- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Orissa And Others v. Sibaram Baral (Simaram Barai) .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent filed a suit to recover Rs 1,46,820 from the appellants. The suit was decreed ex parte. The appellants moved an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) to set aside the ex parte decree. The trial court granted the application on payment of Rs 50 as costs. The respondent sought revision before the High Court, which set aside the trial court’s order and directed the appellants to deposit the entire decretal amount along with costs of Rs 7,500 as a condition for setting aside the ex parte decree. The present appeal challenges the High Court’s order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in a revision petition challenging an order under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, the High Court can direct the judgment-debtor to deposit the entire decretal amount and additional costs as a condition for setting aside an ex parte decree.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted that Order 41 Rule 1(3) CPC empowers an appellate court, in an appeal against a money decree, to require deposit of the disputed amount or security. However, the High Court was exercising revisional jurisdiction, not appellate jurisdiction, because no appeal against the ex parte decree was before it. Therefore, the High Court’s direction to deposit the entire decretal amount and Rs 7,500 in costs exceeded its jurisdiction.
The Court emphasized that the trial court had already used its discretion under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC by imposing a modest cost of Rs 50 when setting aside the ex parte decree. The High Court’s intervention was unwarranted; its role was limited to assessing whether the trial court’s discretion had been exercised properly. The Supreme Court observed that bureaucratic lapses often cause delays and that imposing a heavy financial burden on a public body would ultimately harm public justice.
Given these considerations, the Supreme Court held that the High Court’s order lacked legal foundation and restored the trial court’s order.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Allowed; High Court order set aside and trial court order restored.
The immediate consequence is that the appellants need only pay Rs 50 as previously ordered by the trial court to have the ex parte decree set aside. The decision clarifies that a High Court, while exercising revisional jurisdiction under the CPC, cannot impose conditions akin to those permissible only in appellate proceedings. No new precedent of broader applicability was explicitly established beyond this clarification.
Order
1. Though the respondent had been served with notice on 5-8-1992, till date neither the unserved cover nor the acknowledgement has been received back. Under these circumstances, notice must be deemed to have been served.
2. Leave granted.
3. The only question is whether the High Court can direct the appellant to deposit the decretal amount with costs of Rs 7500 as a condition to setting aside the ex parte decree? The respondent laid the suit to recover a sum of Rs 1,46,820 against the appellants. The suit came to be decreed ex parte. The appellant has filed an application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC to set aside the ex parte decree. The trial court set aside the ex parte decree subject to payment of Rs 50. The High Court in the impugned order dated 8-1-1992 in CR No. 694 of 1991 allowed the revision and set aside the order of the trial court and directed the appellants to deposit the decretal amount and the costs. Order 41 Rule 1(3) of CPC provides thus:
“Where the appeal is against a decree for payment of money, the appellant shall, within such time as the appellate court may allow, deposit the amount disputed in the appeal or furnish such security in respect thereof as the Court may think fit.”
4. When an appellate power is exercised on an appeal filed against the decree of the trial court, the Court exercises judicial discretion to grant conditional stay of the execution of the money decree reasonably based on fact situation. In this case, there is no appeal before the High Court against ex parte decree of the trial court. The trial court itself set aside the ex parte decree subject to the payment of the cost. When revision was carried, the High Court was required to consider whether the trial court properly considered the facts to set aside the ex parte decree and the case called for interference. It cannot exceed its jurisdiction in directing the appellant to deposit the entire decretal amount and also the cost of Rs 7500. The explanation given by the State is well justified as no one takes responsibility for the lapses. Each would pass the buck on the other. Ultimately, it would be the public justice which would suffer and put to jeopardy. Under these circumstances, the order of the High Court is set aside and that of the trial court is restored.
5. The appeal is accordingly allowed. No costs.
Alert