- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bhupendra Nath Prasad v. State Of Bihar .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, the sole accused, was charged with murdering Chandra Mani Lal Chowdhary by allegedly administering poison. The deceased and the accused had prior litigation and were on inimical terms. On 7 February 1979, the accused took the deceased to his house, allegedly offered him betel, after which the deceased experienced multiple bouts of vomiting and dizziness. He was taken to Dr. Arun Kumar Sinha (PW-6) and admitted to the local hospital, where he died at 1:40 a.m.
An FIR was lodged based on the statement of the deceased’s wife (PW-7), and investigation was conducted by PWs 12 and 13. The trial court convicted the appellant under Sections 302 and 328 IPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC. The High Court dismissed the appellant’s appeal. The present decision arises from a further appeal before the Supreme Court pursuant to special leave.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution conclusively established that the deceased’s death was caused by poisoning administered by the appellant.
- Whether the circumstantial evidence relied upon by the trial court and affirmed by the High Court satisfied the legal standard required for conviction under Sections 302 and 328 IPC.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The earliest version given to PW-6 indicated that “somebody” (not specifically the appellant) had offered the deceased wine and betel; later statements implicating the appellant were improvements and therefore unreliable.
- The prosecution failed to establish the precise cause of death: the post-mortem doctor was not examined, the Chemical Examiner’s report on the viscera was not produced, and PW-6 noted death by cardio-respiratory failure which could be due either to excessive alcohol consumption or poison.
- Given these deficiencies, it was unsafe and contrary to settled principles governing circumstantial evidence to sustain the conviction.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court found significant gaps in the prosecution case:
- Causation not proved: The post-mortem certificate merely recorded that viscera were preserved for chemical analysis; no expert opinion on cause of death was produced. PW-6’s bed-ticket attributed death to cardio-respiratory failure, possibly from excessive alcohol or poison, and detected an alcoholic smell on the deceased.
- Unreliable chemical evidence: Although a Chemical Examiner’s report showed Nux Vomica in the gastric wash and vomit, there was no reliable chain of custody or testimony establishing proper seizure and preservation of those samples.
- Defective oral dying declaration: The deceased’s wife and daughters originally told PW-6 that “somebody” offered wine and betel; their later claim that the appellant specifically administered poison was contradicted by PW-12’s investigation notes, undermining credibility.
- Standard for circumstantial evidence: Reiterating that every incriminating circumstance must be conclusively established and must point unerringly to the accused’s guilt, the Court held that the uncertainties surrounding both cause of death and administration of poison created reasonable doubt.
Given these deficiencies, the Court concluded that the prosecution failed to meet the burden of proof.
Holding and Implications
CONVICTION AND SENTENCE SET ASIDE; APPEAL ALLOWED.
The appellant’s conviction under Sections 302 and 328 IPC and the life sentence were quashed, and his bail bond was cancelled. The decision underscores that, in cases hinging on circumstantial evidence and alleged poisoning, the prosecution must present conclusive medical evidence and an unbroken chain of proof. No broader precedent was formally set, but the ruling reinforces existing standards on the necessity for definitive proof of cause of death and reliability of circumstantial evidence.
K. Jayachandra Reddy, J.— The sole accused in the case is the appellant. He has been convicted under Sections 302 and 328 IPC and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life under Section 302 IPC and no separate sentence was awarded under Section 328 IPC. The appeal preferred by him was dismissed by the High Court. Hence the present appeal pursuant to the special leave granted by this Court. It is alleged that he committed the murder of Chandra Mani Lal Chowdhary (the deceased) by administering poison. The prosecution case is as follows:
2. The deceased was the husband of Smt Kamla Kumari Devi, PW 7, the informant in this case. There was a litigation between the accused and the deceased. Therefore they were on inimical terms. However, the accused tried to establish friendship with the deceased putting an appearance of having changed in his attitude and used to visit the deceased now and then. On February 7, 1979 at about 7 p.m the accused visited the house of the deceased and requested him to go to his house. In spite of the protests made by his wife and daughters the deceased went to the house of the accused. He returned at 9 p.m in the night and started vomiting. He informed his wife that after he took betel (pan) offered by the accused at his residence he had five or six vomitings and became restless. The informant PW 7, Kamla Kumari Devi and her family members took the deceased to Dr Arun Kumar Sinha, PW 6 attached to the local hospital. He admitted the deceased in the hospital. He found the deceased to be in drowsy condition. The wife and other family members of the deceased told the doctor, PW 6 that somebody made the deceased take wine and betel and thereafter he started vomiting. PW 6 treated him by giving a stomach wash and preserved the same. He informed the police. The deceased, however, died at 1.40 a.m After recording the statement of PW 7, the wife of the deceased an FIR was registered and the investigation was commenced by PWs 12 and 13, the investigating officers. The dead body was sent for post-mortem. The doctor, who conducted the post-mortem, sent the viscera to the Chemical Examiner and reserved the opinion regarding the cause of death till the report of the Chemical Examiner was available. However, the report of the Chemical Examiner was not even marked in the case and therefore from the post-mortem report the cause of death could not be ascertained. It may also be mentioned that the doctor who conducted the post-mortem was not examined. The prosecution examined the daughters of the deceased namely PWs 8, 9 and 10. The prosecution, however, relied on the Chemical Examiner's report regarding the vomited substance which shows that Strychmine Nux Vocica, a poison was present in the gastric contents and the vomited substance. The trial court relying on the oral testimony of the wife and the daughters of the deceased who deposed that the deceased told them that the accused took him to his house and gave him betel and thereafter he became giddy and vomited and also on the other circumstance that in the vomitings and the gastric contents Nux Vocica was found by the Chemical Examiner, reached the conclusion that the prosecution has established that the accused administered the poison to the deceased which resulted in his death. The appeal preferred by the accused was dismissed by the High Court.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the earliest version was that the deceased told his family members that somebody gave wine and betel to him and it is only in their later version that they improved and implicated the accused by stating that the deceased told them that it was the accused who gave him the betel. His further submission is that the cause of death is not established by the prosecution and therefore it is highly unsafe to convict the appellant.
4. We find considerable force in this submission. PW 6, the doctor, in his chief examination itself has stated that the family members who brought the deceased to the hospital told him that somebody made him take wine and betel and that since thereafter he started vomiting and feeling giddiness. In cross-examination PW 6 further admitted that he has written in the bed-ticket that the death was due to cardio-respiratory failure. It is also elicited from him that such failure could be due to over-drinking of wine or due to poison. He also stated that when brought to the hospital, the wine odour was coming from the mouth of the deceased. So his evidence is not very helpful as to the cause of death. As already mentioned the doctor who conducted the post-mortem has not been examined. However, the post-mortem certificate is on record. It only shows that the viscera was preserved for chemical analysis and the opinion as to the cause of death was reserved till the report of the Chemical Examiner regarding the viscera was received. As already noted no such report of the Chemical Examiner has been produced nor the doctor who conducted the post-mortem has given any opinion as to the cause of death. Therefore we are left with the Chemical Examiner's report given on the basis of the test examination of the stomach wash and the vomited substance, said to have been seized by the police and sent to the Chemical Examiner. PW 6 the doctor does not speak about any such seizure. PW 1, a compounder in the hospital, however, deposed that the vomited substance was put in a bottle and sealed but he does not say that the same was seized. PW 3, however, deposed that the police officer seized the vomited substance at the house of the deceased and a seizure report was prepared and he affixed his signature. PW 12, an Investigating Officer also stated that he seized the vomited substance. It is needless to say that in a criminal case the cause of death has to be ascertained conclusively. As already noted the post-mortem report does not in any manner establish the same. Even accepting that Nux Vocica was found in the vomited substance it cannot be concluded that the death was due to poisoning and particularly when PW 6, the doctor has noted that the death was due to cardio-respiratory failure either due to taking excess wine or due to poison. Admittedly the alcoholic smell was coming from the mouth of the deceased when he was unconscious. Therefore a reasonable doubt arises about the cause of death. Even otherwise there is no satisfactory evidence in this case that it was the accused who gave the betel containing poison to the deceased. The wife and the daughters of the deceased who took the deceased to the hospital stated before PW 6, the doctor that the deceased told them that somebody gave him wine and betel and thereafter he became giddy. These witnesses were cross-examined with their earlier statements and PW 12, an Investigating Officer admitted that the wife of the deceased did not state before him that the accused had taken her husband with him. Thus the evidence regarding the so-called oral dying declaration is also unsatisfactory and does not inspire confidence. It is well settled that in a case depending upon circumstantial evidence all the circumstances should conclusively point towards the guilt of the accused. In this case even the cause of death has not been conclusively established. Therefore, we are constrained to interfere. Accordingly the conviction and sentence awarded against the appellant are set aside and the appeal is allowed. He is on bail. His bail bond shall stand cancelled.
Alert