- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pularu v. State Of M.P .
Factual and Procedural Background
The case arises out of the killing of Suddhu Kurmi on the night of November 22, 1978 in village Bhathlokala. According to the prosecution, the appellant and seven co-accused, armed with tabbals and lathis, assaulted the deceased while he was walking from his new house to his old house. The appellant allegedly struck the first and fatal blow on the victim’s head. Three eyewitnesses (PWs 1, 3 and 5) testified in support of the prosecution.
The trial court acquitted all eight accused, reasoning that the incident occurred at approximately 7 p.m., when darkness would have made identification unreliable. The State appealed. The High Court affirmed the acquittal of A-2 to A-8 but reversed as to the present appellant, convicting him under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and sentencing him to life imprisonment. The appellant then filed the present appeal before the Supreme Court under the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the eyewitness identification of the appellant at approximately 7 p.m. was reliable enough to sustain a conviction despite the trial court’s finding that it was too dark for proper identification.
- Whether the appellant’s act of delivering a single blow with an agricultural implement constituted murder punishable under Section 302 IPC, or culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part II IPC.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The trial court correctly concluded that darkness at 7 p.m. rendered identification impossible; therefore, reliance on the testimony of PWs 1, 3 and 5 was unsafe.
- The same eyewitness evidence had been rejected for seven co-accused; it was inconsistent and should not selectively be used to convict the appellant.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court re-examined the evidence of PWs 1, 3 and 5. It held that the mere fact that the incident occurred at 7 p.m. did not preclude reliable identification because:
- The assault took place in the open, offering sufficient visibility.
- The eyewitnesses were villagers who knew the appellant well, enhancing their capacity to recognize him.
- All three witnesses consistently stated that the appellant delivered the first blow, affording them a clear view of him at a critical moment.
- Medical evidence corroborated their account, showing a single incised head wound consistent with a blow from a tabbal.
However, on the question of intent, the Court noted:
- The appellant, an agriculturist, was armed with an agricultural implement, not a weapon inherently deadly.
- He inflicted only one blow; there was no repeat assault by him personally.
- Given the surrounding circumstances, it was difficult to conclude that he intended either to kill or to cause the specific injury that resulted in death.
Accordingly, the Court ruled that the case did not fall within clauses “firstly” or “thirdly” of Section 300 IPC. The conduct amounted to culpable homicide not amounting to murder, attracting Section 304 Part II IPC.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The conviction under Section 302 IPC and the life sentence are set aside. The appellant is instead convicted under Section 304 Part II IPC and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for seven years. The appeal is partly allowed.
Implications: The decision reduces the appellant’s liability from murder to culpable homicide, shortening his sentence from life imprisonment to seven years. The ruling turns on factual assessment of intent and does not announce a new legal principle, but it underscores that a single blow with a non-inherently-deadly implement may, depending on intent and circumstances, attract Section 304 Part II rather than Section 302 IPC.
Order
1. This appeal is filed under the provisions of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act for offences punishable under Sections 148, 302, 302 r/w 149 IPC. The trial court acquitted all the accused. The State preferred an appeal. The High Court acquitted A-2 to A-8 but convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to undergo imprisonment for life.
2. The prosecution case is as follows:
The deceased, Suddhu Kurmi and all the accused and material witnesses PWs 1, 3 and 5 belong to village Bhathlokala. The deceased had two houses one old and the other new. The houses of the accused were located quite closely. The further case of the prosecution is that there was some misunderstanding between the deceased's and the accused's families and on November 22, 1978 at about 7 p.m the deceased was going from his new house to old house and when he covered a distance of five paces the accused came there armed with tabbals and lathis. The appellant before us who was armed with a tabbal opened the attack and hit the deceased with the tabbal on his head. Thereafter it is alleged that the other accused surrounded and assaulted the deceased. The occurrence was witnessed by PWs 1, 3 and 5 who were also related to each other. The deceased died and the report was given by PW 1 at police station Lormi on the next day. The doctor PW 9 who conducted the post-mortem found only two external injuries: one was an incised wound 8″ × 1″ on the head which resulted in the fracture of skull bones and the other injury was only a lacerated wound. The investigation was completed and the charge-sheet was laid. The accused were arrested and at their instance some weapons like tabbals and lathis were recovered.
3. The prosecution mainly relied on the evidence of PWs 1, 3 and 5 who are direct witnesses and the medical evidence. Before the trial court it was urged that the occurrence time was 7.20 p.m and it was highly impossible for anybody to identify the assailants, as has been spoken by PWs 1, 3 and 5. The trial court looked into the almanac and came to the conclusion that at 7 p.m it must have been dark and, therefore, it would not have been possible for the witnesses to identify the assailants. Mainly in that view of the trial court acquitted all the accused.
4. In the appeal the High Court considered the evidence of PWs 1, 3 and 5 and held that they are the residents of the same village to whom the accused was well-known and held that their evidence to the extent that the appellant was the first to open the attack and inflicted the fatal injury could be relied upon and, therefore, he could be convicted under Section 302 IPC.
5. In this appeal Shri S.S Khanduja, learned counsel for the appellant submits that the trial court has rightly held that it was dark and when the witnesses have implicated as many as eight accused and when their evidence was rejected in respect of seven of them it could be highly unsafe to convict the appellant on the same evidence.
6. We have examined the evidence of PWs 1, 3 and 5 direct witnesses. Merely because it was 7 p.m, it cannot be said that they could not have been able to identify the assailants when the occurrence took place in the open air. That apart all the three eyewitnesses have consistently deposed that it was the appellant who first came forward and attacked the deceased. Therefore, that provided a clear opportunity for the three eyewitnesses to have identified the appellant. The medical evidence to that extent corroborates the evidence of three eyewitnesses. Therefore, the High Court, in our view, was right in holding that the appellant dealt a single blow on the head which unfortunately resulted in the fracture of the bones.
7. That takes us to the nature of the offence. All the three eyewitnesses have spoken that the appellant dealt only one blow with the agricultural implement. Having regard to the time and the surrounding circumstances it is difficult to hold that he intended to cause the death of the deceased particularly, when he was not armed with any deadly weapon as such. As an agriculturist he must have been having a tabbal in his hands and if in those circumstances he dealt a single blow it is difficult to convict him by invoking clause 1stly or 3rdly of Section 300 IPC. It cannot be said that he intended to cause that particular injury which unfortunately resulted in the fracture of bones. Therefore, the offence committed by him would be one amounting to culpable homicide punishable under Section 304 Part II IPC. We accordingly set aside the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 IPC and sentence of imprisonment for life awarded thereunder. Instead we convict him under Section 304 Part II IPC and sentence him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for seven years. The appeal is partly allowed to the extent indicated hereinabove.
Alert