Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ashok Paper Mills Kamgar Union v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 26, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Supreme Court had earlier approved, by order dated 6 July 1996, a rehabilitation scheme for Ashok Paper Mills located in Darbhanga, Bihar. More than two and a half years later, implementation remained stalled. In response to the Court’s direction dated 8 July 1996, the Secretary, Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Government of India, filed a status report identifying the primary bottlenecks. The Court’s present order addresses two immediate impediments: (1) failure of the State of Bihar to supply uninterrupted power as promised under the scheme and (2) the absence of a tripartite agreement with the recognised workers’ union.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State of Bihar, having undertaken to provide continuous power, should furnish a financial guarantee to enable the company to procure alternative power through diesel generating sets.
  2. Whether the tripartite agreement already executed by Ashok Paper Mills Mazdoor Panchayat Union satisfies the scheme’s requirement in view of Ashok Paper Mills Kamgar Union’s refusal or failure to sign.

Arguments of the Parties

Company (NCFL)

  • Sought permission to use a portion of the term loan sanctioned by IDBI to purchase four 1000 KVA diesel generating sets.

IDBI

Ashok Paper Mills Kamgar Union

  • Through senior counsel Mr. Rakesh Dwivedi, asserted readiness to sign the tripartite agreement but alleged that management manoeuvres prevented execution.

Ashok Paper Mills Mazdoor Panchayat Union

  • Indicated that it had already executed the required agreement and represented 243 workers.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Power Supply Issue: The rehabilitation scheme placed the obligation of uninterrupted power supply squarely on the State of Bihar. The status report revealed the State’s inability to comply. To prevent further delay and in the interest of protecting workers’ livelihoods, the Court concluded that the State should honour its original commitment by furnishing a guarantee that would enable the company to acquire four diesel generators costing approximately ₹3 crore.

Union Agreement Issue: The scheme contemplated a tripartite agreement with Ashok Paper Mills Kamgar Union. Because that union had not executed the agreement, and another registered union with substantial membership (Ashok Paper Mills Mazdoor Panchayat Union) had done so, the Court held the latter agreement valid for purposes of the scheme. Nevertheless, it afforded the Kamgar Union a four-week window to execute the identical agreement should it choose to do so, failing which individual members could opt in independently.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: The State of Bihar shall stand guarantee up to ₹3 crore for procurement of four 1000 KVA diesel generating sets. The company is to submit a proposal forthwith, and the State must issue appropriate orders within three weeks of receipt.

Labour Relations: The agreement executed by Ashok Paper Mills Mazdoor Panchayat Union is declared valid. Ashok Paper Mills Kamgar Union may sign the same agreement within four weeks; otherwise, individual members may adhere independently.

Additional Directions: IDBI is directed to respond to IA Nos. 3 and 5 filed by NCFL; the matters will be listed after the summer vacation. The impleadment application of Ashok Paper Mills Mazdoor Panchayat Union is allowed.

Implications: The order removes two critical barriers—power supply and labour agreement—thus facilitating continued implementation of the Court-approved rehabilitation scheme. No new legal precedent was articulated beyond enforcement of obligations specific to the parties.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. The scheme of rehabilitation of Ashok Paper Mills in Darbhanga in the State of Bihar was finalised by this Court after prolonged negotiations by order dated 6-7-1996. More than two and a half years have elapsed, yet the implementation has not been possible for one reason or the other and the parties required to implement the scheme are putting forth blame on one side or the other. This Court had called upon by order dated 8-7-1996 to file a status report indicating what all has happened in the matter of implementation of the scheme and pursuant to the aforesaid order, the Secretary, Government of India, Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion in the Ministry of Industry has filed a status report. The said report indicates that the main obstacle in implementing the scheme by way of running the factory is the supply of power. Under the scheme, the State of Bihar had taken the responsibility of supplying uninterrupted power obviously in the interest of the hundreds of labourers who would have otherwise been disengaged if the factory would have come to a closure. From the status report it transpires that the State is not in a position to supply uninterrupted power to the factory and, therefore, it was suggested that the alternative method of installing four diesel generating sets of 1000 KVA each should be adopted by the entrepreneur NCFL for getting the power in question. The Company wanted to utilise the term loan that was sanctioned by IDBI under the scheme but IDBI does not agree to any part of the term loan being utilised for this purpose as there would be a deviation of the scheme itself. Since the State of Bihar had undertaken the responsibility of continuous power supply to the Company and it has failed to discharge its obligation, we think that the State of Bihar should stand as a guarantor to the Company on whose guarantee the four diesel generating sets of 1000 KVA can be purchased for getting uninterrupted power supply. On query to Mr K.K Venugopal, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the Company he states that the approximate cost of these four diesel generating sets would be three crores. In the circumstances, we direct that the State of Bihar would stand guarantee for the supply of the aforesaid four diesel generating sets to the tune of three crores so that the difficulty in getting the power supply will stand obviated. The Company should give immediate proposal to the State of Bihar in this regard and on getting the said proposal, within three weeks from the receipt of the proposal appropriate orders may be passed by the State of Bihar for standing guarantee to the tune of rupees three crores to meet the costs of the four diesel generating sets.

2. The further dispute is with regard to the labour union who were under the scheme required to sign the tripartite agreement. Under the scheme in question Ashok Paper Mills Kamgar Union was to enter into an agreement on behalf of the labourers. From the status report as well as other documents presented before us in this proceeding it appears that the President of the said Kamgar Union though initially had participated in deliberations but later on resiled from entering into an agreement. According to Mr Rakesh Dwivedi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the said Union the Union was all along prepared to enter into the agreement but it is the manoeuvring of the Management which prevented them from entering into an agreement and the agreement has been entered into by another registered union, namely, Ashok Paper Mills Mazdoor Panchayat Union which is represented by Mr Mishra in this Court. Without delving into the question as to whether the Kamgar Union itself did not participate in the proceedings and did not enter into an agreement or the Union was prevented by some other process since a registered union has already entered into an agreement and that such Union has a membership of 243, we think it appropriate to hold that the said agreement would be a valid agreement for the purpose of implementation of the scheme. But at the same time, we also grant an opportunity to the Kamgar Union to enter into the agreement with the same terms which had already been entered into by the other Mazdoor Panchayat Union and this may be done within a period of four weeks from today and if such an agreement is entered into within this period then this will be in accordance with the terms of the scheme itself.

3. If, however, the Kamgar Union does not enter into any agreement within four weeks from today then they cannot complain of another union having already entered into the terms with the Company and the individual members of the Union, those who are interested in abiding by the agreement already entered into by the other union, can do so on their own and this should be also in compliance with the scheme that has been approved by this Court.

4. IAs Nos. 3 and 5 have been filed by NCFL for further directions from this Court. Response of IDBI may be obtained on the same and they shall be listed after the summer vacation.

5. The impleadment application argued by Mr P.S Mishra, learned Senior Counsel on behalf of Ashok Paper Mills Mazdoor Panchayat Union is allowed.

Court Masters