- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jwala Devi v. Sub-Inspector Bhoop Singh And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, an elderly woman, filed Criminal Writ Petition No. 370 of 1987 before the Delhi High Court alleging that on 15 July 1987 certain police officers entered her house, assaulted and tortured her, outraged her modesty, and paraded her outside after smearing black shoe-polish on her face. The High Court refused relief, stating it was “not appropriate to give any finding of facts” in view of sharply conflicting versions, and advised the petitioner to pursue other proceedings.
The petitioner sought special leave to appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution. On 2 May 1988 the Supreme Court directed the Sessions Judge, Delhi, to conduct an inquiry. Additional Sessions Judge K.P. Verma took evidence from both sides and reported on 1 October 1988 that the petitioner “appears to have made a hill out of a molehill.” Dissatisfied with what it considered a mechanical and negative approach in that report, the Supreme Court reviewed the entire material itself before deciding the present application.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, despite conflicting factual claims, the Supreme Court should grant any relief to the petitioner under Article 136 against the Delhi High Court’s refusal to do so.
- Whether the materials produced before the Court justify compensation or other remedial orders against the Delhi Administration and police officials.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner, an aged lady, was subjected to physical assault, humiliation, and indignity by police officers acting in a high-handed and irresponsible manner.
- Such misconduct by public officers mandated punishment and redress.
Respondents' Position
- The allegations were emphatically disputed; the respondents contended that the petitioner exaggerated events (“made a hill out of a molehill”).
- They suggested that the petitioner's son, a warder at Tihar Jail, and others were involved in illicit drug trafficking, giving the police a legitimate reason to act firmly.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted substantial evidentiary conflicts. It found the inquiry report’s assessment overly mechanical and undertook its own review, yet concluded that disengaging truth from embellishment was as difficult for it as it had been for the High Court. The Justices accepted that “perhaps an incident” supported by police occurred and that the petitioner had been adversely affected, but they could not definitively affirm the full scope of her allegations without prejudicing other pending proceedings.
Recognising both the likelihood of some police excess and the impossibility of making precise findings, the Court determined that a modest monetary award was appropriate to cover the petitioner’s costs rather than to validate her factual claims. It explicitly stated that the payment should not influence outcomes in any related or pending cases.
Holding and Implications
Held: The special leave petition is disposed of with a direction that the Delhi Administration pay the petitioner Rs 5,000 within four weeks.
Implications: The award compensates the petitioner for expenses incurred in pursuing the proceedings but does not constitute a finding on the truth of her allegations or on police misconduct. The decision sets no new precedent and is expressly not to be relied upon in any other pending litigation.
Ranganath Misra, J.— This is an application under Article 136 of the Constitution and is directed against the order of the Delhi High Court in Criminal Writ Petition No. 370 of 1987 dismissing it by saying:
“In view of the rival versions and contentions, we consider it not appropriate to give any finding of facts. The petitioner, if so advised, can take appropriate steps but in the present petition, no relief can be granted.”
2. The petitioner alleged that the respondents entered into her house in the afternoon of 15-7-1987, and physically assaulted her, subjected her to torture in various ways and even outraged her modesty and paraded her in the street after rubbing black shoe polish on her face. The allegations made in the writ petition were seriously disputed and the High Court found it difficult in the face of such challenge to come to any conclusion and, therefore, relegated the petitioner to any other proceeding. This order of the High Court has been assailed in this application for special leave.
3. By order dated 2-5-1988, this Court required the Sessions Judge of Delhi either by himself or through an Additional Sessions Judge under his control to hold an enquiry into the allegations made in the petition and after ascertaining the correctness of the facts to make a report to this Court. The Inquiry Judge was authorised to receive evidence. After some adjournments granted by this Court, the report dated 1-10-1988, was received from Shri K.P Verma, Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi. Several witnesses were examined before him on either side and a good number of documents were produced. After discussing the material in a somewhat mechanical manner, the learned Inquiry Judge came to the conclusion that the ‘petitioner appears to have made a hill out of a molehill’. On reading the report, we formed the impression that the approach of the Inquiry Judge was negative and the mechanical manner in which he made his assessment was perhaps not the right way to treat the matter. With a view to assuring ourselves that the cause of justice does not suffer we required Mr Bana, counsel for the petitioner to place before us the entire material which was available to the learned Additional Sessions Judge, and an analytical submission by counsel. That has been done and we have looked into the papers.
4. Mr Bana has particularly contended that the petitioner, who is an aged lady, has been very badly treated and the public officers whose main job is to maintain law and order have conducted themselves in a very high-handed and irresponsible manner and should be punished. We have acquainted ourselves with the broad aspects of the materials and the stand taken by the respondents. It is difficult for us, as it was for the High Court, to come to any definite conclusion regarding the correctness of the allegations of the petitioner. It is perhaps true that some incident did happen for which the petitioner could genuinely make grievance but the same seems to have been mixed up inextricably with embellishments and, therefore, it has become difficult for the Additional Sessions Judge to disengage truth from embellishments and it has been equally difficult for us to do so. There can be no two opinions that if the allegations as made by the petitioner are true, the public officers must deserve condemnation without any limitation for the dastardly acts. In case there is a ring of truth in the defence plea that the petitioner's son who was then working as Warder in the Tihar Jail and some other persons were engaged or associated with illicit traffic in drugs referred to in the report, the police perhaps had justification to tighten its attitude. The purpose of this inquiry cannot be to find out whether there has been some element of excess or impropriety for which the petitioner would deserve compensation.
5. We are told by counsel of both sides that several other proceedings including the one taken by the petitioner pursuant to the High Court's order are pending. We find it embarrassingly difficult to express any view in a positive way as the pending proceedings are likely to be prejudiced.
6. Yet, we reiterate what has already been said, namely, that there was perhaps an incident which but for the police support would have been difficult to be done. The petitioner has been to that extent affected in the facts and circumstances of the case and the manner in which the proceeding has gone on, we think it appropriate that the petitioner should be awarded a sum of Rs 5000 to be paid by the Delhi Administration. This amount should be paid to her within four weeks. We make it explicitly clear that award of this amount to the petitioner may not be taken as a material to support the stand that allegations of the petitioner were true, or that the police officers had misconducted themselves and the pending cases should not be disposed of one way or the other by relying upon what we have said. The amount of Rs 5000 which we have fixed should be taken as a payment to meet the costs of the petitioner in the proceeding taken by her and not in vindication of the stand she had taken in the court below or before us or in the inquiry.
7. Beyond what we have said above, we do not propose to make any other order in this special leave petition. We direct its disposal on the above terms.
Alert