Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Manoj Alias Bhau And Others v. State Of Maharashtra .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 8, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns six accused who were alleged to have formed an unlawful assembly and fatally assaulted one Raju on 18 April 1990 at about 9 p.m. with a gupti, knife, hockey sticks and a motorcycle chain outside his home in Nagpur. The learned Additional Sessions Judge, Nagpur, convicted all six under Sections 147, 148 and 302 read with 149 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and sentenced them to one year’s rigorous imprisonment (RI) for Section 147, two years’ RI for Section 148, and life imprisonment for Section 302/149, the sentences to run concurrently.

The convictions were affirmed by the Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench, on appeal (Criminal Appeals Nos. 237 and 227 of 1991). Three of the six accused—Accused 1, 2 and 3—filed the present appeal before the Supreme Court. The other three did not appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction could be sustained on the testimony of only two eyewitnesses (PWs 1 and 8) whose statements allegedly contained embellishments, exaggerations and omissions.
  2. Whether, on the evidence, Accused 2 and 3 could be held liable for murder with the aid of Section 149 IPC, or whether their guilt was not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
  3. Whether the conviction of Accused 1 for murder was supported by reliable evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The eyewitnesses (PWs 1 and 8) made substantial embellishments and omissions between their police statements and court testimony, rendering their evidence unreliable.
  • The First Information Report (FIR) was sketchy; because its “foundation” failed, the later oral evidence (“superstructure”) was also unreliable.
  • The presence of PWs 1 and 8 at the scene was doubtful; therefore they could not be treated as eyewitnesses.

Respondent-State's Arguments

  • Any embellishments pointed out by the defence did not go to the substratum of the prosecution case; the core narrative remained intact.
  • Medical evidence corroborated the eyewitness account, especially regarding injuries compatible with the weapons allegedly used by the accused.
  • The prompt lodging of the FIR (within about 30 minutes, police station 3 km away) supported the credibility of PW 1.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook a limited re-appreciation of evidence because two courts below had relied on the same eyewitnesses. It scrutinised the alleged omissions and exaggerations to determine whether they affected the “basic prosecution case” or could be segregated as “chaff”.

Assessment of PW 1 (Father of deceased): The Court noted some omissions—e.g., failure to tell police that the accused emerged from Accused 4’s house or that specific abuses were uttered—but found no material omission about Accused 1’s role. PW 1 consistently stated that Accused 1 had a gupti and delivered 4–5 blows. The medical evidence (17 injuries, any of the first three individually sufficient to cause death) corroborated this. PW 1, however, did not attribute specific overt acts to Accused 2 or Accused 3 beyond a general assertion that “all accused assaulted.”

Assessment of PW 8 (Mother of deceased): Her testimony corroborated PW 1 regarding Accused 1’s gupti blows. Yet she contradicted herself about the weapons of Accused 2 and 3 (stick vs. iron chain) and those details were absent from her police statement. Thus, her evidence was held reliable as to Accused 1 but insufficiently specific regarding Accused 2 and 3.

Section 149 IPC: Because no clear, consistent evidence established specific participation by Accused 2 and 3 or demonstrated the essential common object required under Section 149, the Court held it unsafe to sustain their convictions with the aid of that provision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is PARTLY ALLOWED. Accused 2 and 3 are acquitted of all charges and ordered to be released forthwith unless wanted in another case. The conviction and life sentence of Accused 1 under Sections 302/34 IPC (along with the non-appealing accused) are affirmed.

Implications: The immediate effect is the release of two appellants and the continuation of life imprisonment for Accused 1. The judgment turns on fact-specific credibility assessment and does not establish a new legal precedent, but it underscores the Supreme Court’s willingness to re-examine eyewitness reliability where significant inconsistencies are alleged.

Show all summary ...

G.B Pattanaik, J.— The three appellants, who are Accused 1, 2 and 3 respectively, along with 3 others who have not preferred any appeal were tried by the learned Additional Judge, Nagpur in Sessions Case No. 70 of 1990 for the offences punishable under Sections 147, 148 and 302 read with Section 149 Indian Penal Code on the allegation that they formed an unlawful assembly and mercilessly assaulted deceased Raju by means of a gupti, knife, hockey sticks and a motorcycle chain on account of which Raju succumbed to injuries sustained by him. The learned Sessions Judge on the basis of the prosecution evidence convicted all of them under Sections 147, 148 and 302 read with Section 149 Indian Penal Code and sentenced them to suffer RI for one year and to pay a fine of Rs 100 and, in default to suffer RI for one week for conviction under Section 147, and for Section 148 sentenced each one of them to suffer RI for two years and to pay a fine of Rs 100 each and, in default to suffer RI for one week and imprisonment for life for the conviction under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC with the further direction that the sentences would run concurrently. Against the conviction and sentences two criminal appeals were preferred; one by the present appellants which was registered as Criminal Appeal No. 237 of 1991 and the other by the rest 3 accused persons which was registered as Criminal Appeal No. 227 of 1991 and both the appeals were heard and were disposed of by the common impugned judgment and the learned Judges of the Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench dismissed both the appeals and maintained the conviction and sentences imposed upon the accused persons. As has been stated earlier, only 3 of the appellants have preferred the appeals whereas the other 3 accused persons have not preferred any appeal.

2. The prosecution case in a nutshell is that the 3 appellants are all brothers and the other 3 accused persons who have not preferred any appeal are their friends. The appellants have their houses in front of the house of deceased Raju. The appellants belong to one political organisation called “Chhatrapati Sena” and deceased Raju also was a member of the said organisation. But during the election of the Legislative Assembly in the year 1989 deceased Raju carried the propaganda for the candidate belonging to Congress (I) and on account of this incident the relationship between the accused persons and deceased Raju was strained. On 18-4-1990 at about 9.00 p.m while the deceased and his parents PWs 1 and 8 and one Pitamber were sitting on the terrace of their house Accused 1 to 6 came out of the house of Accused 4 and went to the house of one Shrikhande which is in fact right in front of the house of deceased Raju. All of them then entered into the courtyard and abused Raju and challenged him to come down to the courtyard. When Raju came down, Accused 4 caught hold of the right hand of the deceased and dragged him outside the courtyard whereafter all of them together took him to the front house of Shrikhande. Accused 1 was holding a gupti, Accused 2 was holding a stick and Accused 3 was holding a motorcycle chain while Accused 4 was having a hockey stick and Accused 5 and 6 were having a knife with them. As per the prosecution case the accused persons surrounded deceased Raju and assaulted him by giving blows with the weapons in their hands on account of which Raju fell down on the ground but notwithstanding the same the accused persons continued inflicting blows on him as a result of which he died on the spot. It is also the prosecution case that PWs 1 and 8 followed Raju and when PW 8 requested the accused persons not to assault Raju she was pushed aside. After the accused persons left the scene of the occurrence the parents of the deceased cried for help when people from the village gathered and then the father of the deceased, PW 1 went to the police station and lodged a report which was treated as the first information report Exhibit 21. The police then registered the case and started investigation and after completion of investigation submitted the charge-sheet. The case was then committed to the Court of Session and the accused persons were tried, as already stated. The post-mortem report Exhibit 27 and the evidence of the doctor, PW 2 who conducted the autopsy over the dead body indicate that the deceased had as many as 17 external injuries and Injuries 1, 2 and 3 were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death individually or collectively. The injuries were ante-mortem in nature. This conclusion of the learned Sessions Judge, as affirmed by the High Court has not been assailed before us in this appeal. Out of the three eyewitnesses PWs 1, 8 and 12 learned Additional Sessions Judge relied upon their testimony and came to the conclusion that the prosecution case as against the accused persons has been proved beyond reasonable doubt. On appeal the High Court, however, disbelieved the evidence of PW 12 on a finding that his presence at the scene of the occurrence itself was doubtful but the conviction and sentences passed by the learned Sessions Judge was affirmed relying upon the testimony of the two other eyewitnesses, namely, PWs 1 and 8.

3. Mr U.R Lalit, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants vehemently argued that the two eyewitnesses have made so much of embellishments, exaggeration and padding to their statements recorded under Section 161 CrPC that it is difficult for a court of law to rely on such testimony and the Sessions Judge and the High Court committed serious error in relying upon such untrustworthy testimony to base the conviction. Mr Lalit further contended that the very foundation of the prosecution case as unfolded in the first information report given by PW 1 having failed the superstructure, as unfolded by the two eyewitnesses also must fail and it is highly unsafe to rely on the testimony of these two eyewitnesses only, so far as the alleged assault by the accused persons on the deceased Raju is concerned inasmuch as the entire evidence is only chaff with no grain therein. Mr Lalit also submitted that on a reading of the evidence of PWs 1 and 8 it would appear that both of them were not present at the scene of the occurrence and therefore, they could not have been relied upon as eyewitnesses.

4. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent-State on the other hand urged that the alleged embellishment and exaggeration pointed out by Mr Lalit, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants do not relate to the substratum of the prosecution case and, therefore, the courts below were justified in relying upon the testimony of the aforesaid two witnesses in coming to the conclusion that it is the accused persons who assaulted the deceased with the respective weapons in their hands and this fact is corroborated by the medical evidence indicating the presence of injuries on the deceased which could be caused by the weapons which were found to be in the hands of the accused persons. According to the learned counsel for the respondent there is no justification in the comment of Mr Lalit that the presence of these two witnesses has become doubtful. In view of the respective contentions of the learned counsel appearing for the parties we think it appropriate to examine the evidence of the two eyewitnesses on whose evidence the conviction of the appellants is based. Ordinarily this Court does not reappreciate the evidence when two courts have already scanned and believed the same. But on going through the omissions and exaggerations from their earlier version we thought it fit to scrutinise the evidence of the aforesaid two witnesses to find out whether the so-called exaggerations and embellishments really pertain to the basic prosecution case so that the entire evidence has to be discarded as being untrustworthy or the Court would be justified in embarking upon an enquiry for the purpose of separating the chaff from the grain and accept the grain to base the conviction. PW 1 lodged the report at the police station at 9.30 p.m on 18-4-1990 intimating about the occurrence that took place at 9.00 p.m and the distance between the police station and the place of the occurrence is 3 km. Thus the information to the police has been given with the utmost promptitude. In the first information report itself the names of the 3 appellants had been given as the members of the unlawful assembly who assaulted the deceased Raju with different weapons in their hands. A graphic picture has been indicated as to how the accused persons called Raju and after Raju came down dragged him and surrounded him and thereafter assaulted him. In the course of the argument Mr Lalit, learned Senior Counsel had urged that the FIR is rather sketchy and a vivid account of the incident has not been stated therein. But it is too well settled that the first information report need not be an encyclopaedia of the evidence and what is required to be stated is the basic prosecution case. Judged from that standpoint no grievance can be made in respect of the first information report that was given by PW 1.

5. According to PW 1, who is the father of the deceased, the 3 appellants Accused 1, 2 and 3 were residing in front of his house and he knew them fully well. While the deceased Raju, PW 1 and PW 8 were sitting on their terrace the accused persons entered the courtyard of their house and then called Raju to come down. When Raju came down from the terrace to the courtyard then all the accused persons surrounded him, dragged him to the place in front of the house of Shrikhande and Accused 1 was holding a gupti in his hand while Accused 2 and 3 were holding a hockey stick and motorcycle chain respectively. According to the witness all the accused persons including the 3 who have not preferred any appeal started giving blows on Raju with their respective weapons and even after Raju fell down some blows were further given. It is his further evidence that when the mother of the deceased PW 8 intervened Accused 1 caught hold of her and pushed her aside. Though this witness has indicated that Accused 1 dealt 4 or 5 blows of the gupti on the person of Raju but he had not stated any specific overt act to have been committed by Accused 2 and 3 apart from the general statement that all the accused persons surrounded and assaulted the deceased. In other words that Accused 2 and 3 had given blows on the deceased by means of a motorcycle chain and stick has not been stated by the witness even in the chief examination. In the cross-examination it has been elicited that he had gone on foot to lodge the report after he had visited the scene of the occurrence and on this statement Mr Lalit wanted to urge that he was not present at the scene of the occurrence and reached there later. But this is belied by the very next sentence stated by the witness: “It is not true that I have not witnessed the incident.” The defence had elicited from this witness certain omissions as indicated in para 13 of his evidence which are to the effect that he had not stated before the police that Accused 1 to 6 had come out of the house of Accused 4 and that they had come out and then entered his courtyard and the explanation offered was that he was not in a proper frame of mind. The further omission brought out from the witness is that he had not stated before the police that Accused 1, 4, 5 and 6 abused Raju by mother and sister and also that Accused 4 caught hold of the right hand of Raju and dragged him and all the accused persons then surrounded him as he was then frightened. He had also not stated before the police that Accused 4 had dealt a blow of hockey stick on Raju's head. He had also not stated before the police that Lakhmibai, PW 8 had placed herself over the body of Raju and told the accused not to assault him. It has been elicited in his cross-examination that he had not stated before the police that Accused 4 had given a threat that if evidence is given in the court then he will be murdered. It was also brought out that he omitted to say that the tubelight was burning in front of his house. Considering these omissions from the earlier statement as confronted to the witness we are not in a position to appreciate the contention of Mr Lalit that his entire evidence should be disbelieved, particularly when there has been no material omission so far as the role played by Accused 1 is concerned, that he had a gupti in his hand and assaulted Raju by means of the gupti by giving 4 or 5 blows. The nature of injuries found on deceased Raju and the medical evidence of the doctor fully corroborate the oral evidence of PW 1 so far as the role ascribed to Accused 1 is concerned. As has been stated earlier so far as the role ascribed to Accused 2 and 3 is concerned the witness has not given any definite overt acts except making the general version that all the accused surrounded and assaulted the deceased. In this view of the matter though the evidence of this witness does not assist the prosecution in bringing home the charge against Accused 2 and 3 but so far as Accused 1 is concerned the prosecution case can be said to have been proved beyond reasonable doubt on the basis of the evidence of PW 1.

6. Coming now to the evidence of PW 8, she also apart from stating in her evidence-in-chief that Accused 3 had an iron chain, Accused 2 had a stick in his hand, while indicating the blows given by each of the accused persons she stated that Accused 2 and 3 had dealt stick blows on the person of Raju. This actually contradicts her evidence that Accused 3 had an iron chain in his hand. So far as Accused 1 is concerned, she corroborates PW 1 by stating that Accused 1 started giving gupti blows on the deceased Raju. The omissions from her earlier statement to the police which she had been confronted with that she had not stated before the police that she herself and her husband and Raju were sitting on the terrace and she had stated before the police that her husband had reached there after the accused had run away, on the basis of the aforesaid material Mr Lalit had urged that PW 1 cannot be said to be an eyewitness to the occurrence. We are unable to appreciate this argument inasmuch as reading the evidence as a whole it cannot be said that PW 1 reached the scene of the occurrence only after the entire occurrence was over. So far as Accused 1 giving gupti blows on the deceased is concerned there has been no embellishment and no exaggeration made by this witness in her earliest statement to the police. But though in the Court she had stated that Accused 3 had an iron chain she had not stated so in her statement to the police and that was duly confronted to her. Even she had not stated that Accused 2 had a stick in his hand and that was also confronted to her. Having examined the aforesaid omissions we have no hesitation to come to the conclusion that the role ascribed by this witness to Accused 1 fully corroborates the evidence of PW 1 and there is no reason why the statements of the aforesaid two witnesses should not be relied upon, which have been relied upon by two courts of fact. On the aforesaid basis we agree with the conclusion of the two courts below that Accused 1 holding a gupti in his hand, dealt several blows on the deceased Raju as a result of which Raju ultimately died. But so far as the two other accused, namely, Accused 2 and 3 are concerned, we are of the considered opinion on going through the evidence of the aforesaid two eyewitnesses PWs 1 and 8, that the prosecution case as against the said two appellants cannot be said to have been proved beyond reasonable doubt. Excepting a bald, vague and general statement that all the accused surrounded and assaulted, while ascribing a positive role to different accused persons as to how and with what weapon they had assaulted the deceased and how many blows had been given, but so far as Accused 2 and 3 are concerned, there has been no whisper by either PW 1 or PW 8 and even PW 8 in her earliest statement to the police had not stated that Accused 2 and 3 were having a stick and a motorcycle chain in their hands. In this state of affairs it would be unsafe to convict Appellants 2 and 3 by taking recourse to Section 149 IPC as the necessary ingredients to attract the said section as against Accused 2 and 3 are totally absent. We have not discussed the role played by those accused persons who have not preferred any appeal, but suffice it to say that the eyewitnesses have ascribed a positive role to those non-appealing persons as to how they had given blows on deceased Raju.

7. In the aforesaid premises, we acquit Accused 2 and 3 of the charges levelled against them and direct that they shall be set at liberty forthwith unless required in any other case. But so far as Accused 1 is concerned, he is convicted along with the non-appealing accused persons under Sections 302/34 IPC and their sentence of imprisonment for life is affirmed. The appeal is thus partly allowed.