Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Banwari Ram And Others v. State Of U.P .

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 10, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arises from an armed confrontation between members of the 5th Battalion of the Uttar Pradesh Pradeshik Armed Constabulary (PAC) and the Indian Army at Ramnagar on the night of 21-5-1973 continuing until the afternoon of 22-5-1973. The State Government had directed that the Army take charge of PAC armouries statewide after incidents of indiscipline. When Army personnel, accompanied by a Magistrate, attempted to secure the Ramnagar armoury, PAC members resisted, sounded a bugle, armed themselves, and opened fire. A pitched battle ensued in which 12 Army personnel were killed and 32 injured; four PAC men were also killed.

An FIR was lodged at 7:30 p.m. on 22-5-1973, leading to a charge-sheet against 44 PAC members for offences under the Indian Penal Code, Defence of India Rules and the U.P. PAC Act. The Vth Additional Sessions Judge, Varanasi, acquitted nine accused and convicted the others with varying findings.

Both convicted accused and the State appealed. The Allahabad High Court, by judgment dated 26-9-1979, dismissed some defence appeals, allowed the State appeal in part, and converted certain acquittals into convictions. Nineteen convicted persons then filed two criminal appeals (Nos. 579 of 1980 and 8 of 1980) before the Supreme Court. During pendency two appellants died, leaving nine before the Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in reversing the trial court’s order of acquittal without adequately addressing the trial court’s reasoning.
  2. Whether the absence of inquest and post-mortem reports for the 12 deceased Army personnel undermined the prosecution case and warranted reversal of convictions under Sections 302/149 IPC.
  3. Whether appellant Shambhu Singh, who allegedly arrived after firing started, could be held liable as a member of the unlawful assembly under Section 149 IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The High Court set aside acquittals without engaging with or refuting the trial court’s reasons, violating settled principles governing interference with acquittals.
  • No inquests or post-mortems were conducted on the 12 deceased Army personnel; hence homicidal deaths and cause of death were not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
  • Even if deaths occurred, the prosecution produced no specific evidence that they were caused by shots fired by the appellants.
  • Appellant Shambhu Singh was not present at the initial clash and performed no overt act; therefore, he lacked the common object needed for liability under Section 149 IPC.

No detailed prosecution arguments were recorded in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

On interference with acquittal: The Court reiterated that an appellate court has identical powers in appeals against conviction and acquittal, save for the requirement of leave, and may re-appreciate evidence fully. It must, however, consider the trial court’s reasons. Examining both judgments, the Supreme Court held the High Court correctly found the trial court’s reasoning “totally unsustainable” because once the accused were held to be members of an unlawful assembly, exoneration from liability under Sections 302/149 and 307/149 IPC was fallacious.

Identification and participation: The High Court had relied on (a) testimony of multiple eye-witnesses, including senior Company Commander PW 3, and (b) duty charts showing presence of accused at Quarter Guard. These findings, in the Supreme Court’s view, were proper and justified reversal of acquittals and affirmation of convictions.

Absence of post-mortem: The Court dismissed the argument that lack of inquests or post-mortems was fatal. Twelve Army bodies were recovered at the scene and death certificates were issued. Eye-witness accounts proved that PAC personnel indiscriminately fired, causing deaths; post-mortem reports were therefore not indispensable.

Section 149 liability: The Court held that once membership of an unlawful assembly was proved, each member was vicariously liable for offences committed in furtherance of its common object. Even if particular accused did not fire, their presence encouraged those who did.

Specific plea of Shambhu Singh: Relying on PW 3’s positive identification of Shambhu Singh firing from the Quarter Guard, the Court rejected the contention that he arrived later or lacked participation.

The Court also noted that it independently scrutinised the evidence despite concurrent findings below and found it reliable and trustworthy.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Both criminal appeals were DISMISSED; convictions and sentences imposed by the High Court were affirmed. Bail bonds of appellants on bail were cancelled and they were directed to surrender.

Implications: The decision maintains the convictions of PAC personnel for the 1973 Ramnagar incident and reaffirms appellate courts’ broad authority to overturn acquittals where trial-court reasoning is unsustainable. No new legal precedent was established beyond the reaffirmation of settled principles on Section 149 IPC and appellate review of acquittals.

Show all summary ...

G.B Pattanaik, J.— These two appeals arise out of the same sessions trial being Sessions Trial No. 332 of 1973 in the Court of Vth Additional and District Judge, Varanasi. The appellants are the members of Pradeshik Armed Constabulary belonging to the 5th Battalion and their Headquarters was at Ramnagar. An unfortunate and unsavoury incident occurred on account of the decision of the State Government that the Army should take over charge of the armoury and magazines of the Provincial Pradeshik Armed Constabulary throughout Uttar Pradesh. It is on account of the aforesaid direction the forces belonging to the Pradeshik Armed Constabulary revolted and resisted the Army personnel from taking charge of the armoury and in furtherance of which 12 persons belonging to the Army were killed and 32 were injured. On account of the firing from the Army 4 persons belonging to the Pradeshik Armed Constabulary were killed and some were injured. Ultimately, however, the direction of the State was implemented and the Army took charge of the armoury and other weapons. The incident occurred during the night of 21-5-1973 and continued for a fairly long period till 4.30 p.m of 22-5-1973. On the basis of the first information report given on 22-5-1973 at 7.30 p.m a criminal case was instituted and a charge-sheet was submitted against 44 accused persons including the appellants in these two appeals under Sections 147, 148, 302/149, 307/149, 324/149, 326/149, 395/397, 120-B and 427/149 IPC and Rule 43(5) of the Defence of India Rules as well as under Sections 6(b) and 7(c) of the U.P Pradeshik Armed Constabulary Act. The accused Banwari Ram, Ram Kirat Yadav, Hira Shanker Singh, Sheo Bahadur Yadav, Lal Babu Singh, Ramayan Singh, Indradeo Ram, Rama Shanker Singh, Ram Nath Sharma, Lok Nath Singh and Tara Prasad Tewari were also charge-sheeted under Section 409 IPC. The case was committed to the Court of Sessions Judge by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Varanasi and ultimately the accused persons were tried by the Vth Additional and District Judge, Varanasi.

2. The prosecution case in a nutshell is that the members of the Armed Constabulary formed an Association which was not recognised by the State of U.P The forces belonging to the Armed Constabulary who had been posted in the Lucknow University Campus became undisciplined and some untoward incidents happened there which compelled the State Government to take a decision to disarm the Armed Constabulary and give charge of the armoury and magazines hitherto under the charge of the Armed Constabulary to the Army in the entire State. When this decision was communicated by the IG of Police to the DIG of Police, Varanasi Range, the said DIG had a telephonic talk with the Commissioner, Shri A.K Mustaf, as the situation was going out of control and in accordance with the decision taken by the State Government to hand over the arms and ammunition belonging to the Armed Constabulary to the Army the local Administration at Varanasi requested the Army Commandant Lt. Col. S.K Verma to provide military assistance to take over the charge of the Armed Constabulary Quarter Guard and the Magazine at Ramnagar. The Army personnel discussed the matter with the civilian authorities, chalked out a scheme of action and finally a contingent of the Army was sent to the Armed Constabulary Headquarters at Ramnagar under the leadership of Major C.S Cheema accompanied by a Magistrate, First Class. They started the operation at 2.15 a.m on 22-5-1973 and reached the Tri Junction of the road at Rambagh. The Magistrate then proceeded towards the Quarter Guard Building accompanied by the Company Commanders of the Armed Constabulary leaving their vehicles away on the road at a distance of 50 to 60 yards from Quarter Guard Building. Reaching near the Quarter Guard they found that apart from the guards on duty there were 40 to 50 persons belonging to the Armed Constabulary and when the Commanders directed those people to hand over charge of the armoury to the military, the guards on duty as well as those who were present there became agitated and openly refused to hand over the charge to the military. Those guards also openly declared that if anybody proceeds to take over the charge of Quarter Guard then they would be taught a lesson. The Magistrate present there also tried to persuade the members of the Armed Constabulary not to resist the Army from taking over the charge inasmuch as it was the decision of the State Government but those persons did not pay any attention to the advice of the Magistrate. These Armed Constabulary personnel seeing that the Army was marching towards the Quarter Guard sounded the bugle and then breaking open the locks of the armoury armed themselves to fight out. The Magistrate on duty declared the Assembly of the Armed Constabulary at the Quarter Guard Building as unlawful and ordered their dispersal but instead of dispersing from the place they opened fire from the Quarter Guard Building towards the military force. The officers of the military forces marching towards Quarter Guard Building thereupon returned back the firing and Major Cheema, who was the Commanding Officer of the Army sought for permission of the Magistrate to use force in self-defence. On being permitted by the Magistrate the Army personnel took their position and opened fire and a regular battle started between the personnel of the Armed Constabulary and the Army. The Magistrate then had a telephonic discussion with the District Magistrate and sought for reinforcement of the Army personnel. Lt. Col. S.K Verma reached the place of the incident with the reinforcement of military personnel accompanied by Major N.N Jolly. Under the orders of Lt. Col. Verma a group lead by Major Jolly started approaching the Quarter Guard Building from one direction and another group lead by Lt. Col. Verma proceeded from another direction. Both the groups faced stiff resistance from the personnel belonging to the Armed Constabulary and ultimately the Armed Constabulary personnel surrendered and the military took over the charge of the armoury in the Quarter Guard Building. As already stated, on the basis of the first information report lodged on 22-5-1973 at 7.30 p.m a criminal case was registered and after necessary investigation charge-sheet was filed against 44 persons including the appellants in these two appeals. The learned Additional Sessions Judge acquitted the 9 accused persons of all the charges levelled against them and convicted the accused Banwari Ram, Ram Kirat Singh Yadav, Ganesh Prasad, Sheo Bahadur Ram, Hira Shankar Singh, Lok Nath Singh, Rama Shanker Singh, Ramayan Singh, Lal Babu Singh, Ram Nath Sharma, Indradeo Ram and Tara Prasad Tewari of the offences under Sections 302/149, 127, 148, 307/149, 427/149 IPC and Rule 43(5) of the Defence of India Rules as well as under Sections 6(b) and 7(c) of the U.P Pradeshik Armed Constabulary Act. They were, however, acquitted of the charges under Sections 324/149, 326/149, 325/149 and 120-B IPC. One Chhabinath Singh was convicted only of the offence under Section 7(c) of the U.P Pradeshik Armed Constabulary Act and was acquitted of the remaining charges. The accused Bans Narain Singh, Ghulam Sarvar, Purshottam Singh, Virendra Singh Bhadauria, Indra Singh Rai and Kesh Nath Singh were acquitted of the charges under Sections 302/149, 307/149, 324/149, 326/149, 395/397 IPC and 120-B IPC but were convicted for the offence under Sections 147, 148, 427/149 IPC and Section 43(5) of the Defence of India Rules and Sections 6(b) and 7(c) of the U.P Provincial Armed Constabulary Act. The accused Shambhu Singh, Jagdish Rai, Hira Lal Tripathi, Nand Kumar Yadav, Banshidhar Tripathi, Shamim Ahmad, Markandey Singh, Mushtaq Ahmad, Ram Kewal Singh, Satya Narain Prasad Singh, Anil Kumar Dass, Jagdish Singh, Ram Cheez Yadav, Parsu Ram Yadav, Ambika Upadhyay and Jagdish Prasad Mishra were convicted under Sections 147, 427/149 IPC, Section 43(5) of the Defence of India Rules and Section 7(c) of the U.P Provincial Armed Constabulary Act. They were, however, acquitted of the charges under Sections 148, 302/149, 307/149, 324/149, 326/149, 395/397 and 120-B IPC and Section 6(b) of the U.P Provincial Armed Constabulary Act.

3. Nineteen of the convicted accused persons filed a Criminal Appeal No. 2478 of 1976. The accused Banwari Ram and 11 others filed a Criminal Appeal No. 2587 of 1976 challenging their conviction and sentence passed against them. The accused Chhabinath filed a Criminal Appeal No. 2823 of 1976 assailing his conviction under Section 7(c) of the Provincial Armed Constabulary Act. Three of the accused persons Mushtaq Ahmad, Anil Kumar and Jagdish Prasad Mishra did not prefer any appeal and suffered the sentences awarded against them. The State also filed an appeal against total acquittal of the 11 accused persons as already indicated as well as against the acquittal of other persons of different charges. All these appeals were disposed of by a common judgment dated 26-9-1979 by the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court out of which the present two appeals have been preferred.

4. In Criminal Appeal No. 579 of 1980 there are 5 appellants and in Criminal Appeal No. 8 of 1980 there were 6 appellants out of whom the appellant Banwari Ram and Ganesh Prasad have died during the pendency of the appeal. Thus in all 9 appellants are now before the Court in these two appeals, they being Bans Narain Singh, Shambhu Singh, Satya Narain Prasad, Ramayan Singh, Tara Prasad Tewari, Ram Kirat Singh, Rama Shanker Singh, Lok Nath Singh and Ram Nath Sharma. These appellants have assailed their conviction under Sections 302/149, 148, 307/149 and Section 7(c) of the Provincial Armed Constabulary Act. It may be stated that the appellants Bans Narain Singh, Shambhu Singh and Satya Narain Singh though were acquitted by the learned Sessions Judge of the charges under Sections 302/149, 307/149 and 148 IPC but the government appeal against their acquittal having been allowed by the High Court in the impugned judgment they have also been convicted by the High Court of the charges under Sections 302/149, 307/149 and 148 IPC. Before this Court two sets of arguments had been advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants in the two appeals. So far as the order of acquittal passed by the Sessions Judge having been set aside and 3 of the appellants, as already stated, having been convicted, it was urged that the High Court committed serious error in not adverting to the reasons advanced by the Sessions Judge in passing an order of acquittal and no reasons having been indicated for setting aside the order or acquittal the impugned order of conviction, so far as those appellants are concerned, is on the face of it erroneous and cannot be sustained. The arguments so far as the appellants whose conviction and sentence has been passed by the learned Sessions Judge and affirmed by the High Court is that the prosecution case must be held not to be proved beyond reasonable doubt, inasmuch as in respect of the 12 Army personnel found dead neither there has been any inquest nor has there been any post-mortem report and consequently the fact that homicidal death occurred has not been established. Further argument advanced was that even if it is held that the prosecution has been able to establish the 12 persons belonging to the Army forces died but there is no evidence to indicate that their death occurred on account of the shooting from the appellants and, therefore, the conviction of the appellants of the charge under Sections 302/149 cannot be sustained. It was also contended that so far as the appellant Shambhu Singh is concerned, on the admitted prosecution case that he was not there at the Quarter Guard when the firing started and came at a later stage he cannot be held to be a member of the unlawful assembly nor can he be held to have shared a common object particularly when the prosecution evidence is totally silent with regard to the overt act by the said Shambhu Singh.

5. So far as the contention that the order of acquittal passed by the Sessions Judge has been reversed by the High Court without considering the reasons advanced by the learned Sessions Judge in support of the order of acquittal, we do not find any force with the same. It is now too well settled that under the Criminal Procedure Code there is no difference so far as the power of the appellate court is concerned to deal with an appeal from a conviction and that from an appeal against an order of acquittal excepting that an appeal against a conviction is as of right and lies to courts of different jurisdictions depending on the nature of sentence and kind of trial and the court in which the trial was held, whereas an appeal against an order of acquittal can be made only to the High Court with the leave of the court. The procedure for dealing with two kinds of appeals is identical and the powers of the appellate court in disposing of the appeals are in essence the same. The High Court, therefore, has full powers while hearing an appeal against an order of acquittal, to reappreciate the evidence and to come to a conclusion whether the order of acquittal passed by the Sessions Judge was per se bad or not. If, however, on the evidence two views are reasonably possible, one supporting acquittal and the other indicating conviction then the High Court would not be justified in interfering with an order of acquittal merely because it takes the view that it would have taken the other view sitting as a trial court. It would, therefore, be correct to state that the High Court while reversing an order of acquittal must apply its mind to the reasons given by the trial court and find out whether such reasons are at all sustainable or not. But on examining the reasons advanced by the trial court as well as on reappreciating the evidence on record if the High Court is satisfied that the reasons given by the trial court for acquittal are totally unsustainable and the appreciation of evidence made by the trial court is per se bad then there would be no limitation on the power of the High Court to set aside an order of acquittal. If the impugned judgment of the High Court setting aside the acquittal of some of the accused persons by the learned Sessions Judge and convicting them under Sections 302/149 IPC is examined from the aforesaid standpoint we really do not find any infirmity with the same. The High Court has indicated the fallacy of the reasonings advanced by the learned Sessions Judge in acquitting some of the accused persons by holding that “the trial court having held those accused persons were members of an unlawful assembly, they could not be exonerated under Sections 302/149 and 307/149”. On analysis of the evidence the High Court has come to the conclusion that those accused persons became the members of an unlawful assembly and had seen some of the members of that assembly to have equipped themselves with rifles and have been indiscriminately using them against the Army jawans. Some of the accused persons in fact were injured which establishes the fact of their being present at the place of occurrence and their presence is also otherwise established through the oral testimony of more than two prosecution witnesses. Once it is held that they were also members of an unlawful assembly they will be liable for the unlawful activities of the members of the said assembly, even if they might not have actually fired the guns. On the materials on record the High Court has come to the conclusion that not only the persons concerned were members of an unlawful assembly but also their presence at the spot constituted sufficient encouragement for other members of the said assembly who indiscriminately started firing at the Army jawans. It is well settled that if an offence is committed by some members of an unlawful assembly then the other members of the assembly are also liable for the offence under Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code. We have also carefully scrutinised the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge as well as that of the High Court and we are of the considered opinion that the High Court was wholly justified in reversing an order of acquittal passed by the learned Sessions Judge and we do not find any error of law therein.

6. Coming now to the arguments advanced on behalf of those accused persons whose conviction and sentence passed by the learned Sessions Judge have been upheld in an appeal, it appears to us that the High Court while hearing an appeal against the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge has fully reappreciated the evidence and has affirmed the conclusion arrived at by the learned Sessions Judge by applying the test of identification by two or more of the prosecution witnesses and also by examining the duty chart of the accused persons which indicates persons who were present at the relevant point of time at the Quarter Guard duty. The arguments of the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants that in the absence of any inquest or post-mortem in respect of the deceased Army personnel it has to be held that the prosecution case has not been proved beyond reasonable doubt is an argument which is merely to be mentioned for being rejected. The prosecution evidence unequivocally establishes the fact that the accused persons belonging to the Provincial Constabulary started indiscriminately firing at the Army jawans who had been called upon to take charge of the armoury. On account of such indiscriminate firing by the members of the Provincial Constabulary 12 persons belonging to the Army died whose dead bodies were recovered from the spot itself and the necessary death certificates had been issued by the medical authority. In such an event not holding of any post-mortem examination is immaterial and the contention of the learned counsel appearing for the appellants that the prosecution failed on that score is wholly unsustainable in law and we have, therefore, no hesitation to reject the same. The further argument that the prosecution evidence is not categorical to the fact that the death of the Army jawans occurred on account of firing by the appellants is equally unsustainable in view of the charge under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC and in view of the findings that the accused appellants together with several others belonging to the Provincial Armed Constabulary formed an unlawful assembly and in resisting the Army jawans from taking charge of the armoury and the Quarter Guard indiscriminately fired at them. We have also examined the evidence on record and the conclusion is irresistible that the prosecution case that the accused appellants being members of an unlawful assembly indiscriminately started firing at the Army jawans which resulted in the death of 12 Army personnel has been proved beyond reasonable doubt, and as such, the High Court has rightly convicted them under Sections 302/149 IPC. We have also considered the argument specifically advanced on behalf of the appellant Shambhu Singh to the effect that Shambhu Singh was not there at the Quarter Guard when the firing started and he came at a later stage and as such cannot be held to be a member of an unlawful assembly but we do not find any substance in the same.

7. PW 3 Vishwa Nath Pandey was the seniormost Company Commander in respect of 9 companies constituting the 5th Battalion. He had gone to the place of occurrence several times both in the beginning of the incident as well as after the arrival of the Armed forces and marched with them towards the Quarter Guard. According to him he could see and recognise from amongst the Provincial Constabularies who became unlawful and started firing at Army jawans, 12 persons including Head Constable Shambhu Singh. He further indicated that he had seen all of them at the Quarter Guard and 10 of them were firing. In view of the aforesaid positive evidence of PW 3 the seniormost Company Commander which has been accepted by the two courts below it is difficult for us to sustain the argument advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant Shambhu Singh that he was not a member of the unlawful assembly from the beginning and even at a later point of time he had not done anything so as to convict him by taking recourse to Section 149 IPC. We, therefore, reject the said submission advanced by the learned counsel for Shambhu Singh. Though normally this Court does not reappreciate the evidence where two courts below have already appreciated and held the evidence reliable, but in view of the fact that a large number of appellants were involved and the incident itself occurred in a very peculiar situation we have also ourselves scrutinised the evidence and we find the evidence to be reliable and trustworthy and the learned Sessions Judge as well as the High Court rightly relied upon the said testimony in basing conviction against the accused appellants. We do not find any legal infirmity with the conviction and sentence passed by the High Court against the appellants and in our considered opinion the prosecution has proved the charges against the accused persons beyond reasonable doubt. In the premises aforesaid both the criminal appeals are dismissed.

8. Those accused persons who are on bail, their bail bonds stand cancelled and they are directed to surrender to serve the sentences.