Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India v. Mhathung Kithan And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 18, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1 appeared for the 1985 Civil Service Examination conducted by the Union Public Service Commission and was selected for the 1986 batch of the Indian Administrative Service (IAS). His home State is Nagaland, and he expressed a preference for allocation to the Nagaland cadre. Under a 30-point roster that implemented a 1984 Government policy designed to ensure that at least 66-2/3 % of direct-recruit IAS officers in each State are “outsiders,” both vacancies for Nagaland that year were earmarked for outsiders. Consequently, Respondent 1, classified as an “insider,” was allotted to the Haryana cadre.

Respondent 1 challenged this allocation before the Chandigarh Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT). The Tribunal allowed his application and directed the Union of India to consider his transfer to the Nagaland cadre. The Union of India appealed, leading to the present civil appeal. A second appeal (Civil Appeal No. 12325 of 1996) involving similar facts was heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an IAS officer has a legal right to be allocated to the cadre of his home State or choice under Rule 5 of the Indian Administrative Service (Cadre) Rules.
  2. Whether “insider” vacancies that remain unfilled in a particular recruitment year can be carried forward to the next year, thereby permitting an insider candidate to displace the “outsider” allocation mandated by the 30-point roster.
  3. Whether the Central Administrative Tribunal was correct in directing the transfer of Respondent 1 from the Haryana cadre to the Nagaland cadre in disregard of the 66-2/3 % outsider policy and the 30-point roster.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent 1’s Arguments

  • In the 1984 batch, the roster point earmarked for an insider remained unfilled due to the absence of an eligible insider, and an outsider occupied that vacancy.
  • Because of the unfilled insider vacancy in 1984, one of the two 1985 roster points for Nagaland should be treated as available for an insider, entitling him to a Nagaland cadre allocation.

Appellant (Union of India) – Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the appellant’s specific legal submissions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Rajiv Yadav, IAS (1994) 6 SCC 38; (1994) 28 ATC 228 An IAS selectee has a right to appointment but no right to allocation to a cadre of choice or home State; cadre allocation is an incidence of service. The Court relied on this precedent to reject Respondent 1’s claim of entitlement to the Nagaland cadre, affirming that cadre allocation lies within the administrative discretion of the Central Government.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining Rule 5 of the IAS (Cadre) Rules, noting that cadre allocation is made by the Central Government in consultation with the State Governments concerned and may be altered only with their concurrence. Referring to Rajiv Yadav, the Court reiterated that an officer holds no enforceable right to a particular State cadre.

It then considered the Government of India’s 30-7-1984 policy letter, which raised the outsider element in direct recruitment to 66-2/3 % (a 2:1 outsider-insider ratio). The continuous 30-point roster implementing that policy began with the 1983 examination and, for the 1985 batch, allotted both Nagaland vacancies to outsiders. Respondent 1, as an insider, was therefore ineligible for those roster points.

The Court addressed Respondent 1’s contention that an unfilled insider vacancy from the 1984 batch should carry forward. It found no rule or provision permitting the carry-forward of insider vacancies; the roster mechanism and the policy aimed to increase outsider representation and did not impose an upper ceiling on outsiders. Consequently, the Tribunal’s order disruptively altered the roster and policy framework.

Finding the Tribunal’s reasoning unsustainable, the Court concluded that Respondent 1 could not be accommodated in the outsider vacancies and that the CAT had erred in directing his transfer.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; Tribunal’s order set aside; Respondent 1’s application dismissed with costs.

The decision reinstates the original cadre allocation of Respondent 1 to Haryana, confirms the validity of the 66-2/3 % outsider policy and the 30-point roster, and affirms that IAS officers have no legal right to insist on home-State cadre allocation. No new legal precedent is set, but existing principles on cadre allocation are reinforced.

Show all summary ...

Sujata v. Manohar, J.— Leave granted in both the special leave petitions.

Civil Appeal No. 12310 of 1996 [@ SLP (C) No. 13705 of 1995]

2. Respondent 1 appeared in the Civil Service Examination conducted by the Union Public Service Commission in the year 1985. He was selected for appointment to the Indian Administrative Service in the 1986 batch. The home State of Respondent 1 is Nagaland and he gave his preference for allocation to his home State cadre. There were two seats which were available for allocation to Nagaland. Both these seats were earmarked for outsiders as per the 30-point roster. Hence the first respondent was allocated to the State of Haryana. He challenged this allocation by filing an application before the Chandigarh Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal has allowed the application and directed the appellant-Union of India to consider the transfer of Respondent 1 from the Haryana cadre to the Nagaland cadre in the manner set out in the order. The present appeal is from the order of the Tribunal.

3. Under Rule 5 of the Cadre Rules it is provided as follows:

“5. Allocation of members to various cadres.—(1) The allocation of cadre officers to the various cadres shall be made by the Central Government in consultation with the State Government or the State Governments concerned.
(2) The Central Government may, with the concurrence of the State Governments concerned transfer a cadre officer from one cadre to another cadre.”

4. Rule 5 was construed by this Court in the case of Union of India v. Rajiv Yadav, IAS (1994) 6 SCC 38, (1994) 28 ATC 228. It has held that a selected candidate has a right to be considered for appointment to the IAS but he has no such right to be allocated to a cadre of his choice or to his home State. Allotment of cadre is an incidence of service; and a member of an All India Service bears liability to serve in any part of India. Respondent 1, therefore, had no right to be allocated to a cadre of his choice.

5. Under a policy decision conveyed by the Government of India, Department of Personnel and Training to the Chief Secretaries of all States by a letter dated 30-7-1984, it was decided that for various reasons set out therein, in order to have a proper balance in the State cadre, the ‘outsider’ element in the direct recruitment quota was raised to 66-2/3% or in the ratio 2:1 as between outsiders and insiders in place of 1:1. The letter states:

“It is proposed to give effect to this decision by ensuring henceforth at the time of allocating candidates appointed to IAS and IPS on the basis of Civil Service Examination, that at least 66-2/3% of the officers are from outside the State concerned.”
(emphasis ours)

6. In the light of this policy a continuous 30-point roster was provided starting from the examination held in 1983. The roster follows the cycle, “outsider, insider, outsider, outsider, insider, outsider …”. In any given year the roster starts with the point where the roster ended in the previous year. In the case of the State cadre for the State of Nagaland there were two vacancies for allocation to the batch which had passed the examination in the year 1985. As per the 30-point roster, both these vacancies were for outsiders. Hence the first respondent, who belonged to the State of Nagaland, being an ‘insider’, was not eligible for either of the two vacancies. He was, therefore, allotted to the State of Haryana.

7. The first respondent has contended that in the batch passing the examination in 1984, when the vacancy was for an insider, no insider was available and the vacancy had been occupied by an outsider. Hence he should be considered for one of the roster points available for the batch of 1985. We have, however, not been shown any rule which provides for a carry-over of ‘insider’ vacancies if they are not filled due to non-availability of insider candidates. In the absence of any such rule for carry-forward of insider vacancies, we do not see how the first respondent can be accommodated in the vacancies which are earmarked for outsiders as per the relevant roster points.

8. In the policy statement of 30-7-1984, a reference was made to the fact that State service officers who get promoted to IAS/IPS are in the age group of 40 to 50 and at that late stage, their transfer to another State cadre may give rise to personnel and administrative problems of adjustment. Therefore, in order to restore the outsider-insider balance in a State cadre, it was proposed that the outsider element in the direct recruitment quota required to be increased. In this context it is difficult to accept the contention of the first respondent regarding carry-forward of ‘insider’ vacancies. The roster is framed bearing in mind this requirement of increasing outsiders in the quota of direct recruits. The policy requires that at least 66-2/3% of the officers who are directly recruited are from outside the State concerned. It does not impose a ceiling of 66-2/3%. The Tribunal was, therefore, not right in disturbing the implementation of this policy as per the roster.

9. The appeal is, therefore, allowed with costs. The order of the Tribunal is set aside and the application of the first respondent is dismissed.

10. In view of the above decision, Civil Appeal No. 12325 of 1996 [@ SLP (C) No. 21429 of 1993] is also allowed with costs since the facts are similar to the facts in the above civil appeal.