Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tata Davy Ltd. v. State Of Orissa And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 4, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Tata Davy Limited, like the other appellants, was declared a sick industrial company on 9-2-1988 under the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA). A scheme sanctioned by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) was under implementation.

For Assessment Years 1983-84 and 1984-85, the company was in arrears of sales tax under the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947. The State initiated coercive recovery by attaching the company’s property under Section 13-A of the State Act.

In a writ petition filed by Aluminium Industries Ltd. (similarly situated), the Orissa High Court held that Section 22(1) of SICA did not protect the properties of sick companies from proceedings under Section 13-A. Tata Davy Limited intervened but the High Court rejected its plea. After this Court delivered Gram Panchayat v. Shree Vallabh Glass Works Ltd. (1990), the appellants sought review; the High Court refused. The present appeals were then filed in the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether coercive recovery of sales-tax arrears under Section 13-A of the Orissa Sales Tax Act constitutes “proceedings for execution, distress or the like” barred by Section 22(1) of SICA unless BIFR consents.
  2. Whether the phrase “any other law” in Section 22(1) of SICA encompasses State legislation enacted under Entry 54, List II (sales tax), or must be read down to exclude it.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Relied on Gram Panchayat v. Shree Vallabh Glass Works Ltd. (1990), where this Court held that Section 22(1) of SICA suspends all coercive recovery proceedings, including those under State laws, once an inquiry under Section 16 is ordered.
  • Contended that their situation was indistinguishable from Vallabh Glass Works; hence State recovery without BIFR consent was barred.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Submitted that Section 22(1) must be interpreted so as not to trench upon the States’ exclusive power to levy sales tax (Entry 54, List II).
  • Urged that the words “any other law” in Section 22(1) should exclude List II laws because Parliament is presumed to respect constitutional competence limits.
  • Relied on CTO v. Corromandal Pharmaceuticals (1997) to contend that tax dues are outside Section 22 when the company continues to collect tax after sanction of a scheme.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gram Panchayat v. Shree Vallabh Glass Works Ltd.
(1990) 2 SCC 440
Section 22(1) of SICA automatically suspends coercive recovery proceedings against a sick company once an inquiry under Section 16 is ordered. Treated as directly governing the instant appeals; Court followed it to hold that State tax recovery requires prior BIFR consent.
CTO v. Corromandal Pharmaceuticals
(1997) 10 SCC 649
Amounts of tax collected by a sick company after sanction of a scheme are not protected by Section 22. Distinguished as factually inapposite; liability in that case arose after the sanctioned scheme, unlike the present matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court held that Vallabh Glass Works squarely applied. Under Section 22(1) of SICA, once an inquiry under Section 16 is pending or a sanctioned scheme is under implementation, “no proceedings for … execution, distress or the like” against the company’s property can continue without BIFR consent.

Addressing the respondent’s federal-competence argument, the Court observed that SICA is enacted under Entry 52, List I, empowering Parliament to control certain industries in the public interest. Section 22 advances that objective by centralising control over recovery actions, ensuring the industrial rehabilitation process is not derailed. It does not permanently extinguish creditors’ rights; it only postpones them, with limitation periods correspondingly extended under Section 22(5).

The phrase “any other law” in Section 22 therefore includes State sales-tax enactments. Reading it otherwise would defeat the very purpose of SICA and undermine the coordinated scheme for revival of sick industries.

Finally, Corromandal Pharmaceuticals was held irrelevant because it concerned taxes collected after the sanctioned scheme, whereas the present arrears arose earlier. Consequently, the High Court’s view that Section 22 did not override Section 13-A of the Orissa Act was erroneous.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court judgments set aside. The State respondents cannot recover the arrears of sales tax from the appellants without first obtaining BIFR’s consent under Section 22(1) of SICA.

Implications: The decision reinforces that all creditors, including State tax authorities, must secure BIFR approval before resorting to coercive recovery against a sick industrial company covered by Section 22. It affirms the supremacy of SICA in the field of industrial rehabilitation, though it sets no new legal precedent beyond applying Vallabh Glass Works.

Show all summary ...

S.P Bharucha, J.— The facts that we state relate to the case of Tata Davy Limited (CA No. 1354 of 1991). They are substantially similar to the facts of the other appeals.

2. The said appellant was, on 9-2-1988, declared a sick company within the meaning of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (now referred to as “the Central Act”). On a reference under Section 15 of the Central Act made on 23-12-1989, an inquiry under Section 16 was made and a scheme was sanctioned by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (now referred to as “the Board”) for the said appellant's benefit and it was at the relevant time under implementation.

3. For the Assessment Years 1983-84 and 1984-85 the said appellant was in arrears of the sales tax under the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947 (now referred to as “the State Act”). Recovery of the said arrears was sought to be made by attachment of the said appellant's property under the provisions of Section 13-A of the State Act. The High Court of Orissa was considering the question whether steps to recover sales tax dues under Section 13-A of the State Act were in the nature of proceedings by way of execution, distress or the like contemplated by Section 22(1) of the Central Act in a writ petition filed by M/s Aluminium Industries Ltd. (the appellant in the other appeals) which was, as aforestated, in a position similar to that of the said appellant. The said appellant intervened in the writ petition and was heard.

4. The High Court said in its judgment on the writ petition that the question before it was whether the provisions of Section 22(1) of the Central Act overrode the provisions of Section 13-A of the State Act. It held that there was no irreconcilable conflict between the two provisions as they operated in separate and distinct fields and, therefore, both were capable of being obeyed. The result was that Section 22(1) of the Central Act “would not protect the properties of industrial companies from being proceeded against in exercise of the power under Section 13-A of the State Act”.

5. Very soon after the High Court's judgment this Court decided the case of Gram Panchayat v. Shree Vallabh Glass Works Ltd. (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966 to which we shall make reference. The appellants applied to the High Court to review its decision in the light of the Vallabh Glass Works (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966 judgment. The High Court expressed its inability to do so.

6. Hence, these appeals.

7. For the purposes of appreciating the controversy, Section 22(1) of the Central Act needs to be set down.

“22. Suspension of legal proceedings, contracts, etc.—(1) Where in respect of an industrial company, an inquiry under Section 16 is pending or any scheme referred to under Section 17 is under preparation or consideration or a sanctioned scheme is under implementation or where an appeal under Section 25 relating to an industrial company is pending, then, notwithstanding anything contained in the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956), or any other law or the memorandum and articles of association of the industrial company or any other instrument having effect under the said Act or other law, no proceedings for the winding up of the industrial company or for execution, distress or the like against any of the properties of the industrial company or for the appointment of a receiver in respect thereof and no suit for the recovery of money or for the enforcement of any security against the industrial company or of any guarantee in respect of any loans or advance granted to the industrial company shall lie or be proceeded with further, except with the consent of the Board or, as the case may be, the Appellate Authority.”

8. Learned counsel for the appellants placed reliance upon the judgment in Vallabh Glass Works (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966. Vallabh Glass Works had been declared a sick industrial company within the meaning of Section 3(1)(o) of the Central Act. The appellant Gram Panchayat initiated coercive proceedings under Section 129 of the Bombay Village Panchayat Act against Vallabh Glass Works to recover arrears of property tax. Vallabh Glass Works filed a writ petition in the High Court at Bombay claiming the protection of Section 22 of the Central Act. The writ petition was allowed, and the Gram Panchayat appealed to this Court. This Court noted that the said Board had been satisfied by its order dated 27-8-1987, that Vallabh Glass Works had become a sick industrial company and, consequently, steps had been taken under Sections 16 and 17 of the Central Act. As soon as the enquiry under Section 16 was ordered by the said Board, this Court said, the various proceedings set out under Section 22(1) of the Central Act were deemed to have been suspended. Creditors could then approach the said Board for permission to proceed against the sick company for recovery of their dues and the said Board, at its discretion, could accord such approval. If approval was not granted, the creditors' remedy was not extinguished. It was only postponed. The section provided for exclusion of the period during which the remedy was suspended while computing the period of limitation for recovery of the dues.

9. Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that in the case of Vallabh Glass Works (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966 this Court had dealt with proceedings for recovery of dues under a State Act and had come to the conclusion that Section 22(1) of the Central Act applied thereto. The case of the appellants was, therefore, squarely covered by the Vallabh Glass Works (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966 judgment.

10. Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that Section 22(1) of the Central Act should be so read as not to interfere with the exclusive power of the States to legislate under Entry 54 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution in respect of sales tax. In his submission, the words “any other law” in Section 22(1) of the Central Act must be so read as to exclude all laws on List II subjects, for Parliament must be assumed to know its limitations. Learned counsel cited the judgment of this Court in CTO v. Corromandal Pharmaceuticals (1997) 10 SCC 649, (1997) 2 Scale 640 as supporting his case.

11. The Vallabh Glass Works (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966 judgment covers these appeals. Arrears of taxes and the like due from sick industrial companies that satisfy the conditions set out in Section 22(1) of the Central Act cannot be recovered by coercive process unless the said Board gives its consent thereto.

12. The Central Act is enacted under Entry 52 of List I of the Seventh Schedule. The said Entry 52 empowers Parliament to legislate in respect of “Industries, the control of which by the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be in the public interest”. The Central Act declares that it is “for giving effect to the policy of the State towards securing the principles specified in clauses (b) and (c) of Article 39 of the Constitution”, namely, “that the ownership and control of the material resources of the community are so distributed as best to subserve the common good” and “that the operation of the economic system does not result in the concentration of wealth and means of production to the common detriment”. The Central Act does not impair or interfere with the rights of the States to legislate with respect to sales tax under Entry 54 of List II of the Seventh Schedule. In the larger interest of the industrial health of the nation, Section 22 of the Central Act requires all creditors seeking to recover their dues from sick industrial companies in respect of whom an inquiry under Section 16 is pending or a scheme is under preparation or consideration or has been sanctioned to obtain the consent of the said Board to such recovery. If such consent is not secured and the recovery is deferred, the creditors' remedy is protected for the period of deferment and is, by reason of sub-section (5) of Section 22, excluded in the computation of the period of limitation. The words “any other law” in Section 22 cannot, therefore, be read in the manner suggested by the learned counsel for the respondents.

13. The Corromandal Pharmaceuticals (1997) 10 SCC 649, (1997) 2 Scale 640 judgment dealt with a sick industrial company which was enabled to collect amounts like sales tax after the date of the sanctioned scheme. This Court said: “Such amounts like sales tax, etc., which the sick industrial company is enabled to collect after the date of the sanctioned scheme legitimately belonging to the Revenue, cannot be and could not have been intended to be covered within Section 22 of the Act.” It added that the issue that had arisen before it had not arisen in the case of Vallabh Glass Works (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966. It did not appear therefrom or from any other decision of this Court or of the High Courts “that in any one of them, the liability of the sick company dealt with therein itself arose, for the first time after the date of sanctioned scheme. At any rate, in none of those cases, a situation arose whereby the sick industrial unit was enabled to collect tax due to the Revenue from the customers after the ‘sanctioned scheme’ but the sick unit simply folded its hands and declined to pay it over to the Revenue, for which proceedings for recovery had to be taken”. Clearly, the facts in the Corromandal Pharmaceuticals case (1997) 10 SCC 649, (1997) 2 Scale 640 differ from the facts of the Vallabh Glass Works case (1990) 2 SCC 440, (1990) 1 SCR 966 and those before us. The reference to the Corromandal Pharmaceuticals case (1997) 10 SCC 649, (1997) 2 Scale 640 is, therefore, inapposite.

14. We hold, in the premises, that the respondents cannot recover the aforementioned arrears of sales tax from the appellants without first seeking the consent of the said Board in this behalf.

15. The appeals are allowed and the judgments and orders under appeal are set aside. No order as to costs.