- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rudradhar R. Trivedi v. State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
On 11 July 1953, the State issued a notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 to acquire approximately 567 acres of land for establishing the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT). Declarations under Section 6 followed during 1955-56, and about forty separate awards were ultimately passed to determine compensation. In this particular matter, the second respondent served a Section 9 notice on 15 May 1963; the petitioner submitted objections, and an award was eventually made on 13 March 1985.
The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging both the Section 4(1) notification and the Section 6 declaration, alleging: (i) absence of notice under Section 5-A despite being a sub-lessee, and (ii) inordinate delay in making the award. A learned Single Judge of the High Court dismissed the petition on 16 February 1996. The Division Bench upheld that decision on 12 June 1996. The petitioner then approached the Supreme Court by way of Special Leave Petition (SLP).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether transfer of 60.8312 acres, out of the land originally acquired for IIT, to the National Institute for Training in Industrial Engineering (NITIE) constituted a “fraud on the public purpose” and thereby invalidated the entire acquisition.
- Whether the long interval (approximately 22 years) between the Section 9 notice and the award justified quashing the acquisition on the ground of inordinate delay.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The 1970 Government Resolution allowing IIT to transfer 60 acres to NITIE subverted the original public purpose, rendering the acquisition void.
- Support for the above proposition was drawn from:
- Industrial Development & Investment Co. (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1989 Bom 156.
- Union of India v. Nand Kishore, AIR 1982 Del 462.
- The delay of over two decades in passing the award was so excessive that the acquisition should be quashed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Industrial Development & Investment Co. (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1989 Bom 156 | Asserted by petitioner to show that diversion of acquired land defeats the original public purpose. | The Supreme Court held the precedent irrelevant; land acquired for one public purpose may be used for another compatible public purpose. |
| Union of India v. Nand Kishore, AIR 1982 Del 462 | Also relied on to argue that change in utilisation invalidates acquisition. | Likewise found inapplicable; the Court reiterated that transfer between public institutions does not vitiate the acquisition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court reiterated the settled principle that land validly acquired for a public purpose may, if circumstances require, be applied to another public purpose without offending the Act. As NITIE is a public technical-education institution, the transfer of 60.8312 acres from IIT served a cognate public purpose and therefore did not constitute a “fraud on public purpose.”
Regarding delay, the Court noted that Maharashtra’s procedural rules mandate personal hearings for all objectors under Section 5-A. In a “massive acquisition” of this scale, such hearings inevitably consume considerable time. Moreover, the petitioner sought relief only in 1985, more than two decades after issuance of the Section 9 notice. Given these facts, the Court found no basis to invalidate the acquisition for delay, nor any ground to interfere with the High Court’s discretionary refusal of relief under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Holding and Implications
SLP DISMISSED.
Consequently, the High Court’s dismissal of the writ petition stands affirmed, and the acquisition—together with the subsequent transfer of a portion of land to NITIE—remains undisturbed. The Court set no new precedent; it merely applied existing principles concerning permissible public-purpose transfers and discretionary relief in cases of delay.
Order
1. We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner.
2. Notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short “the Act”) was published on 11-7-1953. Successive declaration under Section 6 came to be published in the year 1955-56. Thereafter, as many as 40 awards have been passed determining the compensation. In this case notice was issued by the second respondent on 15-5-1963 under Section 9 of the Act pursuant to which the petitioner had filed his objections. Thereafter, the award came to be made on 13-3-1985. He filed writ petition challenging the validity of the notification under Section 4(1) and the declaration under Section 6. Primary contention raised in the writ petition was that the petitioner had not been given notice under Section 5-A whereas being a sub-lessee, he was an interested person. The High Court was not impressed with the argument. He further contended that there was inordinate delay in passing the award. On that account, notification under Section 4(1) and declaration under Section 6 were required to be set aside. That contention was also negatived. The learned Single Judge by judgment dated 16-2-1996 dismissed the writ petition. On appeal, the Division Bench in the impugned order dated 12-6-1996 in Appeal No. 423 of 1996 confirmed the same.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that since the land in an extent of 567 acres was acquired for public purpose, namely, establishment of IIT, transfer of 60 acres of land to NITIE by the IIT by a resolution of the Government, viz., 95 of 1970, dated 26-6-1970 was clearly a fraud on public purpose. Therefore, the acquisition is not valid in law. In support thereof, the learned counsel placed reliance on the judgment of the Bombay High Court in Industrial Development & Investment Co. (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra AIR 1989 Bom 156, 1988 Mah LJ 1027 and of the Delhi High Court in Union of India v. Nand Kishore AIR 1982 Del 462, (1982) 22 DLT 251. We find no force in the contention. It is settled law that the land acquired for public purpose can be transferred to another public purpose. Paramount consideration will be service of the public purpose. The NITIE is also one of the public institutions imparting technical education in the region. Under these circumstances, the transfer of 60.8312 acres of land handed over to NITIE pursuant to the resolution made by the Government is not vitiated by any error of law nor the notification under Section 4(1) and declaration published under Section 6 become bad in law. The aforesaid decisions bear no relevance.
4. It is next contended that in view of the inordinate delay in passing the award, the acquisition should be required to be quashed. We find no force in the contention. It is seen that in Maharashtra State, as per the rules prevailing, pursuant to the notice under Section 5-A a personal hearing is required to be given to all the owners. In a massive acquisition like this, it would be wellnigh impossible for the Land Acquisition Officer to pass the award within a short span of time. Under these circumstances, necessarily delay had occasioned in passing the awards. The petitioner had evoked at a belated stage in 1985, after practically 22 years. The High Court was, therefore, clearly right in refusing to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.
5. The SLP is accordingly dismissed.
Alert