- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sri Niwas v. Ram Bharosey
Factual and Procedural Background
The case arises from an incident at about 10:00 a.m. on 29-5-1978 in which the deceased, Jagdish Sharan, was allegedly attacked. According to the prosecution, Respondent 1 (Ram Bharosey) stabbed the deceased with a knife while Respondents 2 and 3 held the deceased, and thereafter Respondents 2 and 3, each armed with a country-made revolver, fired at the deceased. The eyewitnesses (PWs 1 to 4) — comprising the deceased’s son (PW 1), brother-in-law (PW 2), cousin (PW 3), and a neighbor (PW 4) — stated they heard a distress cry near a temple, rushed to the spot, and saw Respondents 2 and 3 coming out of the temple and firing a shot as the witnesses attempted to apprehend them.
PW 1 lodged a complaint after the accused fled. The investigation by PWs 6 and 7 included examination of eyewitnesses, preparation of a scene sketch, and recovery of pellets and two wads; a charge-sheet was filed against all three respondents. The trial court, accepting the testimony of PWs 1 to 4, convicted the respondents under Sections 302/34 IPC and sentenced each to life imprisonment (they had initially been put on trial under Sections 304/34 IPC). The respondents appealed to the High Court of Allahabad, while PW 1 filed Criminal Revision No. 625 of 1979 seeking enhancement of sentence to the death penalty.
The High Court, finding inconsistencies between the eyewitness accounts and the medical/ballistic evidence, allowed the respondents’ appeals and acquitted them, granting the benefit of doubt. It also dismissed the complainant’s revision for enhancement of sentence. The present appeal was filed by the complainant (PW 1) challenging the High Court’s acquittal and the dismissal of his revision. The State did not appeal against the acquittal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court correctly acquitted the respondents by granting the benefit of doubt due to irreconcilable conflict between the prosecution’s ocular testimony and the medical/ballistic evidence.
- Whether there existed justifiable and compelling reasons for the appellate court to interfere with the High Court’s order of acquittal, particularly in an appeal filed by the complainant when the State had not appealed.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court closely examined the medical evidence of PW 5, who conducted the autopsy and documented 16 injuries: multiple incised wounds (Injuries 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8), abrasions (Injuries 9, 10, and 11), a single stab wound (Injury 3), and gunshot wounds (Injuries 12 to 16). Notably, Injuries 1 and 2 had completely severed critical structures in the neck — the trachea, oesophagus, and the jugular and carotid vessels and associated nerves — reflecting extremely severe cutting trauma.
The nature and location of the injuries (most, including Injuries 3 and 8, being above the neck) led the court to observe that a “very formidable cutting instrument,” rather than a knife alone, was implicated. The High Court had summoned and examined the medical officer and a ballistic expert, whose opinions were not consistent with the prosecution’s eyewitness version and indicated the injuries could not have been caused in the manner narrated by those witnesses.
On this basis, the court concluded that the oral testimony was irreconcilably in conflict with the medical evidence and that the prosecution had not presented the true picture of the occurrence without suppression. This justified the High Court’s extension of the benefit of doubt to the respondents and the consequent acquittal. The court emphasized that the State had not appealed the acquittal and found no justifiable or compelling reason to interfere with the High Court’s order.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED.
The appellate court upheld the High Court’s acquittal of all three respondents and dismissed the complainant’s challenge. It also ordered that the bail bonds be discharged. The direct consequence is that the respondents remain acquitted, and the dismissal of the complainant’s bid for sentence enhancement stands. The opinion establishes no new precedent and focuses on the case-specific determination that medical and expert evidence contradicted the prosecution’s ocular version, warranting the benefit of doubt.
1. This appeal is preferred by the appellant on being aggrieved by the judgment of the High Court of Allahabad allowing Criminal Appeals Nos. 895, 978 and 979 of 1979 filed by Respondents 1 to 3 challenging their convictions recorded by the trial court and also against the order of dismissal dismissing Criminal Revision No. 625 of 1979 filed by the appellant before the High Court for enhancement of sentence, namely, praying for imposition of extreme penalty of law i.e death sentence to all the three respondents.
2. All the three respondents were put on trial before the trial court to answer a charge under Sections 304/34 IPC on the allegations that they in furtherance of their common intention caused the death of the deceased, Jagdish Sharan at about 10.00 a.m on 29-5-1978. According to the prosecution, the deceased was attacked with a knife by the first respondent, Ram Bharosey while the deceased was being held firmly by the second and third respondents. After the first respondent inflicted a number of injuries on the person of the deceased, the second and third respondents each armed with country-made revolver shot at the deceased. After causing a number of injuries to the deceased, they all took to their heels.
3. The occurrence is stated to have been witnessed by PWs 1, 2, 3 and 4 of whom PW 1 is the son of the deceased, PW 2 is the brother-in-law of the deceased, PW 3 is the cousin and PW 4 is a neighbour. According to these witnesses, while they were sitting in the house of the deceased, they heard a distress cry near the temple where this occurrence took place. They all rushed to the spot. At that time the second and the third respondents were coming out of the temple. On seeing them, they fired a shot. Though the witnesses attempted to secure them, they could not do so.
4. After the accused had escaped, PW 1 went to the police station and lodged the complaint. The case was investigated by PWs 6 and 7. During the course of the investigation, they examined the eyewitnesses, drew a sketch of the scene of the occurrence, recovered some pellets and two wads from the scene and after completing the investigation, they filed charge-sheet against all the three respondents.
5. The trial court accepted the testimony of PWs 1 to 4, convicted all the three respondents under Sections 302/34 IPC and sentenced each of them to undergo imprisonment for life. All the three respondents filed separate appeals before the High Court. As we have already pointed out that the appellant, namely, PW 1 filed a criminal revision before the High Court for enhancement of sentence. The High Court not accepting the testimony of PWs 1 to 4 in view of the inconsistencies with medical evidence allowed the appeal and acquitted all the respondents giving the benefit of doubt to them. Consequently, the High Court dismissed the revision also.
6. We have perused the medical evidence of PW 5 who conducted autopsy on the dead body of the deceased. The medical officer has found as many as 16 injuries of which Injuries 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 were all incised wounds. Injuries 9, 10 and 11 were abrasions. There was only one stab wound, namely, Injury 3. Injuries 12 to 16 were gunshot wounds. With reference to Injuries 1 and 2, the medical officer has stated in the post-mortem certificate itself that these two injuries, namely, Injuries 1 and 2 had completely cut the trachea, oesophagus at its level and nerves and vessels of left side neck as well as the jugular and carotid blood vessels and nerves parallel to them.
7. Most of the injuries, namely, Injuries 3 and 8 were all above the neck. The nature of the injuries indicates that these injuries could have been caused by a very formidable cutting instrument and not by a knife. The High Court in fact summoned the medical officer and the ballistic expert and examined them who also gave their opinion not consistent with the evidence of the ocular witnesses of the prosecution but stated that these injuries could not have been caused in the manner as spoken to by the prosecution witnesses.
8. We are also of the view that the oral testimony of the witnesses is irreconcilably in conflict with the medical evidence. At any rate, the prosecution has not placed the true picture of the occurrence before the Court without suppressing any part of it. Evidently, this has warranted the High Court to give the benefit of doubt to the respondents and allow their appeals. We are in full agreement with the reasons given by the High Court and we do not see any justifiable and compelling reason to interfere with the order of the acquittal. At this juncture, we point out that the State has not preferred any appeal against the order of the acquittal before this Court and the appeal is directed by the complainant who is the son of the deceased.
9. For all the reasons stated above, the appeal is dismissed. Bail bonds are discharged.
Alert