- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sub-Committee On Judicial Accountability v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
A writ petition has been filed by a body of advocates known as the “Sub-Committee on Judicial Accountability.” The petition questions the validity and implementation of the Speaker of the Lok Sabha’s decision to admit a notice of motion, signed by 108 Members of Parliament under Article 124(5) of the Constitution and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, for investigating allegations of misconduct against a sitting Supreme Court Judge relating to his tenure as Chief Justice of the Punjab & Haryana High Court. The Speaker constituted an Inquiry Committee comprising a Supreme Court Judge, a Chief Justice of a High Court, and a jurist.
The petitioners seek (i) a direction compelling the Union Government to provide all facilities required by the Committee, and (ii) a direction to the Chief Justice of India to withhold judicial work from the concerned Judge during the inquiry. The Court deferred consideration of the second prayer pending final hearing.
The Union Government, via an affidavit sworn by a Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Law and Justice, contends that the motion lapsed with the dissolution of the Lok Sabha, rendering further action unnecessary, including issuance of a Presidential notification under paragraph 9 read with paragraph 11(b)(i) of Part D of the Second Schedule (which would allow the Judges on the Committee to treat their Committee work as “actual service”).
Certain interveners have filed separate writ petitions supporting the Government’s position that the motion does not survive dissolution.
The Supreme Court has now issued an interim order fixing an expedited schedule for hearing the main writ petition and connected matters.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the notice of motion admitted by the Speaker under Article 124(5) survives the dissolution of the Lok Sabha.
- Whether the Union Government is obliged to provide facilities enabling the Inquiry Committee to discharge its functions despite the dissolution.
- Whether time spent by Judges serving on the Committee should automatically count as their “actual service” without a Presidential notification.
- Whether the Chief Justice of India should be directed to refrain from assigning judicial work to the Judge under inquiry during the pendency of the proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (Sub-Committee on Judicial Accountability)
- The Judge under inquiry should abstain from judicial work to protect public confidence in the Supreme Court; alternatively, the Union Government must be ordered to facilitate the Committee’s work.
- No injury would arise from allowing the Committee to function; if allegations are unfounded, the Judge will be exonerated.
- Because Committee members perform a constitutional duty, their service automatically counts as “actual service”; no Presidential notification is necessary.
- Failure to grant relief would damage the Court’s image and public confidence in its justice.
Union Government's Arguments
- The motion lapsed with the dissolution of the Lok Sabha, leaving nothing further to be done.
- In consequence, no advice was given to the President to issue a notification treating Committee service as “actual service.”
Interveners' Arguments
- They generally support the Government’s view that the motion does not survive dissolution.
- Their own writ petitions raise the same threshold question regarding the motion’s subsistence.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court recognized the constitutional importance of the issues and ordered that the main petition and connected matters be heard “day-to-day” beginning 9 July 1991. Counsel must file written submissions by 1 July 1991, and oral arguments must conclude within ten working days; speaking time will be allocated on 9 July.
The Bench declined to grant interlocutory relief at this stage, emphasizing that this refusal does not reflect any view on the merits and should not impede the Committee if it chooses to proceed. It further restrained any other court from hearing or deciding matters related to the same issues for the duration of the proceedings before the Supreme Court.
Holding and Implications
Interim Order: No interlocutory relief granted; the case will be heard from 9 July 1991 on a day-to-day basis, with a bar on parallel proceedings in other courts.
The immediate effect is an expedited hearing schedule and preservation of the Inquiry Committee’s ability to function. The order is procedural and sets no substantive precedent on the constitutional questions raised.
Order
1. This writ petition is by a body of advocates styled “Sub-Committee on Judicial Accountability” and raises certain questions as to the validity and implementation of the action of the Speaker of the Lok Sabha admitting a notice of motion moved by 108 Members of Parliament under Article 124(5) read with the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 and constituting an Inquiry Committee consisting of a Judge of the Supreme Court, Chief Justice of a High Court and a jurist to investigate into the allegations of misconduct made against a sitting Judge of the Supreme Court pertaining to his conduct as the erstwhile Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court.
2. The main prayers in the writ petition are that the Union Government be directed to afford facilities to the Inquiry Committee to discharge its constitutional and statutory functions; and for directions to the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India to abstain from allocating any judicial work to the concerned Judge during the pendency of the proceedings before the Committee. In regard to the latter prayer that notice should go to the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India, we think that aspect of the matter should be deferred for the present and considered at the appropriate stage of the final hearing. In regard to the directions to the Union Government, the Union Government by means of an affidavit subscribed to by the Joint Secretary, Ministry of Law and Justice, has made manifest its stand that in its view the motion initiated by the 108 Members of Parliament on which the Speaker took the decision to constitute a Committee had lapsed with the dissolution of the Lok Sabha and that nothing further remains to be done in the matter. It is in that view, as averred in the affidavit, that the Government of India did not advise the President to issue any notification as required by Para 9 read with Para 11(b)(i), Part D of Second Schedule to the Constitution enabling the sitting Judge of this Court and the Chief Justice of a High Court to reckon the time spent by them in functioning as members of the Committee as part of their ‘actual service’. The contention of the petitioner is that having regard to the constitutional and statutory obligations of the sitting Judges who function in the Committee, the time spent by them in performance of such function is to be reckoned as part of their ‘actual service’ as judges and no notification under the concerned provisions by the President is necessary.
3. It is relevant to mention here that some of the interveners who seek to oppose the writ petition have, in addition to their stand against the writ petition, also filed individual writ petitions of their own in which, more or less, they seek to endorse the stand taken by the government raising the question as to whether the motion survives the dissolution of the Lok Sabha or not.
4. Shri Shanti Bhushan, learned counsel for the petitioner made an impassioned plea that having regard to the dire need of maintaining public confidence in the apex institution and its reputation it is necessary that the concerned Judge should abstain from discharging judicial functions during the pendency of the enquiry against him. In the alternative, it is submitted that if a direction to that effect is not issued, it should at the least necessarily be directed that pending disposal of the writ petition on merits, the Union of India shall afford to the Committee such facilities as may be necessary for its effective and prompt functioning. Shri Shanti Bhushan submitted that even if ultimately the writ petition fails, no loss or injury would be caused to anybody and what would have resulted would only be that the eminent body of Judges would have occasion to look into the allegations against a sitting Judge and if they found the allegations to be baseless, the concerned Judge would be cleared of the imputations and cloud against his conduct. He urged, if such a direction or interim mandamus is not issued it would seriously impair the image of the court as the apex court in the country and affect the confidence of the people in the quality of justice dispensed by it.
5. We have given our anxious consideration to the matter and having regard to the nature and importance of the issues involved it is appropriate that the main matter along with the connected writ petitions is heard as expeditiously as possible. We, therefore, direct that this matter be listed on July 9, 1991 with a direction that hearing of the matters be proceeded with day-to-day until conclusion. We also indicate that arguments on all sides should be completed within a period of ten working days and the learned counsel for all the parties and interveners should file their written arguments in advance latest by July 1, 1991. The actual hearing time to each of the counsel will be apportioned at the commencement of the hearing on July 9, 1991. In this view of the matter, we think it appropriate not to embark upon an examination of the contentions in support of and the prayer for interlocutory relief.
6. We, however, make it clear that our disinclination to issue any interlocutory orders at this stage shall not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the issues either way and shall not also be construed as an interdiction of the functioning of the Committee if the Committee otherwise considers appropriate to proceed with the matter.
7. We also make it clear that during the pendency of these matters before this Court no proceeding pending or filed hereafter in any other court shall be heard or any order passed therein relating to the issues involved in these matters.
Alert