Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shankar Lal And Another v. Sakil Ahmed And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 25, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

Order

1. This appeal is at the instance of Defendant 1. The plaintiff-respondents herein filed a suit for possession against Defendants 1 and 2. Defendant 1 filed a written statement wherein it was stated that he and Defendant 2 are the owners in possession of the land for the last twenty years. Defendant 2 put in appearance through counsel. However, he did not file any written statement. During the trial of the suit, Defendant 2 Poonam Chand died on 1-3-1974 leaving behind four sons, namely, Lal Chand, Bhura Ram, Nem Chand and Prabhu Dayal as his heirs. However, this fact was not brought to the notice of the trial court either by the plaintiffs or by the defendants. The trial court decreed the suit of the plaintiff-respondents. Defendant 1 preferred an appeal before the first appellate court and in the grounds of appeal, one of the objections taken was that in view of the fact that Defendant 2 Poonam Chand who died on 1-3-1974 having not been substituted by his heirs, the suit had abated. The first appellate court was of the view that in view of Order 22 sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the suit had not abated. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. Defendant 1 thereafter filed second appeal before the High Court but the same was also dismissed. It is against the said judgment, Defendant 1 is in appeal before us.

2. Learned counsel for the appellant urged that in the absence of substitution of Defendant 2 by his heirs the suit had abated and the decree passed by the court below was a nullity. Learned counsel also urged that sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of Order 22 which was inserted in the Code of Civil Procedure by Amendment Act 104 of 1976 which came into force with effect from 1-2-1977 had no retrospective application, therefore, the suit filed by the plaintiffs had abated. Learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff-respondents argued that Defendant 1 having participated in the proceedings before the trial court without any kind of objection, it is no longer open to him to raise the plea that the suit had abated in the absence of substitution of the deceased Defendant 2.

3. It is not disputed that Defendant 2 Poonam Chand died on 1-3-1974 leaving behind four adult sons. It is also not in dispute that the plaintiffs did not apply for substitution of Defendant 2 either in the trial court or before the first appellate court. The question, therefore, arises whether under such circumstances, the plaintiffs can take benefit of sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of Order 22. Sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 was brought on the statute-book by Act 104 of 1976 with effect from 1-2-1977, which reads thus:

“4. (4) The court whenever it thinks fit, may exempt the plaintiff from the necessity of substituting the legal representatives of any such defendant who has failed to file a written statement or who, having filed it, has failed to appear and contest the suit at the hearing; and judgment may, in such case, be pronounced against the said defendant notwithstanding the death of such defendant and shall have the same force and effect as if it has been pronounced before death took place.”

4. Admittedly when Defendant 2 died, the said provision was not on the statute-book. It is also not in dispute that the amended provision of Order 22 sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 had no retrospective effect. Under the provisions, as existed then, the plaintiffs were required to substitute Defendant 2 failing which suit was to abate under Rule 4(3) of Order 22 CPC. We are, therefore, of the view that the plaintiffs cannot derive any benefit out of amended sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of Order 22 CPC as it was not in existence then.

5. Coming to the next question, suffice it to say that under the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure as they existed at the relevant date, it was for the plaintiff to have taken steps for substitution of Defendant 2 and in the absence of such steps suit was to abate. Merely because Defendant 1 participated in the proceedings before the trial court without any kind of objection, it does not mean that the defendant had disentitled himself to raise the plea before the first appellate court. In fact, non-raising of objection before the trial court would not amount to waiver or acquiescence or condonation of default committed by the plaintiffs. Since the plaintiffs had not taken any steps for substitution of Defendant 2 the suit had abated under Order 22 Rule 4(3).

6. For the aforesaid reasons, we are of the view that this appeal deserves to succeed. We, accordingly, set aside the decree of the trial court as affirmed by the High Court. The appeal is allowed. Suit No. 49 of 1973 shall be treated as having abated. There shall be no order as to costs.