Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anil Kumar Mitra And Others v. Ganendra Nath Mitra And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 28, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The litigation concerns premises No. 10-D, Puddapukur Road, P.S. Bhowanipur, Calcutta-20. Originally, the property was jointly owned in equal shares by two brothers, Haridas and Gunendra.

  • 1927 – Mortgage and Foreclosure: Haridas mortgaged his half-share to Rabindra Nath Bose. In Title Suit No. 130 of 1927 a preliminary decree for foreclosure was passed on 7-4-1927 for Rs 9,222. Upon non-payment, a final decree dated 16-8-1927 led to a court sale at which Bose purchased Haridas’s half-share; a sale certificate issued on 22-2-1928.
  • 1929 – Compromise Suit: Gunendra, then a minor represented by his mother Sailabala, instituted Title Suit No. 13 of 1929. The matter was compromised on 17-7-1929; Sailabala received consideration from Bose.
  • 1928/1929 – Partition Suit: Bose filed Title Suit No. 69 of 1928 (renumbered 128 of 1929) seeking partition of the half-share he had purchased. A preliminary decree was passed on 17-12-1931 and a final decree on 18-7-1934, allotting Plot “A” and Rs 5,000 to Gunendra. The preliminary decree severed the joint family status between the two branches.
  • 1965 – Fresh Partition Action: The present appellants filed Title Suit No. 71 of 1965 in the Court of the Fourth Subordinate Judge, Alipore, contending that the property remained joint family property and sought partition of the share held by Gunendra through Sailabala.
  • Trial Court and High Court: Both courts rejected the claim. The High Court’s Division Bench judgment dated 29-4-1988 in Original Decree No. 52 of 1978 affirmed the dismissal.
  • Current Proceedings: The appellants sought special-leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, resulting in the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants are entitled to a decree for partition of the share held by Gunendra, treating it as joint family property after the 1931 preliminary partition decree.
  2. Whether the joint family status between the branches of Haridas and Gunendra continued despite the 1931 severance.
  3. Whether the consideration for discharging Haridas’s mortgage debt was paid from joint family funds, thereby preserving the joint character of the property.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The respondents failed to prove their independent financial capacity to discharge the mortgage; therefore, the consideration must be presumed to have emanated from joint family funds, keeping the property joint.
  • No evidence was produced to show an effective severance of the joint family; hence the presumption of joint status should continue.
  • Amended pleadings allegedly indicate that the parties remained members of a joint family, warranting partition.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found the appellants’ contentions unsustainable for want of pleadings and proof:

  • The 17-12-1931 preliminary decree in Title Suit No. 128 of 1929 conclusively severed the joint family status. Following such a decree, no presumption of continued coparcenary exists.
  • To succeed, the appellants had to plead and prove (a) a reunion after the 1931 severance, or (b) blending of the separately allotted share into joint family property, evidenced by conduct and treatment of the property. The plaint contained no such specific averments, nor was evidence produced.
  • The assertion that the mortgage consideration came from joint family assets was likewise unsupported by pleadings or proof. Mere inability of the respondents to establish separate financial capacity does not shift the burden to presume joint funds.
  • In these circumstances, the Court held that the question of partition did not arise, validating the concurrent findings of the trial court and High Court.

Holding and Implications

The civil appeal is dismissed; no order as to costs.

The immediate consequence is that the appellants’ suit for partition of the property fails, and the decrees of the trial court and Calcutta High Court remain undisturbed. The judgment turns on fact-specific deficiencies in pleadings and evidence and does not establish a new legal precedent of general application.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This appeal by special leave arises from the judgment of the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court, made on 29-4-1988 in Original Decree No. 52 of 1978.

2. This case has a chequered history. The property bearing No. 10-D, Puddapukur Road, P.S Bhowanipur, Calcutta-20 is the subject-matter of an endless litigation at four stages. Initially, the property was shared by two brothers Haridas and Gunendra in equal shares. Haridas hypothecated his half share to Rabindra Nath Bose, who had filed Title Suit No. 130 of 1927 for foreclosure of mortgage and a preliminary decree therein was granted on 7-4-1927. A decree for a sum of Rs 9222 was passed. Since the amount was not paid the property was brought to sale and a final decree was passed on 16-8-1927 in which Rabindra Nath Bose had purchased the half share of Haridas. A sale certificate in that behalf was given on 22-2-1928.

3. It would appear that Gunendra, a minor represented by his mother Sailabala, filed Title Suit No. 13 of 1929 which was ultimately compromised by Sailabala and Rabindra Nath Bose by compromise decree dated 17-7-1929 in which she received certain amount, the details of which are not material. Thereafter, Rabindra Nath Bose filed Title Suit No. 69 of 1928, which was renumbered as 128 of 1929, for partition and separate possession of his half share purchased by him towards the share of Haridas. A preliminary decree in that behalf was passed on 17-12-1931 and a final decree was also passed on 18-7-1934 in which Plot No. A was allotted to Gunendra, represented by his mother Sailabala and a sum of Rs 5000 in addition was given. Thus, it could be seen that the joint family status of Haridas and his brother Gunendra had come to be severed after passing of the preliminary decree on 17-12-1931. Another Title Suit No. 71 of 1965 was filed by the appellants in the Court of Fourth Subordinate Judge at Alipore for partition of the properties had by Sailabala with Rabindra Nath Bose claiming that it was a joint family property and the consideration for discharge of the mortgage with Rabindra Nath Bose had passed on from the joint family property. Therefore, they claimed for partition of the half share had by Gunendra at a partition action laid by Rabindra Nath Bose in the partition Title Suit No. 129 of 1929. The question is whether the appellants can claim partition of the share had by Gunendra, represented by his mother Sailabala, as guardian. Both the trial court and the High Court rejected the relief.

4. Shri Arun Prakash Chatterjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellants, contends that the High Court has found that the respondents have not proved their capacity to purchase the property after paying consideration for discharge of the mortgage debt and, therefore, in the absence of their proof of capacity to discharge the debt, it must necessarily be construed that the consideration had flown from the joint family. It is also contended that there is no proof of the severance of the status of the joint family and joint family continues to exist and, therefore, courts below have committed manifest error of law in not passing the decree for partition. We find no force in the contentions. We requested the learned counsel to read out from the plaint whether there is any averment made in the plaint, viz., any averment or issue raised after the final decree was passed in Title Suit No. 128 of 1929 and whether there is any reunion of the members of both the branches and whether the share had by Gunendra was blended so as to be treated as joint family property. Learned counsel sought to read out to us the plaint as amended and sought to contend that it gives the indication that they remained to be members of the joint family and, therefore, that gives a clue that joint family continued to exist. We fail to appreciate the stand taken by Shri Arun Prakash Chatterjee. After preliminary decree was passed in Title Suit No. 128 of 1929, the joint family status existing prior to the date came to a terminus and, therefore, there is no presumption thereafter that both Haridas and Gunendra continued to be members of the joint family. It is true that by the acts of the parties that even after the previous partition, they continued to be members of the joint family. But it should be by conduct and treatment meted out to the properties by the members of the family in this regard. It must be pleaded as a fact and proved that after the preliminary decree was passed on 17-12-1931 and both branches were reunited and Gunendra through his mother had blended the share had in final decree in the joint family property, the parties treated and enjoyed it in that character as joint family property. Unfortunately, there is no such plea nor proof. Under these circumstances, it cannot be held that the joint family continues to exist in the absence of which the question of partition does not arise. Under these circumstances, we do not find any illegality in the decree passed by the trial court as affirmed by the High Court.

5. The civil appeal is dismissed. No costs.