Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S. Ashok Kumar And Others v. State Of T.N And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 17, 1993
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants were appointed through direct recruitment to substantive vacancies in the permanent cadre of District and Sessions Judge, Grade II, Tamil Nadu State Higher Judicial Service. They assumed charge on 16 November 1987 and were placed on probation. Although the relevant rules prescribe a probationary period of 14 months, their services were not confirmed. Seeking a declaration of successful completion of probation and confirmation in the substantive posts, they filed Writ Petition No. 356 of 1990 before the High Court. The High Court dismissed the petition on 10 September 1991, holding that confirmation could not be ordered until inter se seniority between the direct recruits (appellants) and promotee District and Sessions Judges (respondents) was settled. The present appeal was filed by special leave against that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants, as direct recruits, were entitled to automatic confirmation to the substantive posts of District and Sessions Judge, Grade II, upon completion of their probation.
  2. Whether, upon such confirmation, they were entitled to seniority over promotee District and Sessions Judges notwithstanding the earlier dates on which the promotees had started officiating.
  3. How Rules 2(b) and 7(b) of the Tamil Nadu State Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1982, should be interpreted for determining the quota (if any) for direct recruits and the method for fixing inter se seniority.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The High Court erred in refusing to declare that the appellants had completed probation and were entitled to confirmation.
  • Government records showed that specific vacancies (serial numbers 28–33 in the seniority list) had been kept blank, indicating reservation of those posts for direct recruits like the appellants.
  • Once appointed substantively, direct recruits should rank senior to officiating promotees, regardless of the earlier dates on which the promotees had begun officiating.
  • The appellants therefore should be placed in the reserved vacancies and accorded seniority from the date of their appointment.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by analysing Rule 2(b) of the 1982 Rules, noting that it provides two sources of recruitment—promotion (by transfer) and direct recruitment—but merely stipulates that “not more than ten posts shall be filled or reserved to be filled by direct recruitment.” The Court emphasised that the rule does not prescribe a percentage quota linked to the total cadre strength; it only limits the absolute number of direct recruits to ten at any given time. Consequently, the appellants could not claim a one-third share of posts or automatic seniority over promotees.

Turning to seniority, the Court applied Rule 7(b), which fixes seniority for District and Sessions Judges, Grade II, by “the date from which he was continuously on duty” in that grade. Under the proviso to Rule 7(b), seniority of promotees is to be fixed by the Government on the High Court’s recommendation. Accordingly, both direct recruits and promotees must be ranked according to their respective dates of continuous officiation, not by the mere fact of substantive appointment or reservation of vacancies.

While the appellants had indeed completed their probation, the Court rejected the argument that confirmation alone would determine seniority in their favour. Instead, it directed that confirmation be declared and seniority be recomputed strictly in terms of Rule 7(b), thereby ensuring parity of treatment between the two streams of recruitment.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF – The Supreme Court directed the High Court to: (a) declare completion of the appellants’ probation; and (b) recommend to the Government fixation of inter se seniority between the appellants and the promotee respondents in accordance with Rule 7(b) within four months of receiving the judgment.

Implications: The decision clarifies that Rule 2(b) imposes only a numerical ceiling—not a proportional quota—for direct recruitment, and that seniority for District and Sessions Judges, Grade II, hinges on the actual date of continuous officiation as mandated by Rule 7(b). The ruling affects only the parties’ seniority positions and does not establish a new precedent beyond interpreting these specific rules.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted.

2. Heard the learned counsel on either side. The appellants are direct recruits to the substantive vacancies in the permanent cadre of District and Sessions Judge Grade II of Tamil Nadu State Higher Judicial Service. The appointment to the post in category 2 shall be made by the Governor either by recruitment by transfer from the category of Subordinate Judges in Tamil Nadu State Judicial Service or by direct recruitment, “[p]rovided that not more than ten posts shall be filled or reserved to be filled by direct recruitment”. On the appellants' recruitment by the High Court and appointment by the Governor, they started discharging their duties as District and Sessions Judges from November 16, 1987 and they were put on probation with effect from that date. Though they have admittedly completed 14 months of probation as prescribed under the rule, their services were not confirmed. They, therefore, filed a writ petition in the High Court seeking direction for declaration of the completion of their probation and confirmation to the substantive posts. Yet the High Court held that unless inter se seniority is determined between them and the contesting respondents, the Subordinate Judges promoted as District and Sessions Judges, Grade II from the cadre of the T.N Judicial Service, the writ cannot be issued. So the High Court dismissed the writ petition. Thus this appeal by special leave from the judgment in Writ Petition No. 356 of 1990, dated September 10, 1991.

3. Shri Parasaran, the learned senior counsel for the appellants has contended that the High Court has committed serious error in not giving the direction for the appellants' confirmation to the substantive posts; inter se seniority between the appellants and the contesting respondents would flow from that direction. He contended that the State Government had fixed 31 posts of District and Sessions Judges out of which 18 are for the District and Sessions Judges, Grade I and 11 posts are for District and Sessions Judges, Grade II. In the seniority list published by the Government of the cadre of District and Sessions Judges, Grade II placement of 28 to 33 have been kept blank which meant that they are reserved for the appellants. The High Court admitted of their appointment to substantive vacancies and successful completion of their probation. Irrespective of the fact that the contesting respondents were promoted earlier in point of time, the appellants are entitled to be fixed in the vacancies kept reserved for them in the placement of Nos. 28 to 33. In that regard, he contended that once the appellants have been appointed substantively by direct recruitment, they should rank senior to the officiating promotees and therefore the High Court has committed serious illegality in not giving the direction in that behalf. Having given our anxious consideration to the contention raised, we find that on the basis of the rule position, it is difficult to accept the contention. The language couched in Rule 2(b) of the T.N State Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1982 would make the matter clear that appointment to category 2 of the District and Sessions Judges is from two sources, namely, recruitment by transfer from the category of Subordinate Judges in Tamil Nadu State Judicial Service or by direct recruitment. While making a recruitment, the proviso limits its operation that out of the cadre not more than 10 posts shall be filled or shall be reserved to be filled by the direct recruits. It does not indicate that this is meant to be up to a maximum of 1/3rd posts of the cadre. Had the percentage of the posts been linked with the total cadre strength, certainly the direct recruits are entitled to occupy 1/3rd of the posts from the date of their officiation and get seniority from the date of their appointment, subject to successful completion of probation irrespective of the fact whether the promotees have been continuously officiating as District and Sessions Judges prior to the appointment of the appellant in excess of their quota. Their earlier promotion and continuous officiation would not enure to their advantage and they will be pushed down, giving place to the direct recruits within the quota reserved for them. Unfortunately, Rule 2(b) does not prescribe any quota. It would mean that at no point of time the direct recruits would exceed 10 in number. Undoubtedly the object of direct recruitment is to infuse young blood into service to accelerate efficiency and members of the bar opt for selection by direct recruitment with an object to get elevation as High Court Judges. To achieve the purpose the language of the rule should be different.

4. To find the placement of the appellants as District and Sessions Judges, Grade II, Rule 7(b) to be applied for fixing the inter se seniority of the appellants and promotees from the respective dates from which direct recruits and the promotees have been continuously officiating in the posts of District and Sessions Judges, Grade II. Rule 7(b) says that:

“The seniority of person appointed to the post of District and Sessions Judge, Second Grade shall be determined by the date from which he was continuously on duty in the category of District and Sessions Judge, Second Grade:
Provided that the seniority of a person appointed to the post of District and Sessions Judge, Second Grade, by recruitment by transfer from the Tamil Nadu State Judicial Service, shall be fixed by the Government on the recommendation of the High Court.”

As per Rule 7(b) the point of time i.e the date from which the direct recruit as well as promotee District and Sessions Judges are continuously officiating is relevant and material.

5. The High Court is requested to recommend to the Government to fix inter se seniority after declaring completion of the probation of the appellants. Inter se seniority shall be determined in terms of Rule 7(b) of the Special Rules within a period of four months from the date of the receipt of this judgment.

6. The appeal is accordingly disposed of. No costs.