- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dr. P.K Jaiswal v. Ms Debi Mukherjee And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
After the death of Mr. Jaisani in July 1989, a vacancy arose in the post of Assistant Director General (Prevention of Food Adulteration) in the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. At that time the applicable recruitment rules contemplated filling the post exclusively through direct recruitment, and the Ministry sent a requisition to the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) in November 1989.
Before the UPSC could advertise the post, the Union Government informed it on 29 December 1989 that the matter was under reconsideration because the Government was examining the possibility of introducing promotion as an avenue of appointment. Despite this communication, the UPSC advertised the vacancy in January 1990. The appellant applied and was called for interview on 13 December 1990.
Respondent 1, Mrs. Debi Mukherjee, an Assistant Secretary who hoped for promotion under the contemplated new rules, approached the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) and obtained an interim order staying the UPSC selection process. Ultimately, the CAT directed the Ministry to create promotional avenues and granted three months to implement its order. The appellant, whose application for direct recruitment was consequently stalled, filed the present appeal before the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Union Government could withdraw its requisition and halt the UPSC selection process after it had begun but before any vested right to consideration for selection had accrued.
- Whether the CAT erred by overlooking the creation of two additional hierarchical layers (with higher pay scales) introduced pursuant to earlier Supreme Court directions.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Government and the CAT lacked authority to halt the selection once the process had commenced; the UPSC was entitled to complete it.
- The CAT failed to consider that two new hierarchical layers had been created, a fact that should have influenced its decision.
- Relied heavily on N.T. Devin Katti v. Karnataka Public Service Commission to contend that a candidate acquires a vested right to consideration under the rules existing on the date of advertisement, and on Jatinder Kumar v. State of Punjab to emphasise the sanctity of the UPSC selection process.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| N.T. Devin Katti v. Karnataka Public Service Commission, (1990) 3 SCC 157 | A candidate who meets eligibility criteria on the date of advertisement has a right to be considered according to the rules then in force; this right can be lost only if the amended rules are retrospective. | The Court distinguished the present case, noting that no advertisement had been issued when the Government withdrew its requisition; hence no right to consideration had crystallised. |
| Jatinder Kumar v. State of Punjab, (1985) 1 SCC 122 | The UPSC is an independent body whose selection recommendations are binding in the sense that Government must act according to merit, though the ultimate appointment power remains with Government. | Used to illustrate that even if a selection list is prepared, a candidate gains no enforceable right to appointment; the principle reinforced the Court's view that the appellant held no vested right at the pre-advertisement stage. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court framed its analysis around whether any vested right to consideration had accrued before the Government signalled its intent to reconsider the recruitment rules. It observed that:
- The Government’s letter of 29 December 1989 reached the UPSC before any advertisement was issued. Therefore, the selection process had not formally commenced; no candidate, including the appellant, had yet acquired the limited right to be considered.
- Policy decisions regarding whether a post should be filled by direct recruitment or by promotion rest exclusively with the Government. It was thus competent for the Government to direct the UPSC to pause the process until a final decision on amending the rules was taken.
- Proceeding with selection in defiance of the Government’s communication would have been futile and wasteful. The Court termed the UPSC’s decision to advertise the post “hasty and unjustified.”
- The CAT’s omission to discuss the creation of two new hierarchical layers did not affect the legality of holding the selection process in abeyance, because that structural change was unrelated to the core question of when a vested right arises.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court declined to interfere with the CAT’s direction and held that the appellant possessed no vested right to have the selection process completed.
Implications: The decision affirms governmental discretion to withdraw or postpone a requisition before the UPSC issues an advertisement, clarifying that candidates obtain only a limited right of consideration once the advertisement is published. No broader precedent was set beyond reaffirming existing principles on vested rights in recruitment processes.
A.M Ahmadi, J.— Special leave granted.
2. Heard counsel on both sides. The facts giving rise to this appeal, briefly stated, are as under:
One Mr Jaisani, a direct recruit, was holding the post of Assistant Director General (Prevention of Food Adulteration) in the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare of the Government of India. On his passing away some time in July 1989, a vacancy arose which was required to be filled under the extant recruitment rules. The recruitment rules which were then in operation provided for the said post being filled in by direct recruitment only. A requisition was sent to the Union Public Service Commission (‘Commission’ hereafter) some time in November 1989 for selection of a candidate for filling in the vacancy in question.
3. However, before the Commission could advertise the post, the Union Government informed the Commission by letter dated December 29, 1989 received by the Commission on January 1, 1990 not to proceed with the process of selection because it was examining the question of opening up an avenue for promotion from Assistant Secretary to the post in question. Notwithstanding the said communication, the Commission advertised the post in January 1990. The appellant applied for the same and was called for an interview on December 13, 1990. Thereupon respondent 1, Mrs Debi Mukherjee, who was then serving as Assistant Secretary, and was hoping to be promoted as Assistant Director General on the amendment of the recruitment rules, approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, New Delhi and obtained an interim order staying the process of selection initiated by the Commission. It may here be mentioned that in the meantime two further layers above that of Assistant Secretary came to be created providing for higher pay scales by an amendment of the rules pursuant to the directions given by this Court in Writ Petition No. 1118 of 1989 read with the directions in the Contempt Petition No. 5 of 1990 dated May 4, 1990. The two layers thus created provided for higher pay scales but no separate designations. The question regarding the appointment to the vacancy created on the demise of Jaisani, however, had still to be dealt with. The appellant who was affected by the Tribunal's order approached for impleadment/inter∼vention but the Tribunal did not allow the same although we are told that the Tribunal gave a hearing to the counsel for the appellant. The Tribunal ultimately disposed of the petition with a direction to the concerned Ministry to provide promotional avenues to the applicant who had functioned in the post of Assistant Secretary for several years and had held the charge of Assistant Director General as and when the occasion arose. Three months' time was granted to the concerned Ministry to carry out the directions. The failure to carry out the directions had led to the filing of a contempt application also.
4. The grievance of the appellant is twofold. Firstly, he contends that once the process for selection had started it was not open to the government as well as the Tribunal to freeze the process and the Commission was entitled to complete the selection. The second point urged was that the fact of the creation of two layers by the amendment of the relevant rules had been totally overlooked by the Tribunal even though its attention was drawn to the same by counsel for the appellant.
5. In support of the first contention, strong reliance was placed on the decision of this Court in N.T Devin Katti v. Karnataka Public Service Commission (1990) 3 SCC 157, (1990) 14 ATC 688. In that case this Court observed that a candidate who is eligible and otherwise qualified in accordance with the relevant rules and the terms of the advertisement acquires a vested right of being considered for selection in accordance with the rules as they existed at the date of advertisement. He cannot be deprived of that limited right on the amendment of rules during the pendency of selection unless the amended rules are retrospective in nature. While making these observations, it was made clear that a candidate on making an application for a post pursuant to an advertisement does not acquire any vested right of selection or of appointment to the post in question. This is obvious from the ratio of this Court's decision in Jatinder Kumar v. State of Punjab (1985) 1 SCC 122, (1985) 1 SCR 899. In that case, it was clarified that an independent body like the Commission is established to ensure selection of best available talent for appointment to the post in question to avoid arbitrariness and nepotism in the matter of appointment. The selection has to be made by the Commission and on the basis thereof the government has to fill up the post adhering to the order of merit drawn up by the Commission. This Court emphasised that the selection by the Commission is only recommendatory in nature and the final authority for appointment is the government, and if the government declines to accept the recommendation the Constitution enjoins the government to place on the table of the legislature its reasons and report for so doing. Thereby the government is made answerable to the elected representatives under the Constitution. This, however, does not clothe the selectee with any right to appointment that is to say that he cannot force the government to accept the recommendation of the Commission but the government has to make the appointment strictly in accordance with the recruitment rules and merits as determined by the Commission and it cannot disturb the list at its sweet will. Nor can the government appoint a person whose name does not appear in the list. It is obvious from the ratio of these two decisions to which our attention was pointedly drawn that if the Commission issues an advertisement at the behest of the government and pursuant thereto calls a candidate for interview, the candidate has a right to be considered for selection but not a right to be selected or to appointment to the post in question. The right to selection crystallises only after the candidate is called for interview pursuant to the advertisement. But in the instant case the question is whether the government can withdraw the requisition sent to the Commission for initiating the process of selection because at that point of time no right had crystallised in anyone for being considered for selection. If the government is at a given point of time considering the question of amending the recruitment rules with a view to providing for promotion to the post in question, the government can before an advertisement is issued by the Commission and the process of selection is under way request the Commission to withdraw the same till it decides on the question of amending the rules. The decision of the government to withdraw the requisition sent to the Commission in November 1989 before the issuance of the advertisement does not interfere with any vested right of selection because that stage had yet not reached. In the instant case, that is exactly what happened. Therefore, before the appellant acquired a right to be considered for selection the government had already intimated that it was examining the question of amending the recruitment rules with a view to providing for appointment by promotion to the post in question. Once this decision was communicated to the Commission before it had set the process of selection in motion by issuing an advertisement, it was not open to the Commission to insist that it will go ahead with the selection process as the extant rule provided for promotion by direct recruitment and the government could amend the recruitment rules retrospectively, if it so desired, with a view to providing for appointment by promotion. Such an exercise by the Commission would be an exercise in futility, waste of public time and money and hardship to candidates who seek appointment. Whether to provide for promotion as a mode of appointment to the post in question is a matter of policy left to the government to decide and if it desired that the selection process should be held in abeyance till the question was examined and a final decision was taken thereon, it was not open to the Commission to ignore the communication of the government in that behalf and proceed to set the selection process in motion. We think the action of the Commission was somewhat hasty and unjustified. The appellant, therefore, cannot claim any vested right as urged by his learned counsel. Nor can the Tribunal's omission to notice that two new layers were created have a bearing on the government's decision to place the process of selection in hibernation till a final decision is taken on the proposal to provide for promotion to the post.
6. For the above reasons, we are of the opinion that the decision reached by the Tribunal does not require any interference at our hands in exercise of the power under Article 136 of the Constitution. Hence, the appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed with no order as to costs.
Alert