Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Prasad Rajak v. Nand Kumar & Bros. And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 18, 1998
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, landlord of a 6′ × 17 ½′ shop in Giridih, sought eviction of the respondent-tenants. The litigation unfolded in two distinct rounds:

  • Eviction Suit No. 19 of 1985 (general law): filed on grounds of (i) non-payment of rent and (ii) bona fide personal requirement. The trial court dismissed the suit; the landlord’s first appeal also failed. A second appeal was then filed and kept pending.
  • Eviction Suit No. 35 of 1989 (under §14, Bihar Buildings (Lease, Rent & Eviction) Control Act, 1982): confined to bona fide personal requirement. The trial court dismissed the suit, but the District Judge (in Eviction Appeal No. 6 of 1990) reversed and granted a decree for eviction.

The tenants invoked Section 14(8) of the Act to file a civil revision in the High Court. During its pendency the landlord withdrew his earlier second appeal. The High Court allowed the tenants’ revision, holding that (i) the second suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC, and (ii) the landlord’s requirement was not bona fide. The present Supreme Court appeal challenges that High Court judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the landlord’s remedy against dismissal of the first eviction suit lay in a civil appeal under Section 96 CPC or only a revision under Section 14(8) of the Bihar Act.
  2. Whether the tenants’ revision under Section 14(8) against the District Judge’s appellate decree was maintainable.
  3. Whether the second eviction suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC.
  4. Whether the finding of bona fide personal requirement recorded by the District Judge could be interfered with by the High Court in a proceeding that, in substance, lay under Section 100 CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Raised a preliminary objection that the landlord’s appeal to the District Judge was not maintainable because Sections 13 and 14(8) of the Act permit only a revision to the High Court.
  • Contended that the Full Bench decision in Mohd. Jainul Ansari v. Mohd. Khalil was wrong as it conflicted with the Supreme Court ruling in Vinod Kumar Chowdhry v. Narain Devi Taneja interpreting analogous provisions of the Delhi Rent Control Act.
  • Did not press the High Court’s finding that the second suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2.

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Relied on the Full Bench judgment in Mohd. Jainul Ansari, asserting that, upon dismissal of an eviction suit, the landlord’s remedy is an appeal under Section 96 CPC because the Act provides no alternative.
  • Submitted that the Delhi and Bihar statutes are not pari materia; hence Vinod Kumar Chowdhry is inapplicable.
  • Argued that the cause of action for the second suit was different, so Order 2 Rule 2 CPC did not apply.
  • Asserted that the District Judge’s finding of bona fide need was a pure question of fact immune from second-appellate interference under Section 100 CPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohd. Jainul Ansari v. Mohd. Khalil, (1990) 2 Pat LJR 378 (FB) Landlord’s remedy on dismissal of an eviction suit is an appeal under Section 96 CPC; the Act provides none. Accepted; Supreme Court agreed with the Full Bench and overruled the tenants’ preliminary objection.
Vinod Kumar Chowdhry v. Narain Devi Taneja, (1980) 2 SCC 120 Construction of analogous provision in Delhi Rent Control Act. Distinguished; Court held Delhi and Bihar statutes are not pari materia.
Panchugopal Barua v. Umesh Chandra Goswami, (1997) 4 SCC 713 Existence of a substantial question of law is a pre-condition for jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC. Cited to emphasise that the High Court could interfere only if such a question arose.
Kshitish Chandra Purkait v. Santosh Kumar Purkait, (1997) 5 SCC 438 Same principle as above. Re-affirmed the limitation on High Court’s second-appellate power.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Maintainability of the District Appeal: Endorsing the Patna Full Bench, the Court held that because Section 14 of the Bihar Act prescribes no remedy when an eviction suit is dismissed, the landlord could invoke a regular civil appeal under Section 96 CPC. The tenants’ preliminary objection therefore failed.

2. Maintainability of Tenants’ Revision: Section 14(8) allows a revision only against a trial court’s order “for recovery of possession”. The District Judge’s appellate decree did not fit that description, rendering the revision incompetent. Although the objection was not raised below, the Supreme Court—“to meet the ends of justice”—treated the revision as a second appeal under Section 100 CPC, thereby subjecting it to the statutory limitation of requiring a substantial question of law.

3. Order 2 Rule 2 CPC Bar: The cause of action in the second suit (fresh and continuing need under Section 14) differed from that in the 1985 suit; hence O 2 R 2 had no application. This conclusion was conceded by the tenants’ counsel.

4. Bona Fide Requirement – Question of Fact: Whether the landlord needed the premises was a factual issue resolved in his favour by the District Judge after a comprehensive evaluation of evidence. The High Court, sitting effectively in second appeal, lacked jurisdiction to re-appraise the evidence. Its cursory interference without identifying any substantial question of law contravened Section 100 CPC and the principles in Panchugopal and Kshitish.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; High Court judgment set aside; eviction decree restored.

Direct consequences: the respondents must vacate the premises, but are granted time until 14-08-1999 upon filing an undertaking within eight weeks. No costs are awarded.

Broader implications: The decision re-affirms (i) the appellate route under Section 96 CPC for landlords whose eviction suits are dismissed in Bihar, and (ii) the strict gate-keeping role of “substantial question of law” in second appeals. No new legal doctrine was created beyond reinforcing existing jurisprudence.

Show all summary ...

M. Srinivasan, J.— The appellant is the landlord of a shop measuring 6′ × 17 1/2′ which is occupied by the respondents as tenants. The appellant filed Eviction Suit No. 19 of 1985 under the general law in the Court of the District Munsif, Giridih for evicting the respondents on two grounds:

(i) non-payment of rent, and

(ii) bona fide personal requirement.

The suit was dismissed and an appeal by the appellant also failed. He filed a second appeal during the pendency of which he filed the present Eviction Suit No. 35 of 1989 on the file of the District Munsif, Giridih under Section 14 of the Bihar Buildings (Lease, Rent & Eviction) Control Act, 1982 (for short “the Act”) on the ground of bona fide requirement for personal occupation. That suit was dismissed by the trial court. On appeal, the appellant succeeded and got a decree for eviction against the respondents. Against the said decree, the respondents filed a civil revision petition under Section 14(8) of the Act. When the said revision petition was pending the appellant withdrew his second appeal filed in the earlier proceedings and got it dismissed. Thereafter, the High Court allowed the revision petition filed by the respondents on two grounds, namely:

(i) the second suit for eviction filed by the appellant was barred by the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC, and

(ii) the appellant's requirement for personal occupation was not bona fide.

It is that judgment of the High Court which is challenged in this appeal.

2. A preliminary objection has been raised by the respondents at the hearing of the appeal that the appellant's appeal before the District Court against the dismissal of the suit by the trial court was not maintainable and consequently the judgment rendered by the appellate court in favour of the appellant was invalid. The contention of the respondents is that by virtue of the provisions contained in Sections 13 and 14(8) of the Act, the only remedy available to the appellant against the dismissal of his suit for eviction was an application to the High Court for revision of the order of the trial court. In answer to the said contention, learned counsel for the appellant, submits that the question has been discussed and considered in detail by a Full Bench of the Patna High Court in Mohd. Jainul Ansari v. Mohd. Khalil (1990) 2 Pat LJR 378 (Pat) (FB) and that it has been decided by the Full Bench that if a suit for eviction ends in dismissal by the trial court, the remedy of the landlord is to challenge the same under Section 96 CPC as there is no provision in Section 14 or in the Act prescribing any remedy to the landlord. Learned counsel represented that the said judgment of the Full Bench has not been challenged in this Court and it holds the field.

3. It is the contention of the respondents that the judgment of the Full Bench is erroneous as it runs counter to the judgment of this Court in Vinod Kumar Chowdhry v. Narain Devi Taneja (1980) 2 SCC 120 in which a corresponding provision in the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 was considered. According to learned counsel for the respondents, the provisions in the Delhi Rent Control Act and the Bihar Act are pari materia and the judgment of the Supreme Court would govern the question. We are unable to agree.

4. The Full Bench has referred to Vinod Kumar case (1980) 2 SCC 120 and distinguished the same on the footing that the provisions of the two enactments are not pari materia. The Full Bench has also considered the provisions of the two enactments. The reasons given by the Full Bench are appropriate and we agree with the same. We are also of the opinion that the decision of this Court in Vinod Kumar Chowdhry case (1980) 2 SCC 120 will not apply. As we are in agreement with the view expressed by the Full Bench, it is unnecessary for us to consider the question in detail. Suffice it to hold that the decision of the Full Bench is correct in law. Hence the preliminary objection raised by learned counsel for the respondents is overruled.

5. Learned counsel for the respondents has stated before us that he is not supporting the judgment of the High Court insofar as it holds that the present suit for eviction filed by the appellant is barred by the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC. Even apart from his statement, we find that the cause of action for the second suit is entirely different from the cause of action for the earlier suit and there is no chance of Order 2 Rule 2 barring this suit.

6. We have noticed that the respondents filed a revision under Section 14(8) of the Act against the judgment of the appellate court granting a decree for eviction in favour of the appellant. Obviously that revision was not maintainable as there is no provision in Section 14(8) of the Act for a revision against an appellate order. The said sub-section refers only to an order passed by the trial court for recovery of possession in favour of the landlord. If the trial court dismisses the suit, the only remedy of the landlord is to file an appeal under Section 96 CPC. When such an appeal is disposed of by the appellate court, the further remedy of the aggrieved party is only under Section 100 CPC and there is no question of reverting back to Section 14(8) of the Act. By no stretch of imagination, the appellate order or decree can be considered to be an order of the trial court for recovery of possession within the meaning of Section 14(8) of the Act. Hence the revision petition filed by the respondents before the High Court was not maintainable.

7. We find however, the objection as to the maintainability of the revision petition was not taken by the appellant in the High Court. The revision was entertained and allowed by the High Court. In order to meet the ends of justice, we treat the said revision petition as a second appeal under Section 100 CPC and proceed to consider whether the judgment of the High Court is sustainable or not. Once the proceeding in the High Court is treated as a second appeal under Section 100 CPC, the restrictions prescribed in the said section would come into play. The High Court could and ought to have dealt with the matter as a second appeal and found out whether a substantial question of law arose for consideration. Unless there was a substantial question of law, the High Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the second appeal and consider the merits. It has been held by this Court in Panchugopal Barua v. Umesh Chandra Goswami (1997) 4 SCC 713, JT (1997) 2 SC 554 and Kshitish Chandra Purkait v. Santosh Kumar Purkait (1997) 5 SCC 438, JT (1997) 5 SC 202 that existence of a substantial question of law is sine qua non for the exercise of jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC. In both the aforesaid cases, one of us (Dr Anand, J.) was a party to the Bench and in the former, he spoke for the Bench.

8. That apart, on merits, the only other question relates to the bona fide requirement of the appellant that does not give rise to any substantial question of law. It is entirely a matter to be decided on an appreciation of the evidence. On a perusal of the judgment of the High Court, it is evident that it had interfered with a finding of fact arrived at by the Second Additional District Judge, Giridih in the first appeal on an appreciation of the evidence. The High Court made an attempt to reappreciate the evidence and come to the conclusion that the appellant failed to prove his bona fide requirement. In fact, after a scanty discussion of the evidence, the High Court observed, “in this view of the matter I find and hold that the plaintiff miserably failed on factual aspect also to prove his bona fide necessity”. The High Court has acted beyond its jurisdiction in appreciating the evidence on record.

9. We have also been taken through the judgment of the Second Additional District Judge rendered in the first appeal against the judgment of the trial court. We find that the appellate court has discussed the evidence threadbare and considered the matter in the proper perspective. The appellate court has considered all the materials on record and nothing has been omitted to be referred. Learned counsel for the respondents has contended that the appellate court omitted to consider an admission made by the plaintiff that his need could be satisfied if the adjacent shop occupied by another tenant, Harish Chandra Bagga was delivered to him. We do not find any such admission on record. On the other hand, the categoric case of the appellant is that his requirement can be fulfilled only by vacating both the premises occupied by the tenants including the respondents. Insofar as Harish Chandra Bagga is concerned, it is stated by the appellant that he had earlier undertaken to vacate the shop in his occupation and ultimately handed over possession of the said shop to the appellant on 20-9-1997 during the pendency of this appeal. On a perusal of the record, we are of the opinion that the finding of fact rendered by the Second Additional District Judge in the first appeal is conclusive and the High Court has exceeded its jurisdiction in interfering with the said finding.

10. Consequently the civil appeal is allowed and the judgment and order of the High Court of Patna in Civil Revision No. 416 of 1995 (R) is set aside. The judgment and decree for eviction passed by the Second Additional District Judge, Giridih in Eviction Appeal No. 6 of 1990 are restored. There will be no order as to costs.

11. Learned counsel for the respondents prayed for grant of one-year time to vacate the premises. Learned counsel for the appellant has agreed to the same after obtaining instructions. In the circumstances, the respondents are granted time to vacate the suit premises till 14-8-1999 on condition that the respondents file the usual undertaking in this Court within a period of eight weeks from this date failing which, the benefit of grant of time will not be available to them.