- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
K. Manickaraj v. Union Of India .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, a Scheduled Caste employee of the Indian Railways, was initially appointed as an Assistant Station Master and successively promoted, ultimately joining the post of Welfare Inspector Grade III on 27-12-1991. By an order dated 27-1-1993, the Railway Administration restructured the cadre of Welfare Inspectors, prescribing that 35% of posts would be in Grade I, 40% in Grade II, and 25% in Grade III. The appellant claimed that, following this restructuring and the earlier upgradation of three Grade III posts to Grade II for sports personnel (pursuant to a memorandum dated 24-8-1987), the total Grade II strength became 26, entitling Scheduled Caste employees to four reserved posts under the 15% quota. As only three Scheduled Caste officers were then in Grade II, the appellant sought promotion with effect from 2-4-1993. His application (OA No. 267 of 1994) was dismissed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench on 19-9-1995, prompting the present appeal to the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the three posts upgraded from Welfare Inspector Grade III to Grade II for sports personnel should be counted when determining the 15% reservation quota for Scheduled Castes in Grade II.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The upgradation of three posts from Grade III to Grade II in 1987 is of a permanent nature, as the posts have continued for several years.
- With the upgraded posts, the Grade II cadre strength is 26, so 15% reservation mandates four posts for Scheduled Castes.
- Since only three Scheduled Caste officers currently occupy Grade II posts, the appellant is entitled to promotion against the fourth reserved slot.
Respondent's Arguments
- The Grade II cadre strength remains 23; the three upgraded posts are temporary, intended exclusively for sports personnel, and therefore should not be included when calculating reservation.
- Because the effective strength is 23, only three posts fall under the 15% quota, all of which are already filled by Scheduled Caste officers, leaving no vacancy for the appellant.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court focused on the nature and duration of the upgraded posts:
- It noted that the three Grade III posts were upgraded to Grade II as early as August 1987 and have “still continued.”
- Given their longevity, the Court rejected the respondent’s characterization of the upgradation as temporary.
- Consequently, the Court held that the operative cadre strength of Grade II is 26, not 23.
- Applying the 15% reservation quota to a strength of 26 yields four posts for Scheduled Castes.
- With only three Scheduled Caste officers presently in Grade II, one reserved vacancy remains, and the appellant is entitled to be considered for it.
- The Tribunal erred by excluding the upgraded posts from its reservation computation; posts “borrowed” from a lower grade yet continuing for years must be included in the cadre strength for reservation purposes.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the Tribunal’s judgment, allowed OA No. 267 of 1994, and directed the respondents to consider the appellant’s promotion to Welfare Inspector Grade II with effect from 1993.
Implications: The decision compels the Railway Administration to treat long-standing upgraded posts as part of the permanent cadre when calculating reservation quotas, ensuring that reserved category employees benefit from such structural changes. No broader precedent was expressly articulated beyond this clarification of cadre-strength computation for reservation purposes.
G.B Pattanaik, J.— Delay condoned.
2. Leave granted.
3. This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench dated 19-9-1995 in OA No. 267 of 1994. The said application has been filed by the appellant for a direction to the railway administration to promote the appellant as Welfare Inspector Grade II with effect from 2-4-1993 as one post was available in the reserved category.
4. The brief facts necessary for deciding this appeal are stated as under:
The appellant was appointed as Assistant Station Master in the scale of Rs 330-560 and was then promoted to a higher post in the scale of Rs 425-640 with effect from 8-1-1985. He was further promoted as Welfare Inspector Grade III in the scale of Rs 1480-2300 and joined the said post on 27-12-1991. The appellant admittedly belongs to Scheduled Caste. The cadre of Welfare Inspectors consisted of 3 categories; namely: Welfare Inspector Grade I in the scale of Rs 2000-3200; Welfare Inspector Grade II in the scale of Rs 1600-2660 and Welfare Inspector Grade III in the scale of Rs 1400-2300. By Order dated 27-1-1993 the cadre strength of the different categories of Welfare Inspectors was restructured and it was directed that 35% of posts would be in Grade I, 40% in Grade II and 25% in Grade III. In view of the change of percentage of the different categories of posts, the appellant expected a promotion to Grade II but the same having not been done, he filed the application before the Tribunal. It was averred in the application filed before the Tribunal that three posts from Grade III having been upgraded to Grade II, the total number of posts available in Grade II is 26 as against the original number of 23 and since there is reservation of 15% for Scheduled Castes, the total number of posts available for the Scheduled Castes in Grade II would work out at 4 but factually only 3 persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes are working in Grade II, and therefore, the appellant was entitled to promotion to Grade II. The respondent in the counter-affidavit filed, however, contended that there has been no change in the strength of the post in Grade II which remained at 23 but for sports personnel some posts were upgraded from Grade III to Grade II and those upgraded posts cannot be taken into account for determining the number of posts available for reserved category as such upgradation was temporary in nature and is not a permanent addition to the number of posts, and therefore, cannot be taken into account for computation of 15% reservation in the said Grade II. The Tribunal by the impugned judgment accepted the contention raised by the respondent and came to hold that the posts which have been upgraded having been borrowed from Grade III and being specially meant for sports personnel cannot be counted for determining the 15% reserved quota meant for Scheduled Castes, and therefore, the cadre strength of Grade II being 23 only 3 persons from the Scheduled Castes would be promoted to Grade II and thus three persons having already been there the claim of the appellant cannot be allowed. With this conclusion the Tribunal having dismissed the application filed by the appellant, the present appeal has been preferred.
5. The question that arises for consideration, therefore, is whether the number of upgraded posts from Grade III to Grade II meant for sports personnel can be taken into account for determining the number of reserved posts available for Scheduled Castes in Grade II. It is admitted that the total number of posts in Grade II was 23 and 3 posts from Grade III were upgraded to that of Grade II. The upgraded posts which were made as early as in August 1987, as per Memorandum dated 24-8-1987, still continue. It is, therefore, not possible for us to accept the contention of the learned counsel for the respondent that the alleged upgradation was made for a temporary period meant for sports personnel. The posts which were upgraded in the year 1988 having continued till date, the cadre strength of Grade II Inspectors must be held to have become 26 and not 23 as contended by the respondent. If 15% of the cadre is meant for reserved category people then it would work out at 4 and admittedly there are only 3 persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes in Grade II. In that view of the matter the appellant was entitled to be promoted against the 15% reserved quota of posts in Grade II treating the total number of posts in Grade II to be 26. In our considered opinion the Tribunal was in error in not taking into account the upgraded posts which have been upgraded from Grade III to Grade II on the ground that it was meant for sports personnel. While computing the number of posts available for reserved category, there is no justification to exclude the upgraded posts which had continued from 1988 till date.
6. In the aforesaid premises the impugned judgment of the Tribunal is set aside and OA No. 267 of 1994 filed in the Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras stands allowed. The respondents are directed to consider the case of promotion of the appellant to a post in Grade II, Welfare Inspector, with effect from 1993. The appeal is allowed. There will be no order as to costs.
Alert