Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jaipur Development Authority v. Mahavir Housing Coop. Society, Jaipur And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 18, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

By notifications dated 21-8-1969 issued under Section 4(1) of the Rajasthan Land Acquisition Act, 1953, approximately 484 bighas 11 biswas were acquired for the Jaipur Urban Development Scheme. The present appeals concern:

  • Jai Ambe Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. – 4 acres 5 biswas (9,845 sq. yds.).
  • Mahavir Housing Co-operative Society – 10 bighas 7 biswas.

The Land Acquisition Officer (LAO) awarded compensation on 16-7-1981 and 12-10-1981 at Rs 5,000 per bigha (Jai Ambe) and Rs 7,500 per bigha (Mahavir). On reference under Section 18, the Civil Judge enhanced the rate to Rs 40,000 per bigha. Against the Jai Ambe award, the acquiring authority filed Appeal No. 142 of 1992; a Single Judge of the High Court affirmed the enhancement on 2-5-1994. No appeal was filed against the Mahavir award, but an execution objection regarding additional compensation under Section 23(1-A) was dismissed and that dismissal was upheld in Revision No. 1059 of 1993 (20-12-1993).

Alleging fraud and collusion between government officers, counsel and the claimants, the State obtained special-leave and both matters were heard together by the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the just and reasonable market value payable for the acquired lands of the two Housing Societies?
  2. Whether purchasers who acquired the land after the Section 4(1) notification are entitled to claim compensation higher than that payable to the original owners.
  3. Whether the claimants are entitled to the additional amount under Section 23(1-A), enhanced interest under the proviso to Section 28 and 30% solatium, in view of the 1984 Central Amendment Act and its applicability in Rajasthan.
  4. What is the legal effect of fraud and collusion on the earlier reference awards and related execution proceedings?

Arguments of the Parties

State/Appellant

  • Asserted that the Reference Court and High Court awards were the product of fraud and collusion, noting the absence of rebuttal evidence for more than 11 years and parrot-like acceptance of claimant testimony.
  • Contended that purchasers subsequent to the notification cannot claim higher compensation than the original owners.
  • Argued that, under prevailing Supreme Court precedent, courts lacked jurisdiction to award additional compensation, enhanced interest or 30% solatium for awards passed before the 1984 Amendment became applicable in Rajasthan.

Respondent (Mahavir Housing Co-operative Society)

  • Maintained that the award—having attained finality—could not be reopened merely because an illegality was later noticed.
  • Cited State of Punjab v. Mohinder Singh Randhawa to argue that once an award becomes final, subsequent review on the ground of illegality is impermissible.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Umed Industries & Land Development Co. v. State of Rajasthan (1995) 2 SCC 563 Central Amendment Act 68 of 1984 applies in Rajasthan only from 1-8-1987. Used to deny interest at the enhanced statutory rates prior to 1-8-1987.
Prem Nath Kapur v. National Fertilizers Corpn. (1996) 2 SCC 71 Court lacks jurisdiction to grant Section 23(1-A) amount, enhanced interest and 30% solatium for pre-amendment awards; such grants are nullities. Relied upon to declare the additional amount and excess interest/solatium in the execution decree void.
Union of India v. Raghubir Singh (1989) 2 SCC 754 Constitution Bench authority limiting retrospective application of the 1984 amendments. Cited in support of the conclusion that courts cannot extend post-amendment benefits to earlier awards.
Bai Shakriben v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (1996) 4 SCC 533 Reiterates that courts cannot award benefits introduced by Act 68 of 1984 for pre-amendment acquisitions. Strengthened the position that the additional amount awarded was without jurisdiction.
State of Punjab v. Mohinder Singh Randhawa 1993 Supp (1) SCC 49 Final awards normally immune from later review for mere illegality. Distinguished; the Court held that fraud vitiated the earlier awards, converting the defect into one of jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found substantial evidence of fraud and collusion between government officials, counsel and claimants, including failure to file counter-affidavits for 11 years and reliance on unproven oral assertions of Rs 50 per sq. yd. The Court observed:

  • Subsequent purchasers cannot claim a higher right than original owners; they merely step into the vendors’ shoes.
  • The LAO’s awards of Rs 7,500 and Rs 5,000 per bigha represented the baseline. Doubling those figures—taking into account the paucity of reliable valuation evidence—would achieve fairness while avoiding windfall gains to purchasers.
  • Because possession of Mahavir Society’s land was taken on 24-5-1984, interest before that date was disallowed. Interest thereafter was fixed at 6% p.a. up to 1-8-1987 and 15% p.a. until deposit.
  • 30% solatium was allowed on the enhanced compensation, consistent with the 1984 amendments becoming operative in Rajasthan on 1-8-1987.
  • Applying Prem Nath Kapur and related precedents, the grant of additional compensation under Section 23(1-A) in the execution proceedings was ultra vires and a nullity; fraud further unravelled the awards, permitting the Court to intervene notwithstanding their apparent finality.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed. The Court substituted its own determinations:

  • Jai Ambe Co-operative Housing Society Ltd.: compensation fixed at Rs 15,000 per bigha.
  • Mahavir Housing Co-operative Society: compensation fixed at Rs 22,000 per bigha.
  • No entitlement to additional amount under Section 23(1-A); interest recalculated as specified; 30% solatium allowed on the enhanced compensation.
  • Strictures passed by the Reference Court against officials were upheld.

Implications: The judgment reinforces that benefits introduced by the 1984 amendment cannot be retrospectively conferred on pre-amendment awards, especially where fraud taints the proceedings. It also signals that subsequent purchasers cannot leverage post-notification transactions to inflate compensation, thereby safeguarding public funds in acquisition matters.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted.

2. Notification under Section 4(1) of the Rajasthan Land Acquisition Act, 1953 was published on 21-8-1969 acquiring a large extent of 484 bighas 11 biswas of land for Jaipur Urban Development Scheme by different notifications. An extent of 4 acres 5 biswas (9845 sq. yds.) relates to the acquisition in appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 14811 of 1994. In respect of the appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 6519 of 1994, an extent of 10 bighas 7 biswas was acquired. The Land Acquisition Officer determined the compensation by his award dated 16-7-1981 and 12-10-1981 respectively determining the compensation at the rate of Rs 5000 per bigha to the respondent-Jai Ambe Coop Housing Society and Rs 7500 per bigha to the respondent-Mahavir Housing Coop Society. On reference, the Civil Judge enhanced the compensation at the rate of Rs 40,000 per bigha. As regards the award of the Civil Judge, an appeal was filed against the respondent-Jai Ambe Cooperative Society Ltd. The learned Single Judge in Appeal No. 142 of 1992 has confirmed the same by judgment dated 2-5-1994. As regards the award in favour of Mahavir Housing Cooperative Society, no appeal was filed. But in execution an objection has been raised regarding additional amount awarded under Section 23(1-A) which was negatived. On revision, the High Court in Revision No. 1059 of 1993 dated 20-12-1993 confirmed the same. Thus, these appeals by special leave.

3. When the matter relating to Mahavir Housing Cooperative Society initially came up, notice was confined in respect of Section 23(1-A), but later when it was brought to our notice of the fraud and collusion between the officers entrusted with the prosecution on behalf of the appellant and the claimants, we have indicated to the counsel that we would go into the question of determination of the compensation. Thus, these cases are heard together. It is seen that from the evidence adduced before the Reference Court in respect of Jai Ambe Cooperative Housing Society except one claimant Mr Garg, no documentary evidence has been adduced in support of the claimant for enhancement. Two awards under Section 26 came to be filed in which one award relating to the Mahavir Housing Cooperative Society and another award relating to the same notification but an amount of Rs 24,000 per bigha was awarded. As regards the claim in Mahavir Housing Cooperative Society is concerned, they relied upon a judgment of the High Court in which the High Court has granted to some lands at the rate of Rs 12 per sq. yd. which relates to the acquisition of 1964 and also a certificate issued by Tehsildar relating to some other village, which worked out at the rate of Rs 44,000 per acre and the sale deeds in support thereof. One curious fact in both the cases that cannot be lost sight of is that the claimants have purchased these properties after the notification under Section 4(1) was published and a reference came to be made at their instance to the civil court. Though an opportunity was given to the appellant, for well over 11 years, no counter-affidavit has been filed. As a result, they were set ex parte. Yet another curious aspect that we cannot lose sight of is that the Reference Judge has merely with parrot-like but traditional consideration swallowed what with witnesses had stated that the market value is Rs 50 per sq. yd. without subjecting to any scrutiny as per the tests laid down by this Court. It is also to be noted that the same aspect was repeated by the learned Judge of the High Court in Jai Ambe Coop. Housing Society case.

4. The question, therefore, is what would be the reasonable compensation to which the claimants are capable to get? In view of the settled legal position that the claimants being the subsequent purchasers cannot have a higher right than that the original owner himself had. They cannot set up any title to the property on the basis of sale deeds and consideration but may be entitled to the compensation obviously getting into the shoes of the claimant. We need not go into the question of correctness whether or not the reference is valid in this case, though open to doubt since that question was not raised at any stage much less in this Court. We proceed on the premise that the reference under Section 18 was valid.

5. As stated earlier, the entire process has gone on in collusion. When we have issued notice to the appellants as to what steps they have taken against the officers who are responsible even for not filing the appeals or not contesting the matter, an affidavit has been filed in which it was stated that disciplinary action against the Land Acquisition Officer was taken and even the counsel who appeared for the Jaipur Development Authority was in collusion and steps were taken by laying a complaint before the Bar Council for professional misconduct. We need not further dwell upon that fact but suffice it to state that the acquisition proceedings have proceeded in collusion and, therefore, they were not reflected the correct market value as is available in this case. As seen in Jai Ambe Coop. Housing Society case, even their own sale deeds under which they have purchased from one Bhagwan Singh, who was said to be the original owner, were not even filed. Under these circumstances, we thought over the matter as to what would be the appropriate course to be adopted in this case. We are of the view that instead of relegating the matter again, we can ourselves decide the matter on the basis of the evidence on record. Accordingly, we have considered the case on merits.

6. It is seen that the Land Acquisition Officer has awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 7500 per bigha to the lands purchased by Mahavir Cooperative Housing Society and Rs 5000 per bigha to the lands purchased by Jai Ambe Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. Having regard to the facts and circumstances, we are of the considered view that two times more than what was granted by the Land Acquisition Officer would be the just compensation in the given circumstances of the case. Accordingly, we determine the compensation to Jai Ambe Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. at the rate of Rs 15,000 per bigha and to the lands of Mahavir Housing Cooperative Society Rs 22,000 (sic) per bigha.

7. As regards the State of Rajasthan the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act, 68 of 1984 was extended w.e.f 30-4-1987. But the State Legislature had amended the Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 by Amendment Act 29 of 1987 w.e.f 1-8-1987. In Umed Industries & Land Development Co. v. State of Rajasthan (1995) 2 SCC 563, a Bench of two Judges had held that the Central Amendment Act 68 of 1984 would apply from 1-8-1987 to the acquisition in State of Rajasthan. It is seen that in Mahavir Housing Coop. Society case, possession was delivered on 24-5-1984 after the stay was vacated by the Civil Court since the Civil Court granted stay of dispossession on 23-10-1983. Therefore, the respondent-Society is not entitled to the interest prior to 25-5-1984. Therefore, the decree as regards payment of interest from the date of the notification till 24-5-1984 is clearly illegal. It is seen that since the award of the Reference Court is dated 15-6-1990, the claimants will be entitled to interest from 25-5-1984 at the rate of 6% per annum till 1-8-1987 and thereafter 15% per annum on the enhanced compensation till date of deposit in the Court. As regards the solatium is concerned, they are entitled to 30% solatium on the enhanced compensation. As regards the additional amount under Section 23(1-A) is concerned, the claimants are not entitled to the additional amount since the awards came to be passed by the Land Acquisition Officer on 12-10-1981 and 16-7-1981 in Mahavir Housing Coop. Society and Jai Ambe Coop. Housing Society Ltd. respectively.

8. In Prem Nath Kapur v. National Fertilizers Corpn. of India Ltd. (1996) 2 SCC 71, the entire case law was considered by a Bench of three Judges who in held that the power to grant additional amount under Section 23(1-A) and enhanced interest under the proviso to Section 28 and solatium at 30 per cent was due to amendments brought under Act 68 of 1984. Prior thereto the court has no power or jurisdiction to grant them. Therefore, the additional amount, the excess rate of interest or solatium at 30 per cent granted were without jurisdiction and a nullity. The courts cannot correct the award or the decree in exercise of the power under Sections 151 and 152 CPC. This Court has relied upon the Constitution Bench decision in Union of India v. Raghubir Singh (1989) 2 SCC 754, (1989) 3 SCR 316. This Court has reiterated the same principle in another recent judgment in Bai Shakriben v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (1996) 4 SCC 533, (1996) 4 Scale 636. Therefore, objection would be raised in execution under Section 47. The award of the additional amount was one without jurisdiction and so a nullity.

9. It is contended for the respondent in Mahavir Housing Coop. Society case, that since the award was allowed to become final including grant of additional amount under Section 23(1-A), it is not open to the review at a later date since it is not one of initial lack of jurisdiction but an illegality has been committed in awarding the additional amount. In support thereof, learned counsel relied upon a judgment of this Court in State of Punjab v. Mohinder Singh Randhawa 1993 Supp (1) SCC 49. It is true that in a case where the proceedings were properly conducted and the order was allowed to become final, the matter may be construed to be an order of illegality. When it is one of jurisdiction, this Court has repeatedly, in plethora of precedents, had held that the courts have no jurisdiction to award additional amount under Section 23(1-A) since the Collector had already passed the award under Section 11 and the benefit of additional amount would be confined to the period between the date of the notification under Section 4(1) and the award under Section 11 when the proceedings were pending before him. In this case, since we have already recorded the finding that the award became final due to collusion by the officers and the claimants, the principle of illegality in the award does not apply since fraud unravels the entire procedure and makes the award a nullity.

10. The appeals are accordingly allowed as indicated above, but in the circumstances, without costs. As regards strictures awarded by the Reference Court, they stand upheld.