Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jagat Narayan Jha v. State Of Bihar .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 29, 1992
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was employed as a Tour Clerk and Nazir at Kuru West, Khanapuri Camp in the district of Ranchi under Assistant Settlement Officer Shri Akhouri Balbhadra Sahay (PW 7). On 22-2-1977, while PW 7 was on tour, the appellant received a remittance of Rs 1500 from the Head Office, Ranchi. The appellant acknowledged receipt in the General Cash Book. The prosecution alleged that the money was never handed over to PW 7 and that the entry showing such disbursement was forged. The Trial Magistrate convicted the appellant under Section 409 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced him to two years’ rigorous imprisonment. The conviction was affirmed by the appellate court, and the High Court of Patna dismissed the appellant’s revision in limine. The present appeal challenges those concurrent findings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant misappropriated the entrusted sum of Rs 1500, constituting criminal breach of trust under Section 409 IPC.
  2. Whether the appellant’s explanation—that he duly handed over the amount to PW 7 and that the General Cash Book entry reflected a genuine transaction—was sufficiently probable to create reasonable doubt and warrant an acquittal.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Arguments

  • The appellant received Rs 1500 during PW 7’s absence but never remitted it to him upon his return.
  • The entry in the General Cash Book indicating disbursement to PW 7 was a later interpolation and therefore forged.
  • Placement of PW 7’s signature two lines below the relevant figure and the darker ink color suggested tampering by the appellant.

Appellant's Arguments

  • He handed over the money to PW 7 on the evening of 22-2-1977.
  • The disbursement entry, although written by him, was contemporaneously signed by PW 7 in acknowledgment of receipt.
  • The General Cash Book thus accurately recorded both receipt and disbursement, negating any allegation of misappropriation.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court focused on whether the appellant’s defence raised a reasonable doubt:

  • Entrustment was undisputed; hence the burden shifted to the appellant to show that he discharged his obligation, though only on a balance of probabilities.
  • The Court examined a photograph of the General Cash Book entry. It noted that PW 7’s signature appeared two lines below the figure “Rs 1500,” leaving an unexplained gap.
  • If the disbursement entry were forged, PW 7’s signature would logically have been adjacent to the figure, not separated by two lines. This placement cast doubt on the prosecution’s claim of interpolation.
  • Given this “dust of doubt,” and considering that the defence version was at least as probable as the prosecution’s, the Court held that the appellant was entitled to the benefit of doubt.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; CONVICTION AND SENTENCE SET ASIDE. The judgments of the Trial Magistrate, the appellate court, and the High Court are reversed.

Implications: The decision results in the appellant’s immediate acquittal and termination of the two-year rigorous imprisonment sentence. The ruling turns solely on evidentiary doubt and sets no broader precedent beyond reiterating the principle that an accused must receive the benefit of doubt when the prosecution’s case is not proven beyond reasonable doubt.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. The Trial Magistrate recorded conviction of the appellant under Section 409 IPC and sentenced him to two years' rigorous imprisonment. The conviction of the appellant was maintained by the appellate court. His revision before the High Court of Patna was dismissed in limine. Hence this appeal.

2. The case of the prosecution lies within a narrow compass. The appellant was working as a Tour Clerk as well as Nazir at Kuru West, Khanapuri Camp in the district of Ranchi under Shri Akhouri Balbhadra Sahay, PW 7, an Assistant Settlement Officer in the Settlement Office. In routine Shri Sahay, PW 7 went on tour on 22-2-1977. In his absence a sum of Rs 1500 was received in the Assistant Settlement Office from the Head Office, Ranchi. The appellant initially was reluctant to receive the money in the absence of his superior officer, but the latter's counterpart in Kuru East, on asking, guided him that the money could well be received and handed over to Shri Sahay, PW 7 on his return. On acceptance of such suggestion, the said sum of Rs 1500 was received by the appellant. This part of the prosecution case is admitted by the appellant. This means entrustment stood proved.

3. Now with regard to disbursement we enter a grey area. The prosecution case is that PW 7 on his return on the same day was apprised that such a sum had been received in the office by the appellant. The appellant had priorly, in acknowledgment of the receipt of the sum, made necessary entries and signed the General Cash Book. According to the prosecution the said sum had not been made over to PW 7. The writing correspondingly occurring in the General Cash Book purporting to show that the said sum had been handed over to PW 7 was a forgery and an interpolation by and under the hand of the appellant, after PW 7 had made his signatures. The case of the appellant, on the other hand, is that on the return of Shri Sahay, PW 7 in the evening the money was handed over to him and the receipt in the General Cash Book, though written by him, bears the signatures of PW 7 at the appropriate place, in token of his having received the sum.

4. Out of the two words, the courts in the hierarchy preferred to believe PW 7. When the entrustment is admitted by the appellant, it is for him to discharge the burden that the entrustment has been carried out as expected and the obligation has been discharged. It is undisputed that all that was required of the appellant was to hand over the money to Shri Sahay, PW 7. His explanation in that regard has to be examined on preponderance of probabilities and not required to be proved beyond all reasonable doubt. Now whether his version is probable or not can best be seen from the way the document is depicted in the evidence and described by the courts below.

5. We have also had the advantage of seeing a photograph of the relevant entry placed before us by the learned counsel for the appellant, which was not objected to by learned counsel for the State. The visual observation of the entry when tallied with the evidence discloses that on one leaf of the General Cash Book the receipt of Rs 1500 is mentioned by the appellant and on the other leaf disbursement has been shown by him of the said sum, figure of which is in the column meant for mentioning figures. Now in the next column, adjacent and in line to that figure of Rs 1500, are written two lines which are suggestive of the money being handed over to PW 7. It is thereafter, where possible, on the third line, that PW 7 had put his signatures. The placement of signatures raises a dust of doubt. The suggestion of PW 7 that the two written lines above his signatures, by and under the hand of the appellant, were inserted later does stand the test of probabilities, even if we view with suspicion the change of colour of ink of those two lines, ostensibly written on the latter part of the day on the second occasion. Had those two lines not been there, then the signatures of PW 7 would have been adjacent to and in line with the figure of Rs 1500 where the first line is, leaving no gap. There was apparently no reason for PW 7 to put his signatures in the relevant column two lines after which the figure of Rs 1500 occurs. If the version of the PW 7 is to be relied upon, then his signatures should have been adjacent and in line to that figure. The view of the courts below regarding the dark colour of the ink of the entries, on the view we have taken, is not material because the clinching point is the placement of signatures.

6. Thus, we entertain a grave doubt as to whether the prosecution case in this regard is true. It could well be that the appellant had paid the money to PW 7, as depicted in the General Cash Book. But we do not mean to hold so definitely. All what we go to hold is that the defence of the appellant is probable and he must, therefore, get the benefit of doubt.

7. Accordingly, extending the benefit of doubt to the appellant we allow his appeal and set aside his conviction and sentence. The judgments and orders of the courts below are reversed.