Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Deepa v. State Of Rajasthan And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 15, 1995
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns agricultural land over which the appellant claims tenancy and khatedari rights. Respondent 5, Ram Chandra (described as Pujari of Idol Shri Charbhujaji), had earlier accepted the appellant as a tenant during proceedings under the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955.

In the first proceeding, the respondent sought eviction of the appellant under Section 177 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act on the ground that the appellant had used the land contrary to the purpose of the lease, thereby becoming liable for ejectment. That suit was dismissed on the ground that the land formed part of a jagir and, because jagirs had been abolished by the Rajasthan Land Reforms and Resumption of Jagirs Act, 1952, the respondent had no locus standi. This decision was made on 30-6-1963 and was confirmed by the Board of Revenue on 19-1-1978.

In 1987, the respondent initiated fresh proceedings by filing an application before the Collector under Section 82 of the Rajasthan Land Revenue Act, 1956, seeking a reference to the Board of Revenue to recommend an entry in the record of rights in favour of Idol Shri Charbhujaji, with the respondent as Pujari. The appellant objected, contending that the matter could not be reopened in view of the earlier proceedings and asserting that he had become a khatedar tenant under the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, so the record of rights could not be altered to show the respondent as khatedar tenant.

The Board of Revenue rejected the plea of res judicata, held that the appellant’s right was not heritable and transferable, and granted the respondent’s prayer. The High Court declined to interfere, noting inter alia that the appellant had filed Khasra Girdawari relating to Samvat 2012 (1957 A.D.), by which time the Rajasthan Tenancy Act had come into force. The appellant then approached the Supreme Court by way of an appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in light of the earlier proceedings in which the respondent had accepted the appellant as a tenant, the respondent could subsequently assert a different status for the appellant and seek correction of the record of rights in his own favour under Section 82 of the Rajasthan Land Revenue Act.
  2. Whether, on the basis of the Khasra Girdawari entries and the provisions of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act (including Chapter III-A) read with the Rajasthan Land Reforms and Resumption of Jagirs Act, the appellant was to be treated as a tenant and, in particular, as a khatedar tenant with heritable and transferable rights.
  3. Whether the revenue records could lawfully be corrected to show the respondent as khatedar tenant instead of the appellant.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The respondent, having previously accepted the appellant as a tenant in the earlier proceeding under Section 177 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, could not now take a contradictory stand and deny the appellant’s tenancy in the present proceeding.
  • The Khasra Girdawari, now on record, showed that by Samvat 2012 (1957 A.D.) the appellant’s name was recorded as cultivator of the land. As the Rajasthan Tenancy Act had come into force by then, the land could not be treated as khudkasht of the jagirdar, rendering Section 10 of the Rajasthan Land Reforms and Resumption of Jagirs Act inapplicable. Consequently, the respondent’s name could not legitimately be entered as khatedar tenant.
  • Under Chapter III-A of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, even a sub-tenant of khudkasht land can become a khatedar tenant upon compliance with the prescribed procedure. The necessary conditions should be deemed satisfied in light of the Khasra Girdawari entries. Once a person becomes a khatedar tenant, Section 9 of the Jagirs Act confers on him heritable and fully transferable rights, contrary to the view taken by the authorities below.
  • Additionally, reliance was placed on Section 13 of the Marwar Tenancy Act, 1949, which provides that the interest of a tenant is heritable though not freely transferable except as permitted by that Act; there was some objection from the respondent’s side regarding the applicability of this provision.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent’s counsel argued that although the Khasra Girdawari showed the land as under the appellant’s cultivation, this was not as a tenant but merely as an employee of the respondent.
  • The respondent also objected to the applicability of Section 13 of the Marwar Tenancy Act, 1949, as invoked by the appellant’s counsel.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by emphasizing that in the earlier proceedings under the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, the respondent himself had accepted the appellant as a tenant. It held that a position inconsistent with that earlier stand could not now be adopted by the respondent in the present proceedings.

The Court then considered the Khasra Girdawari entries for Samvat 2012 (1957 A.D.), which recorded the appellant as the cultivator of the land at a time when the Rajasthan Tenancy Act was already in force. On that basis, the land could not be regarded as khudkasht of the jagirdar. As a result, Section 10 of the Rajasthan Land Reforms and Resumption of Jagirs Act, which would have operated in relation to khudkasht land of a jagirdar, was inapplicable. This meant that the respondent’s name could not properly be recorded as khatedar tenant of the land.

In addressing the respondent’s contention that the appellant cultivated the land merely as an employee, the Court found this stand untenable. It relied on the Board of Revenue’s own judgment in the present proceedings, which recorded that the land had been given to Deepa’s father (connected with the appellant) for cultivation on “Panti Basis,” i.e., on a share basis. The Court treated this as indicative of a tenancy arrangement under which the cultivator paid in kind, not an employment relationship.

The Court further accepted the appellant’s reliance on Chapter III-A of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act. Under that Chapter, even a sub-tenant of khudkasht land can become a khatedar tenant, subject to completion of the requisite procedure. The Court held that, in light of the Khasra Girdawari entries, this procedural requirement must be deemed to have been satisfied, leading to the conclusion that the appellant had become a khatedar tenant.

Once the appellant was recognized as a khatedar tenant, Section 9 of the Jagirs Act made his rights heritable and fully transferable. Thus, the contrary finding of the authorities that the appellant’s rights were not heritable and transferable was rejected as incorrect. The Court stated that even if Section 13 of the Marwar Tenancy Act, 1949, was left out of consideration, the materials and statutory provisions it had examined were sufficient to establish that the appellant was a tenant and, specifically, a khatedar tenant. On this basis, the Court held that the revenue records could not lawfully be corrected to show the respondent as khatedar tenant.

Holding and Implications

The Supreme Court held that the appellant must be recognized as a tenant and, more specifically, as a khatedar tenant of the land in question. It concluded that the revenue records could not properly be altered to show the respondent as khatedar tenant.

The appeal was ALLOWED with costs, and the Court expressly declared the appellant to be the khatedar tenant of the disputed land.

The direct consequence of this decision is that the appellant retains khatedari rights in the land, which are heritable and fully transferable under the applicable statutory provisions, and the respondent cannot have his name entered as khatedar tenant in the revenue records in place of the appellant. The opinion, as provided, does not indicate that the Court intended to lay down any broader precedent beyond resolving the rights of the parties in this particular dispute.

Show all summary ...

B.L Hansaria, J.— The appellant, who was once accepted by Respondent 5 Ram Chandra (hereinafter the respondent) as a tenant when proceeding under Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955 (Tenancy Act) was initiated against him, has lost that right when the respondent agitated the matter again under Section 82 of the Rajasthan Land Revenue Act, 1956. Shortly put, this is the grievance of the appellant, and the same is well founded as it would appear from what is being stated later.

2. In the first proceeding, the respondent had sought eviction of the appellant by invoking Section 177 of the Tenancy Act on the ground that the latter had become liable for ejectment because of using the land contrary to the purpose for which it was leased. The respondent lost that suit on the ground that the land being part of jagir, he had no locus standi to file the suit, as jagir stood abolished by the force of the Rajasthan Land Reforms and Resumption of Jagirs Act, 1952 (Jagir Act). That order was passed on 30-6-1963 and was confirmed even by the Board of Revenue on 19-1-1978.

3. In 1987 the respondent filed an application before the Collector under Section 82 of the Rajasthan Land Revenue Act for making a reference to the Board of Revenue to recommend making of entry in the record of rights relating to the self-same land in favour of Idol Shri Charbhujaji — the respondent being its Pujari. The appellant contended, inter alia, that the matter could not be reopened in view of the earlier proceeding and, in any case, he having become a khatedar tenant under provisions of the Tenancy Act, the record of rights could not be corrected to show the respondent as a khatedar tenant. The Board of Revenue did not accept the plea of res judicata and having taken a view that the appellant's right was not heritable and transferable, granted prayer of the respondent. On the High Court being approached by the appellant, he did not get any relief, inter alia, because he had filed Khasra Girdawari relating to Samvat 2012 (1957 A.D) by which year Tenancy Act had come into force. Hence this appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution.

4. Shri Sharma, appearing for the appellant, contended, and rightly, that respondent himself having accepted the appellant as tenant in the first proceeding, a stand different from that could not be taken in the present proceeding. He then urged that Khasra Girdawari, which has now been put on record, clearly shows that the name of the appellant had been recorded as cultivator by Samvat 2012, because of which the land could not be regarded as khudkasht of the jagirdar which would make Section 10 of the Jagirs Act inoperative, and so, the respondent's name could not be recorded as khatedar tenant. As to this submission, the learned counsel for this respondent submitted that though the land was shown in the Khasra Girdawari under appellant's cultivation, that was not as a tenant but as an employee of the respondent. This stand is untenable because from the impugned judgment of the Board of Revenue in the present proceeding it appears that the case of this respondent was that Deepa's father had been given the land for cultivation on “Panti Basis”, that is, on share basis, which would clearly show that the land was tenanted to Deepa's father and in lieu of cash he was to pay in kind.

5. Shri Sharma's further contention is that the view taken by the authorities is not correct also because of the provisions in Chapter III-A of the Tenancy Act, under which even a sub-tenant of khudkasht land becomes a khatedar tenant on the required procedure being followed, which must be deemed to have been satisfied because of what has been recorded in the Khasra Girdawari. Now, if a person becomes a khatedar tenant, then by the force of Section 9 of the Jagirs Act, his right becomes heritable and fully transferable; and so, the contrary view taken by the authorities is not correct. Still another weapon in the armoury of Shri Sharma is that under Section 13 of the Marwar Tenancy Act, 1949, (regarding the applicability of which Shri Medh has some objection) the interest of a tenant is heritable but is not transferable otherwise than in accordance with the provisions of that Act.

6. We are satisfied (even if what has been stated in Section 13 of the Marwar Tenancy Act is kept out of consideration) that it is the appellant who has to be accepted as a tenant and a khatedar tenant at that; and so, the revenue records could not have been corrected to show the respondent as the khatedar tenant.

7. The appeal is, therefore, allowed with cost by declaring the appellant as the khatedar tenant of the land in question.