- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
K. Moosa Haji'S Wido... v. Executive Officer, S...
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal was brought before the Supreme Court of India by special leave against the judgment of the Kerala High Court dated 20 March 1995 in Second Appeal No. 995 of 1989. The appellants’ predecessor, Mr. Vellu, had entered into an agreement with the respondent Devaswam on 25 November 1921 (Ex. A-1) to construct a residential building on 3 ½ cents of land. The structure, identified as Municipal No. 177, was erected on this plot. Over time, the appellants expanded their possession to two larger extents—10 3⁄10 cents and 13 1⁄5 cents.
The respondent filed a suit seeking eviction and recovery of possession. Both the trial court and the first appellate court dismissed the suit, but the High Court, in second appeal, held that the appellants’ rights could not exceed the 3 ½ cents granted under Ex. A-1. It instructed the trial court to appoint a Commissioner to demarcate that area and ordered possession of the remaining land to the respondent. The present Supreme Court decision reviews that High Court decree.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court erred in directing delivery of 10 3⁄10 cents to the respondent when the appellants claimed to have obtained that extent under a purchase certificate issued pursuant to the Kerala Land Reforms Act.
- Whether the appellants possessed any lawful title to land in excess of (a) the 3 ½ cents covered by Ex. A-1 and (b) the 10 3⁄10 cents covered by the purchase certificate, particularly when relying on Ex. B-8 (a rent receipt) as the alleged source of title.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The High Court erroneously ordered recovery of 10 3⁄10 cents even though that extent had been purchased by the appellants under the Land Reforms Act.
- The trial and first appellate courts had found that the house existed on the disputed land and that specified boundaries, rather than the stated extent, should prevail; hence, eviction was unwarranted.
- They relied on Ex. B-8 (a rent receipt) as evidence of their title to the additional land.
Respondent's Arguments
- Through counsel, the respondent expressly excluded the 10 3⁄10 cents covered by the purchase certificate from the scope of its present claim, reserving the right to pursue remedies under the Land Reforms Act.
- They maintained that any possession beyond the land granted in Ex. A-1 lacked legal title, as Ex. B-8 was merely a rent receipt and conferred none.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court first recorded the respondent’s concession that it would not seek possession of the 10 3⁄10 cents covered by the purchase certificate; consequently, the Court found it unnecessary to examine the legality of that portion. Focusing on the remaining 13 1⁄5 cents, the Court held:
- Ex. B-8, being only a rent receipt, does not create or evidence title.
- Beyond the original grant of 3 ½ cents under Ex. A-1 and the subsequently purchased 10 3⁄10 cents, the appellants could show no document conferring ownership.
- Accordingly, the appellants’ occupation of the additional 13 1⁄5 cents was unauthorised, and the High Court was correct in ordering its return, subject to exclusion of the land protected by the purchase certificate.
Holding and Implications
Appeal dismissed with modification. The decree stands except that the area of 10 3⁄10 cents covered by the appellants’ purchase certificate is excluded; the respondent is entitled to recover only the remaining 13 1⁄5 cents. No order as to costs.
Implications are confined to the parties: the appellants must surrender possession of 13 1⁄5 cents, while retaining the 10 3⁄10 cents under the Land Reforms Act. The judgment sets no new legal precedent, resting solely on the factual absence of title documents.
Order
1. This appeal by special leave arises from the judgment of the Kerala High Court dated 20-3-1995 made in SA No. 995 of 1989. The admitted position is that the appellants' predecessor one Mr Vellu had entered into an agreement with the respondent Devaswam for construction of residential premises on an extent of 3 1/2 cents of land under Ex. A-1 dated 25-11-1921. The extent is of 5 × 7 sq. ft. Koles with a boundary specified thereunder. The building constructed on this land has Municipal No. 177. Thereafter it would appear that the appellant had extended their possession to 10 3/10 cents and 13 1/5 cents at different times. The respondent has filed the suit for eviction of the appellants and possession thereof. The trial court and the appellate court have dismissed the suit and the appeal. But in the second appeal, the High Court declared that the permission granted by the Executive Officer, Ex. B-8 does not confer any title. The appellants' claim cannot extend beyond what has been granted to her predecessor in interest, Ex. A-1. Accordingly, it directed the trial court to appoint a Commissioner to identify the land covered under Ex. A-1, demarcate the same and that rest of the land should be taken possession of.
2. It is contended by Shri Sukumaran, counsel for the appellants that the High Court has committed error in directing to take possession of 10 3/10 cents since the appellants had purchased it under the Land Reforms Act and, therefore, the decree to that extent is not correct in law. When we asked Mr T.L.V Iyer, the counsel for the respondent, he stated that they have specifically excluded to the above extent and would pursue the remedy as provided under the Land Reforms Act. In that view, it is not necessary to go into the question as to the extent of 10 3/10 cents of the land. The respondents are, therefore, entitled to recover the balance area admeasuring 13 1/5 cents.
3. It is then contended that the trial court and the appellate court after due consideration of evidence found that the house was existing in the land. The boundary prevails over the extent and that, therefore, the appellants cannot be ejected from the land on which the house was erected. We find no force in the contention. When we pointedly asked the counsel to point out the source for the right, the appellant fell upon Ex. B-8, rent receipt, as source of title. The appellant does not get any legal title based on it since Ex. B-8 is only a rent receipt which does not confer any title. There is no other document evidencing the title of the land on which the building came to be constructed in excess of 3 1/2 cents and the purchase certificate which covers 10 3/10 cents. The appellants cannot have any right more than what was conferred under Ex. A-1 which specifically mentions 3 1/2 cents and the purchase certificate which covers 10 3/10 cents including 3 1/2 cents. Under those circumstances, the decree of the High Court does not warrant interference, except for the exclusion of total area of 10 3/10 cents of land covered by the purchase certificate from the decree.
4. The appeal is dismissed with the above modification. No costs.
Alert