- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Director Of Enforcement v. New Central Jute Mills Co. Ltd., Calcutta .
Factual and Procedural Background
The matter concerns an appeal by special leave directed against an order of the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court dated April 28, 1978, which disposed of an appeal under Section 54 of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947.
The High Court held that there had been a violation of Section 5(1)(a) of the Act, affirmed the conclusion warranting imposition of penalty, but reduced the penalty amount from Rs 2,50,000 to Rs 25,000 in view of “extenuating circumstances on record.” The High Court also directed refund of the balance amount already deposited (Rs 2,25,000) by cheque in favour of M/s Khaitan & Co., advocate-on-record for the appellant, and made an order regarding costs and drawing up of the order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Where an appeal under Section 54 of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947 lies to the High Court on a question of law, whether the High Court, while agreeing with the merits (i.e., affirming the finding of violation), can examine and reduce the quantum of penalty.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that although the special leave order did not indicate the point for which leave was granted, counsel for the appellant stated that leave related to the question whether, in a Section 54 appeal (described as an appeal to the High Court on a question of law), the High Court could reduce the “fine”/penalty while agreeing with the merits.
Even assuming the appellant’s submission to be correct in the form presented, the Court rejected the broader proposition that the nature of the statutory appeal would bar the High Court’s jurisdiction to examine the justification for the quantum of penalty. The Court reasoned that “the main matter along with the penalty fused into one” such that the entire matter became the subject matter of appeal; accordingly, the appellate court would be entitled to deal with both the finding on violation and the penalty aspect “in accordance with law.”
The Court further supported this conclusion by referring to the statutory scheme: Section 52(3) confers on the first appellate authority (the Appellate Board) jurisdiction to modify orders subjected to appeal. The High Court, as the second appellate authority under Section 54, was held to be assumed to have the same powers as the first appellate authority, in the absence of any specific bar.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED: The appeal was dismissed, with no order as to costs.
As a direct consequence, the Calcutta High Court’s order stands: the finding of violation of Section 5(1)(a) remains affirmed and the reduced penalty of Rs 25,000 (instead of Rs 2,50,000) remains operative, along with the direction to refund the balance amount deposited as recorded in the High Court’s order. The opinion does not indicate any broader implications beyond upholding the High Court’s authority (in the absence of a specific bar) to examine and modify the quantum of penalty in such an appeal.
Order
1. The appeal is by special leave and is directed against the order of the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court disposing of an appeal under Section 54 of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947, dated April 28, 1978. The order being very brief is extracted below:
“Having taken into consideration the relevant facts and the circumstances of this case, we are of opinion that there has been a violation of Section 5(1)(a) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947, but in view of the extenuating circumstances on record, we reduce the amount of penalty payable by the appellant to the respondent to the sum of Rs 25,000 (Rupees twenty-five thousand only). The refund to the appellant the balance of the penalty, namely, a sum of Rs 2,25,000 (Rupees two lakhs and twenty-five thousand only) already deposited, by a cheque drawn in favour of M/s Khaitan & Co. advocate-on-record for the appellant. The cheque is to be made over to the said (sic).
The appellant is to pay the respondent the cost copy minutes of this order upon the usual undertaking of the said advocates-on-record for the appellant to have this order to be drawn up, completed and filed.”
2. It appears from this order that the conclusion reached for imposing the penalty was affirmed by the High Court but the quantum of penalty which was Rs 2,50,000 (Rupees two lakhs and fifty thousand) was reduced to Rs 25,000 in the special facts of the case. Though at the time leave was granted the point on which such leave was given has not been indicated, counsel for the appellant tells us that it was for the consideration of the correctness of the submission that when under Section 54 of the Act an appeal lies to the High Court on a question of law, would it be open to the High Court while agreeing with the merit of the matter to reduce the fine. Conceding that this submission is correct we are not prepared to accept the position that a statutory appeal of the type in question would bar the jurisdiction of the High Court while dealing with it to examine the justification for the quantum of penalty. The main matter along with the penalty fused into one and the entire matter became the subject matter of appeal. Obviously the appellate court would be entitled to deal with both these aspects in accordance with law.
3. Section 52(3) confers on the first appellate authority which is the Appellate Board jurisdiction to modify orders which are subjected to appeal. The High Court being the second appellate authority under Section 54 must be assumed to have the same powers as conferred on the first appellate authority in the absence of any specific bar.
4. The appeal is dismissed. No costs.
Alert