Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mool Chand v. State Through The Director, Cbi, Scope Building, Lodhi Complex, New Delhi .

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 4, 1991
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Mool Chand Shah, was arrested on 16 April 1991 in Bombay and later produced before a Designated Court in Delhi on 23 April 1991. He is an accused in FIR No. 53 of 1991 registered at Chandni Mahal Police Station, Delhi, under Sections 3 and 4 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (TADA) and Section 8(1) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA). Investigators allege that the petitioner, acting as an unauthorised hawala dealer, channelled large sums of money to militant outfits in Jammu & Kashmir. Several co-accused—Ashfaq Hussain Lone, Shahbuddin Ghauri and Shambhu Dayal Sharma—were apprehended earlier, and their statements allegedly led to the petitioner’s arrest. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) took over the enquiry on 20 April 1991 and recovered substantial cash, foreign exchange, gold bars and Indira Vikas Patras during nationwide searches. The Designated Court rejected the petitioner’s application for regular or interim bail on 3 June 1991, prompting the present special leave petition before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to regular or interim bail under TADA despite allegations of financing terrorist activities.
  2. Whether the alleged non-disclosure of precise accusations and grounds of arrest violates Article 22 of the Constitution and Section 50(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, thereby justifying bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • No evidence connects the petitioner to the funding of terrorist activities; neither the FIR nor remand reports give specific particulars linking him to terrorism.
  • Even if the petitioner engaged in monetary transactions with co-accused, that alone does not prove knowledge of, or participation in, terrorist objectives.
  • The petitioner has made no confession under Section 15 of TADA, so the presumption in Section 21(1)(c) cannot arise.
  • Arrest and detention violate Article 22 of the Constitution and Section 50(1) CrPC because grounds were inadequately disclosed, preventing an effective defence.
  • Relied on Bimal Kaur Khalsa v. Union of India and Selvanathan alias Raghavan v. State to support the contention that mere monetary dealings without knowledge of terrorism cannot attract TADA.

Prosecution's Arguments

  • Disclosure by co-accused Shambhu Dayal Sharma specifically implicates the petitioner as a conduit through whom funds reached militants.
  • The alleged conspiracy has international ramifications; extensive investigation, including inquiries abroad, is still underway.
  • Releasing the petitioner would hinder ongoing investigations aimed at unearthing a deep-rooted terrorist funding network.
  • The petitioner’s continued custody is necessary given the seriousness of the allegations.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bimal Kaur Khalsa v. Union of India (1988 Cri LJ 869; AIR 1988 P&H 95; (1988) 93 Punj LR 189) Cited by petitioner to argue that absence of specific allegations and knowledge of terrorist identity cannot justify detention under TADA. The Supreme Court did not engage with or apply this precedent in its analysis.
Selvanathan alias Raghavan v. State by Inspector of Police (1988 LW (Cri) 503) Relied upon by petitioner to reinforce constitutional and statutory protections against unlawful detention. The Supreme Court did not engage with or apply this precedent in its analysis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court expressly declined to assess the merits of the evidence at the investigation stage but recognised that:

  • The investigation “has to go a long way” and significant time is required to uncover the full conspiracy.
  • The allegations are grave, involving the financing of militant operations in Jammu & Kashmir.
  • Premature release could “frustrate the effort of the investigating agencies” in collecting evidence both domestically and abroad.

Balancing these considerations, the Court found continued detention justified under TADA and dismissed the bail request, while directing the investigating agencies to expedite the probe.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The special leave petition is dismissed; the application for regular or interim bail is refused. The petitioner may renew the bail application after two months.

Implications: The petitioner remains in judicial custody, allowing the CBI additional time to complete its wide-ranging investigation. The decision sets no new legal precedent but underscores the judiciary’s deference to investigative needs in serious TADA cases.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This special leave petition is directed against the order of the Designated Court, Delhi dated June 3, 1991 rejecting the application for regular bail to Mool Chand Shah, the petitioner herein and in the alternative releasing him on interim bail.

2. The petitioner is an accused in FIR No. 53 of 1991 of Chandni Mahal Police Station, Delhi registered under Sections 3 and 4 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (TADA) and under Section 8(1) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA). The prosecution is as follows:

The petitioner is an unauthorised dealer illegally dealing in foreign exchange — commonly known as hawala transaction and he has been instrumental in transferring huge sums received from different sources to the members of militant outfits of Jammu and Kashmir for use in terrorist and disruptive activities. It is stated that on receipt of a secret information, a trap was laid by Delhi Police on March 25, 1991 resulting in the apprehension of accused Ashfaq Hussain Lone from whom three incriminating letters, one addressed to Master Ahsan Dar, Commander-in-Chief of Hizbul Mujaheedin, a banned terrorist organisation of Kashmir Valley and another addressed to one Mashud containing information about making arrangements for a house in Srinagar and for recruiting people in the valley and the third one addressed to Firdaus containing secessionist messages, formation of militant groups etc. were seized. At the time of the apprehension, accused Ashfaq Hussain Lone shouted slogans, ‘Pakistan Zindabad’, ‘Azad Kashmir Zindabad’ etc. the case FIR No. 53 of 1991, referred to above, was registered only after his arrest on March 25, 1991. In pursuance of his statement, 23 drafts for a sum of Rs 15.50 lakhs and a sum of Rs 50,000 in cash were also recovered which amounts are stated to have been given to accused Ashfaq Hussain Lone by accused Shahbuddin Ghauri, a research student of JNU who in turn is stated to have received the same from Dr Ayub Thakur of U.K through illegal means of hawala transaction. Accused Shahbuddin Ghauri was also arrested by Delhi Police on March 27, 1991 and on his pointing out, another accused Shambhu Dayal Sharma at the rate Guptaji who is stated to have delivered the sum of Rs 16.27 lakhs, was also arrested on April 1, 1991. On the disclosure of accused Shambhu Dayal Sharma to the effect that the petitioner, Mool Chand Shah was the person through whom he started transactions at Delhi and passed on the money to different people including to accused Shahbuddin Ghauri which were recovered from Ashfaq Hussian Lone while being taken to Kashmir for terrorist activities, Delhi Police sent a requisition to Bombay on April 13, 1991 for apprehending petitioner/accused Mool Chand Shah who was accordingly arrested at Bombay on April 16, 1991 and was brought to Delhi on April 23, 1991 on a production warrant issued by the court. The petitioner was kept in police custody on court's order up to May 10, 1991 for interrogation and thereafter was sent to judicial custody up to June 29, 1991. (It is now stated at the bar that the remand of the petitioner is further extended.) The investigation of this case was taken over by the CBI on April 20, 1991. The CBI conducted simultaneous searches at 20 places including the place of sub-bankers of hawala from where the accused persons used to collect the money for making payments to different persons and also at the places where the final deliveries were made. According to the prosecution, a huge amount of Rs 93,52,755 in cash and foreign exchange worth Rs 3,69,307, Indira Vikas Patra worth Rs 10,50,000 and gold bars worth Rs 12 lakhs were recovered and the investigation, connecting the terrorist links of the places from where the money had been kept/delivered by the accused persons in this case is continuing not only in India but also abroad and that the investigation is likely to take sufficient time to unearth the whole conspiracy behind the said heinous crime of funding terrorists for illegal terrorist and secessionist activities.

3. Mr Jethmalani, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner strenuously contended that there is absolutely no evidence worth mentioning disclosing the involvement of the petitioner in funding of terrorist activities and that the investigating agencies have not disclosed the precise allegations and particulars either in the first information report or in the remand report connecting the petitioner with the offence in question and that even assuming but not conceding that the petitioner had been dealing with money transaction with any one of the accused that would not be a sufficient ground to hold that the petitioner in any way had any connection with the terrorist activities even remotely or had knowledge of the alleged terrorist activities of the other accused. In continuation of his submission, it has been stated that the petitioner has not made any confession to the police officer within the ambit of Section 15 of TADA Act from which presumption as to offence under Section 3 could be drawn as contemplated under Section 21, sub-section (1)(c) of the TADA Act. According to him, the arrest and detention of the petitioner as well the non-disclosure of the full particulars of the offence or the grounds for his arrest are in violation of Article 22 of the Constitution of India and Section 50(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure and that this non-disclosure of the particulars has deprived him of meeting this case effectively. In support of his contention, the learned counsel places reliance on two decisions, namely Bimal Kaur Khalsa v. Union of India 1988 Cri LJ 869, AIR 1988 P & H 95, (1988) 93 Punj LR 189 and Selvanathan alias Raghavan v. State by Inspector of Police 1988 LW (Cri) 503 to which I was a party. Finally, he drew the attention of this Court to paragraph 6 of the impugned order wherein the Designated Court has made the following observations:

“There is considerable substance in the defence plea that unless it is shown that the applicant/accused knew the identity of persons being terrorist or disruptionists, mere transfer of funds by way of hawala transaction cannot bring his case under Section 3(3) of TADA Act, 1987, as such transaction cannot be treated as amounting to rendering of assistance, financially or otherwise, to terrorist or disruptionist.”

and contended that in the face of the above observation, the petitioner is entitled for bail and more so when it is the admitted case of the prosecution that the petitioner was traced on the disclosure of accused Shambhu Dayal Sharma who was traced on being pointed out by Shahbuddin Ghauri who was traced on the strength of the statements of Ashfaq Hussain Lone.

4. The learned Additional Solicitor General refuted the arguments of Mr Jethmalani stating that Shambhu Dayal Sharma who had delivered a sum of Rs 16.27 lakhs to Shahbuddin Ghauri was arrested on April 1, 1991 and that on the strength of the statement of disclosure made by Shambhu Dayal Sharma to the effect that the petitioner was the person through whom he started transaction at Delhi and passed on the money to different people including to accused Shahbuddin Ghauri which amounts were recovered from Ashfaq Hussain Lone while being taken to Kashmir for terrorist activities and that the offence has got an international ramification and that some more time would be required for completing the investigation and as such the release of the petitioner on bail will be hindrance to the further investigation which has to be intensively carried on not only in India but also abroad. According to him, there is a deep-rooted conspiracy of terrorist activities and the petitioner is very much involved in it.

5. I bestowed my deep and anxious consideration to the submissions made by both the parties. As the matter is under investigation, I am not inclined to express any opinion on the merits or demerits of the case. Suffice to say that the investigation has to go a long way and hence sufficient time will be required for the investigating agencies to complete the investigations. Further, having regard to the seriousness of the allegations levelled against the petitioner, as pointed out by the Designated Court, the release of the petitioner on bail at this crucial stage may frustrate the effort of the investigating agencies in collecting evidence. Hence his bail application is dismissed at this stage. However, the investigating agencies are directed to expedite and complete the investigation as expeditiously as possible. The petitioner is permitted to renew the application for bail after two months.

6. The special leave petition is dismissed accordingly.