Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ganga Dass Alias Godha v. State Of Haryana .

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 2, 1993
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (original Accused No. 1) was tried along with three others for offences under Sections 302 and 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The Trial Court acquitted the other three accused but convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC (simpliciter). The appellant appealed against his conviction, and the State appealed against the acquittal of the other three accused; both appeals were dismissed by the High Court. Special leave was granted.

The deceased, Umed Singh (about 65 years old), was attacked at around 7:45 a.m. on 18 November 1988 at a Mandir while worshipping. His son, Dharampal (PW 6), reached the Mandir and found his brothers present. The deceased, then injured, told PW 6 that the appellant hit him with an iron pipe while he was worshipping. Other eyewitnesses (PWs 12 and 13) also informed PW 6 about the occurrence. PW 6 informed the police; the injured was taken to a Primary Health Centre (examined by PW 11) and then shifted to PGI, Chandigarh. A neurosurgeon (PW 15) operated on 20 November 1988. The deceased died on 5 December 1988, stated to be as a result of head injury leading to septicaemia, renal failure, respiratory failure, and finally cardio-respiratory arrest. An altered FIR was issued and a charge-sheet was filed after investigation.

The accused denied the offence and led some evidence to show enmity. Both courts below accepted the eyewitness evidence and held the appellant responsible for inflicting the blow.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the prosecution version as accepted by the courts below, the appellant’s act attracted liability for murder under Section 302 IPC, or whether the appropriate conviction was for culpable homicide not amounting to murder (Section 304 Part II IPC).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Even if the entire prosecution case is accepted, an offence punishable under Section 302 IPC is not made out.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court accepted the appellant’s submission that the facts did not sustain a conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC. The Court focused on the circumstances surrounding the assault and the causal sequence leading to death:

  • The incident occurred on 18 November 1988, while the deceased died 18 days later on 5 December 1988, with death attributed to septicaemia and other complications.
  • The medical evidence showed only one head injury, caused by a single blow with an iron pipe, and not by a sharp-edged weapon.
  • On these circumstances, the Court found it difficult to conclude that the appellant intended to cause death, or that he intended to cause that particular injury.
  • The medical record indicated that the injured was operated upon, but complications arose and the deceased ultimately died due to cardiac failure and related consequences.

In view of these factors, the Court held that the conviction for murder was unsustainable and that the offence fell within Section 304 Part II IPC.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED: The Court set aside the appellant’s conviction under Section 302 IPC and the life sentence imposed thereunder, and instead convicted the appellant under Section 304 Part II IPC, sentencing him to six years’ rigorous imprisonment.

The fine of Rs 2000 (with the default clause) was confirmed. The direct consequence is that the appellant’s criminal liability was reduced from murder to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Part II, with a corresponding reduction in imprisonment from life to six years. The opinion does not indicate any broader precedential implications beyond this case.

Show all summary ...

K. Jayachandra Reddy, J.— Special leave granted.

2. The appellant, who figured as original accused 1, was tried along with three others under Sections 302 and 302/34 IPC. The trial Judge acquitted the other three accused but convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC simpliciter. The convicted accused namely the appellant filed an appeal challenging his conviction and the State also filed an appeal against the acquittal of the other three accused. Both the appeals were dismissed by the High Court.

3. One Umed Singh, aged about 65 years, is the deceased in the case. On November 18, 1988 he had gone to Mandir to worship where at about 7.45 a.m he was attacked. His son Dharampal, PW 6 reached the Mandir and he also found his brothers there at the Mandir. By then the deceased was injured and on being enquired the deceased told PW 6 that the appellant hit him with an iron pipe while he was worshipping. The other eyewitnesses PWs 12 and 13 also informed PW 6 about the occurrence. Thereupon PW 6 went and informed the police. The injured was removed to the hospital and was examined by PW 11, a Doctor at the Primary Health Centre. Thereafter the injured was shifted to P.G.I, Chandigarh. PW 15, a Neuro-Surgeon at P.G.I, Chandigarh carried out an operation on November 20, 1988 on the injured deceased. However, he died on December 5, 1988 as a result of head injury due to septicaemia, renal failure, respiratory failure and finally cardio-respiratory arrest. An altered FIR was issued and the charge-sheet was laid after due investigation.

4. The accused denied the offence and gave some evidence to show that there was some enmity. Both the courts below having believed the evidence of the eyewitnesses convicted the appellant who was responsible for inflicting the blow on the deceased.

5. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that even if the entire prosecution case is to be accepted, an offence punishable under Section 302 IPC is not made out.

6. We find considerable force in this submission. As stated above the occurrence took place on November 18, 1988 and the deceased died 18 days later on December 5, 1988 due to septicaemia and other complications. The Doctor found only one injury on the head and that was due to single blow inflicted with an iron pipe not with any sharp-edged weapon. Having regard to the circumstances of the case, it is difficult to hold that the appellant intended to cause death nor it can be said that he intended to cause that particular injury. In any event the medical evidence shows that the injured deceased was operated but unfortunately some complications set in and ultimately he died because of cardiac failure etc. Under these circumstances, we set aside the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 IPC and the sentence of imprisonment for life awarded thereunder. Instead we convict him under Section 304 Part II IPC and sentence him to undergo six years' RI. The sentence of fine of Rs 2000 along with default clause is confirmed. Accordingly the appeal is partly allowed.