- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vinod Bhanti v. State Of Bihar And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant was employed as an Orthotist and Prosthetist at the Artificial Limb Centre, Patna, originally run by the Red Cross Society and subsequently taken over by the Government of Bihar. He was confirmed on 11-10-1977 with effect from 22-9-1977. On 6-11-1981 the appellant tendered a resignation to take effect from 30-11-1981, but withdrew it on 6-12-1981 before any governmental acceptance. In the intervening period the Artificial Limb Centre became non-functional, and the appellant was transferred to the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Patna Medical College Hospital, where he formally joined on 3-4-1988.
Despite correspondence from hospital authorities requesting re-assignment and salary release, the State Government issued an order on 24-5-1994 stating that the appellant, having been “absent” for more than five years (6-12-1981 to 11-4-1988), would be deemed to have been relieved from service. The appellant’s writ petition challenging this order was dismissed by a Single Judge of the Patna High Court, and the dismissal was affirmed in Letters Patent Appeal No. 776 of 1995. The present civil appeal challenges those concurrent findings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant could be deemed to have been relieved from service on the ground of alleged continuous absence exceeding five years despite withdrawal of his resignation and the non-functional status of the Centre during that period.
- Whether the appellant is entitled to back wages for the period between 6-12-1981 and 11-4-1988 when the Centre was non-operational.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court found that once the appellant withdrew his resignation, there was no legal basis to treat him as having voluntarily left service. The key factual consideration was that the Artificial Limb Centre remained non-functional from 6-12-1981 to 11-4-1988, eliminating any possibility of the appellant performing duties there during that span. Furthermore, the appellant was permitted by the authorities to resume work on 3-4-1988 and continued in active service until the disputed governmental order of 24-5-1994.
Given these circumstances, the Court held that labeling the appellant “absent” for more than five years was factually incorrect. It also noted that both the Single Judge and the Division Bench failed to appreciate these critical facts, constituting an error apparent on the face of the record.
Regarding monetary relief, the Court applied the principle that wages correlate with actual work rendered. Because the Centre was closed, the appellant could not have worked; therefore, awarding back wages for that interval was unwarranted. Nonetheless, equity required that he receive continuity of service and the attendant benefits.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED; GOVERNMENT AND HIGH COURT ORDERS QUASHED.
The appellant is reinstated with continuity of service and all consequential benefits except back wages for the period during which the Centre was non-functional. The decision directly affects only the parties, sets aside the earlier High Court judgments, and does not establish a new precedent beyond reaffirming that an unaccepted resignation, once withdrawn, cannot ground a deemed termination absent actual misconduct or prolonged voluntary absence.
Order
1. This civil appeal is directed against the judgment dated 1-5-1996 rendered by the Division Bench of the High Court of Patna in Letters Patent Appeal No. 776 of 1995 affirming the judgment of the learned Single Judge.
2. The relevant facts for the disposal of this appeal may be briefly summarised as under:
The appellant joined as Orthotist and Prothotist at the Artificial Limb Centre, Patna run by the Red Cross Society. This Centre was taken over by the Government of Bihar. This Centre was thereafter transferred to the Health Department of the Government of Bihar. The appellant came to be confirmed on 11-10-1977 with effect from 22-9-1977. The appellant was asked by the Professor and Head of the Orthopaedics Department, Medical College Hospital to take lectures in Patna Medical College Hospital. It appears that the appellant on 6-11-1981 submitted his letter of resignation to be effective from 30-11-1981. Before the acceptance of the resignation letter by the Government the appellant on 6-12-1981 withdrew the same. The appellant thereafter came to be transferred to Patna Medical College Hospital in the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. Thus the appellant continued in service.
3. On 3-4-1988 the appellant joined the Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Department. Respondent 4 wrote to the State Government that since the appellant's resignation was not accepted, he may be asked to start the Rehabilitation Centre. Respondent 4 pursued this matter on the same lines and requested the Government to allow the appellant to rejoin at the Artificial Limb Centre which was closed down some three years back so that the said Centre would become functional. In view of this correspondence resting with the Government, Respondent 4 also asked the Government to release the salary of the appellant. From the record it appears that the appellant was awarded certificate of honour in recognition of his good services during the past 25 years at the Limb Centre. However, on 24-5-1994 the Government informed the Professor and Head of the Department (Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Department), Patna Medical College Hospital that although the appellant's resignation was not accepted but as he was absent for more than 5 years from 6-12-1981 till 11-4-1988 he would be deemed to have been relieved from service. Consequently, the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation of Patna Medical College Hospital informed the appellant that he would be deemed to have been relieved from the Limb Centre workshop.
4. Aggrieved by this order the appellant preferred a writ petition claiming certain reliefs. The learned Single Judge by the judgment and order dated 26-7-1995 dismissed the said writ petition. The letters patent appeal filed by the appellant met with the same fate. It is against this judgment of the High Court the appellant has filed this civil appeal.
5. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, we are of the opinion that after having withdrawn the resignation the appellant could not be deemed to have been relieved in view of the facts and circumstances of the case that the Centre was not functional during 6-12-1981 till 11-4-1988. In addition to this the appellant was allowed to resume work from 3-4-1988 and continued to work till he was deemed to have been relieved from service vide order dated 24-5-1994. In our opinion, the material on record does not indicate that the appellant was absent from the service for more than 5 years. In these circumstances, the Government was totally wrong in holding that the appellant was absent for more than 5 years and therefore he would be deemed to have been relieved from service.
6. The learned Single Judge of the Patna High Court as well as the Division Bench did not refer to these aspects while dismissing the cause of the appellant. Since this error is apparent on the face of the record we are of the opinion that the impugned orders of the High Court cannot be sustained. Consequently, the order dated 24-5-1994 passed by the Government and confirmed by learned Single Judge and affirmed by the court of appeal are required to be quashed and set aside and we accordingly do so.
7. The next question that needs to be considered is as to whether the appellant is entitled to back wages for the period 6-12-1981 to 11-4-1988 during which period he was not doing any work at the Centre. As indicated earlier, since the Centre itself had become non-functional there was no question of not working in such a non-functional Centre and therefore we would be justified in denying the back wages for the period for which he did not actually work. This, however, does not preclude the appellant from getting continuity of service and other benefits flowing therefrom. Consequently we direct that the appellant be allowed to resume the work. He will get continuity of service but however he will not be entitled to the back wages during the period for which he did not work at the Centre.
8. In the result, the appeal succeeds and the impugned judgments and orders of the High Court are set aside. Consequently, the order dated 24-5-1994 passed by the Government and communicated by the Department on 1-6-1994 to the appellant are quashed and set aside. In the circumstances, there will be no order as to costs.
Alert