Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ch. Rama Rao v. Lokayukta And Others

Supreme Court Of India
May 9, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government of Andhra Pradesh issued G.O. Ms. No. 62 dated 2-4-1996 allocating funds for expansion works at Osmania General Hospital, Hyderabad, including the erection of two generators. The petitioner, involved in preparing cost estimates, initially projected approximately Rs 15 lakhs per generator; this was later raised to about Rs 21 lakhs. An anonymous complaint alleging irregularities was filed with the Lokayukta under the Andhra Pradesh Lokayukta and Upa-Lokayukta Act, 1983 (“the Act”).

After a preliminary investigation, the Lokayukta issued (i) an interim order dated 29-3-1996 prohibiting the purchase of the generators, and (ii) an interim report dated 6-4-1996 recommending that the Government suspend or transfer the petitioner and take similar action against the Superintendent Engineer.

The petitioner challenged these actions in W.P. Nos. 8274 and 8715 of 1996 before the Andhra Pradesh High Court, also assailing the constitutionality of certain provisions of the Act. On 23-4-1996 the High Court upheld the validity of the Act and declined to interfere with the Lokayukta’s interim report. The present special leave petitions (SLPs) were filed against that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Lokayukta possessed jurisdiction to issue an interim report recommending suspension or transfer of the petitioner despite the existence of a duly appointed Upa-Lokayukta (Section 7 of the Act).
  2. Whether failure to afford the petitioner an opportunity to be heard before submission of the interim report violated Sections 10 and 12 of the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Lokayukta lacked jurisdiction to act because an Upa-Lokayukta had already been appointed and empowered under Section 7(2) of the Act.
  • The procedure adopted was illegal: the petitioner was not given notice or a hearing prior to the interim report, purportedly contravening Sections 10 and 12 of the Act.
  • (At the SLP stage, the petitioner did not press the earlier constitutional challenge to Sections 3, 4, 7 and 12 of the Act.)

Respondent/Government's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents’ legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Jurisdiction of the Lokayukta (Section 7)
The Supreme Court noted that Section 7(3) expressly empowers the Lokayukta to initiate suo motu investigations even in matters otherwise falling within the Upa-Lokayukta’s purview, provided reasons are recorded. Accordingly, the Lokayukta’s assumption of jurisdiction was lawful.

Requirement of Notice or Hearing (Sections 10–12)
The Court distinguished between “preliminary verification” under Section 10(1), which must be conducted confidentially and ex parte, and a “regular investigation,” during which notice and an opportunity to be heard are statutorily mandated. Because the impugned actions occurred at the preliminary stage, the statute implicitly excluded any prior notice. Confidentiality safeguards the investigation from interference or destruction of evidence.

Power to Issue Interim Recommendations
The statutory authority to submit a final report with recommendations necessarily includes, by implication, authority to issue interim recommendations—such as suspension or transfer—designed to facilitate an unimpeded investigation. The Lokayukta therefore acted within his powers when recommending interim administrative action against the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED – The Supreme Court dismissed the special leave petitions, thereby affirming the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s decision and the Lokayukta’s interim measures.

Consequences: the Lokayukta’s interim report remains operative, permitting the State Government to suspend or transfer the petitioner pending further investigation. The ruling clarifies that during preliminary verification under the A.P. Lokayukta Act, the Lokayukta may act without prior notice and may issue interim recommendations; however, no new constitutional precedent was set.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. These special leave petitions arise from the judgment of the Andhra Pradesh High Court made on 23-4-1996 in WPs Nos. 8274 and 8715 of 1996. An order was made by the Government on 2-4-1996 in GOMs No. 62 granting certain amount to the Director of Medical Education for expansion of the works in the Osmania General Hospital, Hyderabad. Two generators were to be erected in the hospital. The petitioner was required to submit the report on the estimates. In furtherance thereof, the petitioner submitted the report to the Superintendent Engineer and tenders were called for. It would appear that several people had submitted their tenders and the initial estimate was of Rs 15 lakhs and odd for one set of the generator. Subsequently, it would appear that the estimate was increased to Rs 21 lakhs per set. In that behalf, an anonymous complaint came to be made before the Lokayukta of A.P constituted under Section 3 of the A.P Lokayukta and Upa-Lokayukta Act, 1983, (Act No. II of 1983) (for short ‘the Act’). After conducting preliminary investigation, the Lokayukta came to submit his interim order dated 29-3-1996 prohibiting purchase of the two sets and also by interim report dated 6-4-1996 directed the Government either to suspend the petitioner or to transfer him and to take similar action on the Superintendent Engineer as well. The petitioner came to challenge the two orders in the above writ petitions. In the writ petitions, the petitioner challenged the constitutionality of Sections 3, 4, 7 and 12 of the Act as ultra vires Articles 14, 16, 19, 21, 226 and 311 of the Constitution of India. He also challenged the validity of the interim report. The High Court dismissed the writ petitions upholding their validity. On the question of interim report, the High Court declined to interfere with it holding that the High Court is devoid of jurisdiction to go into the merits of the interim report. Thus, the petitioner has filed these SLPs.

2. As regards the constitutionality of the above provisions, in fairness, Mr A. Subba Rao, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, had not pressed the same in these SLPs stating that the matters are pending adjudication in another appeal. But he seriously objected to the procedure adopted by the Lokayukta in submitting the report for taking action against the petitioner for suspension of him or to transfer him to any other place. According to the learned counsel, the Lokayukta has no jurisdiction to take action and (sic when) Upa-Lokayukta came to be appointed under the Act. We find no force in the contention.

3. Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 7 give power to Lokayukta and Upa-Lokayukta respectively to investigate into any action concerning persons respectively mentioned therein. Sub-section (3) of Section 7 enables Lokayukta, notwithstanding the power conferred under sub-section (2) thereof on the Upa-Lokayukta to take suo motu action in respect of any action contemplated under the Act. Therefore, the only condition precedent required thereunder is to record reasons for initiating suo motu enquiry divesting the power of the Upa-Lokayukta and taking action under sub-section (3) of Section 7 of the Act. It is next contended that the petitioner has not been given any opportunity before submitting the report to the Government and the action is contrary to Section 10 read with Section 12 of the Act. We find no force in the contention.

4. The Lokayukta is empowered under the Act to conduct such preliminary verification as he deems fit or proposes to conduct any investigation under the Act to find whether the allegation in the complaint prima facie justify for conducting regular investigation. Sub-section (2)(a) of Section 10 postulates that every preliminary verification referred to in sub-section (1) shall be conducted in private and in particular, the identity of the complainant and of the public servant affected by the said preliminary verification shall not be disclosed to the public or the press whether before or during the preliminary verification, but every investigation referred to in sub-section (1) shall be conducted in public. In other words, the statutory provision contemplates that while conducting preliminary verification of the complaint under sub-section (1) of Section 10, the investigation is required to be made in confidentiality and on satisfying from the investigation of the alleged misconduct, etc. he is empowered to take further action under the Act. He is also empowered under Section 11 to collect evidence or have the investigation done as a civil court by operation of sub-section (2) of Section 11 of the Act only when he satisfies that there is evidence to proceed further under Section 10(1)(b). At that stage, he shall afford an opportunity to the aggrieved person to comment on such complaint of the statement and conduct the investigation or enquiry. He is enjoined to give reasonable opportunity to the public servant. After conducting the said enquiry, if he finds that the public servant or the person referred committed misconduct, then he is required to submit the report to the Government as enjoined under Section 12 of the Act. On receipt thereof, under sub-section (3), it shall be lawful for the Government to take action as recommended by the Lokayukta.

5. Considered from the operational conspectus of the above provisions, it would not be necessary to issue any notice or give opportunity to a public servant at preliminary verification or investigation. When the Lokayukta or Upa-Lokayukta, as the case may be, conducts a regular investigation into the complaint, it would be necessary to give prior opportunity to the public servant etc. By implication, such an opportunity stands excluded when preliminary verification or investigation is conducted. The object appears to be that the preliminary investigation or verification is required to be done in confidentiality to get prima facie evidence so that the needed evidence or material may not be got suppressed or destroyed. It is seen from the report submitted by the Lokayukta, that he has prima facie found that there are some allegations against the petitioner. We are not dealing with the nature of the allegations since the matters are yet to be investigated. Suffice it to state that the Lokayukta has power to submit a preliminary report to take further action so as to enable the Lokayukta to conduct further investigation. The power to submit final report with recommendation to take punitive or penal action includes power to submit interim report with recommendation to suspend an officer or to transfer him pending further investigation or the preliminary verification itself. The object of the recommendation is only to enable smooth enquiry or the investigation conducted without being hampered with by the persons concerned or to prevent an opportunity to tamper with the record or to destroy the record. Under these circumstances, we think that the Lokayukta was well justified is not issuing any notice or giving any opportunity to the petitioner at preliminary verification.

6. The special leave petitions are accordingly dismissed.