- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ashok Alias Somanna Gowda v. And Anothe
Factual and Procedural Background
The Government of Karnataka issued a notification on 4 April 1985 inviting applications for 450 posts of Assistant Engineer (Civil) and 110 posts of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) in the Public Works Department. Recruitment was governed by the K.S.C.S. (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1973, which allocated 100 marks to the qualifying engineering degree and 50 marks to the interview, giving the viva-voce a weightage of 33.3 %.
Ashok @ Somanna Gowda (B.E. Civil, 69.96 %) and Rajendra (B.E. Mechanical, 66.40 %) applied. They scored 29.50 and 24.83 respectively in the interview but were not selected because other candidates with lower academic scores obtained very high viva-voce marks. They petitioned the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal, contending that the allocation of marks to the interview violated binding Supreme Court precedent. The Tribunal dismissed the petitions on 24 May 1990. The appellants then approached the Supreme Court, which granted special leave.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether fixing viva-voce marks at one-third of the total (50 out of 150) under the 1973 Rules is violative of the principles laid down by the Supreme Court regarding permissible weightage for interviews.
- If so, what relief, if any, should be granted to the appellants in light of selections already finalized in 1987 and the subsequent service of the selected candidates.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The allocation of 33.3 % of total marks to the interview is excessive and directly contravenes the Supreme Court decisions in Ashok Kumar Yadav and Mohinder Sain Garg.
- Had the interview been limited to roughly 15 % of the total, both appellants would have ranked high enough to be selected.
State of Karnataka's Arguments
- Applying the reduced-weight interview formula would elevate many other candidates above the appellants; granting relief only to them would be inequitable.
- New recruitment rules have since been framed, rendering any declaration on the old rules unnecessary.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ashok Kumar Yadav v. State of Haryana (1985) 4 SCC 417 | The interview should not carry disproportionate weight vis-à-vis academic merit; generally, viva-voce marks should not exceed 12.5–15 % of the total. | The Court held that allocating 50/150 marks (33.3 %) to the interview under the Karnataka Rules violated this principle. |
| Mohinder Sain Garg v. State of Punjab (1991) 1 SCC 662 | Re-affirmation of the permissible limit on viva-voce marks and the need to prevent arbitrariness in selection. | Used as additional authority to declare the Karnataka viva-voce weightage invalid. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court compared the Karnataka scheme (50/150 interview marks) with the ceilings prescribed in Ashok Kumar Yadav and Mohinder Sain Garg, finding the 33.3 % weightage “clearly in violation” of those rulings. The selection records, produced on the Court’s direction of 4 September 1991, showed that many selected candidates had lower academic scores than the appellants but compensated with disproportionately high interview marks. Had the viva-voce been capped at 15 % of the total, the appellants would have ranked within the selection zone.
Despite this illegality, the Court declined to quash the entire 1987 selection on equitable considerations: (i) the recruits had been in service for several years; (ii) the 1973 Rules had been consistently applied for 17 years without allegations of mala fides; and (iii) new rules had already replaced the impugned provisions. Equity also favoured only those who were vigilant; the appellants alone had pursued timely legal redress.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Allowed. The State of Karnataka is directed to appoint Ashok @ Somanna Gowda as Assistant Engineer (Civil) and Rajendra as Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) within two months, subject to their meeting other eligibility criteria.
Implications: The decision re-affirms the ceiling on interview marks and underscores that excessive weightage renders the rule illegal. However, the Court limited relief to the vigilant appellants and did not disturb the appointments of others or formally strike down the obsolete rules. No costs were awarded.
N.M Kasliwal, J.— Special leave granted.
2. Sri Ashok alias Somanna Gowda appellant 1 is a Bachelor of Engineering (Civil) having secured first class with distinction getting 69.96 per cent marks from Karnataka University. Shri Rajendra appellant 2 is a Bachelor of Engineering (Mech.) from Karnataka University and secured 66.40 marks in the qualifying examination. The Government of Karnataka by notification dated April 4, 1985 invited applications for recruitment of Assistant Engineers (Civil) and (Mech.) for the Public Works Department. The selections were to be made on the basis of marks obtained in the qualifying examination and marks secured in the interview, in accordance with the K.S.C.S (Direct Recruitment By Selection) Rules, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’). According to these Rules total marks for qualifying examination were kept at 100 and 50 for interview. Thus the marks allotted for interview amounted to 33.3 per cent of the total marks. Applications were invited for 300 posts of Civil Engineers and 100 Mechanical Engineers initially and subsequently added additional posts of 150 Civil Engineers and 10 Mechanical Engineers, thus in all 450 Civil Engineers and 110 Mechanical Engineers. Both the appellants applied for the posts of their choices in the Public Works Department, Government of Karnataka. Appellant 1 secured 29.50 marks out of 50 marks in the interview and 69.96 marks in the qualifying examination thus in all 99.46 marks out of 150. Appellant 2 obtained 24.83 marks in the interview and 66.40 marks in the qualifying examination thus in all 91.23 marks out of 150. Both the appellants were not selected in merit as the last candidate selected for the above posts secured higher marks than the appellants. The appellants filed a petition before the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal challenging the Rules on the ground that the percentage of marks for viva voce as 33.3 were excessive and in violation of the decisions of this Court. The Tribunal by its order dated May 24, 1990 dismissed the petitions and the appellants aggrieved against the aforesaid decision have approached this Court by grant of special leave. It is not necessary to examine the matter in detail inasmuch as 50 marks for interview out of 150 are clearly in violation of the judgment of this Court in Ashok Kumar Yadav v. State of Haryana (1985) 4 SCC 417, 1985 Supp 1 SCR 657 and Mohinder Sain Garg v. State of Punjab (1991) 1 SCC 662, (1991) 16 ATC 495, JT (1990) 4 SC 704. On a direction given by this Court on September 4, 1991 the record of the Selection Committee was produced before this Court at the time of hearing. From a perusal of the marks awarded to the selected candidates it is clear that a large number of candidates have been selected though they had secured much lesser marks than the appellants in the qualifying examination but had secured very high marks in the viva voce out of 50 marks kept for this purpose. Thus it is an admitted position that if the marks for interview were kept even at 15 per cent of the total marks and merit list is prepared accordingly then both the appellants were bound to be selected and a large number of selected candidates would have gone much lower in the merit list than the appellants. In view of the fact that the result of the impugned selections was declared in 1987 and the selected candidates have already joined the posts, we do not consider it just and proper to quash the selections on the above ground. Further the selections were made according to the Rules of 1973 and this practice is being consistently followed for the last 17 years and there is no allegation of any mala fides in the matter of the impugned selections. However, the Rules are clearly in violation of the dictum laid down by this Court in the above referred cases and in case the marks for viva voce would have been kept say at 15 per cent of the total marks, the appellants before us were bound to be selected on the basis of marks secured by them in interview, calculated on the basis of converting the same to 15 per cent of the total marks.
3. We, therefore, allow the appeal and direct the respondents to give appointment to the appellant Ashok alias Somanna Gowda on the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) and appellant Rajendra on the post of Assistant Engineer (Mech.) in Public Works Department within a period of two months of the communication of this order in case the appellants are found suitable in all other respects according to the Rules. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State of Karnataka pointed out that there are many other candidates who had secured much higher marks than the appellants in case the above criteria is applied for selection. In view of the fact that appointments under the impugned Rules were made as back as in 1987 and only the present appellants had approached the Tribunal for relief, the case of other candidates cannot be considered as they never approached for redress within reasonable time. We are thus inclined to grant relief only to the present appellants who were vigilant in making grievance and approaching the Tribunal in time. Learned counsel for the State also submitted that the State Government has already framed new rules, and as such we do not find it necessary to quash the Rules under which the present selections were made as they are no longer in existence. No order as to costs.
Alert