Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Indian Airlines Ltd. And Others v. S. Gopalakrishnan .

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 12, 2000
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Appellant 1 issued a notice dated 8-8-1997 inviting applications for the post of Junior Operator in its southern region. The notice prescribed, among other conditions, that candidates must have specific educational qualifications, a current heavy vehicle driving licence, and a stipulated period of experience to be computed after the date of acquiring the necessary qualification.

The respondent applied for the post. He held an ITI certificate since June 1994 and a Diploma in Mechanical Engineering obtained in April 1996. He had a licence to drive a light motor vehicle from 9-1-1987, with an endorsement from 29-6-1994 to drive heavy motor vehicles as well. He was not selected on the ground that he did not possess two years’ experience in heavy vehicle driving after acquiring a Diploma in Mechanical/Electrical/Automobile Engineering.

The respondent challenged the non-selection by filing a writ petition before the High Court. The learned Single Judge held that the respondent possessed the necessary qualifications and found the action of Appellant 1 in not appointing him to be arbitrary, granting relief accordingly. A writ appeal against this decision was unsuccessful. Appellants then preferred these appeals by special leave to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, when both qualification and experience are prescribed, the required experience must be acquired after obtaining the prescribed educational qualification(s) for the post of Junior Operator.
  2. Whether the respondent satisfied the prescribed qualifications and post-qualification experience requirements under either eligibility pathway set out in the employment notice and relevant rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
N. Suresh Nathan v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 584; (1992) 19 ATC 928 Experience must be obtained after acquiring the requisite qualification. Relied upon to affirm that experience is to be computed only after the date of acquiring the necessary qualification.
Gurdial Singh v. State of Punjab, (1995) 3 SCC 333 Necessity of post-qualification experience where both qualification and experience are prescribed. Cited to reinforce the requirement that pre-qualification experience cannot be counted.
Anil Kumar Gupta v. Municipal Corpn. of Delhi, (2000) 1 SCC 128 Experience requirement is to be reckoned after obtaining the prescribed qualification. Used to support the interpretation that only post-qualification experience satisfies the rule.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified the “short point” as the job requirements for the Junior Operator post, which were detailed in the employment notice. The corresponding rules prescribed two alternative eligibility pathways:

  • SSC or equivalent with a three-year Government-recognised Diploma in Mechanical/Electrical/Automobile Engineering, plus two years’ experience in equipment operations or driving, and a current heavy vehicle driving licence.
  • SSC with an ITI certificate (or equivalent in associated trades) and five years’ experience in equipment operating or driving, and a current heavy vehicle driving licence.

The employment notice further clarified, in the general information (Item 6), that “experience will be computed after the date of acquiring the necessary qualifications.”

Applying these terms, the Court held that when both qualification and experience are prescribed, the experience required must be acquired after obtaining the necessary qualification, not before. This interpretation was supported by the cited precedents which consistently explained the necessity of post-qualification experience.

Assessing the respondent’s credentials, the Court noted:

  • Under the ITI route (acquired in June 1994), the respondent did not possess five years of experience after obtaining the ITI certificate as required by the rules.
  • Under the Diploma route (diploma obtained in April 1996), the respondent did not have the requisite post-qualification experience by the relevant date.

Given the explicit instruction that experience would be computed only after acquiring the necessary qualification, the Court concluded that the High Court’s contrary view—both at the Single Judge and Division Bench stages—was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: Appeals allowed; High Court’s orders set aside; writ petition dismissed; No costs.

Implications: The immediate effect is that the respondent is not entitled to appointment as Junior Operator based on the qualifications and experience he held as of the relevant date. The decision reinforces, consistent with existing precedent and the explicit terms of the employment notice, that only post-qualification experience counts toward experience requirements when both qualification and experience are prescribed. The opinion applies established principles and sets no new precedent beyond affirming the stated rule.

Show all summary ...

S. Rajendra Babu, J.— Leave granted.

2. Appellant 1 called for applications by notice dated 8-8-1997 for the post of Junior Operator for its southern region. In the said notice, the requisite qualification for appointment as a Junior Operator is that the candidate should have two years' experience in equipment operating or driving and possess current heavy vehicles driving licence. It is also stated therein that the experience would be computed after the date of acquiring the necessary qualification. The respondent, who made an application for the said post, possesses an ITI certificate since 1994 and a diploma in Mechanical Engineering, which was obtained in April 1996 and on 9-1-1987 he was granted a licence to drive light motor vehicle and subsequently the same was endorsed on 29-6-1994 to drive the heavy motor vehicles as well. On the ground that the respondent did not possess two years' experience in heavy vehicle driving after his acquiring diploma in Mechanical/Electrical/Automobile Engineering, the respondent was not selected for the said post. Thereafter he filed a writ petition before the High Court. The learned Single Judge held that the respondent possesses the necessary qualification for being appointed as a Junior Operator and held the action of Appellant 1 in not appointing him and giving him a posting, arbitrary and, therefore, granted the relief. The writ appeal filed against the same also being unsuccessful, these appeals are preferred by special leave.

3. The short point for consideration is as to what is the job requirement of the Junior Operator and they are set out in the employment notice which reads as under:

“To drive, position, connect and operate ground support equipments, including driving of transport vehicles. To carry out refueling, oiling, air-charging, battery replacement and daily checks of group support equipment/vehicles. To perform incidental paperwork for recording, reporting incidents/accidents, operations, maintenance, etc. To assist operators/technicians in performance of their jobs. To tow aircraft and other ground support equipment/dolleys, trolleys, etc. as per laid-down procedures. To keep current licences/permits required for operation/driving of vehicles/equipments as laid down from time to time.”

Under the relevant rules, the qualification prescribed is as follows:

“2.1 SSC or its equivalent with three years' Government-recognised diploma in Mechanical/Electrical/Automobile Engineering and having two years' experience in equipment operations or driving and possessing current heavy vehicle driving licence.
2.2 SSC with ITI certificate or equivalent in associated trades of mechanical/electrical/automobile courses and having five years' experience in equipment operating or driving and possessing current heavy vehicle driving licence.”

4. The respondent has obtained the ITI certificate in June 1994 and he had about five years of experience after obtaining the certificate and diploma in Mechanical Engineering was obtained in April 1996. In any event, it is clear that the experience obtained by him falls short of the requisite qualification. This Court in N. Suresh Nathan v. Union of India 1992 Supp (1) SCC 584, (1992) 19 ATC 928; Gurdial Singh v. State of Punjab (1995) 3 SCC 333 and Anil Kumar Gupta v. Municipal Corpn. of Delhi (2000) 1 SCC 128 has explained the necessity to obtain experience after obtaining the requisite qualification.

5. When in addition to qualification, experience is prescribed, it would only mean acquiring experience after obtaining the necessary qualification and not before obtaining such qualification. In the case of the respondent, he obtained the ITI certificate in the year 1994 and, therefore, did not possess five years of experience as required under the relevant rule. If his qualification as a diploma-holder in Mechanical Engineering is taken note of, he has not completed three years of experience as he got the same in April 1996 and on the relevant date he did not possess such qualification. Indeed in prescribing qualification and experience, it is also made clear in the general information instruction at Item 6 that “experience will be computed after the date of acquiring the necessary qualifications”. Therefore, when this requirement was made very clear that he should have experience only after acquiring the qualification, the view taken by the High Court to the contrary either by the learned Single Judge or the Division Bench does not stand to reason.

6. Therefore, we allow these appeals, set aside the order made by the High Court and dismiss the writ petition filed by the respondent in the High Court. No costs.