999 was the Punjab circular dated 28-6-1961, which required consideration of only five eligible officers for three vacancies; Mr. Gupta was sixth in seniority and thus outside the zone of consideration.
- Under the 28-6-1961 regime, the DPC properly selected three Chief Engineers from the first five officers, rendering the promotions valid.
Respondent’s Arguments (Ex-Major B.D. Gupta)
- Conceded that the 1-10-1999 circular had no retrospective application to the 16-4-1999 DPC.
- Contended that the earlier 17-6-1960 guideline applied, mandating consideration of at least three officers per vacancy; with two (and effectively three) vacancies, six officers should have been considered, bringing him within the zone.
- Asserted a fundamental right to be considered for promotion, which was infringed by the DPC’s omission of his name.
State of Punjab’s Position
- The State filed a brief affidavit before the Supreme Court without endorsing either side, though it had supported the appellant in the High Court.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court’s Reasoning and Analysis
Point 1: All parties agreed that the 1-10-1999 circular could not apply to a DPC convened on 16-4-1999. The Supreme Court therefore rejected the High Court’s foundation for its decision.
Points 2 and 3: The Court held that the 17-6-1960 guideline had been superseded by the Punjab Government Circular Letter dated 28-6-1961. Under the 28-6-1961 guideline, the DPC had to consider five officers for three vacancies. The seniority list showed Mr. Gupta as sixth. The DPC initially called for eight files but ultimately selected three suitable candidates—Mr. Sarabjit Singh, Mr. D.P. Bajaj and Mr. B.K. Thapar—from the first five officers after finding the first two officers unsuitable due to adverse record. This procedure conformed to the 28-6-1961 requirement.
The Court concluded that because the writ-petitioner lay outside the prescribed zone of consideration, he had no enforceable right to have his case evaluated by the DPC on 16-4-1999. Consequently, the High Court’s direction for a fresh DPC was legally unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgment and upheld the DPC recommendation dated 16-4-1999 and the resulting promotions of the appellant and two others. No costs were awarded.
Implications: The decision restores the promotions of the three officers and forecloses the writ-petitioner’s claim for consideration based on the disputed guidelines. The judgment turns on the temporal applicability of departmental guidelines and does not announce a new legal principle beyond affirming that only the guidelines in force on the date of the DPC govern its proceedings.
M. Jagannadha Rao, J.— Leave granted.
2. The appellant Mr Sarabjit Singh (2nd respondent in the writ petition) is aggrieved by the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana dated 7-6-2000 in CWP No. 13240 of 1999 allowing the same in favour of the 1st respondent writ-petitioner, Ex-Major B.D Gupta. The High Court accepted the contention of the 1st respondent that the Departmental Promotion Committee of the State of Punjab was governed by the guidelines issued by the Central Government which were adopted by the State on 1-10-1999 and held that if those guidelines were applied, DPC would have had to consider eight Superintending Engineers for promotion to the post of Chief Engineer and not merely five as done in this case, and if that had been done, the writ petitioner, Ex-Major B.D Gupta would have come within the said zone of consideration and he could not have been omitted from consideration as was done by DPC. Further under the Central guidelines, as adopted by the State on 1-10-1999, the candidates had to get the grading of “very good” while under the earlier State guidelines, “good” was sufficient. Hence the selection of Respondents 2 to 4 in CWP, namely Mr Sarabjit Singh (appellant), Mr B.K Thapar and Mr D.P Bajaj as Chief Engineers was liable to be set aside. The High Court directed a fresh DPC to be conducted in accordance with the State Government's circular dated 1-10-1999 where the State had adopted the Central guidelines. That is how this appeal came to be filed by Shri Sarabjit Singh. Before the matter was listed in this Court, the appellant was reverted back as Superintending Engineer and a fresh date was fixed for the meeting of DPC to consider eight names, including that of the respondent writ-petitioner and others. This Court stayed the fresh meeting of DPC.
3. In this appeal, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant Shri P.P Rao contended that the High Court failed to notice that DPC had met on 16-4-1999 by which date the circular of the Punjab Government dated 1-10-1999 adopting the Central Government's guidelines had not come into being. The other circular dated 25-11-1995 of the State Government referred to the Central Government's guidelines only to the limited extent that DPC must meet periodically. Counsel contended that the earlier Punjab guidelines dated 28-6-1961 applied and DPC which met on 16-4-1999 rightly followed the said guidelines of 28-6-1961 under which, on the facts of the case, it was sufficient to consider the cases of five Superintending Engineers and inasmuch as the writ petitioner (Ex-Major B.D Gupta) fell beyond five in the seniority (being sixth), DPC was not obliged to consider his case. The selection of the appellant and two others (Respondents 2 to 4 in CWP) was perfectly in order.
4. In this appeal, so far as the State of Punjab is concerned, the learned counsel Shri Rajiv Dutta submitted that the State had filed a brief counter-affidavit here without supporting either side while, no doubt, the State had filed a counter-affidavit in the High Court supporting the appellant.
5. The contesting respondent in this appeal is the writ petitioner (Ex-Major B.D Gupta) and he filed a separate counter-affidavit and appeared in person. He contended that he had a fundamental right to be considered for promotion. Of course, he agreed that in respect of a DPC dated 16-4-1999 the Punjab circular dated 1-10-1999 could not have been applied and the High Court was wrong in applying the said circular. He, however, referred to the Punjab guidelines dated 17-6-1960 and contended that they applied to DPC and that for each post to be filled, at least three officers had to be considered. In this case, for two posts, six names should have been considered and he (Mr B.D Gupta) was the sixth person in the list. In fact, here three persons were ultimately selected, as one was on deputation.
6. Adverting to the above contention of the respondent writ-petitioner, Shri P.P Rao learned Senior Counsel for the appellant replied that the guidelines of 17-6-1960 were not applicable and were replaced by fresh guidelines in the Punjab Government Circular Letter No. 4044-5GS-61/23179 dated 28-6-1961 which read as follows:
“In this connection, it is also made clear that, in fact, in the first instance, a list of eligible officers/officials who fulfil the prescribed experience, etc., for promotion is to be drawn up in accordance with sub-paras (i) and (ii) above. Then out of this list, such officers/officials as are considered unsuitable for promotion are to be weeded out and a list of only those who are suitable for promotion has to be drawn up. The selection thereafter is to be confined to the 3 suitable officers/officials of the latter list if there is one post, 4 if there are two posts, and 5 if there are three posts and so on. Unsuitable officers/officials are those who, on the basis of their service record, general reputation etc. are definitely not considered fit for promotion by the Department. Selection for every vacancy has, therefore, to be made from the slab of 3 officers/officials who are considered fit for promotion and unless a junior among them happens to be of exceptional merit and suitability the seniormost will be selected.”
The points for consideration are:
(1) Whether the High Court was right in applying the Punjab guidelines dated 1-10-1999 which adopted the Central Government's guidelines for DPC?
(2) Whether, in case the State guidelines dated 1-10-1999 did not apply, the 17-6-1960 guidelines of the State relied upon by the respondent applied or the 28-6-1961 guidelines relied upon by the appellant applied?
(3) If the 28-6-1961 guidelines applied, whether the decision of DPC dated 16-4-1999 was not liable to be set aside on the ground that the writ petitioner's name was not considered?
Point 1
7. It was practically conceded before us by all the parties that for DPC dated 16-4-1999, the Punjab circular dated 1-10-1999 which adopted the Central Government's guidelines for DPC did not apply. DPC would not have obviously applied the guidelines which were formulated much later. Therefore, the view of the High Court that as per the Central guidelines dated 1-10-1999 adopted by the Punjab Government, eight candidates had to be considered could not be accepted. The entire reasoning of the High Court based on the 1-10-1999 guidelines would fall to the ground. Point 1 is decided in favour of the appellant.
Points 2 and 3
8. In our view, the respondent writ-petitioner is no doubt right in contending that he has a fundamental right to be considered for promotion but this is available only if the 1st respondent falls within the prescribed zone of consideration. That question depends again on the relevant guidelines in Punjab as applicable on the date DPC met, i.e, 10-4-1999.
9. The respondent is not right in relying upon the State guidelines dated 17-6-1960 which no doubt require at least three names to be considered for each post. But, in our view, those guidelines are no longer applicable once the 28-6-1961 guidelines, extracted above, have come into being. Therefore, it is these guidelines dated 28-6-1961 that are applicable and have been rightly applied by DPC. We have already extracted the guidelines of 28-6-1961.
10. Now, it appears that by the date of DPC meeting on 16-4-1999, the position was that the seniority list of Superintending Engineers was as follows: (1) Mr K.K Vasisht, (2) Mr Subhash Malhotra, (3) Mr Sarabjit Singh (appellant), (4) Mr D.P Bajaj, (5) Mr B.K Thapar, (6) Mr B.D Gupta (respondent writ-petitioner), (7) Mr Gurdip Singh, and (8) Mr Gurbax Singh.
11. Admittedly, DPC first called for the files of the first five and later, it also called for the files of the next three, in all eight. At the time of calling for the files, it was not in a position to say whether it could select three candidates for the post of Chief Engineer from the first five. (Mr Bajaj was already on deputation.)
12. But, ultimately, DPC was able to select three from the first five. The procedure followed by DPC, in our view, is consistent with the guidelines dated 28-6-1961, under which for three posts, five names had to be considered. DPC said that having regard to certain adverse remarks/departmental enquiries, it did not find Nos. 1 and 2 in seniority — Mr K.K Vasisht and Mr Subhash Malhotra — suitable for promotion. It recommended the appellant Mr Sarabjit Singh and the two others, Mr D.P Bajaj and Mr B.K Thapar. In other words, DPC was able to select three out of the first five names as explained earlier and this was permissible under the guidelines of 28-6-1961. So far as 25-11-1995 guidelines of the State were concerned, they referred to the Central guidelines only to the extent of the need to have periodical DPCs in time.
13. There was, therefore, no need for considering the name of the writ petitioner, who was the sixth candidate. Therefore, the writ petitioner's case was rightly not considered for promotion. The High Court erred in applying the wrong guidelines and in thinking that eight names ought to have been considered (including the name of the writ petitioner) and in directing fresh DPC on that ground.
14. The judgment of the High Court is set aside and the recommendation of DPC dated 16-4-1999 and the consequential promotions of Respondents 2, 3 and 4 in WP No. 13240 of 1999 (including that of the appellant) are upheld. There will be no order as to costs.
Alert