Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shabad Pulla Reddy And Others v. State Of A.P .

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 20, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Twenty-six individuals were charged in Sessions Case No. 48 of 1983 before the Sessions Judge, Warangal, for offences arising from the murder of Nookala Narayan Reddy on the night of 11 July 1981. During trial, four accused died or absconded, leaving twenty-two facing judgment. The trial court acquitted A-1 but convicted the remaining accused under various provisions, including Sections 120-B, 148, 449, 452, 460, and 302 (or in the alternative 396) of the Indian Penal Code, imposing concurrent sentences.

On appeal, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh acquitted several accused but affirmed the convictions of A-17 to A-22 and maintained A-26’s conviction under Sections 302/149. Those seven convicts filed the present criminal appeals before the Supreme Court, which granted leave and heard the matters together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence of test identification parades and subsequent in-court identification was reliable and sufficient to link A-17 to A-22 with the offences of rioting and murder.
  2. Whether the recovery of allegedly stolen articles from A-17 to A-22, three months after the incident, could lawfully support their convictions under Sections 302/149 IPC.
  3. Whether recovery of the deceased’s gun and cartridges from an open shed could conclusively implicate A-22.
  4. Whether A-26’s retracted judicial confession, after acquittal on the charge of conspiracy (Section 120-B), provided admissible and incriminating evidence of his participation in the murder.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The test identification parades were conducted three months after arrest, rendering them unreliable and vitiated by possible exposure of the accused to witnesses.
  • Recoveries of articles were fabricated or, at best, proved only possession of stolen property long after the crime, insufficient to establish participation in murder.
  • A-22 contended that the firearm was not recovered from his possession but from an open shed owned by another, breaking the chain of custody.
  • A-26 asserted that his confession was coerced after illegal detention and beatings, and in any event was exculpatory as to the actual murder.

Prosecution’s Position

  • Relied on eyewitness testimony corroborated by two test identification parades conducted by a Judicial Magistrate.
  • Pointed to recovery of stolen jewellery, torch, and firearm as corroborative circumstantial evidence connecting the appellants to the crime.
  • Invoked A-26’s judicial confession as proof of the conspiracy culminating in the homicide.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court accepted the concurrent factual finding of the trial court and High Court that the murder occurred in the manner alleged by the prosecution. However, it scrutinised the specific evidence against the appellants:

  • Delay in Test Identification Parades: The parades were held approximately three months after A-17 to A-21 were arrested and almost the same period after A-22’s arrest. The prosecution offered no explanation for this “unusual and unexplained delay”. The Court held that such delay undermines the reliability of any identification because witnesses are unlikely to retain a clear image for so long.
  • Recovery of Articles: The Court found it “too artificial to be believed” that, three months post-incident, each accused would still be carrying a stolen item (including a torchlight) instead of disposing of it. Even assuming lawful recovery, the lapse of time precluded drawing a presumption of participation in the murder; at best, it might indicate dishonest retention, an offence for which no charge under Section 411 IPC was framed.
  • Recovery of Firearm from A-22: Evidence showed the gun and cartridges were taken from an open shed owned by PW 9, not from A-22’s personal possession; therefore, it did not conclusively incriminate him.
  • Confession of A-26: The statement detailed a conspiracy but was exculpatory regarding the actual killing. Once the charge of conspiracy failed, and given the statement’s retracted nature, it could not be used to convict. No other substantive evidence linked A-26 to the homicide.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the prosecution had not proved the appellants’ involvement beyond reasonable doubt.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS ALLOWED; CONVICTIONS AND SENTENCES SET ASIDE; APPELLANTS ACQUITTED.

The immediate consequence is that A-17 to A-22 and A-26 are discharged from their bail bonds and stand free of all charges in this case. The judgment turns on evidentiary deficiencies—particularly unexplained delay in test identification and questionable recoveries—without establishing new legal doctrine. Its implications are confined to the parties and underscore the Supreme Court’s insistence on stringent proof where identification evidence is delayed.

Show all summary ...

M.K Mukherjee, J.— Leave granted.

2. In Sessions Case No. 48 of 1983 on the file of the Sessions Judge, Warangal 26 persons were initially placed on trial to answer charges under Sections 120-B, 148, 449, 452, 460 and 302 IPC. An alternative charge under Section 396 IPC was also framed against them. During pendency of the trial A-12 and A-14 died while A-13 and A-25 absconded. Hence, the trial continued against the other twenty-two. On conclusion thereof the learned Judge acquitted A-1 of all the charges and convicted the others as under:

(i) A-2 to A-11, A-15, A-23, A-24 and A-26 under Section 120-B IPC;

(ii) A-8, A-15 to A-22, A-24 and A-26 under Section 148 IPC;

(iii) A-15 to A-22 under Section 449 IPC;

(iv) A-22 under Section 302 IPC (simpliciter);

(v) A-8, A-15 to A-21, A-24 and A-26 under Sections 302/149 IPC and

(vi) A-2 to A-7, A-9 to A-11 and A-23 under Sections 302/109 IPC.

For the convictions so recorded they were sentenced to different terms of imprisonment with a direction that the sentences shall run concurrently.

3. Against their convictions and sentences they preferred separate appeals in the High Court. In disposing of the appeals by a common judgment the High Court set aside the convictions of A-2 to A-11, A-15, A-16, A-23 and A-24 but confirmed those of A-17 to A-22. As regards A-26, his conviction under Section 120-B IPC was set aside but that under Sections 302/149 IPC maintained. Assailing the above judgment of the High Court A-17 to A-22 and A-26 have filed these appeals which have been heard together and this judgment will dispose of them.

4. The prosecution case, to the extent it is necessary to be reproduced and is relevant for disposal of these appeals (now that the charge of conspiracy has failed and some of the accused have been acquitted), is as follows:

(a) A-2 is the son of A-1. A-4 is the son-in-law of A-3. A-3 and A-24 are brothers. A-7 is the son of A-24. A-1 to A-8 and A-25 are the residents of Upparigudem village. A-10 and A-11, who are brothers, are residents of Modugulagudem. A-15 to A-23 are residents of different villages. Nookala Managamma (PW 11), an issueless widow, adopted the deceased Nookala Narayan Reddy. The deceased also did not beget any children and, therefore, he adopted Nookala Ranjith Reddy (PW 1) as his son. Smt Rangamma, mother-in-law of PW 11, had adopted A-1, son of her elder sister. The families of Rangamma and Managamma possessed considerable properties in or around Upparigudem. Over the adoptions there were misunderstandings between the above two families which led to disputes regarding their properties. Later on the disputes were referred to arbitration and the arbitrators decided that PW 11 and the deceased should take 9/16th share and Rangamma and A-1 should take 7/16th share. In spite of the award, the disputes and differences continued and two factions were created: one led by the deceased and the other by A-1. To strengthen his faction A-1 brought A-24, a resident of Bojjannapeta village, to his village after his release from a murder case and appointed him as his seradar. A-26, who was originally a resident of Gudur, was also brought by A-1 as his farm servant.

(b) In the night of 10-7-1981, A-12 and two strangers came to the house of A-24 and slept there. On the following morning i.e on 11-7-1981, all three of them went to the sapota garden of A-24, A-2 to A-5, A-7, A-15, A-23, A-24 and A-26 also came and joined in the talks with A-12. At or about midday A-24 asked Mathiah (PW 8), his farm servant, to bring lunch and he obliged. In the afternoon A-24 asked PW 8 to bring two axes and 10 cart pegs. Accordingly PW 8 brought them. Then A-12 asked PW 8 to go towards “Sankeesa bata” saying that six persons would come and asked him to bring them. Accordingly, PW 8 went to Sankeesa bata, saw six persons coming and brought them to the sapota garden. They all proceeded towards the house of the deceased. At that time the deceased, his son PW 1, his domestic servant-cum-cook Venkatiah (PW 2), Kishtiah (PW 5), another farm servant, and PW 11 were there. At or about 8.00 p.m PW 2 told them that dinner was ready and asked them to get up. PW 5 then got up to go back to his house and opened the main entrance door only to find some persons there. Suspecting foul play PW 5 went out of the room through the doorway on the south and having closed it looked through the peepholes. He saw A-15, A-17 and A-22 entering the bedroom of the deceased, and then dragging him. They then snatched away the gun (MO 1) from underneath the bed of the deceased and one of them aimed the gun at the deceased and asked him where he had kept gold and other valuables. One of the miscreants then broke open the wooden box and all papers were thrown pell-mell. Then PW 1, who was in the other room, saw the deceased being dragged into the bedroom of PW 1. A-15, A-17 and A-22 then opened the wooden box and took away 19 cartridges and cash therefrom and also two earrings, gold chain and bangles from PW 11. Meanwhile, A-18 to A-21 also joined A-15, A-17 and A-22. When PWs 2 and 11 pleaded to leave the deceased, they were pushed in the bedroom of PW 1 and bolted from outside. The miscreants then brought the deceased out and axed him to death. Afterwards they left the place raising slogans.

(c) In the early morning of 12-7-1981 PW 1 went to Seerole Police Station and gave a report of the incident (Ext. P-12) to the Sub-Inspector Ramesh Babu (PW 28) who registered a case thereupon. PW 28 gave an information about the incident to Shri Murthy (PW 31), Inspector of Police, and both of them reached the scene of occurrence. PW 31 held inquest over the dead body and sent it for post-mortem examination. Dr Reddy (PW 17) conducted autopsy and found 7 external injuries and out of them injuries 1 to 6 were over the head and other vital parts of the body. He opined that the death was due to shock and haemorrhage as a result of multiple injuries.

(d) In the course of investigation Shri Inniah (PW 29), Sub-Inspector of Police, Khammam arrested A-26 at Yudlapuram. From his possession two cartridges (MO 15) were recovered and they were seized under Ext. P-47. PW 29 sent a requisition to Shri Krishnaiah (PW 16), Judicial Magistrate of Madhira to record the confessional statement of A-26. Accordingly A-26 was produced before PW 16 and after giving necessary warnings and putting necessary questions, he recorded the confessional statement of A-26 (Ext. P-34). After receiving the message about the arrest of A-26 and making of his confessional statement PW 31 went to Khammam and obtained a copy of the confession. On the basis of the details mentioned therein, he proceeded with the investigation. Shri Reddy (PW 30) the Inspector of Police, Khammam arrested A-22 on 13-9-1981 and seized the gun (MO 1) and 12 cartridges under Ext. P-46. On 4-10-1981 PW 31 arrested A-17, A-18, A-19, A-20 and A-21. From A-17 he seized the gold chain (MO 5), from A-18 a pair of gold bangles (MO 6), from A-19 a torchlight (MO 8), from A-20 a gold ring (MO 3) and from A-21 a pair of gold ear-flowers (MO 7). After their arrest PW 31 gave a requisition to Shri Lachiah (PW 6) Judicial Magistrate, Narasampet to conduct test identification parade of A-15 to A-21. Accordingly PW 6 conducted a test identification parade on 4-1-1982 in which PW 1 identified A-17 to A-21 and PW 2 identified A-18, A-20 and A-21. PW 31 gave a similar requisition for A-16 and A-22 and in the second parade held on 12-1-1982 PW 1 and PW 10 identified A-22. After completion of the investigation PW 31 lead the charge-sheet on 14-6-1982.

5. When examined under Section 313 CrPC the accused persons pleaded not guilty to the charges levelled against them. So far as the appellants before us are concerned, the specific defence of A-17 to A-21 was that they were taken into custody much earlier than on 4-10-1981 as claimed by the police and that their photographs were taken and shown to the identifying witnesses. A-22 stated that he was taken from his house at Kaikondagudem and shown to the identifying witnesses. A-26 stated that three days prior to the alleged incident he had gone to Chinnakodur village to see his ailing mother and there the police arrested him. They took him in a jeep first to the outskirts of the village and then to Mahbubabad. There the Inspector of Police and Sub-Inspectors of Police beat him and coerced him to confess, and for three days continuously he was beaten. On the fourth day he was shifted to Dornakal and there he was again beaten by the Inspector of Police and the Inspector of Police pressurised him to make a statement regarding the offence. He was confined illegally at the Police Station, Dornakal for about six or seven days and later he was again shifted to Mahbubabad and he was pressurised to make a statement before the Magistrate as directed by the police. He was threatened that he would be shot dead if he did not make a statement as wanted by the police.

6. The prosecution examined in all 31 witnesses of whom PWs 1, 2, 5 and 11 figured as eyewitnesses. Both the trial court and the High Court discussed the evidence of these witnesses at length and found that their evidence so far as it related to the manner in which the incident took place was satisfactory and safely reliable. Since the FIR promptly lodged by PW 1 also contained the substratum of the prosecution case and the medical evidence corroborated the version of the eyewitnesses, the courts below concluded that the incident took place in the manner alleged by the prosecution. We do not find any reason therefore to disturb the above findings. Incidentally it may be mentioned that the learned counsel for the appellants also did not assail the above findings.

7. That brings us to the crucial question as to whether the prosecution has been able to conclusively prove the involvement of the appellants in the above offences of rioting and murder. To connect A-17 to A-22 with the crimes, the prosecution relied upon the evidence of their identification in court by the witnesses and the corroborative evidence of their earlier identification in two test identification (TI) parades held on 4-1-1982 and 12-1-1982 by a Judicial Magistrate (PW 6). The evidence of PWs 1 and 2 along with that of PW 6, proves that in the TI parades PW 1 identified A-17, A-19 and A-21 and PW 2 identified A-18, A-20 and A-21. In other words, A-17 and A-19 stand identified by one witness, namely, PW 1 and A-20 and A-21 by both the witnesses, namely, PWs 1 and 2. Though the trial court and the High Court accepted the evidence of such identification in Court as it was corroborated by the evidence of their identification in TI parade, we find it difficult to rely upon the same as no explanation — much less plausible — was offered by the prosecution for the inordinate delay in holding the TI parades. As earlier noticed, the occurrence took place on 11-7-1981 and five of the above six accused persons (A-17 to A-21) were arrested on 4-10-1981 and the TI parades were held 3 months after their arrest. Thus unusual and unexplained delay in holding the TI parades makes it difficult for us to conclusively hold that after such a long lapse of time the witnesses were still able to have a clear image of the accused in their minds and identify them correctly at the identification parades. So far as A-22 is concerned, he was arrested earlier — (on 13-9-1981) — and was identified in the TI parade by PW 1 as one of the miscreants. He was also identified by Papaiah (PW 10), who claimed to have seen him earlier in the day in question, going across the field armed with an axe. For the reasons earlier mentioned, we are also unable to accept the identification of A-22 by PWs 1 and 10. The other evidence on which the prosecution relied upon — and both the learned courts accepted to convict A-17 to A-21 — is the alleged recovery of gold chain (MO 5), a pair of gold bangles (MO 6), a torchlight (MO 8), a gold ring (MO 3) and a pair of gold ear-flowers (MO 7) from them respectively, on 4-10-1981 when all of them were arrested. According to the prosecution all those articles either belonged to the deceased or to the members of his family. In our considered view, the evidence of recovery is too artificial to be believed. It seems strange that even after three months of the incident all of them were carrying a stolen article each — including a torchlight. If really they had stolen such articles, at the time of the murder, it was expected in the fitness of things that they would dispose of them as early as possible — more so when the nature of articles was such that they could pass hands quickly. This apart, even if we proceed on the assumption that evidence regarding the identification of the articles and recovery thereof is acceptable, still then, no presumption can be drawn after such a long lapse of time that they were party to the murder itself. The most favourable conclusion that can be drawn for the prosecution from such recovery is that they dishonestly retained the stolen properties knowing them to be stolen but in absence of any charge framed under Section 411 IPC and on their acquittal of the charge under Section 396 IPC, no order of conviction can be recorded against them. So far as A-22 is concerned, the allegation is that the gun belonging to the deceased along with cartridges was recovered from his possession, but then the only reliable evidence in support thereof is that those arms and ammunition were recovered from an open shed belonging to PW 9 and not from him. It cannot, therefore, be said that the prosecution has been able to conclusively prove its case against A-22. Lastly, coming to A-26, we find that the prosecution relied upon his retracted judicial confession and some other evidence in corroboration thereof. On carefully going through the confessional statement we find that A-26 confessed about a conspiracy to commit the murder of the deceased, but did not at all confess that he was a party to the murder. In other words, so far as the incident that took place in the night of 11-7-1981 in which the deceased met with his death, the statement made by A-26 before the Magistrate is exculpatory. Once the confession made by A-26 is left out of consideration — as it must be in view of the acquittal of the charge under Section 120-B IPC — there is no other substantive evidence to connect him with the offences in question. Incidentally it may be mentioned that though, admittedly, A-26 was a resident of the same village and was known to PW 1 from long, he did not name him as one of the miscreants nor mention his name in the FIR.

8. For the foregoing discussion, we allow these appeals, set aside the order of convictions and sentences recorded against the appellants and acquit them. The appellants, who are on bail, are discharged from their respective bail bonds.