Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mahendra Singh Chotelal Bhargad v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 12, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Uttamrao Baburao Raut (“the appellant”) was tried alongside two police officers—Inspector Uttamrao Baburao Raut (A-1) and Sub-Inspector Abdul Kadar (A-2) of Ramdaspeth Police Station, Akola—for allegedly obtaining an illegal gratification of Rs 3000 from Rajkumar Mohanram Sawani (PW 1) through the appellant. All three were convicted by the trial court under Sections 161 IPC and 5(1)(d) read with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947; the appellant was additionally convicted under Section 163 IPC.

On appeal, the Bombay High Court acquitted A-1 and A-2 but affirmed the appellant’s conviction under Section 163 IPC. The appellant then filed the present appeal before the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant could be legally convicted under Section 163 IPC when the alleged primary offenders (A-1 and A-2) were acquitted.
  2. Whether the factual record satisfied the statutory ingredients of Section 163 IPC—namely, that the appellant accepted gratification as a motive or reward to induce a public servant by personal influence.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised the text of Section 163 IPC and identified two essential ingredients:

  • The accused must accept, agree to accept, or attempt to obtain a gratification;
  • The gratification must be intended as a motive or reward to induce a public servant through the accused’s personal influence.

Applying these requirements, the Court observed that the prosecution’s positive case—based on PW 1’s testimony—was that A-1 and A-2 originally demanded the money and directed PW 1 to deliver it to the appellant. The appellant thus acted merely as a conduit; he neither negotiated nor promised to use personal influence over A-1 or A-2. Consequently, the statutory condition that the gratification be linked to the appellant’s personal influence on a public servant was not satisfied.

The Court acknowledged that accepting money to pass to another could amount to abetment, but noted that (a) no abetment charge had been framed, and (b) A-1 and A-2 had already been acquitted. Therefore, sustaining a conviction under Section 163 IPC would be legally unsound.

Holding and Implications

Conviction Set Aside; Appellant Acquitted.

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, reversed the appellant’s conviction under Section 163 IPC, and discharged him from his bail bonds. The decision underscores that liability under Section 163 IPC arises only when the accused accepts gratification to exercise personal influence over a public servant; acting merely as an intermediary does not suffice. No broader precedent was established beyond clarifying the statutory elements of Section 163 IPC.

Show all summary ...

M.K Mukherjee, J.— For obtaining an illegal gratification of Rs 3000 from Rajkumar Mohanram Sawani (PW 1) through Mahendra Singh, the appellant before us, Uttamrao Baburao Raut, Inspector and Abdul Kadar, Sub-Inspector (hereinafter referred to as A-1 and A-2 respectively), of Ramdaspeth Police Station, Akola were convicted under Sections 161 IPC and 5(1)(d) read with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947, while the appellant was convicted under Section 163 IPC. Aggrieved thereby, they preferred separate appeals before the Bombay High Court which were disposed of with an order of affirmation of the conviction of the appellant and acquittal of the two police officers. Hence this appeal.

2. According to the prosecution case, in the night intervening 12-4-1984 and 13-4-1984, A-1 and A-2 carried a raid at Seema Guest House of Akola and found Madhukar @ Shaligram Raut (PW 10) and one Ashok Thakur indulging in immoral sexual activities with two girls. They were arrested and brought to the police station by A-1 and A-2. Rajkumar (PW 1), the Manager of the Guest House, and Pramod Gangaramji Bhirad (PW 5), a friend of the persons arrested, went to the police station and secured their release on bail after paying Rs 1200 to A-2 as illegal gratification. It is the further prosecution case that a few days later A-1 and A-2 demanded a sum of Rs 5000 as a consideration to drop the prosecution launched against Seema Guest House and its proprietor for immoral trafficking, but ultimately the consideration was fixed at Rs 3000. On 27-4-1984 A-1 instructed PW 1 to pay that amount to the appellant, who stayed in a nearby hotel, on the following day. On the same day PW 1 lodged a written complaint with the Anti-Corruption Bureau for the illegal demand made by A-1 (Ext. 58) and Mr Rade (PW 14), an Inspector of the Bureau, arranged a trap. On 28-4-1984 when the appellant accepted the currency notes worth Rs 3000 at the tea-stall of Mahadeo (PW 3), as per earlier arrangement, the raiding party apprehended him with the notes.

3. To prove the accusation levelled against the three accused persons, the prosecution relied upon — and the trial court accepted — the evidence of PW 1 and the members of the raiding party, to convict them. The High Court, however, declined to accept the prosecution case regarding the demand made by A-1 and A-2 for illegal gratification as it found the evidence of PW 1 (on which the prosecution solely relied to prove the demand made by A-1 and A-2) unsatisfactory. Since, however, the evidence of PW 1 that the amount of Rs 3000 was paid to the appellant stood corroborated by its recovery from the appellant, as testified by the trap witnesses, it convicted the appellant.

4. It passes our comprehension as to how the High Court, after having disbelieved the prosecution case qua A-1 and A-2, could convict A-3 and that too for the offence under Section 163 IPC. On a plain reading of the said section it is manifest that to convict an accused for the above offence the following ingredients are required to be proved:

(i) The accused accepted or agreed to accept, obtained or attempted to obtain for himself or anyone on his behalf, a gratification;
(ii) The gratification must be as a motive or reward to induce a public servant by the exercise of personal influence:

(a) to do or to forbear to do any official act; or

(b) to show in exercise of his official functions favour or disfavour; or

(c) to render or attempt to render any service or disservice to any person with the Central Government or State Government or with any public servant, as such.

The gist of the offence, therefore, is that the person arraigned must accept the gratification to induce a public servant by the exercise of his personal influence (emphasis supplied) to do any of the acts mentioned in the section. It is the positive case of the prosecution, as testified by PW 1, that it was A-1 and A-2 who initially demanded the money from him (PW 1) and in terms of an arrangement that he had with A-1 and under his instruction and direction that he paid the money to the appellant. It was not the appellant who struck the deal and received the money to induce A-1 and A-2 to show some favour to Seema Guest House and its proprietor. On the contrary, it was A-1 and A-2 who had struck the deal and the appellant was the recipient of the money in terms of an arrangement which he had (obviously) entered into with A-1 and A-2. By no stretch of imagination, therefore, can it be said that the appellant is guilty of the offence under Section 163 IPC. Of course, the acceptance of the money by the appellant from PW 1 for handing over the same to A-1 or A-2 would certainly constitute an abetment of the offences allegedly committed by A-1 and A-2, but then this aspect of the matter need not detain us: firstly, because, such was not the charge framed against the appellant and secondly, because, A-1 and A-2 stand acquitted of the offences alleged against them.

5. We, therefore, allow this appeal, set aside the conviction of the appellant under Section 163 IPC and acquit him. The appellant, who is on bail, will stand discharged from his bail bonds.