- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kondiba Rama Papal Shirke (Dead) By His Heirs And Lrs. And Another v. Narayan Kondiba Papal .
Factual and Procedural Background
The High Court, while hearing the plaintiff's appeal, reversed the concurrent decrees of the trial court and the first appellate court. It held that the fact of the plaintiff’s adoption was proved and proceeded to consider its legal validity under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (the “Act”). Relying on a judicially recognised custom in the territory of the former Bombay State permitting adoptions at any age, the High Court upheld the adoption even though the adoptee was about 22 years old at the time. An appeal was thereafter filed challenging the High Court’s decision. The present opinion dismisses that challenge.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an adoption of a person who had completed fifteen years of age is valid under Section 10(iv) of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 when a custom prevails that permits adoption at any age.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Anirudh Jagdeorao v. Babarao Irbaji, AIR 1983 Bom 391 | Affirms the judicial recognition of a custom in the former Bombay State allowing adoption of persons over fifteen years of age. | Used to reinforce the High Court’s conclusion that the plaintiff’s adoption, although of a 22-year-old, was valid. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court endorsed the High Court’s finding that:
- Section 10(iv) of the Act bars adoption of a person over fifteen years unless a “custom or usage” permits it.
- A long-standing, judicially recognised custom in the erstwhile Bombay State allows adoption at any age, even when the adoptee is older than the adopter or is already married.
- Because that custom had already been recognised by prior case-law, it did not need fresh proof in the present matter.
Accepting that analysis, the Court observed that the High Court’s view is “well supported by a long line of decisions,” specifically mentioning the Full Bench ruling in Anirudh Jagdeorao. Finding no error, the Court declined to interfere with the impugned judgment.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED
Consequences: The validity of the plaintiff’s adoption stands affirmed, and the decrees of the courts below remain set aside. No order as to costs was made. The decision does not create new precedent but reinforces existing authority recognising the Bombay-State custom permitting adoptions irrespective of the adoptee’s age.
T.K Thommen, J.— Allowing the plaintiff's appeal and setting aside the decrees of the courts below, the High Court, after finding that the factum of adoption had been established, stated as follows on the question of the validity of the adoption:
“The question then arises, is the adoption legal and valid in law in view of the provisions of the Act? Section 10 of the Act inter alia provides that no person shall be capable of being taken in adoption unless the four conditions therein laid down are fulfilled. We are concerned with the fourth condition and it is as under:
‘(iv) he or she has not completed the age of fifteen years, unless there is a custom or usage applicable to the parties which permits persons who have completed the age of fifteen years being taken in adoption.’
At the time when the plaintiff was adopted he was about 22 years old, but even though there is a difference of opinion between various schools as to the age when a boy may be adopted, so far as the Bombay State is concerned the position is well settled in view of more than one judicial decision. As pointed out in Mulla's Hindu Law (14th edn. at page 550) in the Bombay State a person may be adopted at any age though he may be older than the adopter and though he may be married and have children. The adoption is not invalid although it took place after the thread ceremony of the boy was performed. Thus the custom is judicially recognised in the Bombay State as regards adoption of a child at any age. Once the custom is judicially recognised, it is not required to be independently proved in subsequent cases. The plaintiff and defendant 1 belonged to the area which was part of the old Bombay State and accordingly such a custom prevailed amongst them as regards adoption of a child at any age. Even independently of this position, in the old Bombay State evidence was led of two instances of adoption of persons belonging to the same caste as the plaintiff where a child was adopted at the age above 15 years after the Act came into force. Thus in my opinion, in view of the settled position in law as judicially recognised, if the factum of the adoption is established its validity cannot be challenged on the ground that the adopted child had completed the age of 15 years at the time of his adoption.”
2. This observation of the High Court is well supported by a long line of decisions of that Court including the subsequent decision of the Full Bench of that Court in Anirudh Jagdeorao v. Babarao Irbaji AIR 1983 Bom 391, 1983 Mah LJ 379, 1983 Hindu LR 446. In the circumstances we see no reason to interfere with the impugned judgment. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed. We shall, however, make no order as to costs.
Alert