Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Workmen Of Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. Hindustan Lever Ltd. And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 7, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The three workmen—Shiv Raj Singh Verma (Area Supervisor), Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C. Saxena (both Block Supervisors)—were employed in the respondent’s unit for manufacture of dehydrated peas. On 7-10-1972 the unit was closed and their services were terminated. The industrial dispute referred to the Labour Court questioned (i) non-payment of wages/compensatory leave for weekly offs and (ii) the legality of their termination. By its award dated 6-8-1983, the Labour Court held the termination illegal and directed reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages.

The respondent challenged this award in a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court. On 27-2-1997, the High Court allowed the writ, set aside the Labour Court award and thus relieved the respondent of the reinstatement and back-wage obligations. Aggrieved, the workmen (through their union) filed a special leave petition (SLP) before the Supreme Court. During pendency of the litigation they had been receiving interim wages under Section 17-B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the non-payment of wages in lieu of weekly offs or failure to grant compensatory leave to the workmen was proper and lawful.
  2. Whether the termination of services of the three workmen on 7-10-1972 was proper and lawful, and if not, what relief they were entitled to.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The manufacturing unit had been closed since 7-10-1972; consequently, the workmen had not rendered any service since that date.
  • The workmen had already received considerable sums under Section 17-B of the Industrial Disputes Act from the date of the Labour Court award until the High Court judgment.
  • In view of the long passage of time and closure of the unit, a lump-sum monetary compensation would be more appropriate than reinstatement.

Petitioners’ (Workmen’s) Position

  • Initially sought reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages as directed by the Labour Court.
  • During Supreme Court hearing, agreed to forgo reinstatement if adequate lump-sum compensation was paid.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted the prolonged period since termination and the fact that the unit had ceased operations. Observing that the workmen had not actually worked since 1972 yet had already received statutory interim wages, the Court considered a negotiated monetary settlement to be equitable. On a suggestion mooted during the hearing, the respondent agreed to pay:

  • Rs 5 lakhs each to Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C. Saxena (in addition to the amounts already paid under Section 17-B).
  • Rs 2.5 lakhs to the legal heirs of the deceased workman Shiv Raj Singh Verma (also in addition to amounts already received).

Counsel for the workmen accepted these terms and expressly abandoned the claim for reinstatement and other consequential benefits. The Court found the settlement fair in the circumstances and decided to dispose of the SLP on these agreed terms.

Holding and Implications

The special leave petition was DISPOSED OF with a direction that the respondent pay the agreed sums—Rs 5 lakhs each to Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C. Saxena, and Rs 2.5 lakhs to the heirs of Shiv Raj Singh Verma—within four weeks.

Implications: The dispute is finally resolved through a consensual monetary settlement; the workmen relinquish any right to reinstatement. The order is confined to the parties and sets no broader precedent.

Show all summary ...

D.P Wadhwa, J.— Three workmen of the respondent through their Union, seek leave to appeal to this Court against judgment dated 27-2-1997 of the Allahabad High Court allowing the writ petition filed by the respondent. In the judgment, the High Court set aside the award dated 6-8-1983 of the Labour Court holding that termination of the services of the three workmen was not legal and directed that the respondent

“shall reinstate them on work with continuity of their past service and to pay to them full wages and other allowances which they would have drawn if their services would not have been terminated for the period 7-10-1972 to their reinstatement”.

2. Of the three workmen, one would have retired on 31-8-1990 if he had continued in service. He later expired. He is Shiv Raj Singh Verma. During the pendency of the writ petition in the High Court, he has been paid a total sum of Rs 1,33,233 in view of Section 17-B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The other two workmen, namely, Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C Saxena have each been paid Rs 2,27,033 under the similar provision till the award was set aside by the High Court by the impugned judgment. It is stated before us that these workmen have about two more years of service if they had continued in service with the respondent.

3. The industrial dispute which was raised and referred to the Labour Court was as under:

“Whether the non-payment of wages in lieu of weekly offs or not giving any compensatory leave in lieu thereof, by the employers to their workmen, Shri Shiv Raj Singh Verma, Area Supervisor and Messrs Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C Saxena, Block Supervisors in accordance with the employer's order dated 1-2-1969, is proper and/or lawful, if not then, to what benefit/compensation are the workmen concerned entitled and from which date and with what other details.

Whether termination by the employers of the services of their workmen, Shri Shiv Raj Singh, Area Supervisor and Messrs Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C Saxena, Block Supervisors is proper and/or lawful, if not, to what benefit/compensation are the workmen concerned entitled and with what other details.”

4. While the Labour Court held in favour of the workmen, the High Court did not agree and set aside the award. The workmen are aggrieved.

5. During the course of hearing, it was submitted by Mr Sudhir Chandra, Senior Advocate appearing for the respondents, that from the date of termination of services of the workmen from 7-10-1972, when the unit for manufacture of dehydrated peas of the respondent was closed and till this date, the workmen did not work though they were being paid their wages in terms of Section 17-B of the Industrial Disputes Act from the date of the award till the impugned judgment of the High Court. In the facts of the case, a suggestion was mooted that if the workmen are paid a lump sum amount by way of compensation, they would not press their claim for reinstatement as per the award of the Labour Court which stands set aside by the High Court. We are happy to record that in view of this, the respondent had agreed to pay a sum of Rs 5 lakhs each to Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C Saxena over and above the amounts which had already been paid to them and similarly, the respondent would pay a sum of Rs 2.5 lakhs to the heirs of the deceased workman, Shiv Raj Singh Verma. This has been accepted by learned counsel for the three petitioners and their demand of reinstatement etc. has been given up.

6. This special leave petition is, therefore, disposed of in the above terms and a direction is given to the respondent to pay Rs 5 lakhs each to Bhuj Vir Singh and G.C Saxena and Rs 2.5 lakhs to the heirs of the deceased Shiv Raj Singh Verma within a period of four weeks from today.