Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

India Cements Ltd. v. Collector Of Central Excise .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 25, 1989
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a manufacturer of superfine cement, paid Rs 22,43,002.09 as excise duty on the cost of packing material for the period 4 July 1974 – 1 March 1975. Contending that this amount was paid “under protest,” the company sought a refund. The Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Tirunelveli, rejected the claim, invoking the six-month limitation in Rule 11 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, on the ground that the payment had not been made under protest. The Appellate Collector of Customs and Central Excise upheld this decision on 7 February 1981, explicitly noting that the merits of the refund claim were not in dispute. The Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (CEGAT) also dismissed the appeal on 25 July 1984, again solely on the question of limitation. The present appeal challenges those concurrent findings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant’s letter dated 11 June 1974 constituted a valid protest, thereby exempting the refund claim from the six-month limitation period under Rule 11 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944.
  2. If the payment was indeed under protest, whether the appellant is entitled to a refund of Rs 22,43,002.09 with consequential relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The letter of 11 June 1974, which raised comprehensive objections to the levy on packing charges, amounted to a formal protest.
  • A revisional decision of the Central Government in Birla Cement Works (31 December 1980) had already recognised that packing costs for superfine cement should not be included in assessable value; therefore, the merits of the refund were indisputable.
  • Trade Notice No. 232/79 dated 29 October 1979 from the Madras Collectorate likewise confirmed that packing costs were not dutiable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The payment was not made under protest; hence, the refund claim was time-barred under Rule 11.
  • Even if the letter were treated as a protest, the Trade Notice of 29 October 1979 could not apply retrospectively; therefore, the case, if reopened, should return to the Tribunal for examination of other issues.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Birla Cement Works (Central Government revisional order, 31-12-1980) Cost of packing for superfine cement should not be added to assessable value. Used to demonstrate that, on merits, the department itself had accepted identical claims; thus no dispute on substantive entitlement to refund.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the contents of the appellant’s letter dated 11 June 1974 and found that it raised “all possible contentions” against including packing charges in assessable value. The Court held that an ordinary reading of the letter made it clear that the appellant “was not accepting the liability without protest.” Given the absence of a prescribed form for protests at the relevant time, the letter qualified as a valid protest. Consequently, the six-month limitation in Rule 11 did not apply.

The Court rejected the respondent’s request to remand the matter for consideration of the Trade Notice, noting that:

  • The Central Government’s decision in Birla Cement Works had already resolved the substantive issue nationwide.
  • The departmental authorities below had conceded that only limitation, not the merits, was in controversy.

Accordingly, once limitation was held inapplicable, the appellant’s entitlement to refund followed inevitably.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed. The orders of the Assistant Collector, the Appellate Collector, and the CEGAT are set aside. The appellant is entitled to a refund of Rs 22,43,002.09, with interest at 6% per annum from the date of refusal of refund, and costs of Rs 10,000.

Implications: The decision clarifies that a protest need not follow a specific form if it clearly communicates objection to the duty; payments made under such a protest are exempt from Rule 11’s limitation period. The ruling offers direct relief to the appellant but does not establish new legal doctrine beyond reinforcing the principle that substance prevails over form in determining a “payment under protest.”

Show all summary ...

G.L Oza, J.— This appeal involves the determination of the only question as to whether the appellant is entitled to refund of Rs 22,43,002.09 paid as excise duty on the price of packing material used for packing of superfine cement which according to the appellant was paid under protest whereas according to the respondent, it was not paid under protest and therefore, the claim of refund is barred by time.

2. The brief facts necessary for determination are:

“The appellant Company is a manufacturer of superfine cement. The company preferred the claim for refund of Rs 22,43,002.09 alleged to be duty on price of packing material of the aforesaid product paid during 4-7-1974 to 1-3-1975.”

3. This claim of refund was rejected by Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Tirunelveli on the ground that Rule 11 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 was applicable as duty was not paid under protest and the claim was barred by time. On appeal, the Appellate Collector of Customs and Central Excise by the judgment dated 7-2-1981 maintained the order passed by the Assistant Collector on the same ground of limitation, as the merits of the claim was not disputed by the department. This is clear from the following observations in the Appellate Collector's order:

“They based their claim on the Trade Notice No. 232/79 dated 29-10-1979 of Madras Collectorate declaring that the said cement is not the variety of cement requiring packing to prevent deterioration, and the cost of packing of such cement is not liable to be included in the assessable value. The ground on which the claim was made is not disputed in this appeal.”

4. Thereafter, the appellant unsuccessfully approached the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal. Before the Tribunal also, only the question of limitation was put against the appellant. The Tribunal by its order dated 25-7-1984 has stated:

“Before us, the only question argued was the question of limitation. It was urged that the letter dated 11-6-1974 amounted to a protest so that the period of limitation prescribed in Rule 11 of the Rules ceased to be applicable.”

5. The Tribunal also took the view that the letter dated 11-6-1974 was not a protest to save the period of limitation.

6. Hence this appeal.

7. We heard learned counsel for parties. It is not in dispute that the duty was paid for the period from 4-7-1974 to 1-3-1975. If it was paid under protest, the orders of the authorities cannot be sustained. It is, therefore, necessary to refer to the contents of the letter dated 11-6-1974. The letter raised many objections against the levy of packing charges. It was stated that the duty on packing charges on superfine cement was not leviable. The appellant finally said:

“If the department feels that the duty is leviable on packing charges, we have no option, but to suggest the rates fixed by the Government of India from quarter to quarter, as packing charges.”

8. The counsel also referred to us the decision of the Central Government in the case of Birla Cement Works where a similar claim was allowed by order dated 31-12-1980. Counsel further referred to us the Trade Notice dated 29-10-1979 issued by the Collectorate, Madras wherein it was clearly indicated that the costs of packing was not liable to be included in the assessable value.

9. Learned Additional Solicitor General frankly conceded that at the material time, there was no particular form prescribed for protesting against the levy or paying under protest. He also contended that if the letter is treated as a protest and the payments are held to be payments under protest then the limitation prescribed under Rule 11 admittedly would not be applicable, but the Trade Notice issued by the Madras Collectorate on 29-10-1979 could not be given retrospective effect and, therefore, the matter should go back to the Tribunal for disposal on other questions.

10. We gave our anxious considerations to the rival submissions. A perusal of the letter dated 11-6-1974 clearly shows that all possible contentions which could be raised against the levy of duty on the value of packing material were raised. If this could not be said to be a protest one fails to understand what else it could be. It does not require much time to analyse the contents of the letter. An ordinary reading with common sense will reveal to anybody that the appellant was not accepting the liability without protest. We have no hesitation to hold that the letter was in the nature of protest. That being the position, the question of limitation does not arise for refund of the duty.

11. It is rather strange that learned Additional Solicitor General wants the matter to go back to the Tribunal for considering the effect of Trade Notice. The Central Government in their revisional order dated 31-12-1980 in the case of Birla Cement Works gave the benefit without any Trade Notice. There it was observed:

“In the circumstances Government accepted the petitioner's plea and observed that superfine cement is nothing other than ordinary portland which is ground to a very high fineness of not less than 3500 CM 2.gm and that this higher fineness does not lead to its deterioration without packing. The Government, therefore, accept the contention of the petitioners and hold that the impugned goods being capable of being sold without packing like ordinary grey portland cement the cost of packing for superfine cement should not be added to the assessable value.”

12. The authorities ought to have extended the view taken by the Central Government in the case of Birla Cement Works to all similar cases. Moreover, the Appellate Collector and the Tribunal clearly stated that the only question agitated before them was the question of limitation. The order does not indicate that the counsel for the department or the departmental representative raised any other question on merits. Indeed no objection could have been raised on the merits of the matter in view of the order of the Central Government in the Birla Cement Works.

13. In these circumstances, the appeal is allowed, the orders passed by the Tribunal and other authorities are set aside. It is declared that the appellant is entitled to refund of the amount. The appellant shall be paid interest at the rate of six per cent from the date of refusal of refund with costs of this appeal quantified at Rs 10,000.