Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Orissa And Another v. Dr. Asim Kumar Mohanty And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 24, 1989
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government of Orissa issued a Prospectus for admission to a two-year in-service postgraduate medical course for the 1988-1989 session. Out of 113 total seats, 17 were reserved for Scheduled Caste (SC) candidates and 6 for Scheduled Tribe (ST) candidates. Sixty-nine seats were classified as “general seats” reserved for in-service doctors of the Government of Orissa.

The Prospectus stipulated that if reserved seats remained unfilled, they would revert to the general category. Thirteen of the 23 SC/ST seats went unfilled and therefore reverted. The State Government, however, diverted 8 of those 13 seats to in-service doctors employed by the Government of India or its public-sector undertakings (PSUs). Three Orissa in-service doctors challenged this diversion by separate writ petitions before the Orissa High Court.

On 3 August 1988 the High Court held that the 8 seats should have been added to the general category meant exclusively for in-service doctors of the Government of Orissa and directed that the writ-petitioners be admitted. The State appealed to the Supreme Court by special leave; those appeals are the subject of the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under the Prospectus governing admissions, SC/ST seats that revert to the general category may be allocated to in-service doctors of the Government of India/its PSUs rather than to in-service doctors of the Government of Orissa.
  2. Whether the selection of eight Government-of-India doctors could be justified on the ground of higher merit despite the Prospectus provisions.
  3. Whether the High Court erred in granting relief to the writ-petitioners without impleading the eight already-admitted doctors.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant State of Orissa

  • Produced the merit list and contended that the eight Government-of-India doctors had higher marks than the respondents and were selected on merit.
  • Invoked paragraph 5.3.3 of the Prospectus, arguing that candidates could apply for both reserved and general seats, implying the eight doctors were eligible for general seats.
  • Asserted that because the eight doctors were not impleaded before the High Court, their admissions should remain undisturbed; further, wait-listed candidates allegedly had higher marks than the respondents.

Respondent In-Service Doctors of Government of Orissa

  • Challenged the diversion of the 8 reverted SC/ST seats, contending that the Prospectus restricted “general seats” to in-service doctors of the Government of Orissa.
  • Maintained that the impugned admissions violated the Prospectus and that they were entitled to those seats.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s interpretation of the Prospectus:

  • Construction of Paras 5.3 and 5.5: The Prospectus fixed 69 general seats exclusively for in-service doctors of the Government of Orissa. When reserved seats remained vacant, para 5.5 mandated that they “will be filled up by general candidates,” meaning they merged with the 69 general seats.
  • Meaning of “General Seat”: The term was not separately defined; therefore, the logical reading was that a general seat inheres in the same category described in para 5.3—i.e., Orissa in-service doctors. The High Court’s analysis on this point was “unassailable.”
  • Invalidity of State’s Merit Argument: Even if the eight Government-of-India doctors scored higher, they were not eligible for general seats because eligibility was confined to Orissa in-service doctors. Hence, para 5.3.3 could not legitimize their admissions.
  • Non-impleadment of Selected Candidates: The objection was raised for the first time in the Supreme Court and lacked force. The academic session was already over, none of the wait-listed candidates pressed their claims, and equity favored finality.
  • Accordingly, the Court found no error in the High Court’s directive to admit the two remaining writ-petitioners (one had already been admitted).

Holding and Implications

Appeals Dismissed; High Court Judgment Affirmed.

Consequences include:

  • The two respondent doctors are entitled to admission in the 1988-1989 postgraduate course.
  • The State must implement the High Court’s order within one week of the Supreme Court’s judgment; contempt proceedings pending in the High Court are deemed closed based on the State’s undertaking and respondents’ consent.
  • The appellants must pay consolidated costs of ₹3,000 to the respondents. No new precedent was set; the ruling turns on the specific language of the Prospectus.
Show all summary ...

Ranganath Misra, J.— These are two appeals by special leave and are directed against a common judgment of the Orissa High Court dated 3-8-1988, whereby the High Court directed the two respondents and another to be admitted to the two years in-service medical postgraduate course for the session 1988-1989.

2. The Prospectus published by the State Government indicated that the total number of seats were 113 out of which 17 seats were reserved for Scheduled Castes candidates while 6 were so reserved for Scheduled Tribe candidates. Para 5.3 of the Prospectus indicated the various classifications and it was stated therein: “number of general seats to be filled up by inservice doctors of Government of Orissa is 69”.

3. The note under para 1.2 of the Prospectus defined “inservice doctor” as “one who is in the employment of the Government of Orissa, Government of Orissa Public Sector Undertakings and other organisations under the Orissa Government and Government of India. This includes all categories of employment like ad hoc, temporary, contract, regular or substantive on the date of application.” Para 5.5 laid down that in case of non-availability of candidates for any of the reserved seats, the same will be filled up by general candidates. As against the 23 seats reserved for Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe candidates, 10 were available and 13, therefore, were to revert to the general category.

4. Six (sic sixty-nine) seats, as it appears from para 5.3, were originally reserved for candidates belonging to public sector undertakings and other organisations of Government of Orissa and Medical Officers who are permanent residents of Orissa and serving under Government of India and their public sector undertakings. When 13 seats became available the State Government allotted 8 out of them to in-service doctors under Government of India and their public sector undertakings. Three of the candidates who were in-service doctors of Government of Orissa challenged the diversion of 8 out of the 13 reserved seats to Government of India and their public sector undertakings by filing separate writ petitions. The High Court considered the provisions of the Prospectus and the respective stands taken by the parties before it and ultimately held that the 8 reserved seats which reverted to the general category could not have been filled up by the inservice doctors under Government of India or their public sector undertakings.

5. The conclusion of the High Court is unassailable. The combined effect of the provisions contained in paras 5.3 and 5.5 of the Prospectus is that 69 out of the 113 seats were intended to be filled up by inservice doctors of Government of Orissa and these were the general seats. When reservation made for any of the categories indicated in para 5.3 in respect of 44 out of the total 113 seats did not work out and any seat remained unfilled, such seat was to be treated as a general seat coming within the last group in para 5.3 of the Prospectus. “General seat” having not been explained or defined anywhere in the Prospectus, the High Court was right in its analysis and conclusion. Of the 13 seats which came from the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe categories, therefore, would have come to the in-service doctors of Government of Orissa and the number of 69 in the Prospectus should have gone up to 82. The State Government having bound itself by the terms of the Prospectus was not justified in allotting 8 out of the 13 seats to a category other than the general category.

6. Counsel for the appellant State produced before us the merit list prepared in terms of the Prospectus and contended that the 8 candidates had secured more marks than the respondents and had been selected on the basis of their own respective merit apart from being allottees under a specified category. He referred to para 5.3.3 of the Prospectus to support this submission. That paragraph states that candidates claiming eligibility for admission to reserved seats specified in paras 5.2 and 5.3 may apply for only one reserved category of seat as well as for general seats. This submission has got to be rejected as unsustainable in view of the fact that none of the 8 doctors who secured admission on the basis of the impugned government order was qualified to apply for a seat in the general category.

7. Counsel for the State contended that the High Court has not disturbed the admission of the 8 doctors in terms of the government order as they were not impleaded in the proceedings before the High Court. Of the three candidates who went before the High Court challenging the government order, one has already been given admission by the Government and, therefore, the question of admission of the remaining two candidates is in issue. According to appellants' counsel, a waiting list had been drawn up in the various specialities and the candidate included in such list had secured higher marks than the two candidates before us. Therefore, they could not be preferred to the candidates in the waiting list. This contention appears not to have been placed before the High Court and has been raised for the first time in the present forum at the time of argument. The time for admission into the particular academic session is long over and none of the wait-listed candidates came forward to press his or her claim. Though ordinarily the more meritorious candidates, if there were any, would have been entitled to preference over the respondents, in the circumstances stated we are not of the view that the objection raised by the State has any force.

8. The appeals fail and the decision of the High Court stands affirmed. The respondents shall be entitled to their costs of the appeals. Consolidated hearing fee is assessed at Rs 3000.

9. Before we part with the appeals, we would like to notice the fact that contempt action is pending in the High Court on the allegation that the appellants have failed to implement the direction of the High Court. Counsel for the State has stated to us that the order of the High Court shall be given effect to within a week from pronouncement of our order and in view of such statement, respondents' counsel made a statement in course of the hearing that the contempt action in the High Court need not be pursued. In these circumstances, the contempt proceedings before the High Court shall be taken as closed.