- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sunil Kumar And Others v. State Of M.P .
Supreme Court of India – Criminal Appeal under Section 379 CrPC
Factual and Procedural Background
Sunil Kumar, his father Hargovind (owners of a rolling-mill in Village Chichli, District Narsinghpur, Madhya Pradesh) and their three casual employees—Suresh, Nazim and Rafiq—had an ongoing land dispute with brothers Dayashankar (deceased) and Ramesh Chandra (PW-1), both cultivators from the same village.
- Prior to the incident, the appellants’ cattle damaged the brothers’ crops, leading to assaults and repeated threats that their “hands and legs would be cut.”
- On 30-7-1981, around 10:30 a.m., while the brothers were returning from their fields, the five appellants attacked them. Weapons used included lathis, a hockey stick and axes. Ramesh’s left arm and leg were severed; Dayashankar’s right hand and foot were severed, causing his death on the spot.
- Labourers alerted the victims’ mother (PW-2) and nephew Yogendra (PW-3). PW-3 telephoned the police; Inspector V.K. Saxena (PW-6) arrived, recorded PW-1’s statement, sent PW-1 for treatment and conducted the inquest.
- The investigation recovered blood-stained weapons and clothing, which the Forensic Science Laboratory later confirmed bore human blood.
- The Additional Sessions Judge, Narsinghpur acquitted all five accused of offences under Sections 147, 302/149 and 307/149 IPC (rioting, murder with common object, attempt to murder).
- On State appeal, the Madhya Pradesh High Court reversed the acquittal and convicted the appellants on all counts.
- The present Supreme Court appeal challenges the High Court’s conviction.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the five appellants were the perpetrators of the murder of Dayashankar and the attempted murder of Ramesh Chandra, rendering them liable under Sections 147, 302/149 and 307/149 IPC.
- Whether the trial court erred in treating the non-disclosure of the assailants’ names in PW-3’s telephonic message—and in treating PW-1’s subsequent statement as hit by Section 162 CrPC—as grounds for acquittal.
- Whether the cryptic telephone call (Entry Ext. P-17) constituted the First Information Report, and the legal consequences of that determination on the admissibility of subsequent statements.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
- Reliability of PW-1 (Ramesh Chandra): The Court deemed the trial court’s rejection of PW-1’s testimony “patently perverse.” PW-1 was the only surviving eyewitness; his account was consistent with medical evidence and was promptly narrated to PW-2 and PW-3.
- Corroboration by Early Statements: PW-1’s statement to the Magistrate (treated as one under Section 164 CrPC) was recorded when he was in critical condition, reducing any likelihood of tutoring. This statement matched his in-court testimony.
- FIR Determination: The Supreme Court ruled that PW-3’s telephone message—recorded as Station Diary Entry Ext. P-17—was the true FIR because it first informed police of a cognizable offence. PW-1’s later statement (Ext. P-2) was therefore a Section 161 statement. Nonetheless, this finding did not weaken the prosecution because PW-1’s Section 164 statement and in-court evidence remained legally corroborative.
- Non-examination of Labourers: The Court held that Section 114 illustration (g) Evidence Act could not be used against the prosecution; there was no proof that any labourer actually witnessed the assault.
- Dismissal of DW-1’s Testimony: The Assistant Postmaster’s claim that PW-3 did not name the assailants was found unreliable. It was outside his duty to listen to the conversation, and his own cross-examination showed inconsistencies.
- Medical Evidence: Autopsy findings (PW-4) and the treating doctor’s report (PW-13) matched PW-1’s narrative, establishing use of sharp heavy weapons for amputations and blunt weapons for scalp injuries.
- Motive and Prior Threats: A written complaint (Ext. P-1) lodged days before the incident documented explicit threats by the appellants to “cut them to pieces,” lending credence to the prosecution version.
- Conclusion: The Court found that the appellants formed an unlawful assembly, committed rioting, murdered Dayashankar and attempted to murder Ramesh, thereby upholding the High Court’s conviction.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed; Conviction and Sentences Affirmed. The appellants, presently on bail, were ordered to surrender and serve the sentences imposed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court.
Implications: The decision reinforces that (i) cryptic telephonic information can constitute an FIR even without naming offenders, and (ii) early, consistent statements of an injured eyewitness, corroborated by medical evidence, suffice to sustain convictions despite the absence of independent eyewitnesses. No new legal precedent was explicitly set beyond these reaffirmations.
M.K Mukherjee, J.— This appeal under Section 379 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is directed against the judgment and order dated 12-9-1985 of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 1217 of 1982 whereby it set aside the acquittal of the five appellants of the offences under Sections 147, 302/149 and 307/149 of the Indian Penal Code recorded in their favour by the Additional Sessions Judge, Narsinghpur and convicted them thereunder.
2. The appellants Sunil Kumar and his father Hargovind are residents of Village Chichli within the police station of Gotetoriya in the District of Narsinghpur where they own a rolling mill and the other three appellants are their casual employees. The deceased-Dayashankar and his brother Ramesh Chandra (PW 1) also hailed from the same village and they earned their living from cultivation.
3. According to the prosecution case the appellant Hargovind was trying to forcibly take over the land of the deceased and PW 1 and threatening them that he would cut off their hands and legs. Sometime before the incident with which we are concerned in this appeal the cattle of Sunil Kumar and Hargovind had damaged the standing crops of the deceased and PW 1. When PW 1 protested a quarrel ensued in the course of which he was beaten up with shoes by Hargovind and appellant Rafu @ Rafiq. On 15-1-1981 Hargovind and Rafu made an attempt to kill the deceased and PW 1 but failed. Over that incident PW 1 lodged a complaint with the police station. Again on 30-5-1981 PW 1 found that Hargovind had brought the other three appellants, who were all residents of Uttar Pradesh, to their village and apprehending that Hargovind might get them killed, the two brothers lodged a written report before the Superintendent of Police, Narsinghpur on 13-6-1981 (Ext. P-1) seeking protection of their lives and properties. The police however turned a deaf ear to their complaints.
4. The further prosecution case is that on 30-7-1981 at or about 9 a.m the deceased and PW 1 went to their field for measuring the work done by their labourers as that was the day for payment to them. After the measurements, at or about 10.30 a.m when they were returning home to fetch money for payment to those labourers and on the way had reached the lane in between the fields of Chhotelal Sahu and Dalchand the five appellants came from behind. Of them, Sunil Kumar and Suresh were carrying lathis, Hargovind a hockey stick and Nazim and Rafiq axes. Hargovind first gave a lathi blow on the head of PW 1 and he fell down. Thereafter Rafu and Nazim hacked him with their axes severing his left arm and left foot. All of them then attacked the deceased with their respective weapons in a similar fashion severing his right hand and right foot. Then they fled away.
5. On hearing the cries of the victims, the labourers, who were working in the field of PW 1 came to the spot and seeing their condition rushed to their house to inform Imartibai (PW 2), mother of PW 1 and the deceased. On getting the information PW 2 hurried to the spot and heard about the incident from PW 1. Dayashankar had, in the meantime, succumbed to his injuries. Yogendra Kumar (PW 3), a nephew of the deceased and PW 1, and some others of the village also reached there and to them also PW 1 narrated the incident. PW 3 then rushed for medical help but the doctors expressed their unwillingness to attend to the victims on the plea that as it was a medico-legal case they could not do so without requisition from the police. PW 3 then went to the village post office and reported the incident to the police over telephone.
6. On getting the information Inspector V.K Saxena (PW 6) came to the site of the incident accompanied by Sub-Inspector Mithilesh Tiwari (PW 8) and other police personnel. Reaching there he recorded the complaint of PW 1 (Ext. P-2) and after forwarding it to the police station for registering a case thereupon sent PW 1 to Gadarwara Hospital for treatment. He then held inquest upon the dead body of Dayashankar and despatched it for post-mortem examination. From the spot he seized the severed limbs of the two victims, some bloodstained earth and the metal portion and the handle of an axe in the presence of the witnesses.
7. Dr P.K Budhisagar (PW 13), Asstt. Surgeon of Gadarwara Hospital, examined PW 1 and finding his condition critical sent an information to the police for recording his dying declaration. On receipt of such message the police requisitioned the services of the local Magistrate who came to the hospital and recorded his statement (Ext. D-2).
8. SI A.K Bhandari (PW 12), who took up the investigation of the case from PW 6 arrested the appellants and pursuant to their respective statements seized a lathi and a bush shirt which were bloodstained from Nazim, one bloodstained axe from the house of Hargovind, a hockey stick and a lungi, both bloodstained, from Suresh, bloodstained kurta and pyjama from Hargovind and bloodstained trousers, bush shirt and baniyan from Sunil. PW 12 prepared separate sealed packets in respect of those articles and sent them to Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL) for chemical examination. After receipt of the reports of FSL and of the autopsy held on the dead body of Dayashankar by Dr Dhan Singh (PW 4), and on completion of investigation he submitted charge-sheet against the five appellants.
9. The appellants pleaded not guilty to the charges and stated that they were falsely implicated. The appellant Rafiq took a plea of alibi also. In support of their respective cases the prosecution examined thirteen witnesses and the defence one.
10. That Dayashankar (deceased) was brutally murdered and PW 1 mercilessly beaten up, stand proved by overwhelming evidence on record. Inspector V.K Saxena (PW 6) testified that when he reached the site of the incident he found the dead body of Dayashankar in a bullock-cart and Ramesh (PW 1) lying on the ground nearby, with both of them having one of their legs and hands amputated. Under his directions SI Mithilesh Tiwari (PW 8) seized those severed parts besides other articles found there. PW 8 fully corroborated the above testimony of PW 6. Dr Dhan Singh (PW 4), who held autopsy on the dead body of Dayashankar on 31-7-1981, stated that he found the following injuries on his person:
“1. Lacerated wound 1″ × 1/2″ bone-deep in the right parieto-occipital region;
2. Lacerated wound 3/4″ × 1/3″ × 1/3″ on the parietal region;
3. Incised wound 3″ × 1/2″ × bone-deep just left of the midline;
4. Lacerated wound 2″ × 1/2″ × bone-deep on the frontal region just right of midline;
5. Bruise 2½″ × 1/2″ just lateral of right eyebrow with swelling on the right temple 4″ × 3″;
6. Abrasion 1¼″ × 1/2″ over the right shoulder;
7. Abrasion 1/2″ × 1/2″ on top of the right shoulder;
8. Bruise 4½″ × 1/2″ on left forearm, close to elbow joint;
9. Incised wound cutting whole thickness of the right forearm, separating the hand from rest of the body. Ulna and radius cut in one plane slightly oblique — just above the wrist joint;
10. Bruise 3″ × 2″ on the right thigh;
11. Incised wound involving the whole thickness of the right leg just above ankle joint with skin flap cut in different directions suggesting more than one blows with sharp, weighty object, chopping the right foot off from rest of the body. Tibia and fibula bones cut in two different planes; and
12. Incised wound 1¾″ × 1″ × bone-deep on anterior aspect of left leg 3″ above the ankle joint. Tibia cut 1/3rd deep.”
11. He opined that all the injuries were ante-mortem and Injuries 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10 were caused by a hard and blunt object while Injuries 3, 9, 11 and 12 were caused by a sharp and heavy object. According to PW 4 Injuries 3, 4, 5, 9 and 11 were individually and collectively sufficient to cause death. He further opined that the incised wounds seen by him could be caused by a heavy sharp object like an axe.
12. Dr P.K Budhisagar (PW 13) who examined PW 1 on 30-7-1981 at or about 5 p.m testified that he found the following injuries on his person:
“1. Lacerated wound 3″ × 1/2″ × bone-deep over scalp, 3″ behind mastoid;
2. Lacerated wound 1″ × 1/4″ × bone-deep, 1½″ above Injury 1;
3. Lacerated wound 2″ × 1/4″ × bone-deep on the left side of midline and 1″ above Injury 1;
4. Lacerated wound 3″ × 1/4″ × bone-deep on midline 1″ above Injury 3;
5. Lacerated wound 2″ × 1/4″ × bone-deep 1½″ above Injury 4;
6. Lacerated wound 4″ × 1/4″ × bone-deep over midline joining both tragus of the ears;
7. Lacerated wound 4″ × 1/4″ × bone-deep, 1½″ above Injury 6;
8. Left arm fully cut below elbow muscles, nerves bone cut in oblique line from lateral to medial side;
9. Left leg cut at ankle joint, clean-cut 13″ below tibial tuberosity; oblique medial to lateral side. Tibia, fibula and tendons cut;
10. Incised wound 1½″ × 1/2″ × 1/2″ — 4″ above right wrist on the antero-lateral aspect;
11. Incised wound 2″ × 1″ × bone-deep 1″ above right wrist. Bone cut in the depth of the wound. Gap is 3″ deep including bone thickness;
12. Incised wound 3″ × 2″ × 2″, 2″ above Injury 11 — muscle tendons cut and bone fractured; and
13. Incised wound 2″ × 1½″ × 2″, 1½″ above Injury 12; muscle cut and bone fractured.”
13. He opined that the injuries found by him on the right arm, left leg and left arm were caused by a heavy and sharp instrument like an axe and wounds on scalp were caused by a hard and blunt object like a hockey stick. He further opined that all the injuries collectively were sufficient to cause death if the patient was not treated in time.
14. Considering the nature, number and extent of injuries inflicted on Dayashankar (deceased) and Ramesh (PW 1) there cannot be any manner of doubt that whoever caused those injuries are guilty of the offences of committing murder and attempting to commit murder respectively. The next and crucial question that falls for our determination is whether the appellants are the authors of the above crimes as alleged by the prosecution.
15. The mainstay of the prosecution to prove this part of its case is, needless to say, Ramesh (PW 1), who detailed the incident as well as the events leading thereto. To corroborate his evidence the prosecution relied upon the fact that immediately after the assaults took place, he narrated the incident to his mother (PW 2), and nephew (PW 3) who reached there. Besides, his statements, one made before Shri V.K Saxena, Inspector of Police (PW 6), which was treated as the FIR (Ext. P-2) and the other before the Magistrate, (Ext. D-2), which was then recorded as a dying declaration were pressed into service as corroborative evidence. To prove that the ocular evidence of PW 1 fitted in with the injuries sustained by him and his brother the prosecution examined the two doctors referred to earlier.
16. From the judgment of the trial court we find that the principal reason which weighed with it for disbelieving the prosecution case altogether was the fact that in the message that Yogendra (PW 3) gave to the police regarding the incident, after having been apprised of the same by PW 1 and which was recorded by the police in the station diary book (Ext. P-17), he did not disclose the names of the assailants. According to the trial court if really PW 1 had disclosed the names of the assailants to PW 3 it was expected, in the fitness of things, that he would disclose those names in his telephonic message to the police. Such non-disclosure of the names according to the trial court, completely belied the prosecution story that the appellants were the perpetrators of the crimes in question. The other related observation that the trial court made was that since the telephonic message disclosed a cognizable offence and pursuant thereto the police had come to the spot and started investigation, the statement that was made by PW 1 before the Inspector of Police (PW 6) was hit by Section 162 CrPC and consequently, the prosecution's claim that the evidence of PW 1 was corroborated by the said statement, being the FIR, could not be legally entertained. Another reason which weighed with the trial court in disbelieving the prosecution case was that it did not examine any labourers or any other person who were working in the field near the site of the incident to prove the incident and instead thereof relied upon the evidence of only two interested witnesses, namely, PW 2 and PW 3, who, on their own showing, came after the incident was over. The trial court lastly observed that even the evidence of the sole eyewitness, namely PW 1 was also discrepant.
17. In reversing the judgment of the trial court, the High Court held that the findings of the trial court were perverse and against the evidence on record. According to the High Court the cryptic message that was given by PW 3 over telephone to the police could not be treated as FIR, more particularly, when he testified that owing to disturbance in the telephone line he could not disclose the details of the incident; and the statement given by PW 1 before PW 6 (Ext. P-2) was the FIR of the case. The High Court next observed that there was no evidence on record to indicate that at the time the incident actually took place anybody was present so as to entitle the trial court to draw an adverse presumption against the prosecution under Section 114, Illustration (g) of the Evidence Act for non-examination of material witnesses. The High Court lastly observed that the evidence of PW 1, as corroborated by PW 2 and PW 3, who came immediately after the occurrence, the FIR and the medical evidence clearly proved the case of the prosecution. In drawing the above conclusions the High Court also took note of the fact that only a few days prior to the incident the deceased and his brother had in their complaint before the police (Ext. P-1) categorically expressed their apprehension that their lives and properties were in jeopardy as these accused persons had openly given out that they would kill them after cutting them to pieces.
18. This being a statutory appeal we have carefully gone through the entire evidence on record and judgments of the learned courts below. Our such exercise persuades us to unhesitatingly hold that the finding of the trial court that the evidence of PW 1 is wholly unreliable is patently perverse. Considering the fact that except the two victims (PW 1 and the deceased) there was nobody else present at the time the assaults actually took place as the evidence on record clearly indicates there could not be any other witness to the incident. The question of presumption under Section 114 of the Evidence Act could have been drawn in the instant case only if the defence could have succeeded in proving that there were other persons present and had seen the incident and in spite thereof the prosecution, without any justifiable reason, withheld such witnesses. Coming now to the evidence led by the prosecution to corroborate PW 1, who detailed the entire prosecution case, Imartibai (PW 2) stated that on getting the news that Dayashankar was lying dead and Ramesh injured she rushed to the place and gave him some water as he was asking for the same. When she asked Ramesh as to how he sustained those injuries and Dayashankar died, he (PW 1) detailed the entire incident including the names of the appellants as the assailants. The evidence of PW 2 was disbelieved by the trial court on the ground that she was examined by the Investigating Officer after one and a half months. This fact by itself should not, and could not, have been made a ground for disbelieving her for it is expected of a mother who gets information about the assaults on her sons to immediately rush to their help and ascertain the details of the assault. Judged in that context, if the Investigating Officer did not examine PW 2 immediately after the incident it can only be said that it was a dereliction of duty on his part; but such delayed examination by itself would not make the evidence of PW 2 suspect, particularly when she was a natural and probable witness and was readily available for examination by the investigating agency.
19. Equally important in the instant case is the evidence of PW 3, who testified that when he came to the spot and talked to Ramesh who was lying injured he told him about the incident as also the names of the assailants. As already noticed it was PW 3 who gave information to the police about the incident over telephone. In his testimony he said that when he contacted the police from the sub-post office over telephone he got a reply that they could not hear properly. However he could succeed only in communicating that there was a fight in which hands and legs of two persons were cut. In the cross-examination he admitted that he did not tell the names of the accused persons over phone; but explained that owing to some disturbance on the telephone line he could not properly communicate. To disprove the above explanation of PW 3 the defence examined Harishankar Dubey (DW 1), the then Assistant Postmaster of the sub-post office. He testified that on 31-7-1981 one Yogendra came to the post office and asked him to book a telephone call to Gotetoriya Police Station. He (DW 1) asked him as to why he wanted to book a phone and in reply to his query told that he wanted to give a message that a person was murdered and another seriously injured. When he asked him as to who were the assailants Yogendra told him that he did not know their names. Relying upon the above evidence of DW 1 the trial court held that the prosecution version that the appellants were the assailants could not be accepted. In disbelieving DW 1 the High Court, however, pointed out that he figured as a witness for the prosecution and only when he was given up as hostile to it, that the defence examined him. According to the High Court even though in his examination-in-chief he stated that he could hear all that was being conveyed by Yogendra over telephone, in the cross-examination he admitted that he could not hear anything. Besides the above grounds, the other reason which persuades us to hold that he was an unreliable witness is, that it being no part of his duty to ascertain why PW 3 wanted to book a call or what message he wanted to convey, his claim that he was present at the time PW 3 talked over the phone is not tenable. We hasten to add that even if we proceed on the assumption that Yogendra did not disclose the names of the assailants over the phone it would not in any way affect the testimony of PW 1, or corroboration of such testimony by PW 3, for PW 1 not only stated that he disclosed the names of the assailants to PW 3 but PW 3 also asserted that PW 1 did tell the names of the assailants to him. In other words, the evidence of PW 1 that at the earliest opportunity, he disclosed the names of the appellants as his assailants to PW 3 was corroborated by PW 3.
20. While on this point we wish to mention however that the High Court erred in not treating the telephonic information that PW 3 gave to the police station as the FIR. It is not disputed that PW 3 did give information to the police station wherein he stated that one person had been killed and another person had been dismembered and it was recorded accordingly in the daily diary book (Ext. P-17). The same entry discloses, notwithstanding the absence of the names of the assailants therein, a cognizable offence and indeed it is on the basis thereof that PW 6 initially started the investigation. Ext. P-17 will therefore be the FIR and the statement of Ramesh (Ext. P-2) which was recorded by him in the course of the investigation is to be treated as one recorded under Section 161 CrPC. This conclusion of ours, however, does not in any way affect the merits of the prosecution case for we find that immediately after PW 1 was taken to the hospital his statement was recorded as a dying declaration which, consequent upon his survival, is to be treated only as a statement recorded under Section 164 CrPC and can be used for corroboration or contradiction. This statement recorded by the Magistrate at the earliest available opportunity clearly discloses the substratum of the prosecution case including the names of the appellants as the assailants and there is not an iota of material on record to show that this was the upshot of his tutoring. On the contrary, this statement was made at a point of time when PW 1 was in a critical condition and it is difficult to believe that he would falsely implicate the appellants leaving aside the real culprits. In view of the observation of the trial court that his evidence was discrepant we carefully looked into the same and found that there were only some minor inconsequential contradictions which did not at all impair his evidence. Then again, as already noticed, the evidence of the doctors fully supports his version of the incident. Another related aspect of the matter is the lodging of the complaint by PW 1 and his brother before the Superintendent of Police (Ext. P-1) (which we have earlier referred to) wherein they sought for police action against the threat meted out by the appellants that they would cut them to pieces — a threat which was brutally (and literally) translated into action.
21. As from the evidence on record we are satisfied that the appellants committed rioting and in the course thereof they killed Dayashankar and attempted to kill Ramesh we uphold the judgment of the High Court and dismiss the appeal. The appellants, who are on bail, shall now surrender to their bail bonds to serve out the sentence imposed upon them by the High Court.
Alert