Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of M.P And Others v. Raghuveer Singh Yadav And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 8, 1994
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Madhya Pradesh issued an advertisement on 27-07-1987 to fill the posts of Inspectors in the Department of Weights and Measures. The advertisement required a degree in Arts, Commerce, Science or Engineering, or a Diploma in Engineering. Written examinations were conducted and results declared on 26-08-1989, after which interview cards were dispatched to successful candidates.

Before the recruitment process was completed, the Government, in consultation with the Government of India and the Public Service Commission, amended the eligibility requirements through the M.P. Standard of Weights and Measurement (Enforcement) Rules, 1989. The amendment limited eligibility to candidates holding (i) a Science degree with Physics, (ii) a Degree in Engineering or Technology, or (iii) a Diploma in Engineering.

Candidates who had qualified under the original advertisement (respondents) filed OA No. 2484 of 1989 before the M.P. Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur, contending that the amended rules could not be applied retrospectively. By order dated 12-10-1993, the Tribunal accepted their plea and directed the State (appellant) to complete the selection on the basis of the original qualifications. The State appealed to the Supreme Court, resulting in the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government could withdraw the original recruitment notification and issue a fresh one based on the amended statutory rules prescribing new educational qualifications.
  2. Whether candidates who had cleared the written examination under the unamended rules had an accrued or vested right to be considered for appointment on the basis of those rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • The recruitment process had already commenced under the original advertisement, conferring a right to be considered on the basis of the then-existing qualifications.
  • The 1989 amendment introducing a B.Sc. (Physics) requirement should not operate retrospectively to disqualify candidates who were otherwise eligible when they applied.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka, (1990) 1 SCC 411 An additional qualification imposed after initiation of recruitment cannot retrospectively govern an ongoing selection. The Court distinguished the case, holding that Mahendran involved additional qualifications during an existing recruitment, whereas here the State withdrew the earlier notification and intended a fresh recruitment under changed rules.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the amended rules were statutory and validly framed; the State possesses the authority to prescribe or alter qualifications for public employment. Because the Government decided to withdraw the earlier notification and initiate a fresh recruitment, no candidate could claim a vested right to appointment. At most, the respondents had a “legitimate expectation” to be considered, which does not override statutory changes.

The Court emphasized that the amended rules would operate prospectively, meaning they govern any future recruitment. As the State chose to start the process anew, the respondents’ claim based on the prior advertisement lapsed. The precedent in P. Mahendran was deemed inapplicable, as that decision concerned additional qualifications imposed mid-process without withdrawing the original notification.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED. The Tribunal’s order was set aside.

The State Government is directed to issue a fresh recruitment notification within six weeks in accordance with the amended rules. No costs were awarded. The decision affirms the State’s discretion to withdraw an incomplete recruitment process and restart it under newly enacted qualifications, without conferring vested rights on candidates from the earlier process.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Delay condoned.

2. Leave granted.

3. This appeal arises from the order of the M.P Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur in OA No. 2484 of 1989 dated 12-10-1993 directing the appellant to proceed with the selection of the candidates without taking into account the amendment made to the rules, introducing the B.Sc as a qualification for consideration of the applications of candidates. The facts lie in a short compass.

4. For recruitment to the posts of Inspectors, Department of Weights and Measures in the State of M.P, an advertisement was issued on 27-7-1987 calling for applications from eligible candidates. The qualification prescribed for eligibility was degree in Arts or Commerce or Science or Engineering or Diploma in Engineering. It would appear that written examinations were held and results were declared on 26-8-1989. Thereafter, the Board issued interview cards to the successful candidates. In the meanwhile, the Government amended the rules by M.P Standard of Weights and Measurement (Enforcement) Rules, 1989 in consultation with Government of India and Public Service Commission and altered the eligibility qualification for appointment to those posts by presenting degree in Science with Physics as a subject or Degree in Engineering or Technology or Diploma in Engineering. The respondents challenged the amended rules on the ground that having issued the notification for filling up the posts of Inspectors with Degree of Arts and Commerce the State had to proceed with the recruitment only as per the qualification prescribed in the notification and the subsequent amendment to the rules should not stand in the way of the Recruitment Board to consider the claims on the basis of marks secured in the examination and also interview to be held. In other words the amended rules have no retrospective operation. This contention found favour with the Tribunal and accordingly the Tribunal allowed the application.

5. It is not in dispute that Statutory Rules have been made introducing Degree in Science or Engineering or Diploma in Technology as qualifications for recruitment to the posts of Inspector of Weights and Measures. It is settled law that the State has got power to prescribe qualifications for recruitment. Here is a case that pursuant to amended Rules, the Government has withdrawn the earlier notification and wants to proceed with the recruitment afresh. It is not a case of any accrued right. The candidates who had appeared for the examination and passed the written examination had only legitimate expectation to be considered of their claims according to the rules then in vogue. The amended Rules have only prospective operation. The Government is entitled to conduct selection in accordance with the changed rules and make final recruitment. Obviously no candidate acquired any vested right against the State. Therefore, the State is entitled to withdraw the notification by which it had previously notified recruitment and to issue fresh notification in that regard on the basis of the amended Rules.

6. The ratio in P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka (1990) 1 SCC 411, (1990) 12 ATC 727, AIR 1990 SC 405 has no application to the facts in this case. In that case, for the posts of Motor Vehicles Inspector, apart from the qualifications prescribed, they issued additional qualifications and selection was sought to be made on the basis of additional qualifications. It was held that since recruitment was sought to be made on the basis of the qualifications prescribed, the additional qualifications prescribed thereafter have no retrospective effect to the recruitment already set in motion. Under those circumstances, additional qualifications were directed not to be taken into account for considering the claims of the candidates on the basis of the original advertisement. The ratio therein is clearly inapplicable to the facts in this case.

7. The appeal is accordingly allowed but in the circumstances without costs. The State is directed to issue fresh notification within a period of six weeks from the date of the receipt of this order for recruitment in accordance with the amended Rules.