- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A. Arumugam Chettiyar v. Lokanayakammal (Smt) And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant was inducted into possession of the disputed house as a tenant in 1971. Subsequently, the landlord executed a mortgage of the same house in favour of the appellant by a deed dated 28 April 1977, thereby creating the dual relationship of tenant and mortgagee in respect of the appellant.
The core controversy before the courts below was whether the terms of this mortgage deed brought about an implied surrender of the appellant’s pre-existing tenancy rights. The trial court examined the mortgage deed and held that its terms conclusively established an implied surrender of tenancy, treating the appellant thereafter only as a mortgagee. On this basis, the trial court ordered the appellant’s eviction.
The High Court, applying principles laid down by the Supreme Court in earlier decisions, affirmed the trial court’s view that there was an implied surrender of tenancy and that the appellant’s status was solely that of a mortgagee. The High Court therefore confirmed the direction for eviction. The present opinion is the Supreme Court’s decision in the appellant’s further appeal against these concurrent findings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, on the facts of the case and the terms of the mortgage deed dated 28 April 1977, the mortgage of the house by the landlord in favour of the tenant resulted in an implied surrender of the appellant’s tenancy rights, leaving the appellant only in the capacity of a mortgagee.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shah Mathuradas Maganlal & Co. v. Nagappa Shankarappa Malage, (1976) 3 SCC 660; AIR 1976 SC 1565 | The principles governing when a transaction (such as a mortgage in favour of a tenant) results in an implied surrender of tenancy rights. | Cited as part of the settled law on implied surrender of tenancy, forming the legal basis adopted by the High Court to conclude that the mortgage deed in this case indicated surrender of tenancy. |
| Gambangi Applaswamy Naidu v. Behara Venkataramanayya Patro, (1984) 4 SCC 382; AIR 1984 SC 1728 | The same line of authority on the legal effect of transactions between landlord and tenant, particularly regarding implied surrender of tenancy. | Relied on by the High Court, along with other Supreme Court decisions, to determine that the appellant’s tenancy had been impliedly surrendered by the mortgage transaction. |
| Nand Lal v. Sukh Dev, 1987 Supp SCC 87 | Part of the Supreme Court’s precedents settling the principles on implied surrender of tenancy. | Treated as one of the authoritative decisions underpinning the High Court’s conclusion that the appellant was only a mortgagee after the mortgage deed. |
| Nemi Chand v. Onkar Lal, (1991) 3 SCC 464; AIR 1991 SC 2046 | Further clarification of the legal principles governing implied surrender of tenancy. | Invoked as part of the consistent Supreme Court jurisprudence confirming that, in circumstances such as those present here, the terms of the mortgage can show that the tenancy has been surrendered. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted that the decisive legal principles on the issue—whether a mortgage in favour of a tenant can amount to an implied surrender of tenancy—had already been “authoritatively settled” by it in the cited earlier cases. Accordingly, the Court stated that it was not necessary to re-examine the question in detail in the present appeal.
The Court recorded that both the trial court and the High Court had concurrently found, on examination of the terms of the mortgage deed dated 28 April 1977, that there was an implied surrender of the appellant’s tenancy rights. Based on this finding, the courts below held that the appellant’s status was only that of a mortgagee, and ordered his eviction.
The Supreme Court further noted that the High Court had specifically applied the law as laid down in the earlier Supreme Court judgments (Shah Mathuradas Maganlal & Co., Gambangi Applaswamy Naidu, Nand Lal, and Nemi Chand) to interpret the mortgage transaction in this case. On that basis, the High Court concluded that the deed reflected a surrender of tenancy.
Finding that the conclusions of the courts below were in line with the settled law and that the findings regarding the nature and effect of the mortgage deed were concurrent, the Supreme Court held that there was no ground to interfere with those findings. The appeal was therefore dismissed.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the concurrent findings of the trial court and the High Court that the mortgage deed resulted in an implied surrender of the appellant’s tenancy rights and that the appellant remained only as a mortgagee. The order directing the eviction of the appellant was thereby affirmed. The Court made no order as to costs.
Implications: The decision confirms the application of already settled Supreme Court principles on implied surrender of tenancy where a landlord mortgages the tenanted premises in favour of the tenant, and reinforces the weight accorded to concurrent findings of the courts below. The opinion operates primarily to resolve the dispute between the parties on the basis of existing precedent and does not purport to establish any new legal rule.
Order
1. The appellant was put in possession of the house in dispute as a tenant in the year 1971. The landlord mortgaged the house with the tenant by a deed dated 28-4-1977. The question before the High Court was whether the mortgage deed resulted in an implied surrender of the appellant's right in the house as a tenant. The trial court and the High Court have concurrently found that the terms of the mortgage deed conclusively show that there was implied surrender of the tenant's rights. On the said findings the courts below have directed the eviction of the appellant.
2. It is not necessary for us to go into the question in detail as the principles have been authoritatively settled by this Court in Shah Mathuradas Maganlal & Co. v. Nagappa Shankarappa Malage (1976) 3 SCC 660, AIR 1976 SC 1565, Gambangi Applaswamy Naidu v. Behara Venkataramanayya Patro (1984) 4 SCC 382, AIR 1984 SC 1728, Nand Lal v. Sukh Dev 1987 Supp SCC 87 and in Nemi Chand v. Onkar Lal (1991) 3 SCC 464, AIR 1991 SC 2046. The High Court on the basis of the law laid down by this Court in the above-mentioned judgments has come to the conclusion that the deed of mortgage in the present case indicates that there was surrender of tenancy and the appellant was only a mortgagee. We do not see any ground to interfere with the concurrent findings reached by the courts below.
3. The appeal is dismissed. No costs.
Alert