Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Municipal Council, Mandsaur v. Fakirchand And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 6, 1997
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Three brothers, asserting joint ownership of undivided Hindu family property, filed a suit for permanent injunction against the Municipal Council, Mandsaur. The trial court decreed the suit in their favour. The Municipal Council appealed to the lower appellate court. During the pendency of that appeal one of the brothers died. Despite being aware of the death, the Municipal Council did not substitute the deceased brother’s legal representatives; instead, it applied for deletion of his name from the array of parties. The surviving plaintiffs contended that because no substitution occurred, the entire appeal abated. The High Court accepted this contention in Second Appeal No. 115 of 1968. The Municipal Council then brought the present appeal to the Supreme Court. Preliminary issues of delay and an amendment in a substitution application were disposed of by orders condoning the delay and allowing the amendment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court correctly held that the municipality’s appeal abated in its entirety on account of the failure to bring on record the legal representatives of one deceased co-owner during the pendency of the lower appellate proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Municipal Council, Mandsaur)

  • The property in question was pleaded to be joint Hindu family property; therefore, it was sufficiently represented by the eldest surviving brother, acting as karta.
  • Because of such representation, non-substitution of the deceased brother’s legal representatives should not result in abatement of the entire appeal.

Respondents (Surviving Plaintiffs)

  • Failure to substitute the legal representatives of a deceased co-owner rendered the appeal incompetent, causing it to abate in toto.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court rejected the appellant’s contention that the eldest brother acted as karta representing coparcenary property. It observed:

  • The plaint merely stated that after their father’s death, the three brothers became owners of “joint Hindu family property,” but did not show the property was coparcenary in nature.
  • If the property were coparcenary, the brothers would have obtained rights even before their father’s death, contradicting the plaint’s wording.
  • No evidence indicated that any family member, including the eldest brother, was functioning as karta; rather, all three brothers had jointly instituted the suit, signifying individual assertion of ownership rights.
  • Given these facts, each co-owner was a necessary party whose presence was essential; the death of one without substitution of legal representatives created a fatal defect under the law governing abatement.

Consequently, the High Court’s conclusion that the entire appeal had abated was affirmed.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s finding that the municipality’s appeal stood abated for non-substitution of a deceased co-owner’s legal representatives. The direct consequence is that the trial court’s decree in favour of the plaintiffs remains intact, and the Municipal Council’s challenge fails. The decision turns on established procedural rules regarding abatement and does not lay down a new precedent beyond reaffirming the necessity of timely substitution in appeals involving multiple co-owners.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Delay condoned.

2. Application for amendment in substitution application is allowed.

3. The short question that arose for decision in this appeal is whether the High Court has correctly decided by the impugned judgment in SA No. 115 of 1968 that the appeal preferred by the appellant-Municipal Council, Mandsaur stood abated in view of the fact that legal representatives of one of the co-owners were not brought on record when the appeal was pending before the lower appellate court.

4. It may be stated here that initially three plaintiffs being brothers claiming to be the owners of the joint Hindu family property, filed a suit against Municipal Council, Mandsaur for a permanent injunction by asserting their title to the property. Such suit was decreed by the trial court and the Municipality thereafter preferred an appeal before the lower appellate court. During the pendency of such appeal, one of the three brothers died. The Municipality did not bring the heirs and legal representatives of the deceased brother on record despite knowledge of such death but made an application that the name of the deceased brother should be deleted from the array of parties. The question thereafter was raised by the remaining plaintiffs that the appeal had abated as a whole because the heirs and legal representatives of one of the co-owners had not been brought on record. Such contention has been upheld by the impugned decision.

5. Mr S.K Gambhir, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant, has contended before us that since in the plaint the plaintiffs had stated that the property was a joint Hindu family property, such property must be deemed to be represented by the karta of the joint family and as the eldest brother was alive, it must be held that such joint Hindu family property was represented by the eldest brother and in that case, there was no question of abatement of the appeal as a whole.

6. We are however unable to accept such contention of Mr Gambhir for the reason that from the statement made in the plaint it cannot be definitely held that the property was coparceners' property which could be represented by a karta. It has been alleged in the plaint that after the death of the father, all the three brothers became owners of the said joint Hindu family property. It may be indicated here that if it was a coparcenary property then the sons would have been coparceners even before the death of the father and there was no necessity to wait till the death of the father to get ownership of the property. The averments in the plaint really means that the disputed property was the undivided property of the said three joint owners who had inherited the father's interest after his death. That apart, even if it is assumed that it was coparcenary property there is nothing on record to indicate that any one member or the eldest male member of the family was acting as a karta of the joint family. On the contrary, it appears that all the co-owners filed the said suit for injunction, which on the face of it, only indicates that all of them intend to exercise their right as co-owners of the property and they have not authorised any one of them to represent the property as a karta of the joint Hindu family property. In the aforesaid circumstances, the decision of the High Court cannot be said to be erroneous for which any interference by this Court is called for. The appeal, therefore, fails and is dismissed without any order as to costs.