Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tara Singh (Since Deceased) Through Lrs. And Others v. Kehar Singh And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Mar 31, 1989
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Smt. Bhagwani, widow of Sunder Singh, owned 88 bighas 14 biswas in Village Bathan Kalan and another parcel allotted to her in substitution of Khasra No. 1086. In 1914 she mortgaged the first parcel to Chuhar Singh, Mita Singh and Lachman Singh for Rs 2,000. Their mortgage rights were assigned to Waryam Singh in 1919; the present appellants are Waryam Singh’s heirs (Defendants 1–4). The second parcel was mortgaged to Ballaura Singh (Defendant 5).

Bhagwani died intestate in 1960. With no heirs, her property escheated to the State of Punjab and the revenue records were mutated accordingly. In 1968 the Collector, acting under the Nazool Lands Transfer Rules 1956, allotted both parcels to the respondents/plaintiffs, directing them to deposit Rs 2,230 and Rs 743 to redeem the respective mortgages. After deposit, the Collector issued warrants of possession. The respondents initially obtained possession but Defendants 1–4 regained it through a suit for injunction. Consequently, the respondents filed the present suit for possession.

The trial court rejected all defences, ordered re-deposit of the mortgage amount in court, and decreed possession to the respondents. The first appellate court affirmed. The High Court, though doubting the applicability of the 1956 Rules, upheld the decree on the basis that the respondents had a statutory charge under Section 55(6)(b) TPA and could redeem under Section 91. Defendants 1–4 obtained special-leave and appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Nazool Lands Transfer Rules 1956 applied to Village Bathan Kalan after its transfer to Punjab in 1950, and if not, whether the Collector’s allotment conveyed any title to the respondents.
  2. Whether, in the absence of a registered conveyance or agreement of sale, the respondents could be treated as “buyers” entitled to a charge under Section 55(6)(b) of the Transfer of Property Act for the amount deposited.
  3. Whether the respondents, as charge-holders (if so found), were entitled under Section 91 TPA to redeem a usufructuary mortgage and obtain possession from the appellants.
  4. Whether the appellants could resist redemption on the ground that the land had not validly escheated to the State or that the respondents were required to sue as simple mortgagees.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • Because the 1956 Pepsu Rules were inapplicable after 1950, the Collector’s allotment conveyed no title; therefore the respondents lacked standing to redeem or seek possession.
  • Without a registered sale deed—or at least a valid agreement of sale—the respondents were not “buyers” and could not claim a statutory charge under Section 55(6)(b) TPA.
  • At best the respondents were simple mortgagees who should have sued to sell the hypotheca rather than for direct possession, citing Muhammad Usan Rowthan v. Abdulla.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The appellants had enjoyed the land for nearly 70 years for a nominal payment; equity demanded redemption and possession in favour of the State’s allottees from the weaker sections.
  • Upon escheat, the State stepped into the shoes of the mortgagor and could either redeem directly or authorise its allottees to do so; the Collector’s allotment and warrants of possession validly empowered the respondents.
  • The appellants’ reliance on lack of registered conveyance was technical; the doctrine of promissory estoppel protected the respondents’ allotment and charge.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shankri v. Milkha Singh, AIR 1941 Lah 407 Section 55(6)(b) TPA applies in Punjab on the basis of justice, equity and good conscience. Used to justify extending the statutory charge concept to Punjab, enabling the respondents to rely on Section 55(6)(b) despite the Act’s non-application to the State.
Nadoda Khima Keshar v. Bombay State, ILR 1967 Guj 323 A purchaser who acquires property in contravention of statutory prohibition is not a “buyer” and gains no charge under Section 55(6)(b). Distinguished: unlike the Gujarat case, there was no statutory bar to the State’s allotment to the respondents.
Dnyanu Baba Chobe v. Gulab Eknath Bhais, (1960) 62 Bom LR 940 An agreement of sale invalidated by statutory tenant-purchase rights confers no charge under Section 55(6)(b). Distinguished: here, no statutory tenant-purchase rights impeded the State’s allotment; therefore the charge could arise.
Muhammad Usan Rowthan v. Abdulla, ILR 1901 24 Mad 171 Remedies of a simple mortgagee are limited to sale of hypotheca before seeking possession. Rejected: the Court held the respondents were transferees of the mortgagor (State), not simple mortgagees, so the precedent was inapplicable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court agreed that the Pepsu Rules 1956 did not govern Bathan Kalan after its 1950 transfer to Punjab, but held that this did not exhaust the State’s power. Because Bhagwani died without heirs, title had vested in the State by escheat. As owner and successor-mortgagor, the State unquestionably possessed the right to redeem the usufructuary mortgages.

The key issue became whether the State could authorise its nominee to effect redemption and obtain possession. The Court answered “yes” for three reasons:

  1. Allotment and Warrants of Possession: The Collector’s order and warrants conferred possessory rights on the respondents. Even if procedurally defective, they created expectations the State was bound to honour.
  2. Promissory Estoppel: These governmental assurances estopped the State from denying the respondents’ entitlement. Consequently, the respondents acquired an equitable interest tantamount to that of buyers.
  3. Statutory Charge and Redemption Rights: Having deposited the price-cum-redemption money, the respondents fell within the principle of Section 55(6)(b) TPA, which, by Shankri, applies in Punjab on equitable grounds. As charge-holders they could invoke Section 91 to redeem the mortgages.

The Court dismissed the appellants’ argument that only a registered conveyance or agreement could create buyer-status; equitable principles sufficed. It further rejected reliance on Gujarat and Bombay precedents as factually and legally distinguishable, and clarified that the respondents were not simple mortgagees but transferees of the equity of redemption.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.

Consequently, the decree for possession in favour of the respondents stands affirmed; the appellants must surrender the mortgaged land upon receipt of the redemption money. The ruling re-emphasises the applicability of Section 55(6)(b) TPA in Punjab on equitable grounds and recognises promissory estoppel as sufficient to vest equitable buyer-rights in government allottees, but it does not create a new precedent beyond the specific factual matrix.

Show all summary ...

S. Natarajan, J.— This appeal by special leave by the defendants is directed against a judgment of the High Court affirming the decree for possession passed by the trial court and the first appellate court in favour of the respondents/plaintiffs.

2. An extent of 88 bighas and 14 biswas of land in Village Bathan Kalan belonged to one Smt Bhagwani, widow of Sunder Singh. Besides the said land she owned another item of land also which was allotted to her in substitution of her land bearing Khasra No. 1086. Smt Bhagwani created a mortgage with possession over the first item of land in favour of Messrs Chuhar Singh, Mita Singh and Lachman Singh for a sum of Rs 2000 on 1-1-1914. The said mortgagees sold their rights under the mortgage to one Waryam Singh under sale deed dated 3-7-1919 for a consideration of Rs 2230. The present appellants (Defendants 1 to 4 in the suit) are the heirs of Waryam Singh, and they became entitled to the rights of Waryam Singh after his death. The second item of land which Smt Bhagwani owned was likewise mortgaged with possession to one Ballaura Singh, who figured as Defendant 5 in the suit.

3. Smt Bhagwani died in the year 1960 without leaving any heirs. Consequently, her properties went by escheat to the State of Punjab and they were “duly mutated in the Revenue Registers. After the lands had reverted to it, the State allotted the two items of lands to the respondents/plaintiffs under the Nazool Lands Transfer Rules, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”). The allotment was made by the Collector on behalf of the State by means of an order dated 21-5-1968.

4. As per directions given in the order of allotment, the respondents deposited two sums of money viz. Rs 2230 towards redemption of the mortgage in favour of Defendants 1 to 4 and Rs 743 towards redemption of the mortgage in favour of Defendant 5. On the said sums of money being deposited, the Collector issued warrants of possession and served notices on the two sets of mortgagees informing them that the respective mortgages in their favour stood redeemed and that they should surrender possession of the mortgaged items of land to the respondents. It would appear that warrants of possession were also issued by the Collector and the respondents took possession of the two items of land and had deposited at that time a sum of Rs 607.60 towards compensation for the standing crops on the lands. After the respondents had taken possession Defendants 1 to 4 filed a suit for injunction and obtained an order of temporary injunction and in the garb of protecting their possession, they had wrested the possession of the land from the respondents. On account of that, the respondents filed a suit for possession of the mortgaged lands from the defendants.

5. While Defendant 5 did not contest the suit, Defendants 1 to 4 contended that (a) Smt Bhagwani had in fact left behind certain heirs and hence her properties had not reverted to the State by escheat; (b) that the suit was barred by limitation; and (c) that their rights as mortgagees were not affected by the allotment order made in favour of the respondents by the Collector.

6. All the contentions were rejected by the trial court but, however, the trial court held that a deposit of the mortgage amount in the State Treasury would not amount to a valid tender for redemption of the mortgage and, therefore, the respondents should re-deposit the amount in court so that the mortgage can be redeemed through court. It is common ground that the respondents complied with this direction and deposited the amount in court and were thereupon granted a decree for possession. The appellate court concurred with the findings of the trial court and affirmed the decree for possession.

7. Against the concurrent findings of the two courts, the appellants preferred a second appeal to the High Court and contended therein that the allotment order made under the Rules was invalid since the village Bathan Kalan, in which the suit lands are situate, and been transferred to the State of Punjab under the Provinces and the States (Absorption of Enclaves) Order, 1950 from the erstwhile Patiala and East Punjab State Union (Pepsu) in 1950 and consequently the Rules framed by the Government of Pepsu in 1956 would not apply to the mortgage lands. It was further urged that even if the State of Punjab had become the owner of the lands by escheat, the respondents can derive title to the lands only if the State Government had conveyed the lands to them by a registered deed of conveyance. The High Court saw merit in the first contention but even so the High Court declined to interfere with the decree for eviction passed by the courts below on the ground that since the respondents, acting under the order of allotment made in their favour, had deposited a sum of Rs 2230 towards the sale price-cum-redemption charges of the mortgage land but were not given possession, they became entitled to a charge over the mortgage lands under Section 55(6)(b) of the Transfer of Property Act and as holders of a charge, they are entitled to redeem the usufructuary mortgage in terms of Section 91 of the Transfer of Property Act. On the basis of such reasoning the High Court confirmed the respondents' decree for possession and dismissed the second appeal. The aggrieved defendants have thereupon preferred this appeal by special leave.

8. Mr Anil Dev Singh, learned Counsel for the appellants contended before us that once the High Court had accepted the position that the Rules framed by the Pepsu Government in 1956 had no application to the mortgaged items of land on account of the transfer of the lands to the State of Punjab in 1950, the High Court must have further held that no title passed to the respondents under the order of allotment made by the Collector and hence the respondents had no right to seek redemption of the mortgage or demand possession of the land. The second submission of the learned Counsel was that even if the land had escheated to the State and the State wanted to allot the lands to the respondents as a rehabilitative measure, the respondents would not constitute “buyers” of the land in the eye of law merely because of their deposit of the sale price-cum-redemption charges of the land without having acquired title to the land under a registered deed of conveyance in their favour. The third submission was that the respondents should have had at least a valid agreement of sale in their favour if they are to claim the benefit of a statutory charge under Section 55(6)(b) for the sale price deposited by them.

9. Mr Mahajan, learned Counsel for the respondents controverted the arguments of Mr Anil Dev Singh and argued that this was a case where the appellants wanted to unjustly cling to their possession and enjoyment of the land in spite of having been in enjoyment of the land for about 70 years by reason of having paid a meagre sum of Rs 2230 to the previous mortgagees and obtaining an assignment of their rights in their favour. He pointed out that as the land had reverted to the State, the State wanted to rehabilitate the respondents belonging to the weaker section of the society and had, therefore, allotted the land to them subject to the condition that they should deposit the mortgage amount for redeeming the mortgage but the appellants have been successfully keeping the respondents out of possession for over 20 years by filing successive appeals and in such circumstances this was not a fit case for this Court to examine under Article 136 of the Constitution the merits of the contentions of the appellants. Insofar as the legal contentions of the appellant's counsel are concerned, Mr Mahajan stated that once the lands had reverted to the State, the State stepped into the shoe of the mortgagor and was entitled to redeem the mortgage and allot the land to the respondents or in the alternative the State can allot the land first and empower the allottee to redeem the mortgage and take over the possession of the lands.

10. On a consideration of the matter we find that none of the contentions advanced by the appellant's counsel is a tenable one. It is no doubt true that the village Batan Kalan in which the mortgaged land is situate had been transferred to the State of Punjab in 1950 and, therefore, the Rules framed by the Pepsu Government in 1956 for distribution of Nazool lands would not apply to it. That would not however mean that the Government had no power to allot the land to the respondent. It has been concurrently found by the courts that the land had reverted to the State of Punjab on the death of Smt Bhagwani as she did not leave behind any heirs to inherit her properties. The State had, therefore, stepped into the shoes of the erstwhile owner and become entitled to redeem the mortgage and take over the possession of the land. Mr Anil Dev Singh had to concede the position that if the State itself had sought to redeem the mortgage through its officers, the appellants would have no right to refuse redemption of the mortgage or to surrender possession of the land. He also accepted the position that a transferee of the State Government would also be entitled to redeem the mortgage but only contended that there should be a valid deed of conveyance in favour of the transferee or then should at least be a valid agreement in his favour for transfer of the land to him by the State. His argument therefore was that since there was no registered deed of conveyance or a valid agreement for conveying title to the respondents, but only an order of allotment issued by the Collector, the respondents could not in law be treated as the buyers of the land and held entitled to deliver of possession of the land and in the absence of delivery, to be entitled to a charge over the land under Section 55(6)(b) of the Transfer of Property Act for the sale price deposited by them. In support of his arguments the counsel placed reliance on two decisions, one rendered by the High Court of Gujarat and the other by the High Court of Bombay.

11. Attractive as the arguments of the appellant's counsel seem to be they do not really have merit in them. As we have already stated the reversion of the land to the State and the right of the State to redeem the mortgage is beyond dispute in the case. The only question for consideration is whether the redemption should have been sought for by the State itself through it officers or whether the redemption can be sought for by a nominee of the State Government under an order or (sic of) allotment made in his favour. In this case, in addition to the order of allotment made by the Collector, warrants of possession had also been issued in favour of the respondents. By reason of these two orders the respondents had acquired a right under the doctrine of promissory estoppel to call upon the government to regularise the allotment of the land to them if for any reason the order of allotment made by the Collector was defective in any manner. Such being the case, even if no registered deed of conveyance or agreement of sale had been executed by the Government, the respondents had become entitled in law to claim title to the land and seek delivery of possession of the allotted land to them and to ask for a charge, in the absence of delivery of possession over the property for the money deposited by them under the allotment order. Viewed from this angle, there is no room whatever for any contention that the respondents would not constitute the buyers of the land and are, therefore, not entitled to claim a charge over the allotted land under Section 55(6)(b) of the Transfer of Property Act. Though the provisions of the Transfer of Property Act are not applicable to the State of Punjab the principle enunciated in Section 55(6)(b) has been held applicable to Punjab on grounds of justice, equity and good conscience (vide Shankri v. Milkha Singh AIR 1941 Lah 407). The logical consequence would then be that as charge-holders the respondents would be entitled under Section 91 of the Transfer of Property Act to seek the redemption of the mortgage.

12. We may now deal with the decisions relied upon by the appellant's counsel. In Nadoda Khima Keshar v. Bombay State ILR 1967 Guj 323, a vendor sought to contend that the deed executed by him was not a deed of sale but only a mortgage and hence he was entitled to seek scaling down of the debt and recover possession of the land under the Saurashtra Agricultural Debtors Relief Act, 1954. When the first two courts concurrently held that the transaction was an outright sale and not a mortgage, he alternatively contended that the purchaser stood in the position of a charge-holder under Section 55(6)(b) of the Transfer of Property Act and in that event also the Debtors Relief Act was attracted. That contention was rejected by the High Court by pointing out that the sale as well as the agreement of sale which preceded it were in contravention of the Saurashtra Attachment of Agricultural Debtors Property Temporary Exemption Act and consequently the defendant would not constitute a buyer in the eye of law and therefore there can be no question of the defendant being entitled to a charge under Section 55(6)(b) for the sale price advanced by him. This authority is of no relevance to this case because there was no bar in law for the State Government to allot the land to the respondents after it had become the owner of the land by escheat or to the respondents claiming delivery of possession as the transferees of the land as per the order of allotment made in their favour and the warrant of possession issued to them. The second decision Dhyanu Baba Chobe v. Gulab Eknath Bhais (1960) 62 Bom LR 940 rendered by the Bombay High Court pertains to a case where the holder of an agreement of sale filed a suit against the owner of the land and his vendee for recovery of the earnest money paid by him and incidentally sought a charge on the land agreed to be sold to him which by then had been purchased by the cultivating tenant himself in exercise of the right given to him by statute to purchase the tenancy land. The High Court held that the agreement of sale was invalid in law because of the right conferred by statute on cultivating tenants to purchase the lands in their tenancy and secondly because the tenant/purchaser had not derived title to the land under any contract of sale with the owner but by reason of the statutory rights in his favour. In the present case there was no such legal impediment to stand in the way of the State allotting the land to the respondents or to the respondents seeking delivery of possession of the land allotted to them.

13. Another submission made by appellant's counsel was that in any event the respondents would only stand in the position of a simple mortgagee and hence their remedy was only to file a suit for bringing the hypotheca to sale and in the event of their purchasing the hypotheca, to file a suit thereafter for recovery of possession. In support of this contention reference was made to the decision in Muhammad Usan Rowthan v. Abdulla ILR (1901) 24 Mad 171. The contention is wholly misconceived because the State which stood in the shoes of the mortgagor had parted with the equity of redemption in favour of the respondents and called upon them to deposit the sale price so that it could be paid to the appellants to redeem the mortgage in their favour. There was, therefore, no question of the respondents deemingly entering into a mortgage transaction or their filing a suit for enforcement of the mortgage.

14. The appellants' plea that the lands had not escheated to the State having failed, the appellants cannot resist the redemption of the mortgage irrespective of whether the redemption was sought for by the State itself through its officers or by a transferee of the State duly authorised to redeem the mortgage and obtain delivery of possession of the allotted land.

15. For the aforesaid reasons the appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed with costs.