Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Goa, Daman And Diu Housing Board v. Ramakant V.P Darvotkar .

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 6, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Goa, Daman and Diu Housing Board, entered into four construction contracts with the respondent for building tenements at Vasco-da-Gama, Goa between March 1972 and July 1973. Each contract contained a completion deadline. Despite multiple extensions, the respondent did not finish the work. Relying on clause 3 of the contracts, the Board issued a termination notice on July 1, 1975 and formally rescinded all four contracts on July 31, 1975.

The respondent served a notice disputing the rescission and, after the Board sued for damages in April 1978, invoked the arbitration clause. The Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panaji, stayed the suit, had the arbitration agreement filed in court, and directed the Board to appoint an arbitrator. Shri J. S. Pinto (Retd. Superintending Engineer) was appointed on March 29, 1979 and delivered four separate awards on March 23, 1981, granting the respondent amounts ranging from Rs 46,321.32 to Rs 3,36,230.36.

The Board objected, alleging misconduct and absence of reasons in violation of clause 25 (which required reasons for claims exceeding Rs 50,000). The Civil Judge rejected the objections on August 26, 1981 and made the awards rule of court. On appeal, the Bombay High Court (Panaji Bench) found that the arbitrator had supplied no reasons, held this to be misconduct, and remitted the awards to the arbitrator for reasons under Section 16(1)(c) of the Arbitration Act, 1940. The Board obtained special-leave appeals to the Supreme Court challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether failure by the arbitrator to provide detailed reasons, as required by clause 25 of the contracts, constituted misconduct warranting setting aside of the awards under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.
  2. Whether the High Court was justified in remitting the awards to the arbitrator for recording reasons under Section 16(1)(c) of the Act instead of setting them aside.
  3. Whether, on the face of the awards, sufficient reasoning was already present to satisfy the contractual and statutory requirements.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The arbitrator provided no reasons for awards exceeding Rs 50,000, violating clause 25 and amounting to misconduct.
  • The High Court, having found misconduct, should have set aside the awards under Section 30 rather than remit them for reasons.
  • Sending the awards back to the same arbitrator was “totally unwarranted by law.”

Respondent's Arguments

  • The arbitrator heard both sides, considered documents and issues, and his awards were neither illegal nor improperly procured.
  • The only alleged defect was absence of reasons, which at most justified remission under Section 16(1)(c), not setting aside under Section 30.
  • The arbitrator’s integrity and impartiality were unquestioned; thus, the High Court’s order fell squarely within the court’s power to remit the matter for clarification.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined Section 16(1) of the Arbitration Act, which permits remission only in three specified circumstances. Clause (c) allows remission when an objection to legality is apparent on the face of the award. The Court noted:

  • The High Court labelled the arbitrator’s omission of reasons as misconduct but did not find any bias, unfairness, or procedural impropriety.
  • An inspection of the four awards showed that the arbitrator had “considered all the specific issues” and given “cogent reasons.” Therefore, the premise that no reasons existed was factually incorrect.
  • Because adequate reasoning was present, no illegality appeared on the face of the awards; consequently, Section 16(1)(c) was inapplicable.
  • Absent proven misconduct under Section 30, the awards were valid and should be made rule of the court.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court order set aside; the four arbitral awards are upheld and shall be made rule of the court. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision reinstates the arbitral awards in favour of the respondent and clarifies that an award will not be remitted or set aside merely because a reviewing court subjectively finds the reasoning insufficient; the deficiency must be apparent on the face of the award or amount to misconduct under Section 30. No new legal precedent was expressly established beyond applying existing principles governing remission and misconduct.

Show all summary ...

B.C Ray, J.— The above four appeals on special leave by the appellant were filed against the judgment and order dated February 7, 1983 made by the Panaji Bench of the Bombay High Court in First Civil Appeal Nos. 35.B to 38.B of 1981 disposing of all the four appeals filed by the appellant against the judgment and order of the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panaji, Goa dated August 26, 1981 confirming four different awards by an arbitrator appointed in pursuance to the agreement between the parties. Appeal No. 35 of 1981 relates to the award, awarding to the respondent against the appellant Rs 2,75,091.13. Appeal No. 36 of 1981 relates to an award, awarding to the respondent a sum of Rs 1,88,968.36. Appeal No. 37 of 1981 relates to an award, awarding to the respondent Rs 3,36,230.36 and Appeal No. 38 of 1981 relates to an award, awarding to the respondent Rs 46,321.32.

2. The facts leading to these appeals are as follows:

The appellant Goa, Daman and Diu Housing Board entered into two contracts on March 15, 1972, and one contract each on July 11, 1973 and on July 4, 1973 with the respondent for the construction of tenements at Vasgo-da-Gama, Goa. The appellant accepted two tenders of the respondent on March 9, 1972 and remaining two on February 24, 1973. There was a time-limit in all the aforesaid four contracts for the completion of the work referred to therein. Several extensions were granted to the respondent for completing the work but the respondent failed to complete the construction work undertaken by him under the said four contracts. On July 1, 1975 the appellant issued a notice to the respondent under clause 3 of the said contract for exercising the right of termination in view of the fact that the respondent was unable to fulfil the contractual obligation of completing the contruction work in spite of the various extensions granted to the respondent. On July 14, 1975, the Engineer-in-Charge of the appellant Board exercised its unilateral right of terminating the contract under clause 3 of the agreement in view of the fact that the respondent did not complete the work of construction undertaken by him in spite of various extensions granted to him. On July 31, 1975, the Chairman of the appellant Board confirmed that all the four contracts stood rescinded. On May 17, 1976, the respondent served a notice to the appellant on the ground that the appellant had rescinded the work contracts. The respondent stated therein various reasons why the work could not be completed. Thereafter in April, 1978, the appellant filed a suit claiming damages for a sum of Rs 4,38,786.96 with interest against the respondent in the Court of the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panaji, Goa. Subsequently, an application was filed by the respondent under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act for stay of the suit. Respondent also made another application to the court under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act for directing the Housing Board to file the arbitration agreement in court and in pursuance of clause 25 of the agreement to appoint an arbitrator. Accordingly, the court by its order dated February 28, 1979 had the agreement between the parties filed in court and directed the Housing Board to appoint an arbitrator. On March 29, 1979 Shri J.S Pinto, retired Superintending Engineer was appointed as arbitrator.

3. The arbitrator on March 23, 1981 submitted four awards granting the claims of the respondent as stated hereinbefore on the basis that the appellant was responsible for the slow progress and non-completion of work and the work could not be completed as the contract was terminated by the appellant, the Housing Board. The said award was filed in the Court of Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panaji, by the arbitrator on March 31, 1981 for making the award rule of the court. The appellant submitted his objections for setting aside the awards on April 27, 1981 on the grounds inter alia that the arbitrator had misconducted himself by not framing the main issue i.e whether or not the claimant abandoned the work and thereby committed breach of the agreement. The arbitrator misconducted himself by ignoring the letter of termination wherein it was clearly stated that the termination has been done on account of the abandonment of the work by the claimants; the learned arbitrator failed to decide upon the question of the abandonment of work and has wholly side-tracked the issue; the learned arbitrator misconducted himself by not giving reasons for the award as required under the agreement under which he was appointed.

4. The learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panaji by his order dated August 26, 1981 rejected all the objections raised on behalf of the appellant against the said awards and confirmed the same. All the four impugned awards have been made rule of the court.

5. The appellant thereafter filed the aforesaid First Civil Appeal Nos. 35.B, 36.B, 37.B and 38.B of 1981 against the said order of the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panaji, Goa on the ground that the Civil Judge did not consider that the arbitrator misconducted himself in making the awards without recording any reasons for the same, even though the claim was Rs 50,000 and above as provided in clause 25 of the agreement between the parties and as such the awards should have been set aside by the court.

6. The High Court held that having regard to the clause 25 of the terms of the agreement specifically providing that in all cases where amount of claim in dispute is Rs 50,000 and above the arbitrator was bound to give reasons for his award. The statements that have been made by the arbitrator while giving his findings could not be considered to be the reasoning for his finding of the award. The court also held that:

“The award nowhere contains any reasoning for the same nor does it even obliquely mention that in giving his findings the arbitrator has even sought to adopt the reasoning of either of the parties. In our view as the obligation of the arbitrator under clause 25 of the agreement stands, the reasons should appear to be so in this case.”

7. It was further held that as the arbitrator failed to give reasons for the award it would be a misconduct on his part and the award was liable to be vitiated on that ground. The court allowed all the appeals. The order of the lower court was set aside and the awards were remanded back to the arbitrator for giving reasons for the same as required under clause 25 of the arbitration agreement and thereafter to file the same in the Court of Civil Judge, Panaji, within eight weeks after the order is served on him.

8. Against this judgment and order the impugned appeals by special leave were filed.

9. The learned counsel on behalf of the appellants has contended that the High Court acted illegally in not considering at all that the arbitrator did not record any reasons for making awards allowing the claims each of which exceeds Rs 50,000 as provided under clause 25 of the arbitration agreement and as such the arbitrator has misconducted himself in the proceedings and instead of sending the awards made by the arbitrator to him for recording his reasons ought to have set aside the awards under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act. It has also been contended that the High Court though it held that the arbitrator was guilty of misconduct and the awards made by him were liable to be vitiated on that ground yet in spite of setting aside the awards they were sent to the arbitrator for recording reasons which is totally unwarranted by law.

10. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent, on the other hand, submitted that the awards made by the arbitrator after hearing the parties cannot be said to be illegal or unwarranted as the same were made after considering all papers and documents filed by the parties and after duly hearing the parties. As such there was no illegality nor any misconduct committed in making the awards. The arbitrator has fairly considered the issues and made the awards in question. The misconduct, if any, on the part of the arbitrator does not concern with the probity and impartiality of the arbitrator. The only allegation against the arbitrator is that he has not recorded the reasons for the awards made by him as per term of clause 25 of the arbitration agreement. It has, therefore, been contended by the learned counsel on behalf of the respondent that the order of the High Court in remanding the awards to the arbitrator for recording reasons clearly falls within the purview of Section 16(1)(c) of the Arbitration Act, 1940 as the objection to the legality of the award is apparent on the face of it. It does not fall within the provision of Section 30 of the said Act inasmuch as the arbitrator has not misconducted himself or the proceedings and the awards in question have not been improperly procured. Several decisions have been cited at the bar in support of the respective contentions advanced by the counsel for the parties.

11. Before considering the question whether the directions made by the High Court in remitting the award to the arbitrator for giving reasons do fall within the purview of Section 16 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, it is appropriate to set out the relevant provisions of Section 16(1):

“16.(1) The Court may from time to time remit the award or any matter referred to arbitration to the arbitrators or umpire for reconsideration upon such terms as it thinks fit—

(a) where the award has left undetermined any of the matters referred to arbitration, or where it determines any matter not referred to arbitration and such matter cannot be separated without affecting the determination of the matters referred; or

(b) where the award is so indefinite as to be incapable of execution; or

(c) where an objection to the legality of the award is apparent upon the face of it.”

12. Section 16 empowers the court to remit the award to the arbitrator for reconsideration only in three cases specified therein. Clause (c) of Section 16(1) provides that the award shall be remitted to the arbitrator by the court where an objection to the legality of the award is apparent on the face of it. Of course, the High Court has come to a finding that the arbitrator was guilty of misconduct for his failure to give reasons as required. There is, however, nothing to show that the arbitrator misconducted himself or the proceedings in any other manner nor there is anything to show that the awards have been improperly procured. There is no allegation, far less, any finding, that the arbitrator was biased or unfair or he has not heard both the parties or he has not fairly considered the submissions of the parties in making the awards in question. In our opinion, it is evident from the four awards made by the arbitrator that the arbitrator has considered all the specific issues raised by the parties in the arbitration proceedings and came to his finding after giving cogent reasons. The above awards cannot under any circumstances be considered to be made by the arbitrator without recording any reasons for the same. Therefore, in such circumstances, it is not proper to hold that the arbitrator has misconducted himself or in the proceedings in the matter of giving the awards.

13. In these circumstances, we are unable to hold that the four awards made by the arbitrator are bad for not recording reasons. We, therefore, uphold the said awards and we do not think it necessary to decide the question as regards the scope of Section 30 or Section 16 of the Arbitration Act. The decision of the High Court remitting the awards back to the arbitrator for giving reasons is set aside and the awards made by the arbitrator are upheld. Let these awards be made rule of the court. The appeals are, therefore, allowed as aforestated. There will be no order as to costs.